Chapter Text
Midnight
Randy plops on the ground, looking at the stars, He misses Sidney. Sometimes he still dreams of her, not anything like, sex. He never dreamed of her like that. He just wanted to go on movie dates, and give her little trinkets.
Now he can't.
He takes a swig of beer and chews his lips. He needs to get his mind off her. He wants to get over her. But he doesn't know how too.
But
There's two boys in the house who he thinks is hot.
He's not a fag.
But who cares?
It's just for the night.
He gets up and chugs his beer before leaving it in the grass
Stu pick a movie and puts it in the TV, Billy drinks beer as Randy sits back down.
"Well, look who wanted to join us." Stu says, sitting next to Randy. The geek now in between the two killers.
Randy climbs on top of Billy.
"What-" Billy can't finish his sentence without Randy smashing his lips against the Mama's boy's lips. Stu watches intensely. Billy moans softly as Randy starts biting his neck.
Stu gets closer, wanting in. Billy moans louder and throws his head back.
"Guys?" Stu says softly. No matter the situation, he never wants to be left out.
Randy kisses Stu and leaves Billy. Billy watches as the geek kisses his boyfriend. Stu whimpers, grabbing onto Randy.
Stu starts grabbing Randy's shirt, trying to pull it off. Randy pulls away to be pulled off. His shirt gone, somewhere on the floor.
Stu looks at Randy's chest scar. "Woah.,"
Billy takes his shirt off and kisses Randy. "I thought no sex?" Billy teases. "Breaking the rules?"
Randy groans. "Shut up."
Both killers get Randy undressed and undress themselves.
"Come on, pretty boy." Stu bites Randy's neck, looking identical to Billy's bites.
Randy gets pinned on the floor, both Billy and Stu being on top of him. The TV has a girl getting murdered but neither of them cared.
Randy felt himself getting hard. Stu grins.
"Someone is excited. So excited." Stu giggles. Starting to slowly jerk Randy off.
Billy grins. "This boy need to use his mouth for something."
Randy whimpers. "Like what?"
"Get on your knees. Now." Billy demands.
Randy complies and gets on his hands and knees.
"Brutal murders or soft when watching a horror movie?" Billy asks. Stu knows this code.
"Brutal?" Randy is confused as he looks up at Billy. Billy holds his chin.
"Well, Randy, you can tight ass is gonna be in so much pain." Randy looks confused and scared.
-Idk how to write this I don't read a lot of smut-
Stu slowly slides his cock into Randy's ass. Randy groans and whimpers. Billy positions his cock in front of Randy and makes the geek suck him off.
It's almost like they're forcing him, but Randy loves it. The room is filled with moans, groans, whimpers and slapping.
Randy eventually cums. Moaning as Billy and Stu finish inside him. They pull out and lay with Randy on the floor.
"Geek lost his virginity!" Stu giggles, tickling Randy. Randy giggles as the tree off then look at the TV.
Randy falls asleep. Billy and Stu smile.
"He's ours now." Stu giggles.
"Yeah." Billy whispers