Archive of Our Own ^beta

Chapter Text

Jason:

- Jason would be pretty indifferent to physical appearance and style in general, at least outwardly. He’d be far more observant than he’d let on, though

- Clothes that suited your style would randomly appear in your wardrobe, Jason discreetly peeping at you when you went through your things to see if you liked them

- Finds your lip glosses and such so cute. He’d be so fascinated with your individual style, despite not really showing it

- If he caught you wearing something of his he’d freeze, staring to make sure it actually did belong to him and flushing up when he realized it did. He would love it though, happy that you felt close enough to him and comfortable enough with him to do that kind of thing

Bubba:

- He’d be drawn to your style right away. He wears suits too so he’d be happy that your styles more or less matched

- Bubba loves when you wear lipstick and lip gloss, finding the colors so beautiful and even helping you pick them out (he would love anything colorful and bright especially!)

- You wouldn’t have to steal his clothes because he’d let you wear them anyways. If he had something he thought you would like, it’s yours! He would love to share things though, feeling closer to your for it

- Bubba would be so supportive and cute, always making happy little noises to show his support at your different outfits. (This would include anything, btw. Even pajamas. He doesn’t care, you look amazing in anything!)

Brahms:

- Brahms finds your style so interesting and pretty, especially loving to see you in suits

- He’d adore your short hair, loving to ruffle it up and play with it if you allowed (He’d still want a lock of your hair though, even if it was shorter, because that’s just Brahms. Please 🥺)

- If you ever stole his clothes and wore them? Omg. He’d intentionally leave things lying around for you, waiting impatiently to see if you’d wear them

- Once he’s confident enough about it, he’d compliment you all the time on literally everything, in a sort of overly poeticized way that you would find sweet but also lowkey funny. He’d want you to be well aware of how special you were to him, and he’d end up leaving you a blushing mess (to his satisfaction) at how direct he could be.

Billy:

- Billy doesn’t even notice at first? If he likes you he likes you, he wouldn’t pay much mind to pretty much anything else (Mostly because he’d be too concerned with how you’d perceive him at first, barely having enough attention left over to notice how you looked lol)

- When he eased up around you though, he’d find he was completely taken with you. Your short hair would be his absolute favorite, and you’d eventually have to keep him at arms length unless you didn’t mind him messing with it all the time

- He’d get kind of worked up when he saw you wearing his clothes for the first time, feeling strangely exposed by the intimacy of it. When he warmed up to it, however, he’d like it a lot, it making him outwardly cocky and inwardly soft

- He’d probably wear your clothes too. You leave something lying around of yours? Good luck getting it back!

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- Thomas would thoroughly melt. He’s starved for affection and kindness, and probably wouldn’t even know how to handle it at first, only staring at you with reddened cheeks and ears

- He’s a sucker for compliments, especially — he’s been spoken to/about poorly most of his life, so it’s foreign to him. Your seemingly endless drawls of honey-coated words soften him up beyond repair, building his confidence up more than you would even be aware of (imagine his widened eyes and fumbling hands as you spoke 🥺)

- It would take some time, but you’d make him like things about himself. You compliment his eyes? He would slowly begin to too, since you did. You played with his hair, rambling on about how pretty it was? Fluttering eyelids, profuse blushing, can’t handle it. He likes it too from then on, and hopes you play with it more.

- Of course, Thomas would adore that you were physically affectionate. He’d be more than willing anytime you wanted hugs or kisses, his tummy always filling with butterflies at your touches. Besides kisses, he’d especially adore casual intimacy - touching his arms in passing, or playing with his hands and fingers absent-mindedly as you sat with him. It would make him feel so loved and happy. (Also: snuggling up to him/nuzzling into his neck. He would melt, amazed that you were so trusting and comfortable with him)

- Your sweetness would be so endearing to him, almost feeling undeserving of it. He’d question why you were so tender with him, often needing reassurance. He’d be quite protective of you anyways, but your sweet personality would only further this.

Brahms:

- This would be perfect for Brahms. He’s very affectionate himself, so he’d be happy to receive any affection that came his way

- Seriously. If you began being casually affectionate with him, spoiling him with kisses, hugs, and little touches in passing, he’d do the same, probably taking advantage of it a little (only because he’s quite touch starved)

- Compliments, however, would be received a little different. Not badly, only with more reservation. He’s unused to them, and would often flush up at your sweet words, stammering clumsily to thank you as he tried not to blush too hard

- Your sweet, caring and affectionate personality would melt his heart, so thankful that you came along. Your sweet words and affectionate nature would be so mending to a severely neglected part of him

- Often times, you’d have a hard time getting him to let you go when you hugged or cuddled up to him. He’d cling to you tightly, nuzzling up to you and savoring every moment of it

Michael:

- You would have to be patient with Michael when it came to any kind of affection. He wouldn’t mind, but he’d be a little wary of it, especially at first

- Gentle, caring and purposeful touches would soften him up a bit. Things like you caring for any wounds he happened to get while ~out and about~, and looking after him in ways he wasn’t used to

- Compliments and doting would be met with surprise, though you wouldn’t be able to tell. If you look closely enough, you’ll see his eyes are widened behind his mask when you speak lovingly of him

- Your sweet personality would intrigue him, especially seeing as he was the object of your affections. His own affection would be shown by being protective and gentle with you, willingly accepting your affection, albeit with some amount of awkwardness

- He would have a hard time not letting his guard down and completely melting into your touches and at your affection. Slowly but surely, he’d loosen up. One day you’d absent-mindedly lift your hand to his arm or cheek once he was warmed up to you, and he’d surprise you by leaning into it just slightly, scanning your reaction nervously. Don’t push your luck and overreact though, he’ll get awkward and temporarily disappear. An encouraging smile will do!

Jason:

- Jason would *adore* this. So much. You would always make him feel so warm and loved, any insecurities he had would slowly melt away

- He would feel grateful that he wore a mask sometimes, embarrassed at how flushed you could make him without even having to try

- Has some reservations about physical affection at first, but your patience and sweetness would rapidly chip away at them. In fact, he’d regret keeping you at arms length at first, as he’d worry you weren’t being as affectionate as you wanted to be because of it (you actually were, he just wants more)

- You can always tell he’s beaming beneath the mask when you compliment him, savoring your words and making sure he won’t forget them. Although he might not always agree with the sweet things you said about him, they made him feel special and loved

- His biggest weakness would be his neck. You would occasionally kiss the side of his neck near his jaw in lieu of his face when he wore his mask, and each time you could watch as his ears turned crimson, eyes widened slightly, always prompting a giggle from you

Bubba:

- Bubba is quite affectionate too, so you’d be a cute match

- He might have reservations about being too affectionate in the beginning, as he wouldn’t want to scare you away. However, when you proved yourself to be just the same as him, the dam would break and he’d rarely not be spoiling you with affection

- Your compliments and sweet words would always leave him a blushing mess, genuinely confounded at how you could make him feel so warm and fluttery inside

- Bubba is definitely the cuddliest so prepare yourself for endless snuggles, happy to return your affection like that. If you were to walk up and give him a random hug, he’d melt, dragging you off somewhere to sit with you for hours, you snuggled up in his arms

- He cannot cope with the casual little kisses you give him, especially if you pepper them across his face. He would never get used to them despite loving them, turning the sweetest shade of pink each time and rambling on in a sort of awkward panic

Chop Top:

- Chop Top would lovingly tease you about how affectionate you were with him, finding it completely adorable. He would end up shutting up about it as he wouldn’t want to discourage you, though

- Compliments and sweet words would be met with a big, silly smile or chuckle, followed by him asking you if you really meant it. He’d find you so sweet, and would return your affectionate words in his own weird, Chop Top-esque way

- Nothing has an effect on him quite like random, unexpected touches. He’ll be going on in his typical loud, extra way when you’d stand next to him and slip your hand into his, your other hand clinging to his arm as you pressed up to him slightly. His voice would falter as he glanced at you with a nervous chuckle, rambling nervously and trying to remain ~composed~

- Your sweetness would be somewhat puzzling to him, particularly because it was directed toward him. He wouldn’t be used to people being so gentle and polite with him, so he wouldn’t even know what to do with it at first

- Ends up being more affectionate than you. He loves having you in his arms and smothering you with chaotic, needy kisses. He’d have loads of weird, super-specific nicknames he’d call you, and would love if you had some for him, too.

Nubbins:

- So soft for you! Seriously. He’d treat you like you were made of glass, uncharacteristically protective of you

- Anytime you touched him he’d break into the sweetest smile, melting into your hands. *Loves* when you play with his hair, nuzzling up against your hand

- Anytime you complimented him, called him loving nicknames, or anything like that he’d flush up and wouldn’t be able to stop smiling

- He’s so used to being mistreated that your sweet and gentle personality would make his heart race. He’d cling to you any chance he got, finding comfort in you

- He’d be just affectionate back, but in a sort of clumsy, awkward way. It would be new to him, and he’d want to be all gentle and sweet with you, but instead he’d be a bit rough and unpracticed. He’d play with your hair a bit roughly, hug you a little too tightly, and would kiss you with too much fervor for it to be as sweet as the intention behind it

Beetlejuice:

- Beetlejuice wouldn’t really know how to take this/deal with it. He can be quite vulgar and straightforward, so it would be an adjustment. Not an unwelcome one, just different

- He’d find himself getting embarrassed by his own lewd comments and gestures, finding you far too sweet for that, and wanting to treat you as such

- When you complimented him, his first instinct would be to be cocky and teasing about it. As he realized how genuine you were, he’d get surprisingly embarrassed, genuinely appreciating your words and not forgetting them

- Finds himself adoring your soft, sweet touches, leaning into them and hoping they’d last longer than they did. Of course, you were always happy to cater to him, stopping whatever you were doing to shower him with soft attention that you knew he needed more than he was aware

- His personality would completely soften around you, looking at you as though you were the most precious thing in the world. The second someone else was around though? Back to his usual shenanigans.

Candyman:

- Daniel would pretty much be the same as you, always spoiling you with the sweetest, loveliest words that would leave your heart fluttering and cheeks flushed

- He’d find your sweet personality endearing, being particularly gentle and soft with you. Any kind of affection you wanted, you would get

- Adores your touches, and returns them without hesitation. He’s a romantic, so he’d love your kisses in particular, smiling anytime you would randomly kiss him, and often wrapping you up to steal more than a simple peck

- He would be so sweet and romantic constantly, cherishing every little bit of affection you gave him. He’d always be amazed at how gentle you were and how you made him feel

- He would (not so) secretly love being doted over by you. Would melt at how adoringly you looked at him, and would be happy to just sit with you as you snuggled up to him, making him feel all soft and special

Bo:

- This is so foreign to Bo. Literally, he’d look at you like you were absolutely nuts, having no idea how to react to half the things you said

- Your soft, doting words flustered him far more than he would have liked to admit, even to himself. Every compliment would wrap itself around his thoughts and tug at his heartstrings

- Did you really mean the things you said about him? You were so soft and genuine, he was always amazed at how you could feel so sweetly toward him. He’d feel so privileged, in a way, to be the object of your affections

- Your physical affection would *always* be welcome. He would definitely return it, though not without some amount of flirting and teasing. Calls you every cute moniker in the book, sweetheart being his favorite for you. (He’d never admit it but if you call him things like that too, he’d melt)

- Of course, he’d adore whatever affection you gave him, but it would be the sweet, unfamiliar things that would really get him. If you held his hand in yours as you walked, kissed his cheeks, played with his hair or even did something as silly as booping his nose, he’d scoff, half rolling his eyes and pretending to find it silly. The pink spreading across his cheeks and nose would not be lost on you, though, nor the soft smile that would slowly emerge

Vincent:

- Vincent would be a little bit nervous about affection at first. He’d definitely want it, but it would just be new to him. He’d have to warm up to you first

- Verbal affection would be best in the beginning, sweet words easing him up to you (and making it much harder to keep you at arms length). If he allowed you to see him without his mask, he’d rarely not be blushing (to be honest, you would be able to sense that he was anyways, even when he did wear it)

- Little things like touching his shoulders or arms in passing would make him so soft. When he’s comfortable with it, you’d begin holding his hands and hugging him, which would almost always result in him nuzzling up to you and rapidly getting clingy

- His favorite thing would be cuddling up with you for hours, feeling safe and warm tangled up with you. He’d also love when you played with his hair, and kissed the scarred side of his face, quickly getting overwhelmed with emotion

- He would be as caring and sweet toward you as you would be with him. Your loving personality would be deeply appreciated by him, and he’d make sure that you knew it

Lester:

- Lester would be the softest ever for you, your sweet personality being what drew him to you. He’d be used to people being mean and rude, so when you weren’t, he’d already be putty in your hands

- Every word that came out of your mouth would prompt a big, expectant smile, no matter what it was about. However, anytime you indulged him with compliments and kindness, he’d hardly be able to maintain eye contact, too embarrassed and flattered to even properly hear you

- Being with you would perpetually keep him in a good mood. No amount of meanness from anyone would matter anymore — if you liked him, that’s all that would matter!

- He spoils you just as much with affection and compliments as you do him, thinking you were the sweetest person on earth, and wanting you to know it

- Loves all kinds of physical affection you give him, but he really just likes to have you close. Hand holding, arms wrapped around each other, and so on would make feel safe and warm

Graverobber:

- Graverobber would be pleasantly surprised with how soft you were with him, finding himself almost amused by it. Not in a bad way, but as with almost everyone else he just wouldn’t expect it

- Any random affection, verbal or physical, would be met with a cocked eyebrow and a small smirk — only because he loves watching the blush creep over your cheeks in embarrassment

- He’d love it though, and would be quick to reassure you despite his initial teasing. He’d find you so endearing and would appreciate you a lot, though he’d be more apt to express it with actions rather than words

- Alternatively to teasing when you were being particularly sweet, he’d pull you up next to him and wrap his arm around you. If you were alone, he’d be a bit touchier, peppering your face with kisses and grinning in satisfaction as he made you laugh and blush

- He would find you so cute, often unable to keep a smile off his face when you were around

Luigi:

- You would certainly be a stark contrast to Luigi. This pairing would be a mystery to his family and pretty much everyone else, though he wouldn’t understand why

- Your sweet, affectionate personality would cut through his angry, brazen one a little, at least when he was around you. Despite his temper, he’d have a hard time actually getting angry when you were around, even toward other people (this results in everyone else hoping you would stay attached at the hip, so to speak. *Please*)

- He’d adore your affection, needing soft and sweet attention more than he knew. He’d love to be wrapped up in your arms, or have you wrapped up in his — it really wouldn’t matter, he’d be happy either way. (Also likes PDA, as he’s a show-off)

- Your praises and compliments would always light up his face with an endearing smile. He’d go out of his way to impress you and live up to your words. He could also be quite smug, too, agreeing with your compliments half-seriously and half in an attempt to make you laugh

- You would (unintentionally) have him wrapped around your finger, without him even realizing it.

Pavi:

- Pavi would be fascinated by this, so used to less innocent forms of affection. He definitely wouldn’t be used to sincere, loving words directed toward him, especially paired with innocent touches without ulterior motive

- He’s used to people flocking around him to simulate whatever he wanted, often times because of who he was, rather than out of genuine interest. If you gave him attention freely, because you wanted to, it would unlock a completely different side of him

- He would be enamored with you, quickly losing interest in everyone else as he fixated on you. Your praises, kindness and attention would always leave him a smiling mess

- Needless to say, Pavi is very physically affectionate, so he’d adore that you were, too. You wouldn’t have many opportunities to initiate it, though, as he’d be quite clingy and touchy without prompting

- Pavi returns affection and compliments, of course. He praises you and talks sweetly (at least, you think it’s sweet?) in his typical eccentric way, bragging about you and how much you loved ~the Pavi~ to his siblings (and probably anyone who listens)

Billy Lenz:

- Billy can say the lewdest things, yet somehow still manages to get flustered when you give him any type of affection

- That doesn’t mean he doesn’t like it though. Quite contrarily, he’d (discreetly, or so he thought) give you every opportunity to give him affection, not wanting to seem obvious or have to ask

- He could literally curl up in your lap like a cat and just fall asleep, clinging to you and melting into your touches

- Your compliments would often be received with a clumsy attempt at self-assuredness, too embarrassed by your sweet words to keep up the ruse. That wouldn’t stop him from attempting it, though

- He adores your sweet personality, and would be far softer than you might think with you. Keeps lewd, awkward comments to a minimum and replaces them instead with sweeter, gentler words (well, to the extent that he is capable of, anyways)

Chapter Text

Chop Top:

- Although Chop Top has his own funky little style going on, I honestly think he’d be totally oblivious to anyone else’s for the most part

- He’d think you’re pretty and would like your individuality a lot though

- However, he will love when you wear his things! So much! Will literally take off whatever he’s wearing and give it to you just so you can try it (including his wig)

- Loves your lip colors too, especially anything glossy, glittery, or flavored/scented. He’d want to try them too but waits for an invitation to do so (plz let him)

Nubbins:

- He’d find you so pretty and intriguing. Loves taking your picture, if you let him

- Shares his clothes with you all the time without you having to ask. In fact, he’d insist! Rummages around to find things he thought you would like and leaves them to surprise you

- He thinks you’re so cute and has no problem telling you so. Though he’d be a little shy and embarrassed, he’s super sweet and would be sure to hype up every outfit and lip color you wore (honestly just hypes you up in general)

- Loves playing with your short hair, and will absolutely offer to trim it for you once it starts growing out. If you let him (plz don’t) you will end up with an extremely uneven, awkward haircut that you don’t have the heart to complain about because he’d be so proud

Michael:

- Michael wouldn’t have any outward expression about this. You’d assume he really didn’t care about how you dressed and such — and to be honest, he wouldn't — though he would notice more than you realized

- Especially if you wore something of his. He’d actually be visibly confused, to your amusement: tilts his head, looks you up and down to check if it was really his, and then just stares at you like…Why?

- Not that he minds! He’d just be confused. Why would you even want to wear his clothes?…Is this a thing? Should he be wearing your clothes?

- You’re just going through your things and hey…Where’d this lip gloss come from? (You turn around to Michael standing in the doorway, quickly disappearing before you can ask)

Thomas:

- Thomas would be pretty indifferent to appearance/style in general. He thinks you’re beautiful, and wouldn’t really pay much mind

- …Still, you do catch him staring a little longer than normal when you’re looking particularly sharp, or when you’re wearing a pretty lipstick

- If you catch him, he’ll get so embarrassed, quickly finding the nearest escape route and taking it

- You wear his clothes? He will turn such a bright shade of red so quickly, and he isn’t even sure why. He isn’t used to people being so comfortable and close with him, but he’ll love it — thinks you look so cute in his clothes, and would stare admiringly at you when you wore them, wondering how you could make his dirty old shirts look so nice

Beetlejuice:

- Beetlejuice would have seemingly never-ending compliments for you. A whole flirt, obviously. He’d adore your style a lot!

- He would love your suits, and kind of wants to match with you. Secretly wants to see you in his black and white suit, too

- You like wearing his clothes? Eyebrow wiggles and smirking all the time. Here, have his suit…!

- Loves your lipsticks and glosses a lot, particularly bold, vivid colors! Kind of wants to try to put it on for you, but ends up making a whole mess

Bo:

- Bo would find you so cute, and wouldn’t have any reservations on reminding you of it frequently

- You’re wearing his clothes? Cue raised eyebrows and a small, adoring (smug) smile. Lets you keep them, insisting that you look better in them than he does (which he would mean, but he also just wants to see you in his clothes)

- Lip glosses/lip sticks will never go unnoticed by him. There would be no shortage of sweet compliments on how pretty it looked

- Gets in the habit of taking his hat off and sloppily popping it onto your head, earning a playful eye-roll from you each time (hey, if you’re going to wear his clothes, you might as well wear the whole ensemble!)

Vincent:

- Vincent, I imagine, would be very appreciative of self-expression and individuality. That having been said, he’d adore it!

- Shyly encouraging of you. He wouldn’t be bold enough to be a flirt like Bo, and he’d be too shy to praise you with compliments all the time like Lester, but in his own way he’d be so sweet and thoughtful

- Thinks your short hair is so cute and pretty. He’d love playing with it and would occasionally playfully ruffle it up, smiling to himself at how cute you looked

- Will completely melt if he catches you in one of his sweaters. You’d give it back, but would later notice that it had ~somehow~ found its way back into your things

Lester:

- Lester would probably find you a little intimidating at first, particularly if you wore suits and the like. Thinks you’re fancy!

- However as you began dating, he’d love it so much, finding you so interesting and pretty. Compliments you *a lot*

- If you wore his clothes, part of him would melt at how cute you looked and how close it made him feel to you, and part of him would feel insecure at how dirty his clothes could be (reassure him 🥺) He’d take greater care to keep things cleaner just for you from then on

- He’d be really sweet and thoughtful, noticing you like lip glosses and such and sometimes buying you some while he’s out to surprise you. He’d pick out the most random things (flavored lip balms, those cute lip glosses that come in shaped containers, etc.) but he’d be so eager and excited about it that you’d find it completely adorable

Chapter Text

Brahms:

- When Brahms heard you talking to yourself as if someone else were there, he’d initially assume you were talking to the doll and wouldn’t think much of it.

- I mean, you’re more talkative than some of the other nannies who sort of jokingly talked with it, but he doesn’t mind! In fact, he’d like it — he’d love to hear your voice, and hearing what he thought was you talking to Brahms the doll would make him feel closer to you. It would make the old manor house feel a little less empty, so he loves it.

- If you did it when the doll wasn’t around and it was just you, he might be kind of confused, but after a while would decide it was just a habit and would find it endearing. Again, he doesn’t mind at all, kind of wishes you’d do it more tbh.

- Also wishes you’d speak up a little so he could hear you better though

Billy Lenz:

- Billy would be a little more startled by this than Brahms, at least at first.

- The first time he heard you talking to yourself as if someone else was there, he’d freeze, full well knowing no one else was around besides him. He’d listen in confusion, heart racing slightly, wondering if you had caught on to him.

- When he realized it was just a habit of yours, he’d find it kind of cute, and would be intrigued. He’d probably get careless, getting closer than he normally would to try and hear what you were saying.

- This is how you’d learn about him, honestly. He’d be clumsy and you’d catch on to him, or he’d quote things you’d said to yourself when he called, making you realize

Chapter Text

- Your birthday with Chop Top would be, needless to say, kind of chaotic

- He’d be more excited about it than you, far more hyper and excitable than usual. Even if you wanted to keep it simple, you wouldn’t have the heart to deny him of his fun

- He ~sloppily~ decorates everything with whatever he can scrounge up: colorful lights, balloons, a piñata probably (chaos ensues) and so on. Bubba helps, Drayton complains but ends up doing the most lol

- Chop Top would be a surprisingly thoughtful gift-giver, as he’d be more observant of your interests and likes/dislikes than you might think. He would give you something small, but meaningful and thoughtful — something like a record or piece of jewelry that reminded him of you (alternatively: matching pins. He’d do this anyways, to be honest, and would insist that you wore it)

- When you lit up when you saw it, he’d get the biggest grin on his face, laughing in self satisfaction and making you melt with how sweet he really was

- He would attempt to bake you a cake, but it would somehow end up melting away in the oven, so he’d probably just steal one from some poor local bakery (hey, at least he remembered to get your favorite flavor!)

- Makes you blow out birthday candles (they are trick candles, of course) and obnoxiously sings happy birthday the whole time, starting the song over and over as the candles relight and you keep blowing them out, (lovingly) laughing at you all the while

- Takes you for a drive in the evening, if you like, playing your favorite songs and going a little too fast. He’d pull you toward him, wrapping his arm tightly around you and keeping it there the whole time. He’d be unusually sweet and affectionate, wanting you to know how special you were to him, without him actually having to say it. He’d brush his thumb against your arm as he drove, occasionally leaning over to leave a sloppy kiss on top of your head, giving you the biggest, silliest, sweetest smile each time

Chapter Text

- When Jason first noticed your hand tremors, he’d be overcome with concern. He’d take your hands into his, quizzically looking at you to prompt you for an explanation

- His heart would sink, his first thought being that it was because he’d frightened you. It would be the last thing he’d ever want to do, and the thought of being the cause of it would make him a nervous wreck

- However when you explained, he’d be so helpful and sweet. If you had a hard time with something because of it, he’d be quick to sweep in and help

- In fact, he’d do certain things without prompting, anyways. Absolutely will tie your shoes for you each time without you having to ask

- Anytime he sees you’re having a hard time with something he’ll do his best to help you, if you like. He’d be quietly observant, peeking at you discreetly to see if you wanted/needed help with things

- Overall Jason is always concerned with your well-being. Not just with your hands, but with everything. He’d always be sweetly fretting over you, looking out for your safety and making sure you were okay. If you did the same for him his heart would melt, feeling lucky to have you

Chapter Text

- You want to play video games with him? Okay! Anything for you!

- (literally five minutes later, after realizing he isn’t good at it right away) I hate it let’s do something else >:(

- Of course, he’s happy to continue, if you really want. The second (you let him win) he wins he’ll have a newfound love for it, asking to play it with you so often you’d quickly get bored of it

- If it’s a horror game, he’ll happily give it a try, although any jump scares or disturbing parts would leave him completely flustered. Excuse him, Y/N… (He saunters off trying not to seem defeated. Note the bright red of his ears, also!)

- He’s always happy to try things you like, even if they aren’t to his taste. He’s curious, particularly about you, so of course he wants to know all about the things you’re interested in and enjoy

- Plus, anything that means he gets to spend time with you instantly gets points from him. However, he’d much prefer your attention to be focused on him, rather than on the game itself (baffles you by asking to play and then complaining after just a short while because he wants you to give him attention lol)

Chapter Text

- Otis wouldn’t be very observant right away, often not even noticing your hand tremors. He’d even get impatient with you sometimes, wondering why it was taking you longer to do certain things

- When he realized, however, he’d feel so bad, though he wouldn’t be great at expressing it. Rather than apologizing, he’d surprise you by being uncharacteristically patient with you, and helping you out when he felt he should

- He’d also be surprisingly concerned. Becoming Otis’ S/O would mean that he cared for you very deeply, so he’d (quietly) be worried about you all the time

- Won’t say anything, but anytime he saw you struggling with something, he’d help without hesitation. When you thank him he’ll just wave it away, walking off as he’d be a little embarrassed. He wouldn’t be used to being affectionate and caring like that, so it would take him a while to get used to it. It wouldn’t stop him from being helpful and sweet in his own way, though

- Holds your hands *a lot*. It becomes a habit that he would hardly even notice, just gently snatching them up without realizing

- His family would tease him about it. While they’d find it somewhat endearing and cute, they wouldn’t be able to resist (cue Otis defensively cursing at everyone out of embarrassment) as him being so caring and gentle would be completely new to everyone

Chapter Text

Bubba:

- When you tell Bubba you have feelings for him, he’d melt. It was no secret that he had feelings for you too, but he wouldn’t have any expectations of you

- Hearing you admit your feelings would make him so happy, the reality exceeding any imagined version of it. He’d be quite surprised at first though, cheeks going pink and eyes widening as he processed it

- He wouldn’t hesitate to pull you into the tightest, sweetest hug in acknowledgement, making you grin as you wrapped your arms around him

- Good luck getting away from Bubba for a while. Now that you’ve openly admitted you have feelings, expect nothing but affection, sweetness and cuddles. He would need a lot of reassurance too, especially at first — he’d be genuinely concerned you’d change your mind :(

Chop Top:

- Chop Top would be equal parts smug and surprised. On one hand, he would want to tease you a bit, but on the other, he’d find you so sweet and wouldn’t want to ruin it

- He’d ask you if you meant it, probably several times. He would find it too good to be true at first, but later you’d realize he would just like hearing you repeat yourself, chuckling each time you answered positively

- Rather than affirming that he had feelings for you too, he would ask if it meant you were a couple. You’d shrug, saying it was up to him, to which he’d reply by swinging his arm around you as he grinned wickedly

- He won’t shut up about it for forever. Drayton (and Bubba, surprisingly. Also Grandpa?) roll their eyes when you’re both around, as he always brags about you to them. He can’t help it! He’d adore you so much and would be secretly amazed that you liked him and decided to stick around. Of course he’s going to brag!

Nubbins:

- The biggest, sweetest grin would spread across his face as he listened to you, his heart skipping a beat (several probably) at the suddenness of it. Finds you so cute, shyly admitting your feelings like that

- A blushing mess. He would quickly confirm his own feelings for you, making you smile with how shy he was about it. His words would be clumsy, cheeks red and hands fumbling as he spoke

- He’d be nothing but smiles for the rest of the day, mulling your words over and feeling honored (and surprised) to be the object of your affection

- Super clingy going forward. Follows you around like a puppy, holding your hands and wrapping his arms around you (even better: you wrap your arm around him. He’ll melt, nuzzling all close to you)

Chapter Text

- Asa is a bit…reserved, so your relationship would be very on the surface at first. He *likes* you, but actually opening up? And letting you know about his interests? Ehm.

- He’d be a bit careful and reluctant around you at first. Suspicious, even. He would be talking about something completely mundane and you’d be staring intently, causing him to slowly lose his train of thought and go quiet

- He would appreciate it more than you’d realize, though. Like, you actually wanna hear about his bugs? 👉 👈 He’s a nerd and would be happy to indulge you with his encyclopedic knowledge of insects!

- He’d get embarrassed after going on for a while, apologizing for boring you when you’d just shake your head and urge him to go on, a sweet smile erasing any doubts he had about your sincerity

- You’re so attentive and impressed by him that sometimes he’d get kind of cocky, too. Watching your eyes light up as you listened to him talk about something random would always make him laugh inwardly, not even realizing himself that he was smitten with you

- He’s attentive towards you too, far more than you’d realize. He’d pick up on things you never even mentioned, easily reading your moods and knowing your likes/dislikes without much effort. You casually mention something you’re interested in? Ahem, excuse him while he goes and learns every possible thing there is to know about it… (You’d never know it though! He’ll listen to you go on for ages about things you like too, never revealing he already knows all about it)

- Caring for him and looking after him would be met with a lot of uncertainty and awkwardness, but he loves it. Anytime you asked him questions about his well-being, or took care of any injuries he had, he’d watch you with wide, unreadable eyes, always making your heart flutter and cheeks burn. He’d go out of his way to give you opportunities to be like that with him, without even noticing it. Tries to be as unintimidating as possible around you so you’ll never be reserved or reluctant about it

- He’d start talking more frequently around you, going on about things without any hesitation or prompting, making you smile to yourself at how much he’d opened up

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- Thomas might be hesitant at first, but the second you took his burly hand into your own, he’d melt

- You would get complete creative control — he wouldn’t mind what colors you chose, and any worries of being teased by his family would disappear as he watched how eager you were

- Seeing you so fixated on his hands would make him blush beneath his mask, though he would appreciate the opportunity to freely stare at you as you worked

- He’d smile to himself every time he looked at them, and would happily let you do it again (No one, even Hoyt, dares to tease him about anything relating to you after a certain point, knowing it’s off limits! So he’ll happily show them off. Luda Mae thinks it’s precious, but is also kind of salty that you haven’t offered to do hers lol)

Brahms:

- Brahms would take any affection and attention he could get, so the second you even suggested it he’d just sit down and put his hands out for you

- You wouldn’t be able to stop smiling at how seriously he took it. He’d have a surprisingly good eye for color combinations, handing you the colors he liked and making you blush with how he focused on you

- He’d want to polish yours too: matching colors, of course (when you noticed this, you’d smile even wider, which would not go unnoticed by Brahms, who would smile in self satisfaction)

- This would probably become a regular thing. He’d adore anything like that, that made him feel close to you. Of course you have to match though! Or at the very least, coordinate 👉👈

Michael:

- Michael wouldn’t really know how to react to you asking about it, to be honest. He wouldn’t really mind, he’d just be kind of iffy about it

- It would probably take him a while to warm up to this (or pretty much anything) but he ~might~ allow it, since it’s you

- If you reach for anything pastel or colorful he’d just take your hand to stop you and shake his head, causing you to have to hold back a laugh

- He wouldn’t admit it, but he’d actually like how it looked. He’d forget about it, and would think of you every time he noticed them. He isn’t really soft but he would be for you

Jason:

- You’d be going through your nail polishes when you’d gesture for him to come over and sit, offering to paint his nails

- He agrees of course! Like he’s gonna refuse anything you wanna do for him like that!…Although you’ll have to excuse his slightly crusty hands

- He always admires your own nail polish, thinking the colors are so pretty and cute. If you offer to let him pick out the colors he’ll just shake his head, knowing you’ll choose something nice

You, reaching your hand to hold his while you polish: Okay, gimme your hand

Him, ~misunderstanding~: *takes your hand as if to hold it*

You: 🥺🥺🥺

(A bonus thought that you might disagree with: if you’d been in a relationship with Jason for a while, he’d begin to pick up on his own cuteness. Or at least, what you think is cute. And he’d take advantage of it, if only to make you smile. Also, he secretly loves the effect he has on you alsdkfj)

Bubba:

- Bubba would love this. He’d carefully watch and learn, already planning on doing yours too

- If you hold his hand while you do it his stomach would be full of butterflies, cheeks all pink beneath his mask. He adores when you’re soft with him like that

- He’d probably chip them up really quickly, to his own dismay. When he would notice, he’d want them done again asap, as they’d remind him of you

- You would melt when he did yours. He hold your hand close to his face, focusing intently and going slowly to make sure it was perfect

Chop Top:

- It would probably be his idea to be honest. He’d see you doing your nails and would excitedly pester you about it until you did his, too

- You end up getting ~playfully~ annoyed, as he’d keep pulling his hands away to look and would keep changing his mind on what colors to use

- Eventually you just snatch his hand and hold it still so you can finish. He’d stop whatever he was saying with a nervous laugh, getting surprisingly flustered at you being like that with him

- He’d be another that would paint yours, too, trying his best to pick colors that would suit you. He’d adore his, and would want to impress you by doing his best!

Nubbins:

- Nubbins would see you doing your own nails and wouldn’t even give you the opportunity to offer to do his. He’d just pick up a random color and would start doing it himself (badly)

- You don’t really notice at first but after a while you glance up and chuckle at what a sloppy job he’s done, prompting him to smile at you so sweetly that you don’t even say anything about it

- Instead, you just gesture for him to hand it over, which he happily does. You can’t help but smile at how delicately he drapes his hands into your own, allowing you to fix his mistakes and finish it

- Once you’re done he’ll continue holding your hand, too. Good luck getting unlatched for a bit. Nubbins will use any excuse he can to be close to you (tbh he doesn’t need an excuse but if he has one he’ll use it)

Beetlejuice:

- Beetlejuice would probably tease you for suggesting it, despite the fact that he’d be choosing his colors as he did

- Spooky colors only, of course! Neon purple, black, green, things like that. He’d love it, tbh

- He’d be flirting with you the entire time, enjoying the close proximity as he could watch your face flush as he spoke

- Despite his teasing, he’d actually enjoy things like that a lot. He’d love that you wanted to do things like that for him, feeling all special and cared for

Candyman:

- Daniel would probably seem a little indifferent to it at first, although he would enjoy seeing you dote over him like that

- He’d smile to himself as he watched you carefully pick colors, refraining from suggesting anything because he’d want to see what you thought would suit him

- He makes you melt the whole time, his hand gently draped over yours as you try to ignore his intense gaze, gnawing at your lip all the while

- He would unintentionally show them off *a lot*, showing off his hand way more than he normally would. You’d have to hold back smiles as you noticed, finding it so sweet

Bo:

- Sort of like Beetlejuice in that he’d tease you and act playfully annoyed like, “You want to paint my nails? Pfft, I don’t know…” (he says, while sitting down and stretching his hands across the table for you)

- Isn’t really paying attention (or so he’d have you think), just looking around or closing his eyes while you polished away, occasionally glancing over to see what you were up to when he thought you weren’t looking

- If Bo liked you, he’d pretty much go with anything tbh. You could paint his nails the softest, brightest colors and he wouldn’t even really have the heart to gripe about it, seeing you all smiley over it

- Will be all smiley himself anytime he looks at them, but if someone else notices (besides you) he’ll shoot them a death glare

Vincent:

- You wanna paint his nails? Okay! He has no hesitation whatsoever and will ask no questions — if you want to, you can

- You’re so cute to him and he loves your attention, anything you want to do like that he’ll allow. If you want to do his nails, brush/play with his hair, or anything like that, you can! In fact, please do 🥺

- Will be smiling the whole time behind his mask, happily suggesting colors if you ask. He’ll end up with cute and sparkly rainbow nails because you both keep finding different colors you like

- He would do yours, too. All the colors you couldn’t fit on his hands will go on yours! You both have equally colorful nails that will be teased by Bo and Lester, who are both secretly envious of Vincent (plz do their nails too)

Lester:

- When you asked if you could polish his nails, he’d immediately light up, loving the idea of it but quickly getting shy

- He’d disappear for a second so he could go scrub his hands and make them as clean and pretty as possible for you

- He’d be kinda nervous?? His eyes would be flickering back and forth between your face and his hands, smiling as he watched you

- Little things like this would make his heart flutter endlessly, and he’d try so hard to keep them all tidy and unchipped. (This would result in him being ridiculously delicate with everything he touched) He’d love them no matter what colors you chose!

Graverobber:

- Graverobber has some clammy, crusty hands, (I mean, he hangs out in dumpsters) so beware. Still, if you offer to paint his nails, he’ll just lazily offer up his hands without a second thought

- Watches you the whole time with a satisfied smile. Anytime you glance up and catch him, he’ll give you a look that somehow manages to be both sheepish and smug, wiggling his eyebrow to make you laugh

- He’d smile every time he looked at them, thinking of you. You’d match them to the streaks in his hair which makes him just :o !! Will show them off a lot too

- He’d wear them until they were completely chipped up (which wouldn’t take long), patiently hoping you’d offer to do them again

Luigi:

- Luigi would initially agree with no complaints, but chances are you’ll only get a few nails done before he gets impatient

- He feels kind of bad about it later, though, seeing them unfinished and smiling a bit as they reminded him of you. If he’s in a grouchy mood he’ll ease up right away when he sees them

- He’ll let you finish later, though not without some amount of awkwardness, as he’d be embarrassed to bring it back up

- Of course, you’re happy to do it though! You snatch his hands right up and get to work, choosing colors such as black, red and white. He’d smile the whole time he watched you. His expression would change freakishly fast if someone interrupted, though

Pavi:

- He probably paints his nails anyways, but he’d always be happy to be doted over by you, so of course he’ll accept your offer!

- If you offer while he’s already wearing nail polish he’ll quickly run off and remove it so you won’t change your mind

- Compliments you the whole time, even if you’re just messing around. You end up giggling the whole time at how extra he is, calling you an artist and talented and actually making you blush quite a bit with how sincere he was about it

- Shows his nails off endlessly, staring at them constantly and making it a point to be as showy with his hands as possible. The moment they chip he’ll be so over-the-top dramatic, only feeling better once you’ve redone them (you will forever be Pavi’s manicurist from then on, sigh)

Billy Lenz:

- Probably confused by it, but he’d be happy to give it a try. He’d watch you intently the entire time, saying very little

- …Which would result in you getting nervous, low-key trying to rush through it and accidentally messing one or two up (Cue Billy looking at you like smh, Y/N, smh…)

- He’s only messing though, he genuinely couldn’t care less about it really. You could be painting his whole finger and he doesn’t even mind because he’s more focused on you and the fact that you’re doing something like that for him

- He is unused to being treated like this so he never really knows how to react. Any kind of looking after will always be met with some amount of nervousness, though he adores it. Will retreat to the attic afterwards and just stare at his nails like 🥺 (Even the messy ones! Especially the messy ones tbh)

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- He’d agree to you doing his nails so quickly that you’d actually be shocked, not expecting compliance at all. He’d offer up his hands so willingly that your jaw would almost hit the floor

- Nothing flashy! He just wants tidy, pretty nails. He’s very sure about what he wants, which would almost make you laugh, as he’d be quite assertive about it

- Needless to say, he’d stare at you intently the whole time, lips twisted into a small but wicked smile as he noticed your cheeks flushing and eyes refusing to meet his

- He’ll do yours too, of course. You have to bite your lip the whole time to keep yourself from smiling because he’s so meticulous. He’ll carefully choose a color, eyeing you for approval before pulling your hand close to his face, seriously and slowly polishing each nail

Otis Driftwood:

- Otis will absent-mindedly swat your hand away when you try to do his nails. However, when he glanced over to see you frowning at his grouchiness, he’ll feel bad and will just roll his eyes as he gives up his hands

- Will complain the whole time though. It smells! It’s cold! Stop squeezing my hand! (Tbh he loves these kinds of gestures, but he’s guarded, to put it simply, so he doesn’t know how to deal with it. So, he’ll gripe, all while staring at you lovingly when you aren’t looking)

- You end up using simple colors such as black and white, and he would end up liking it much better than he thought he would. In fact, he’d want you to do it again in the future, but would be too embarrassed about his complaining to ask

- You’re going to have to give the whole family manicures now too though, especially Baby (honestly probably pedicures too? They’d get greedy lol)

Chapter Text

- These two would get so caught up in their own little competition to win your feelings that they’d begin to forget what it was even about

- Nubbins would be doing his best to woo you (which, coming from Nubbins, is unique to say the least) when Chop Top runs over and shoves poor Nubbins into oblivion. It’s his turn!

- However, they begin to argue before Chop Top can even shoot his shot, leaving you feeling a bit guilty but also trying not to laugh as their argument would veer off into totally unrelated subjects

- You quickly get overwhelmed by their unrelenting attention, the two both anxiously trying to seduce you to the best of their abilities, which are very unpracticed and chaotic. When one finally lays off for a while, the other will appear

- Drayton and Bubba are *tired*. You’re the topic of conversation half the time and their usual antics are amplified greatly by what they view as a competition for your feelings

- Despite the chaos, however, they’re both quite sweet and charming in their own ways. Nubbins is particularly sweet around you — he’s always doing his best to impress you, blushing relentlessly at any attention you give him. He’s a bit more shy than Chop Top, often staring at you and easily getting flustered

- Chop Top is better at getting *you* to blush. He’d also have a talent at getting you to laugh and smile easily, to his satisfaction. Asks you a million questions about your interests and such too, listening intently to whatever you have to say as he’s genuinely intrigued by you

- No matter who you choose, it’s okay of course. In the end they’ll get over it (and will often remind you that you can change your mind if you want lol)

- Plot twist! You choose Bubba or Drayton. Chop Top and Nubbins just blame each other for ruining the other’s chance (only kidding of course. Unless you do choose one of them, in which case, good for you!)

Chapter Text

- If you enjoy walking in the woods, this will become a regular thing with Bubba. He enjoys them too, since he gets to spend time with you!

- He’s so easily fascinated and amazed by things. Your walk is slow-going because he wants to stop and smell the roses, so to speak! He will stop to admire every little thing, pointing out things you didn’t notice

- Will collect things as you go — flowers, leaves, acorns, stones and so on. He’s crafty and will no doubt find a way to make interesting things out of them!

- You end up with flowers and clovers in your hair or behind your ears. Will blush if you do the same for him, as it makes him feel cute. Won’t remove them for ages! He’ll also keep the ones you picked for him among his things, even when they dry out

- If there’s any rough parts he’ll insist on holding your hand. If you even seem like you’re going to trip, he’ll panic, firmly helping you along. If there’s any thistles or thorns? No way, you have to pick a different path!

- He’s surprisingly peaceful company. He’ll explore wherever you like (again — assuming it isn’t dangerous!) for as long as you like. He’s the type to notice little details and be easily amazed, which helps you to appreciate things more yourself

- Sometimes you bring along a blanket to sky-watch as well, lying down somewhere pretty and watching the birds through the trees. He adores this! So much! Especially if it’s at night and you watch the stars. You can’t help but smile at how awe struck he is

- He loves all the forest animals! If you like them too, he’ll point them out excitedly every time (he’ll do this anyways tbh) Will be /delighted/ if he sees any squirrels, frogs, chipmunks, etc.

- This time is so precious and peaceful for him! Before you know it he’ll be inviting you out without you having to bring it up. Eventually, he’ll start bringing drinks and snacks for picnics, so you can explore longer!

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- Thomas would find your height so precious, but he’d also be extra gentle and careful with you, since you’re smaller

- If you were insecure about your height he’d be so confused. He’d feel ridiculous standing by you, feeling all big and bulky — why are *you* insecure?

- It might actually make him feel a little better, in a weird way. If you could be insecure about something that he found cute about you, maybe it would be the same the other way around?

Brahms:

- He *adores* your height. You’re so small next to him he could melt

- Would nearly engulf you with his hugs, wrapping you up in his cardigan and loving how folded up in him you were

- When you mentioned you were insecure about it, he’d tilt his head in confusion and would very firmly tell you that whoever made you feel insecure about being short was *wrong*, no further discussion!

Michael:

- Michael would simply raise an eyebrow at the sudden revelation that you’re insecure about your height, unsure why anyone would think being short is bad

- I mean Michael really isn’t the guy to go to for reassurance, but he’d somehow manage to make you feel better about it anyway, just by not even really understanding and being confused by why anyone would care

- Michael isn’t the type to easily get close to you or be affectionate, so when you kept your distance from him when he tried, he’d get kind of upset. Like…he’s /trying/ Y/N!…What’re you doing T-T When you explained it was because you feel kind of ridiculous because of being shorter, he’ll just sigh, wrapping his arm around you to reassure you in his own subtle way

Jason:

- Like Thomas, Jason would feel a little bulky and big next to you, so hearing you admit that you were insecure about your height would surprise him a lot

- Scrambling clumsily right away to reassure you, as he would with any insecurity you had

- You’re so small next to him! He thinks you’re so cute, he melts anytime you look up to meet his gaze or stand on your tiptoes to kiss him. Very protective and gentle

Bubba:

- Bubba thinks you’re the cutest. You’re so small next to him, he’d want to wrap you up and protect you

- Like Thomas, he’d also be extra careful and gentle with you out of fear he might hurt you accidentally. If you reassured him however, he’d be so affectionate, spoiling you with all the hugs and little pats on the head that he could

- If you mention that you’re insecure about your height, he’d shake his head vehemently to reassure you. He loves your height!

Chop Top:

- Chop Top doesn’t even notice your height until you point it out by telling him you’re insecure about it

- He’ll reassure you kind of strangely by listing off some of the benefits of being shorter, all while chuckling nervously and watching your reactions to see if it was working

- Just be patient and go with it! He wants to make you feel better but it makes him surprisingly nervous because he isn’t used to it and doesn’t know what to say. He’s sincere though!

Nubbins:

- He loves your height difference! He isn’t picky though, he wouldn’t mind either way. Still, he can’t help but think it’s so cute how small you are next to him

- Honestly though he really doesn’t think too much about it. Height is height, y'know? He’d think it’s cute but it wouldn’t be something he noticed right away or anything like that

- When you tell him you’re insecure about your height, he’ll really just be confused as to why. He’s always liked your height!

Beetlejuice:

- Beetlejuice is on the shorter side (at least compared to everyone else on this list) so of course he’d love it! You’d make him feel taller lol

- Will reassure you about any insecurities you have with joking self deprecating humor to cheer you up (and let you know that he also has some insecurities, even if he doesn’t always show them)

- In all seriousness, he’ll actually be pretty good at making you feel better about it. Definitely makes a comment or two about how ridiculous it is that anyone told you it’s a bad thing though!

Candyman:

- Daniel is so over-the-top romantic, he’d just spoil you with pretty words until you felt better

- Anytime you mentioned anything you were insecure about, he’d be very quick to bombard you with compliments and affection

- He loves your height. Makes you swoon by lifting your chin gently with his finger anytime he kisses you, or anytime he’s being particularly sweet with his verbal affection

Bo:

- Bo finds your height cute. He really wouldn’t get why you were insecure about it

- But Bo being Bo, he’d have a hard time being sweet and reassuring about it. He wants to so bad, he loves you so much and wants to tell you that you’re cute and reassure you, but like…./how/

- So when you bring it up one day it would be responded to with awkward, angry babbling about how you having nothing to be insecure about. He’d genuinely want to make you feel better but he’d also be mad at whoever told you you’re too short

Vincent:

- Vincent is so sweet and understanding with any insecurities you have. He has his fair share of them too, so he know how it feels

- Similar to Bo, he’d be upset that anyone made you feel insecure about it anyways. He’ll be surprisingly defensive if anyone makes any comments like that while he’s around

- Really loves everything about you and wants you to too. Definitely a sweetheart when it comes to reassuring you and making you feel better about it

Lester:

- Lester is also on the shorter side (again just by slasher standards lol) so he thinks it’s cute!

- He wouldn’t really mind about height either way. Tall or short, it would matter to him. But when you told him you were insecure about it, he’d be so quick to reassure you

- Lester is a sweetheart. If he even suspects you’re insecure about something he’ll clumsily compliment you on whatever it is. He also loves that you’re both on the shorter side, will say you have to stick together for that reason x-x (he can tell if you feel insecure while standing next to him too, which will earn you a reassuring pat on the arm and a cute smile to make you feel better)

Graverobber:

- He’ll probably tease you a little about it, I won’t lie. He can be kind of a butt sometimes (I mean this lovingly I promise)

- Only he can tease you, though. If anyone else says a word about it he’ll get uncharacteristically serious and defensive, especially if you are visibly bothered by it

- He loves your height though, and will take advantage of it. Your head is now his arm/hand rest, and he’ll pat it a lot randomly, too. If he’s in a softer mood, he’ll actually be really sweet and reassuring. Definitely loves engulfing you with his hugs, too

Luigi:

- If anyone made any comments about your height while Luigi was around (or even so much as looked at you the wrong way) he’ll be so defensive of you

- If you put physical distance between yourself and him because you don’t want it to be obvious, he’ll actually be kind of hurt? He feels better by you and might be a bit bitter

- This will only encourage him to help you overcome your insecurity, though

Pavi:

- Pavi adores everything about you, including your height of course. Genuinely shocked when you admit you’re insecure about it, in his own overly dramatic way

- Pavi has insecurities too, so he’s actually quite good at reassuring you. Makes you laugh with how over-the-top he is as he showers you with compliments, most of which aren’t even related to your height, to cheer you up

- If anyone makes you feel bad about your height or says anything he’ll turn so red (not that you can really tell) and ardently defend you! (not without some timidity of course)

Billy Lenz:

- He’d probably call you nicknames related to your height at first, to be honest. He wouldn’t even think it would upset you, as he’d find your height cute

- The second he realized you were insecure about it though he’d feel so bad, clamming up and apologizing right away. Even if you didn’t mind his nicknames he wouldn’t use them anymore

- Compliments and reassures you a lot, even when you don’t bring it up. He’d actually be pretty observant of you, always able to tell if you were feeling insecure, quickly (and clumsily) bombarding you with a bunch of sweet words, watching your expression and grinning in self-satisfaction when he finally got you to crack a smile

Asa (The Collector):

- You won’t even have to mention being insecure about your height, he’s intuitive enough to notice on his own

- He’d notice just by your body language when you were next to him, keeping your distance as you’d feel ridiculous standing by him. He’d be wickedly amused, pulling you closer to him and winding his arm tightly around you

- Despite being kind of a tease, he really likes your height and doesn’t want you to be insecure. So in his own way, he’ll /try/ to reassure you

Chapter Text

Brahms:

- Brahms would wake up to the sound of your crying, his heart sinking before he could even open his eyes

- He had nightmares too, so he knew exactly how to comfort you. Not from experience sadly, but from what he wished someone would have done for him

- He’d wrap his arms around you, caressing your back as he let you recover from your nightmare. If you wanted to talk of course you’d be welcome to, though he wouldn’t push it

- So concerned about you throughout the following day, following you around even more than usual and trying to cheer you up in his own way. If you don’t want to get out of bed because of it, he’s happy to oblige, keeping you company and comforting you as long as you like

Billy Lenz:

- Probably watches you sleep tbh so he’ll notice you’re having a nightmare and will wake you up

- Out of this group, he’s the one who knows how to comfort you least. He would want to, but mostly, he just waits until you stop crying and gives you your space

- If you snuggle up to him or hug him for comfort, he won’t object! This is easier than trying to find something comforting to say so he’ll happily wrap his arms around you and nuzzle up to you in hopes that it makes you feel better

- Very patient though. You can stay in bed all day and he’ll leave you be if you like, giving you time to feel better (Of course, he won’t complain if you want him to stay in bed with you, either)

Jason:

- Jason would rarely sleep, so like Billy, he’d notice before you woke up. When he noticed tears falling from your closed eyes, he’d panic, gently shaking you by the shoulder to wake you up

- Lets out a little sigh of relief when he realizes it was a nightmare, though he’d be concerned to see you so upset by it

- Even under the circumstances, he wouldn’t be able to help but blush when your arms found their way around his waist, snuggling up to him for comfort. He was consistently amazed that you could find comfort in him and wanted to be close to him like that

- Puts his own embarrassment aside though and comforts you. Honestly he’s so comforting that he’d probably put you to sleep again despite being upset, as I think Jason would make his S/O feel very safe

Bubba:

- Instant concern and panic! He hates seeing you upset about anything. His heart breaks at the sight of you waking up crying and he’ll get watery-eyed himself

- So many hugs and snuggles. Roughly pets your head and wipes away your tears until you stop crying

- If you don’t want to get out of bed for a bit that’s fine by him! He’ll take care of you until you feel better, checking in and effortlessly cheering you up with how sweet and caring he is

- Will make a habit of trying to get you in a good mood and thinking of happy things before bed so you won’t have nightmares

Chop Top:

- He has nightmares too sometimes so he knows how it is :(

- Always kind of panics when you cry. His normal goofy expression would fall into a drawn, concerned look as he realized how upset you were, scrambling to comfort you

- Little head pats and hugs until you stop crying. He isn’t naturally the best at comforting, but he really tries

- Good at getting your mind off of it and distracting you. Will talk about anything and everything in hopes to make you forget about it and feel better

Chapter Text

- Bo isn’t as ignorant as you might guess so, although you might have to explain certain things to him, it wouldn’t be as much as you might think

- And although Bo is definitely a jerk at times, he isn’t a jerk about it at all. In fact, he’s quite tactful, believe it or not? He doesn’t have much to say but he’ll surprise you when he does by actually being knowledgeable and supportive in his own way

- If anyone were to ever be rude to you about it he will snap. He is very defensive of you and has no problems confronting anyone who upsets you

- He’d help you however he could. Coming from him, it might sometimes be in more subtle ways (such as letting you borrow his clothes, and taking you shopping) but he would want you to know as non-verbally as he could manage (he isn’t the most expressive person) that he supports you

- He’s actually really concerned and caring about you but isn’t the best at actually outright asking about things or expressing it

- So proud of you tbh! Despite being emotionally reserved, he’ll actually tell you, especially when he thinks you need to hear it. He can be surprisingly sweet if it’s just you and him

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- Thomas often smells of sweat and metal, and sometimes a little musty from the basement. He doesn’t want to but it is what it is :/ He isn’t opposed to cleaning up, however! At his cleanest, he’ll have a soapy, woody smell.

Brahms:

- Not as bad as you might think. He’s a little dusty and sweaty but the faded smell of detergent from his cardigan remains, blended with his natural smell. Could be better, could be worse.

Michael:

- I picture him mostly smelling of outside, if that makes sense. Like weirdly fresh? If you smell a lil too deep you’ll get a whiff of something metallic along with a weird look from him :^) Somehow he doesn’t smell bad at all though! ~Crisp~

Jason:

- Depends! He looks pretty clean in the second/third movie. Probably smells earthy and woodsy, like bonfires, pine, and rainy autumn leaves. However, in the later movies, he’ll smell a little less fresh :< He’s musty and dirt-covered, so…

Bubba:

- All the Sawyers (*maybe* except Drayton. MAYBE) don’t smell great. Bubba smells a little sweaty and the smell of blood and meat lingers on him a bit too. He ~occasionally~ tries to put in more of an effort, adding perfume/cologne and cleaning up a bit, though it would just blend with his other smells lol but he tried :<

Chop Top:

- Probably not great? From afar he’ll smell like some cheap, fruity and sweet perfume he randomly found and liked. Might also smell like outside, though not in a bad way. Fresh air, grass and rain smell! But if you get too close… :|

Nubbins:

- Nubbins smells like sweat and dirt. Honestly he could be worse? A slight improvement from his brothers. Doesn’t really put in much of an effort, but he doesn’t naturally smell that bad. Just a lil dusty?

Beetlejuice:

- I mean, you might except him to stink (and he definitely does) but also kinda smells good? Like he *does* smell like dirt and must, but there’s a weird hint of something like patchouli, herbs, licorice and crisp autumn air lingering on him as well :o

Candyman:

- He *should* smell not great, all things considered, but I just can’t see that so :> Musk, warm honey and spice. He’s so alluring and captivating, his smell would have to match that (at least in my mind x_x)

Bo:

- Sexy :/ Like alcohol, car oil, sweat and faded woody/spicy cologne :/ :/ :/ (maybe it isn’t sexy and I’m weird idk)

Vincent:

- I mean, it goes without saying that he’d smell mostly of wax. He doesn’t smell bad, however. He’d smell a little like detergent from his sweaters, and if he’s had a shower he’ll smell like sweetly scented shampoo and fresh linen. Very faint, but sweet and clean scent

Lester:

- If he’s been working he’ll smell like carcass, sweat and dirt :| If he hasn’t and he’s cleaned up, he still might smell a little ~musky~, but also like cheap scented soap and body spray :’)

Graverobber:

- He probably doesn’t smell very nice all things considered? He hangs out in graveyards and dumpsters so :o Probably smells like dirt!…Maybe mixed with the smell of rain and a bit like someone else’s perfume

Luigi Largo:

- Luigi would smell of coffee and some sort of expensive, fresh cologne. Something woody and citrus. Might smell like sweat a little too because he gets angry and worked up easily

Pavi Largo:

- Pavi would also wear expensive fragrance - something with amber, woody musk and floral undertones. You would be able to smell it from a good ways off too. Probably refreshes his scent several times a day with one of those dramatic poof spray bottle things

Billy Lenz:

- I mean, attic smell :/ If you don’t know what I mean: dust and old cardboard. Not really the worst smell? Just not great. Definitely not as stinky as some of them! He’ll actually wash up (at your request, anyways) and remove some of the cobwebs from his hair :’) When he does, he’ll smell like your soap and shampoo. A little trace of the dusty smell remains forever though :<

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- Regular Asa would smell good. He’s very clean and tidy, and probably smells faintly of aftershave and a fresh detergent with just a hint of his natural smell. If he’s in his collector persona, he’d smell the same, with the addition of latex and disinfectant. If he’s been particularly ~active~, he’ll smell metallic and sweaty.

Otis Driftwood:

- He doesn’t smell good normally. Metal, cigarettes, alcohol and dirt. If he cleans up he’ll smell about the same tbh lol, maybe slightly less dirty and metallic but he’d perpetually smell a little grimy

Charles Lee Ray:

- You know he probably uses a specific kind of shampoo/conditioner so anytime a breeze rolls by you get a whiff of highly scented hair products :o Also: clean clothes, aftershave and something herbal and spicy that you can’t quite put your finger on

Tiffany Valentine:

- Cigarettes, cheap perfume, and *slightly* like the smell of makeup and spearmint. Her perfume would be something floral, spicy and warm. Probably something with jasmine

Chapter Text

- Chop Top will be elated when you reveal the news to him. Literally won’t shut up. This is half because excitement and half from the realization that he’d soon be a parent. Not that he’s upset! It would just take a second for it to sink in

- He’s surprisingly good with you, and will keep his antics away from you during your pregnancy (at least to some extent). Will surprise his brothers by being uncharacteristically stern if they act up around you, shooing them off or dragging you away

- Alternatively, he wouldn’t treat you differently at all. He’d be pretty unaware, especially at first. A little chaotic but he’ll learn :’)

- He loves baby shopping so much. Picks out the most bizarre outfits, most of which are in his own style (you are left wondering where he even finds half of it)

- Probably the type to take awkward pregnancy photos but he’s completely serious about it

- Picking baby names is as you’d expect. You try to make lists but they end up being a mess of too many names you both add. Mysteriously, the ones he hates that you like get scribbled out (he likes surprisingly cute and unique names??)

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- Pretty unfazed by it, though he doesn’t particularly enjoy anyone popping out in front of him (insert him glaring at the actors until they walk off in defeat)

- Concerned that you’ll be scared though 🥺 Has his eye on you the whole time because he’s afraid you’ll get startled. If you’re visibly enjoying yourself he’ll just :’) because you’re so cute and interesting

- His heart will explode if you get scared and hold his hand or something like that. Reads a lot into it and is happy you feel protected by him and such. Can’t stop smiling to himself, very pure

Brahms:

- Good luck trying to get Brahms to leave the house at all, let alone for something so ~unnecessary~ :/

- In the unlikely event that he would go, he’ll be complaining about how ridiculous it is the whole time, if only to attempt to seem like he isn’t secretly trying not to jump at everything happening (Literally squeezing your hand the whole time. It keeps getting worse. RIP your hand)

- If you get scared and cling to him? This will change things. He is now proud of himself. All the stuff he was just freaked out by suddenly isn’t scary! (Ok, it is, but he can handle it better if he feels like he’s protecting you)

Michael:

Haunted house employee: *jumps out and tries to scare you*

Michael:

Haunted house employee: :/

- He doesn’t hate it, he just…Doesn’t have any reactions at all

- Admittedly he probably loves Halloween-themed things. Finds it amusing, but of course, you’ll never be able to tell. If you get freaked out easily he won’t be the most comforting because he kinda thinks it’s funny lol

Jason:

- He isn’t startled by anything really, but you gotta explain in advance because if someone tries to scare you or looks threatening he’ll be…Protective 💀

- Mostly he’s just fascinated that you enjoy that sort of thing? Probably really attentive to everything and all your reactions because he’s intrigued lol

- No opinion really, it’s not his thing but if you like it he’s okay with pretty much anything

Bubba:

- Scared x_x Startled at each loud noise, music and jump scare. Clings to you all the while, confused as to why you even wanted to come

- If you’re visibly enjoying it, he’ll ease up a bit, trying to enjoy himself and see the appeal for your sake. If it’s visually appealing/creative/pretty he’ll actually end up liking it? If it’s just pop-outs and stuff though then probably not :/

- Instant blushing if you hold his hand or grab him when you get scared. Better yet, just hold his hand throughout the whole thing :^)

Chop Top:

- Gets genuinely startled and scared believe it or not, though he enjoys it and laughs each time. Probably won’t stop commentating the whole time though

- Ooo look at that! *gremlin laughter* (he says, while pointing at some random gruesome thing that leaves you like :O but what did you expect)

- If you like that sort of thing, it will give him ~ideas~. He’ll decorate everything all spooky and such and will attempt to scare you throughout the season (and just in general really)

Nubbins:

- Like Chop Top will get startled easily but enjoys it. Insists on going through more than once, or at least finding another one to go through

- Probably won’t notice if you get scared because he’s too fascinated by everything so :o If you hold his hand or anything he’ll blush so much though

- If he catches you getting startled he’ll be both teasing and reassuring. You can get scared Y/N it’s ok but it’s all fake you know… (he says as if he hasn’t gotten scared several times)

Beetlejuice:

- He will either be really underwhelmed because obvious reasons, or he’ll just find the whole thing funny

- You like being scared? He can definitely do better than any haunted house 👀

- Chaotic times ensue! He’ll try to get a reaction out of you going forward by scaring you when you least expect it. Of course coming from him there really isn’t any limit as to what can happen so x_x

Candyman:

- Similarly to Jason, he’s just kind of amused that you enjoy that sort of thing. Weirdo (lovingly) :’)

- Very unlikely that he’ll actually get startled but he’s not going to complain if you cling to him if you’re scared (but of course, if you like being scared, maybe he’ll just leave you be and let you have fun)

- Doesn’t pay much attention to anything going on, and just smiles lovingly at you the whole time

Bo:

- Pfft a haunted house? He’ll humor you of course, but he’ll tease you about it

- If you get scared and grab onto him he’ll be so cocky though he’ll seem playfully annoyed. Attempts to conceal his smile but fails :’)

- Will never admit it, but he gets startled throughout. If you bring it up he’ll never do it again though, so… x_x

Vincent:

- Not really his thing, though he’ll enjoy seeing all the displays and such

- Vincent would be willing to do just about anything if you enjoyed it, though. He isn’t easily startled at least, although he’ll make you smile by jumping a time or two at pop-outs and brushing up against you as he draws back

- If you get startled he’ll laugh to himself a bit, though you’ll probably miss it. Smiles his way through after that

Lester:

- He wouldn’t enjoy anything really extreme but would love the traditional ones! Actually really fun :’)

- Easily startled and makes you laugh at his reactions each time. Very cute and will clutch his heart and laugh at himself, teasing you (lovingly) if you get startled too

- Will melt instantly if you grab onto him at any point though or hold his hand on your way through, giving it a squeeze and smiling over at you

Billy Lenz:

- Kind of chaotic as he’d be a bit overwhelmed. He’d be fascinated though and he does enjoy it. Laughs at some of the displays/actors lol

- If you get startled at any point and hold his hand/grab him he’ll be like oH! And proceeds to do the same thing throughout the rest of it

- Will take any excuse to be clingy he can get. In all seriousness though I think he’d really enjoy any time spent with you at all, regardless of what you’re up to. So no complaints from him in other words :^)

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- He’ll be another one that’s kind of difficult to convince. Thinks the whole thing is kind of silly, but he’ll begrudgingly agree if you really want to

- Probably staring at everything with wide eyes. Especially you tbh. He’s constantly fascinated by you and your interests/reactions to things

- He’d be kind of amused if you get scared at anything because like…You’re with *him*. You’ve definitely seen some things but you jump at random, fake-looking pop outs with loud noises? Hmm

Otis Driftwood:

- Depends on his mood! He can be grumpy but if he likes you well enough and he’s in an okay mood it can be fun. He likes anything ~spooky~ (to put it lightly) so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

- Similar to Asa if you get easily startled. Like, really Y/N? Pfft. (He obviously thinks you’re cute though. No, he isn’t going to hold your hand so you feel better. He says as he’s holding your hand)

- Will make remarks about how his own creations look better though :/ (eyeballs you to see if you agree)

Charles Lee Ray:

- He’ll complain about it up until the point that you get visibly startled. Then, he won’t stop laughing and teasing you about it

- Kind of annoying, he’ll probably try to make it worse for you throughout. Laughs each time you jump. Will have no complaints if you’d like to hold onto him throughout, although he’ll probably tease you for it

- No, he did *not* just get startled at that sudden pop-out. Don’t even ask! (he did)

Tiffany Valentine:

- Cute ;-; She’d be fascinated by everything, and adores all the spookiness! She gets startled with each jump scare but enjoys it, laughing at herself for getting scared

- Might take advantage and cling to you a little just because. If you are scared she won’t stop teasing you, only because she finds it sweet

- Will watch you out of the corner of her eye the whole time, melting at your reactions to jump scares and random loud noises. Makes a mental note to make it a tradition so she can see it every year :’)

Chapter Text

- Asa spots you one day as he’s walking home, and barely pays any mind to you at first. He’s a little intrigued to see you rummaging through some tall grass on the side of the street but continues, glancing over with a raised eyebrow

- When he notices you picking up what looks like an insect, of course he gets more curious and stops. You hold it gently in your palms and smile at it so brightly that he’s almost endeared. He can’t help but feel a little connected to anyone who loves and appreciates bugs after all

- You catch him staring and turn, offering him a closer look at what you’re holding. Even though he’s a stranger, he looks toward your hands so curiously that you can’t help but find it a bit sweet, and show him without much reservation

- He quietly comes up and looks, taking it into his own hand and examining it as he does with his big sparkly eyes. He’d start rambling about what sort of bug it is and how rare it is, while you nod along and smile, completely taken with how knowledgeable he is

- He gets a soft spot for you pretty easily with how well you listen and how interested you seem. When he talks about his own collection and lets slip that he’s an entomologist, your interest would be piqued even more (which doesn’t go unnoticed by him)

- Absolutely will offer to show you his collection at some point, but he actually means his bugs because he would like you right away. Your innocent personality combined with your shared interests would actually make him a little protective. You shouldn’t go around just talking to any random stranger about things, after all! Not everyone is a harmless, well-meaning, insect-loving stranger like him *wink wonk*

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- You’re so cute 🥺 And pretty 👉👈 No he isn’t staring! (If you catch him he’ll be so embarrassed plz)

- Brings you flowers he finds around the fields and forest surrounding the house, thinking of you each time he sees them :’)

- He really isn’t one to care too much about style but he thinks you’re so bright and pretty! Probably feels a little insecure about himself since he is all dirty and such but if you reassure him he’ll be wrapped around your finger

(a random thought: Thomas would adore being doted over, complimented and praised. I will not elaborate at this time lol x_x)

Brahms:

- Thinks you’re so cute and will stare at you very obviously. Not really in a creepy way? (Okay kind of creepy) But he just thinks you’re pretty!

- Plushies? He will melt at how cute this is. Will also steal one, but he’ll feel bad about later and will return it (hoping you don’t notice it disappeared)

- Constantly admiring you and complimenting you. He adores your style and isn’t shy to tell you so

Michael:

- Pretty indifferent to personal style and appearance in general, tbh. Still, he’d be a bit amused by your love of pink and cute things like plushies. You are the total opposite of him and he can’t help but find it a little endearing

- Anytime he sees cute and pinks things while ~out and about~ he tilts his head and thinks of you. Contemplates taking it to you but…No

- Well, maybe. Sometimes. Only if he knows you won’t know it was him that gave it, though. (Cue you finding a random plushie you’ve never seen before among your own and being like…Michael??? *door closes in distance as he quickly exits*)

Jason:

- Jason doesn’t care too much about style and such, you’re perfect no matter what! Still, he does find you totally adorable

- Like Thomas, he’ll bring you things like flowers and such he finds that reminds him of you

- He adores how colorful your outfits can be and how bright you are. Your love for plushies is also extremely sweet to him :’) (brings you a random forest animal one day since you seemingly like fluffy little animals and you’re like um…Jason what am I supposed to do with this squirrel :/ and the squirrel is like lol yall why :/ but he MEANS WELL)

Bubba:

- Bubba adores it so much. You look like a doll, wearing all pink, skirts, heels, etc.

- Supportive and compliments you a lot. Notices anytime you wear something new and makes sure you know how pretty it is! If he sees something pretty and pink you’re definitely getting it

- Also thinks your love of plushies is very cute. He’s pretty crafty and will probably make you his own version if you like

Chop Top:

- Thinks you’re cute! Gives weird compliments though but he means well

- He’ll steal your clothes and plushies sometimes. He’ll also give you new ones though, don’t worry y/n :^)

- He would like any kind of personal expression as far as style goes. Whatever that means to each individual doesn’t matter, but he would appreciate when people (you in this context) outwardly express themselves. In other words he likes your style a lot lol:)

Nubbins:

- No comment really, especially at first, but thinks you’re cute. No, he isn’t staring. No, he isn’t blushing, either. sHH

- Gives you plushies that are slightly dirty that came from who knows where. He’s very eager and happy about it so….accept and cherish them lol

- Cute and shy compliments. You’re pretty 🥺 You’re so bright and colorful :’) You look like a flower <3 things like that (very supportive in other words, says sweet stuff like that every day)

Bo:

- Thinks you’re cute, and he’ll be sure to tell you often in his own way

- He is shameless when it comes to admiring you. He would no matter what your style was to be honest, looking you up and down while you watch and grinning if he gets you to blush

- Calls you surprisingly sweet monikers (honey, sweetheart, etc) constantly. So often, in fact, that when he actually uses your name you get surprised

Vincent:

- Subtle and probably doesn’t seem to notice/pay much attention, visibly. He definitely does notice though, he’s just more of the ~admires from afar~ type

- Makes you pretty art you inspired. Paintings, wax figurines, etc. all in pastel colors and of pretty things that reminded him of you

- He really thinks you’re so pretty regardless of style though. Like of course he loves your style. But you could really wear a potato sack and he’d think you’re the most beautiful person because he’s romantic lol

Lester:

- Genuinely admires you. You’re so pretty and bright! He’ll stare when he thinks you aren’t looking, shyly turning away if you catch him (or just smiling shamelessly because why wouldn’t he stare??)

- Gives the cutest compliments. They’re always a little awkward and badly phrased which is what makes them so endearing

- Your love for plushies really does him in. It’s the cutest thing ever and he’s very supportive, also loves them he learns. If he finds them while out and about he’ll pick one up every now and then and melts at your reactions to them

Billy Lenz:

- Fascinated, he loves your bright colors and style. He’s another one that doesn’t really care about style and appearance and such, but he thinks you’re very pretty:)

- He already calls you his piggy anyways but since you’re so pretty and colorful, now he has a million other variations to call you

- Billy, like Brahms, would also steal one of your plushies. However, as Billy is a gremlin, he would not return it. Tough luck, Y/N :^)

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- He adores your style so much and isn’t shy to express it. You’re wearing heels/skirt? Asa will be staring shamelessly

- He thinks of you more than you’d think. Anytime he sees something that reminds him of you, he’ll surprise you with it, though in a subtle way, leaving it for you to find later (will wait around for you to mention something about it later expectantly)

- 100% will give you bug plushies with a deadly serious face. Don’t laugh, Y/N 👀

Tiffany Valentine:

- She adores it! You have similar tastes but you’re like the pastel, pink version and she thinks it’s precious (this would be such a cute pair T-T)

- Shopping trips :’) She gets mostly gothic and dark things and you’re the opposite and it’s *cute*

- Thinks you’re the cutest and is sure to tell you often. She can be really sweet so her compliments reflect that

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- Honestly I think he would love to have a pet so he is instantly intrigued, albeit a little hesitant because he’d be adorably respectful of your pets space and wouldn’t want to push his luck

- Very cute, bonds with your pet easily and is so gentle. He thinks you’re both the cutest and finds it so sweet you bring them along everywhere

- Also very protective of you both! If his family makes comments (mostly Hoyt, Luda Mae and Monty like your pet, Luda thinks you’re adorable and also likes seeing Thomas interact with them) he’ll be very moody and defensive, and eventually the topic is off-limits to tease you about

Brahms:

- It’s mentioned Brahms isn’t good with animals if I remember right, so he might not be the best with your pet at first

- But since the pet is so important to you, he’ll learn. He still might not be great around animals in general but he’ll be friendly with yours

- I can see Brahms being a cat person once he gets used to them. He and your cat would end up with a mutual respect for each other lol like they both stay out of each other’s ways, until they don’t (and you walk in with your cat snuggled up next to him while he sleeps T-T)

Michael:

- Very indifferent, as usual. Really doesn’t even notice, it’s just one of the many things about you that he’s a little intrigued by/finds endearing

- He isn’t really the animal type normally but since you seem to care for your pet so much he’ll just mostly ignore it

- One day you walk in on him petting your pet or them sitting on his lap when he thought you weren’t around and he just freezes and stares at you lol

Jason:

- Thinks it’s endearing. Won’t easily interact with your animal because he’s afraid he’ll accidentally hurt them (even though he’s gentle around you and your pet and could never)

- He already thinks you’re the sweetest, but this only makes him adore you even more. You’re so loving and caring and he can’t help but watch you like :’)

- Also very protective of your pet. Since you care so much about them he’ll be so gentle and makes sure they’re always safe and there isn’t anything harmful around/they can’t get lost

Bubba:

- Very sweet, as usual. He loves your pet right away. Similar to Jason, he might be a little hesitant at first but when he’s comfortable he’s the cutest

- 100% supportive of you bringing them everywhere with you because he gets attached too

- Also protective of your pet. Drayton is iffy about the whole thing (secretly loves your pet too though) but Bubba insists! If anything happened to your pet he’d also be heartbroken

Chop Top:

- Intrigued! He thinks you’re very endearing right away and probably makes you smile with how curious he is about your pet

- Doesn’t really notice that you bring them along with you everywhere admittedly? Or at least doesn’t really think anything of it because why wouldn’t you?

- He will get attached to your pet too but he isn’t as easily affectionate as Bubba or Nubbins, mostly because he doesn’t want to take from your time with your pet. But of course if that’s ok he won’t complain if you let him have a snuggle…🥺

Nubbins:

- Nubbins/your pet interactions are very cute. Asks lots of questions about them and is very gentle and sweet

- He can be very reckless/clumsy but he isn’t with your pet. If it’s a snuggly animal like a cat, he’ll be just as attached as you. Lots of hugs and nuzzles :’)

- And completely understands if you’d be emotional if something happened, he would be too

Bo:

- Will tease you, although he and his brothers have a shared dog and he really has no room to talk lol

- Not as good with animals as his brothers though, and really doesn’t get the attachment (or so he says)

- 100% the type of person to insist you don’t get pets/keep them around, only to be the one that is closest with your pet later on

Vincent:

- Constantly melts because of you and your pet. You couldn’t be any sweeter to him and he loves you both a lot :’)

- Happy if you bring it to his room/work area, and he makes sure any dangerous stuff is always put away when your pet is around. Very careful and attentive

- Will watch you interact with your pet with a huge smile, though of course sadly you won’t even be able to tell (at least at first)

Lester:

- You probably catch his eye originally because of your bringing your pet along with you. He thinks it’s the cutest and instantly goes off about his own dog, bonding with you because of it

- Also the type to be really upset if something happened to his pet so he understands. He’d get attached to yours quickly too and would be the same

- So cute though, introduces your pet to his own and you have a cute little family together :’)

Luigi Largo:

- Oddly enough, I think despite his bad attitude he’d weirdly like pets, especially yours since you care so much about them

-…But it takes a while for this character development to transpire. He complains about it a lot at first, especially if you’re bringing them along with you a lot

- In the end he’ll bond with your pet a lot and it will make him feel a little more calm/comforted. Very protective of them and if anyone makes comments about you bringing them places he’ll be very defensive

Pavi Largo:

- Treats your pet with so much love and respect that it always makes you smile. Like Chop Top he doesn’t really notice you bringing them along with you everywhere, sees no reason not to

- Has a million nicknames for your pet and spoils them (and you) thoroughly lol

- Will also be shattered if anything happens to it because your pet is very much apart of your little family so he understands and is very protecting and attentive (he’s also very rich so like your pet is getting nothing but the best lol)

Billy Lenz:

- Instantly takes to your pet. I feel like he’d be pretty good with animals, and understands and respects your attachment to your pet without question

- He’d end up having his own bond with your pet too. You want to take your pet with you when you go out? Um…He’s going too then:)

- You gotta have a talk with him about not randomly taking your pet off to the attic without saying anything, temporarily making you panic about where they went lol

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- Won’t even really comment on it tbh. He has dogs and bugs that he is close to too and doesn’t really think much of it honestly

- Honestly I can see him liking cats/dogs especially so he’d be friendly and sweet (in his own way) with your pet

- Quietly supportive and protective. Very particular with your pet and makes sure they stay out of harms way/they are well taken care of. Also secretly thinks you’re very sweet but won’t say so easily lol

Charles Lee Ray:

- Probably not the most pet-friendly man ever admittedly, but if you insist, he’ll just ignore it most of the time

- However if someone makes any remarks of you bringing your pet along, he’ll get very defensive. Also protective of your pet, though he won’t admit to it or show it around you

- If you catch on to the fact that he’s starting to like your pet he’ll just mask it with a lot of complaining and eye-rolling (don’t be fooled though lol)

Tiffany Valentine:

- Thinks it’s so cute, you’re the sweetest to her and your love for your pet only strengthens that belief

- She tries to bond with your pet right away! Since they’re so important to you, she’ll care for them as best as she can, probably spoiling them a little in the process

- Mostly though she just thinks you are both precious x_x has very cute interactions with your pet too and talks to them often

Chapter Text

- Believe it or not I don’t think he’d get jealous easily. If you’re with him you’re more or less apart of the family, and he’s pretty confident in himself

- When he does get jealous he’ll either ignore it and get grouchy with you later on, *or* not even express it to you and instead just tell off whoever he got jealous of

- I feel the opportunity for anything to happen that would make him jealous would be pretty rare too. He’ll probably keep his arm around you a lot when you’re in public together and glaring if anyone pays you any special attention

- Most often he’ll just get grouchy with you though, and of course, he won’t even tell you why (mostly because he’d feel kind of ridiculous for even feeling that way) so you either have to just leave it and let him get over it or pester him about it until he tells you lol

- If you ask a lot he’ll seemingly get more annoyed but admittedly he likes the attention you give him like that and thinks you’re cute. He still won’t admit to it but he’ll be in a slightly better mood after, pleased you care enough to ask

- More likely to get jealous of someone from your past if you mention them or they reappear, like someone else you were close with. Bitter sometimes because he feels like you are comparing lol

- Gets jealous sometimes if you spend a lot of time with everyone but him and leave him alone a lot. Once again he’ll just get grouchy and needs a lot of reassurance

Chapter Text

- Chop Top is very chaotic as we all know. Dating him would obviously be no different. He’s very spontaneous, active and fun, so things would never be boring to say the least!

- He’s clingy once you both get comfortable around each other, in a casual way. He loves having his arm around you, clinging to your shoulders and just generally invading your personal space (respectful if you want him at arms length however!)

- He’d get nervous around you *a lot* at first, which is shown by way of rambling on a lot and easily losing his train of thought around you

- Similarly, he’ll clam up a lot with affection and such at first. Once he is comfortable with it he’ll be very affectionate as I said, but it would take a while

- Long drives listening to music, especially during the evening and at night. He’d love wrapping you up under his arm while you drive together

- Of course, music is a big part of your relationship. He loves sharing music with you and loves when you share music with him too. Music shop dates and listening to the radio together (occasionally with his brothers too, especially Bubba)

- Lots of hand holding :’)

- Talks about you constantly around his family. He’d pick up on your personality, interests, etc. easily and would constantly talk about them and want to learn about things you’re into

- I said it somewhere before, but you’d definitely take on a little of his style as would he yours. For example: matching pins, bracelets, things like that

- He’d be really encouraging and compliments you a lot, but in a really specific/kind of unique way? Like his compliments are things people wouldn’t usually think about, and it would make you feel special to know he noticed certain things (like he’ll spot things that are unique and interesting about you and really loves them. It could be anything really)

- Long conversations about the most random things, especially late at night. He has a lot of…interesting thoughts and things to say and if you let him ramble on about things he’ll be so happy. Loves hearing all your random thoughts too

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- Thomas is very sweet and understanding. If you aren’t feeling well you won’t lift a finger to help out with anything and he’ll spoil you until you feel better

- Somehow, he knows exactly what to do to make you feel better (somehow meaning every time he leaves the room Luda Mae tells him what to do lol) Brings you teas, snacks, whatever you like that makes you feel better

- Probably neglects his own duties because he’s concerned about you more than anything. Absolutely will snuggle with you all day if it makes you feel better. Tbh even if it doesn’t he’s happy to anyway

Brahms:

- Doesn’t know what’s wrong at first and won’t pick up on it unless you say something. If you aren’t feel well though he’ll be really concerned, which he shows by following you around and staring at you like 👁👄👁 until you tell him

- He takes care of you for once. Where you are usually the more caring one that tends to him often, he’ll do his best to be like that for you, even mimicking the things you do for him and taking care of the things you’d normally do instead. Even if it’s sloppily, he’ll try his best!

- Really sweet tbh. Will make you food and take care of you if you like, doing his best to make your favorites and do whatever he can think of to make you feel better and cheer you up

Michael:

- Pretty oblivious, probably won’t notice if you don’t say anything

- If you’re not feeling well of course he’ll be a little more concerned, though Michael being Michael he isn’t great at expressing it

- He’ll linger around a little more than usual to see if you’re alright. Half the time you won’t even notice this though because he’ll just peep in on your from afar more often than usual (which, while being a little creepy, is his way of being sweet so ;-;)

Beetlejuice:

- Won’t make a fuss, he’ll just offer to help you however he can

- Beetlejuice would be surprisingly sweet with his S/O so he’ll always look after you however he can (gotta write some individual headcanons for him bc I have /thoughts/)

- If you’re not feeling well he’ll cheer you up however he can. Coming from him there really isn’t much of a limit as to what he can do to make you laugh and cheer you up so x_x

Bo:

- Kind of awkward? Of course he’d want to make you feel better but like…Probably doesn’t really know what would make you feel better and is too afraid to ask lol

- A little sweeter than usual. He’ll check in on you a lot to make sure you’re okay, without really asking anything specific

- He would completely shock you by suddenly inviting you over to snuggle up next to him, for no reason. Though he’d really like cuddling secretly, he wouldn’t often give the opportunity for it, so you’d be shocked!…But it would be his way of trying to comfort you. And probably himself too lol

Vincent:

- Hates seeing you being uncomfortable/not feeling well, and actually gets a little panicked because he doesn’t really know how to make you feel better at first

- Thoughtful and attentive, nervously checking in and making sure you’re alright. Anything that makes you feel better he’ll happily try!

- Very gentle and reserved with you while secretly worried all the while about making you feel better and such. Probably needs a little reassurance himself. If you ask him to just come sit with you and snuggle up he’ll melt :’)

Lester:

- Similar to Vincent, he hates seeing you feel bad, but I think he’d be *slightly* less panicked. Asks you a bunch of questions about what he should do and what will make you feel better and does whatever you need/want without question

- Really sweet, he’d tend to you so attentively that it would almost be too much. He’d happily make a trip out to get you whatever you need, bringing you a little surprise specific to your personality to cheer you up and completely lighting up if he got a smile out of you

- A complete sweetheart in pretty much every regard. Very caring, sweet and thoughtful both when you aren’t feeling well and otherwise

Billy Lenz:

- Kinda similar to Brahms, won’t leave your side if he knows you aren’t feeling well

- Will bombard you with things that he thinks will make you feel better. You end up surrounded with a pile of things around you and him standing there like plz 😶

- Very sweet, gets really upset if you’re visibly not feeling well. Will snuggle you up without prompting, holding you tight and mumbling to you quietly, being surprisingly sweet (by his standards anyway) to make you feel better

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- Asa is surprisingly nice. Like yeah, you wouldn’t think all things considered he would be nice/caring etc, but he is? Especially when he’s ~Asa~ (I could do a whole post on this tbh)

- Mostly he just leaves you be, though he’ll do anything he can to make you more comfortable. He’s very attentive to you specifically so he quickly picks up one what makes you feel better

- Makes you smile with how often he checks in on you. He isn’t really the most sweet/tender but sometimes he’ll surprise you (and even himself) with how much he cares for you

Otis Driftwood:

- Otis certainly isn’t the most thoughtful and considerate of the slashers, but he doesn’t like to see you uncomfortable or feeling unwell, either

- He’d do his best to make sure you were comfortable, in his own way, asking surprisingly sweet questions (disguised in a grumpy voice, because he can’t be too tender of course!) and check in on you a lot

- If you accidentally make a mess he really doesn’t mind. Those things happen! He wouldn’t want you to feel embarrassed so he might even pretend he didn’t notice. If you know he knows he’ll try so hard to make it seem like not a big deal, trying to cheer you up in his own way

Josef (Creep):

- Sweet! And kind of arrogant admittedly. He’s very sure of himself that he can make you feel better, even though he doesn’t know what to do really

- Will get so dramatic if you aren’t feeling well and there’s nothing he can do about it really. Wants to be helpful:(

- If you just want to snuggle up with him and rest he will both melt and clam up so bad. Just being close with him can make you feel better and comfort you? Umm :) (will be thinking about this forever, won’t stop smiling to himself)

Chapter Text

- Bubba would appreciate your explanation, because he admittedly would be a little ignorant (not completely, he just doesn’t know a lot of the details such as binding and such)

- So, he’ll pay attention so carefully when you explained, just nodding along and staying silent while you speak

- He admires you, actually. He would appreciate that you live sincerely to yourself and will express it to the best of his ability. A sweetheart!

- He’s very encouraging and helpful. He’ll raid his own wardrobe and bombard you with things he thinks you’d look good in

- He wants to be helpful but doesn’t really know how? So he’ll do little things like that at first and would be so happy if he got a smile out of you

- He’s very eager to learn and be helpful however he can though. Plz tell him how to be supportive and he’ll do it 🥺 Even if it’s just being encouraging and validating he’ll be the sweetest and best at it

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

- Thomas’ cuddles are 10/10 for sure

- Like yes, it takes him a minute to get comfortable with that sort of thing. But once you’ve reassured him and such he’ll happily cuddle up with you at any time

- He’s so big and warm?? Will gently hold onto you and play with your hair, stroke your arms nervously, etc.

- But if *you* wrap him up in *your* arms and give him that kind of affection? He’ll blush so bad, shoulders stiffening until he eventually relaxes, completely melting

- Knowing you want to be close with him like that would make him so happy. Also: big on hugs and is amazing at them, very warm and soft :’)

Brahms Heelshire:

- Brahms has no reservations whatsoever about this. He adores physical affection and can cuddle for hours

- Absolutely won’t mind if you ignore the rules and schedule if you want to come snuggle up with him. In fact, please do :)

- Will cuddle up to you at any time of the day/no matter what you’re doing. He’ll get really clingy if you aren’t careful 👀

- Will get as physically close to you as possible when you cuddle. It doesn’t matter if he’s wrapped up in your arms or the other way around, he will be glued to you

- Feels really safe and comfortable when you cuddle him is why. He’s very touch starved and sometimes afraid you’ll leave so when you cuddle up with him he’ll feel very relieved and comforted

Michael Myers:

- It would take a pretty long while before you got to this point with Michael. He’s very reserved and entirely unused to giving and receiving affection, the whole thing is a new concept to him really

- You start with little things like wrapping your arm around his, or holding his hand, or even just sitting/standing closer to him. He won’t mind at all, sometimes surprising you by moving closer to you first

- His way of expressing this kind of thing or sort of signaling he doesn’t mind (aka quietly hoping you’ll just…give him affection without reservation lol) is just standing as close to you as he can like Y/N…plz

- Once he’s more comfortable he’ll let you snuggle up to him as much as you like, though his reactions will still be a little restrained at first

- Stares at you a lot, half out of curiosity and half from amazement/bewilderment

Jason Voorhees:

- So reserved at first. He would adore cuddling and being affectionate with you, but once again it’s new to him and even the littlest thing will turn him bright pink

- Will not complain if you initiate things first and kind of lead him along. He’ll be too reserved/unused to that kind of thing to himself but wants to so plz :^)

- If you like cuddles and affection then he’ll happily give them to you anytime you like, will feel a little more encouraged and confident

- Very sweet and protective and he’ll love having you close to him like that for that reason. Another one that’s big on holding hands and hugs (especially back hugs x_x) and he’ll go out of his way to be overly gentle

- Once you finally get him to remove his mask he’ll love if you leave little kisses and touches over his face, though he’ll be very shy and nervous about it

Bubba Sawyer:

- Literally always ready for cuddles but kind of nervous about initiating it at first, afraid you won’t want to

- Will start with little things like holding your hands and nudging up against you a little, standing close and seeing how you react

- Also hugs a lot! Very soft, warm and lengthy hugs in which he’ll probably squeeze you just a little too hard but it’s sweet :’)

- If you’re okay with it he’ll love cuddling anytime he has a chance (which admittedly isn’t as often as he’d like, sigh) so he’ll make it count when he does have time!

- Can cuddle you for hours at a time though. Nothing fancy, just likes being snuggled up and having his arms around you, caressing your arm and leaning his head against yours

Chop Top Sawyer:

- Sweet! Happy to accept any affection from you, no matter how you like to give it

- Can be clingy at times, loving to have his arm wrapped around you and holding your hand

- It’s rare you just quietly sit with each other like that though, he’d prefer to have music going and chat with you the whole time

- Will completely lose his train of thought if you pull him closer to you or leave little affectionate touches over him, smiling to himself and contentedly accepting it

- Also can be pretty shameless if he’s in the mood for affection/cuddles. Will just come over and sit in your lap or next to you and lean into you like Y/N plz :^)

Nubbins Sawyer:

- Very affectionate with you if you let him be. Loves holding hands, wrapping his arm around you, anything like that

- And if you like cuddling/physical affection like that even better! He’ll use that as an excuse to be clingy with you most of the time :’)

- Anytime he sits next to you he’ll just nudge against you, brushing his arm against yours and smiling until you notice and give him affection

- Leans over your shoulders when you’re doing really anything, draping his arms over you and wrapping them around, chatting along and occasionally pecking the side of your face/nuzzling against you

- I’ve said it before but he’d be kind of awkward/unpracticed with this sort of affection at first. He’ll really love being close to you but sometimes he can be a little clumsy, accidentally elbowing you or squeezing you a little too tight. You almost can’t complain because of how smiley and well-meaning he is though

Beetlejuice:

- Massive grin and eyebrow wiggles when you suddenly pull him over toward you and wrap him up in your arms

- You just wrap him up in your arms and cuddle up to him? Has no idea what to do, it’s new to him

- Secretly really craves kindness and affection, and it will take *a lot* for him not to completely melt at things like cuddling. He’ll smile to himself a lot and look at you sweetly when you aren’t looking

- Is a big fan of affection and cuddling and after the initial newness and awkwardness wears off, and he’ll be very open about it. Almost every time he sees you he’ll just wave you over like come hither :^)

- If you touch him affectionately and casually, he’ll almost follow your touch as you pull away, making how needy he is more obvious than he’d like

Candyman:

- So romantic, loves having you near to him in any way so if you’re cuddly he won’t mind

- Nothing with him is ever really casual so of course if you’re expecting a relaxing and sweet time you’re probably not going to get it with him lol

- He’ll make your heart race and cheeks heat up easily, knowing exactly the right things to say to get a reaction out of you

- Gentle and affectionate, loves if you sit/lie in front of him, allowing him to have you wrapped up in his arms while he trails kisses along your neck/jaw and sends shivers down your spine with the way he talks to you

- Melts at sweet affection such as touches across his face and innocent snuggles and cuddles. Thinks you’re so cute ;-;

Bo Sinclair:

- Bo is not opposed to affection, he just isn’t used to it. At least, nothing so sweet and genuine. He definitely wouldn’t be opposed, try as he might to convince you otherwise

- You would pull him close, asking him to come and cuddle with you. His instinct would be to laugh and tease you a little, but he’d only manage a nervous laugh, complying so easily that it surprises you both

- He’d be surprisingly uncomfortable and awkward with this sort of thing. If you took the lead and wrapped him up in your arms he’d melt, slowly relaxing into you and resting his head against you

- He would feel so safe with you like that, eventually wrapping you up tight into his arms and not letting you go for quite a while. Those kinds of moments are rare with him but he’d appreciate them a lot

- Will give you lots of forehead/top of the head kisses, lazily draping his arm around you and even dosing off, signaling just how comfortable and safe he really feels around you

Vincent Sinclair:

- A little stiff and reserved about affection at first, especially anything like this. He would want to but you’d have to be the one to initiate it!

- That having been said, he’d be so happy once you did. It would still take him a bit to completely relax but he’d adore being so close to you like that

- Will love having you sit next to him, his head rested slightly on yours/on your shoulder, his arm wrapped around you, sweater sleeve slightly covering/bunched up in his hand

- Affection like that and hand holding, random touches, etc. will make his stomach twist into knots, and he’ll be grateful you can’t see how affected he really is under his mask

- Can easily stay like that for hours, though it’s rare he’ll fall asleep when you’re cuddling at first. He’ll only do that much later into your relationship when he’s completely comfortable, strands of hair messy in his now-exposed face, half buried in your neck or pressed against your back/chest :’)

Lester Sinclair:

- Cute 🥺

- Loves having his arm around you all the time! And loves if you snuggle up to him when he’s driving

- A big cuddler, and happy to admit it too. He’s very soft and loves having you close to him like that

- Any kind of affection is fine by him! He would adore having you wrapped up in his arms while you sit/lie next to him, and even better if you face him so he can pepper your face with kisses

- And if you do the same for him? He will be a smiling, blushing mess, will wrap his arms tighter around you and hide his face in your neck

Graverobber:

- Mostly likes cuddles when he’s sleepy, a lazy cuddler? Like if you want to snuggle up to him that’s fine but that’s as good as it’s going to get lol

- Okay, maybe he’ll wrap his arm around you too. And his leg. Now you’re stuck though, good luck getting away for a while!

- Not the most talkative but happy to listen and nod along if you talk while he pats your head/plays with your hair

- Rests his head in your lap a lot, loves if you run your fingers through his hair

- More affectionate and sweet than usual when you’re cuddling, at least sometimes. Admittedly he likes being soft and affectionate with you and he’ll show it with hugs, forehead kisses, and wrapping you up in his arms randomly/hugging you from behind

Luigi Largo:

- Won’t admit it, but he’s got a soft spot and secretly wishes to be cared for and cuddled

- He’d be raving on when you’d just pull him over and completely shut him up, mouth pressing closed as he eyeballs you suspiciously

- Sometimes he likes being the more passive one, letting you cling to him and acting a little indifferent (he definitely isn’t though), especially if you’re out in public (like holding onto his arm, hand, etc.)

- Sometimes if he’s in a mood he’ll be putty in your hands, however, and is actually really needy for gentleness and affection like that

- Looks at you really lovingly anytime you give him affection, and adores if you play with his hair, pull him over without prompting to cuddle, wrap him up in your arms when he’s sleeping, etc. Always notices more than you think and loves it

Pavi Largo:

- Constantly ready for any kind of physical affection lol

- Sweet affection like that, however, is different, especially coming from an S/O. He’d start out flirtatious and extra, quickly getting a little flustered at the sudden intimacy and sweetness of it

- He almost doesn’t know what to do? He’s not inexperienced but at the same time he is, at least with things like that

- Will just go with whatever you like, as he’d like pretty much anything you did. If you like to spoil him with affection and snuggles then he’ll be delighted, lazily allowing himself to be doted over by you (all while he nervously rambles on and stares at you intently)

- But he’ll like just as much to lie with you while you fall asleep, completely enamored with how casual and sweet you are with him. It’s new and unfamiliar but in a good way!

Billy Lenz:

- Will keep you at arms length at first, despite how straightforward he is with his comments and such, because he’d be less comfortable with affection than he’d let on

- However, once he’s comfortable, he’s very clingy

- Like he’ll actually just follow you around until you give up and stop for a while to pay attention to him lol. Of course he won’t outright ask but you get the point pretty easily

- Kind of greedy, like yes he’ll snuggle up to you but he likes to be spoiled. Loves to lay in your lap while you play with his hair and to be wrapped up in your arms

- Another one that won’t easily let you go once he’s comfortable, if you even shimmy around too much he’ll lock his arms around you and pull you closer

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- As usual, it kind of depends? In general he won’t mind cuddling because he’d be very fascinated by you and enjoys having you close, if even for unconventional reasons

- Kind of like Michael, will stare at you a lot. Don’t mind him lol :^)

- Probably not the type to actually just sit still with you and cuddle, though. The time that’s most likely to happen is when he’s working as Asa, sitting on the couch and reading through things while you sit next to him

- At those times you’ll snuggle up at his side, earning a disapproving (but not really) side-eye as he continues working, though eventually he’ll give up and focus his attention on you instead

- As with anything with Asa, even cuddling can be kind of intense and nerve-wracking, mostly because of how intently he’ll pay attention to you. Not the most tender unless he’s in a rare mood (or sleepy asdflkj) and then he’ll let himself be snuggled, or occasionally drape his arm over you and draw you in closer

Otis Driftwood:

- You really think he’s gonna just sit there and cuddle with you? *Cuddle*? Well you’re right >:(

- Those sorts of moments aren’t as few and far between as you might think. He’ll have his arm around you half the time anyway, but he’d like cuddling more than he’d admit, at least sometimes

- Especially if you’re alone together in his room, he’ll be less affectionate around others but when you’re alone he’ll love when you snuggle up to him, even if he sometimes pretends to be annoyed

- If you like cuddling that helps, if not he won’t really initiate it himself most of the time

- Feels really comfortable snuggled up with you like that, however, as out of character as some of you might find that! I think he’d like having his S/O leaned up against him with his arm around them, playing with their hair or just absent-mindedly rubbing their arm a little while he rambles on about things

Charles Lee Ray:

- His initial reaction is similar to Otis. Like…um, Y/N? No. Well, maybe, if you insist. You don’t insist? Um…Well, you want to anyway?

- Don’t laugh 👀

- He’ll never admit it but he can be very clingy and enjoys your attention, though he’ll tease you and pretend he doesn’t, at least at first

- Surprisingly can be pretty relaxed and maybe not ‘sweet’, but as close to it as he’ll get. Will wrap his arm around you and grin if you rest your head on his shoulder or lean into him

- Sometimes he get in a rare mood in which he’ll actually keep you to himself all day, enjoying your attention and affection more than he lets on. Will make no complaints if you’re as affectionate as you like, it saves him the trouble of having to actually ask lol (also: likes having his hair played with x_x)

Tiffany Valentine:

- She’d adore affection, so she’d always be ready for cuddles lol (and she deserves them ok)

- If you initiate it first and invite her over to snuggle up with you? She’ll melt, unable to stop smiling to herself as she wraps you up in her arms and quickly hides her face

- Can easily remain like that for hours, sometimes falling asleep

- Loves cuddling when you watch movies together, laying her head into your lap or pulling you into her arms while she plays with your hair

- Talkative anytime you cuddle, rambling on about random things. She can be really sweet and romantic, or really dark and sometimes goofy (would love to make you laugh/smile), but no matter what she’ll love having you close like that

Josef (Creep):

- Very reluctant about affection and such. Not because he doesn’t want it, but because he isn’t used to it, and isn’t used to being vulnerable around anyone

- You have to take the lead, pulling him close to you and wrapping him up in yourself. He’ll be so stiff and unrelaxed at first, smiling over at you in an endearingly awkward way

- Once you get him to relax a little, he’ll completely melt, nuzzling up and tangling his arms around you. He’s still awkward but it’s only because it’s new to him and he isn’t used to it

- Will either be completely silent or won’t stop going on at times like that. If he’s going on and you rearrange yourself, sliding up to him closer he’ll lose his train of thought, laughing nervously and going quiet

- Probably falls asleep and snores really loudly like right in your ear though, sorry :/

Chapter Text

- Drayton brings along a whole picnic and blanket, and yells at the other three to help him carry things (they do not, besides Bubba) plz help him lol

- Nubbins and Chop Top waste no time, running ahead and swimming before anyone else does. Loud :') And will splash everyone else sitting by the lake

- Bubba sits by the lake most of the time quietly. Will roll up his pants and wade his feet into the water but doesn't actually swim

- But plz keep him company! He'll love sitting by the lake with you and hearing you talk and laugh about things

- Drayton, of course, yells disapprovingly at Chop Top and Nubbins, who are loud most of the time. He'd be in a better mood than usual, however, enjoying stretching out in the sun and resting a while

- He'd also enjoy having you around and talking with you, even though he isn't the best at expressing it. If you keep him company he'll be happier than he lets on

- Chop Top is definitely a flirt and will eventually come out and sit next to you, going on and on about things while he leans back onto his hands and grins over at you

- Nubbins isn't the best swimmer but is also the one that stays in the lake the longest, clumsily swimming around and urging you to come out with him

- If you swim he'll be so happy. This will also coax Chop Top back into the water, though don't expect this to be a peaceful and relaxing swim :')

- Bubba, meanwhile, is searching the lake beach for pretty stones, flowers, etc. to use in his crafts (search with him! He'll love the things you find in particular)

- If you don't swim Bubba/Drayton/you bonding times ensue. The other two will get grumpy eventually and come out to sit with you, a little envious and wanting to spend time with you too

- All of them love having you there with them at times like that! They'd view you as a part of their little family and despite grumpiness and chaoticness they'll all really enjoy times like that

Chapter Text

Bubba:

- He’ll cherish anything you give him! And he’ll give you similar gifts, since he knows you like them

- I think Bubba would be kind of touched if you give him gifts like that, especially if it’s stuff from your own collection. He is kind of affectionate so expect hugs anytime you give him things!

- Is nifty and will turn the things you give him into little crafts to use to decorate his room

Thomas:

- Thomas will adore anything you give him! Happily opens up his big hands for your little gifts anytime :’) (alsdkfj they’d look so small in his palm why am I soft for this)

- I think he’d have a similar collection of little trinkets and things. Sometimes he’d search for things from his collection he thought you might like, randomly surprising you with them

- He’ll even go searching around the fields and forests surrounding his house, looking for little pebbles, stones, etc. for you, so happy if he got a smile out of you when he gave them to you

Brahms:

- He will adore this so much. Everything you give him ends up on display in his room, lined up on his shelves so he can easily see them and be reminded of you

- Slightly less likely to steal your things if you give him gifts like that :^) He is kind of fixated on you? So needless to say anything you give him will be majorly cherished!

- He’ll give you things he thinks you’ll like to, but it’s mostly expensive jewelry and family heirlooms from around the house, along with little things he’s collected over the years

Vincent:

- Vincent would think you’re so sweet and cute ;-;

- He adores your little gifts so much. Gives you the sweetest look anytime you give him things, and he’ll keep them all safely hidden in his room. Looks at them sometimes and won’t stop smiling to himself

- Like Bubba, he’s pretty crafty and artsy, so he’ll find ways to use the things you give him in his art

Chapter Text

Bubba:

- Not the first to notice physical things like style and hair color, but he does like it (it’s not so much that he doesn’t notice really it’s just he won’t actually have any reaction until he’s comfortable around you)

- When you’re comfortable with each other he’ll love playing with your hair if you let him, half of the time without even realizing it. Would become an absent-minded habit

- If you dye your own hair he’ll help you! Expertly careful about it too, and if you decide to switch it up he’ll love picking colors with you

Chop Top:

- Chop Top would love your vibrant hair so much! It catches his eye the second he sees you. A big fan of any kind of self expression like that

- Most likely to get inspired and dye his own hair all colorful (aka get a vibrant wig, or several :’) costume wigs that are poorly placed on his head lol)

- Gives you nicknames based around your hair (and pretty much everything else, I definitely see him as the type to have a bunch of random personal nicknames he calls you)

Nubbins:

- When Nubbins first meets you he’ll stare at you a lot, thinks it’s so pretty and unique. He wants to ask about it but doesn’t want to be rude so instead he’ll just shyly compliment you with a big, expectant smile

- However your vibrant hair is one of the many things he really likes and admires about you! Once you’re a little closer, he’ll be sure to let you know it

- Sort of like Bubba in that he plays with your hair a lot too, though more intentionally. He’ll be rough about it though unlike Bubba, who’s always gentle and sweet. Will just fluff it up and make it messy shamelessly lol

Chapter Text

- Brahms is reluctant to go anywhere, having lived not only exclusively at home for so long but actually in the walls so it takes a good while to convince him to go places

- Going to a park is a good first step though! He likes hanging out in the manor garden from time to time so something outdoors with only a few people around would be okay (preferably none besides you though)

- Clingier than usual during these sorts of outings. Wherever you go, he follows (In other words, if you want to mess around and slide down slides and such he’ll be right behind you lol)

- However, his attention will avert slightly from you and onto his surroundings. Easily excited at the smallest things, and notices every little detail and thing (birds, flowers, little animals, etc.)

- He’d actually love taking little walks with you around the park, too, once he got more used to it. Don’t expect his hand to leave yours, though

- However, in the end, he’d much prefer being at home with you. But, if you like park dates, he’ll push himself out of his comfort zone for your sake *occasionally*

Chapter Text

- So honored! He’ll happily assist and will secretly melt at the thought of you even having a desire to try it. He’s usually the one to um…be kind of inspired by other people’s styles sort of:)) So if *you’re* the one trying *his* look he’ll be like !!!! /finally/

- Kind of thirsty for validation and such so when you actually want to try to do your makeup similar to his or something he’ll be surprisingly flustered and pleased with the idea

- And of course he’d help (although idk how good he’d be at helping, since people usually help him get ready lol)

- When you show him the finished look, he’ll think you’re the cutest ever (which??? is that conceited a little bit?? maybe, but it’s fine) you go out together in his style, confusing everyone but completely elating him :’)

- Admittedly, he would prefer your own style more, though. Like does he like to see you all done up like him? Yes. But he loves your own style too! However if you ever want to do it again he won’t be opposed to it, finds the whole thing very sweet and kind of confidence-boosting

- And of course…It’s Pavi. He’ll steal from your style a little too, especially if you do Pavi-inspired makeup on occasion. Even if only in subtle ways, like wearing your favorite color or something

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

- This is pretty new to Thomas. His family probably doesn’t even acknowledge Halloween most of the time so when you’re all enthusiastic about it he’ll be pretty intrigued/confused as to why

- However, he certainly isn’t opposed to the whole thing. He’s always happy to go along with whatever makes you happy, and will go the extra mile to make you smile as much as he can

- You definitely aren’t getting any trick-or-treaters where he lives, but he’s happy to help you decorate everything up and make up for it however he can. You both end up drowning the house in spiderwebs and pumpkins, tying together the already somewhat unsettling appearance of it. Believe it or not, the whole family gets into it in their own ways, happy to actually be celebrating for once (even if certain family members gripe about it lol)

Brahms Heelshire:

- Like Thomas, Brahms never really did much for Halloween, either (if anything at all). So when October comes along and you’re all excited for spooky season and Halloween, he’ll be a little confused and interested since it’s something you’re into and he hasn’t ever seen you so excited about something

- Very happy to go along with whatever you like. If you want to plaster Heelshire manor in jack-o-lanterns, cobwebs, orange lights, etc. go for it! He doesn’t mind at all, in fact, he would appreciate the change of scenery. The house is very uptight so to see a splash of color and festivity throughout would cheer him up more than you’d notice

- Won’t really help you decorate unless you ask, though he’d secretly hope you would. Since it is new to him, he’d be more excited and giddy about the whole thing than he’d let on. Comfortably celebrating things like that is a pretty unfamiliar concept to him, and seeing you all excited and happy to be spending a time of year you love so much with him would make him all warm and fluttery. Watching spooky movies together, decorating, dressing up, etc. would put a huge smile on his face, and Halloween would quickly become one of his favorite times of the year, too

Michael Myers:

- Considering Halloween is sort of his thing, he’ll be happy to know you’re as enthusiastic about the holiday as you are

- Loves to see all the decorations you put up and such, as he admittedly loves the spookiness and atmosphere of the holiday

- He might even forgo his usual Halloween ‘activities’ to spend it with you, since you love it so much. Very intriguing to him to see how lit up and excited about it you are. No, he won’t be helping you pass out Halloween candy, but he might even help you do some holiday baking (aka eat what you’re making as you go along) or help you carve a pumpkin!

Jason Voorhees:

- Jason finds your love for Halloween to be very endearing and sweet. Very supportive of anything that makes you happy so he’ll get into it in his own way, too

- Will melt if he comes home one day and finds you’ve decorated his cabin, especially if you’re waiting all smiley and excited about it. Adores it and you so much

- Halloweens with Jason would be on the simple side, considering where he lives and such. There really isn’t much around so you won’t get trick-or-treaters or anything, but in his own way, he’d really want to make it special. Will bring you random autumny/spooky things he finds around the woods or decorations he finds, and happily goes along with any other traditions you have/want to start with him. Baking, decorating, carving pumpkins, etc, he’ll happily help! Shy and reluctant if you want him to dress up with you though, but he’ll still go along with it for your sake (and if you compliment him in his costume?? He’ll blush so bad, can’t deal with praise and compliments at all, in a good way)

Bubba Sawyer:

- Very happy to go along with your love for Halloween. If you want to go all out with decorating, he’s very supportive!…And in fact, will waste no time helping you get right to it

- Whether you want to go out and buy up a bunch of things or make them yourself, he’ll help. He’s pretty handy so he’ll help you craft things to decorate the house with, gathering items to use on autumny walks

- He’s likely to get just as excited and enthusiastic about it as you are, simply because he loves seeing you like that. The entire month of October is extra festive with Bubba as he’ll try to make it as special as he can! If he gets smiles out of you for his efforts he’ll be a blushing, smiling mess

Chop Top Sawyer:

- Probably gets into Halloween himself to some extent so when you talk about how much you like it with him, it will only get him more excited to spend it with you

- Loves to see how happy and excited you are about it. Will surprise you with random decorations/spooky things he finds throughout the month and won’t stop grinning if he gets a reaction out of you. He’d love helping your decorate but, of course, he’s chaotic about it (which actually works out really well because everything ends up looking really good and spooky so??)

- Of course he’ll want to dress up on Halloween with you. Something matching or at least coordinated, and very extra. He’d happily pass candy out with you (eating half of it before handing it out lol) but would also love to go driving around and listening to your favorite Halloweeny songs together. Maybe even wants to visit a haunted house or two if you like? 👀

Nubbins Sawyer:

- Nubbins is kind of a mix of Bubba and Chop Top. He gets into it a bit too but not as much. But like Bubba, he’s happy to go along with whatever makes you happy

- He is very creative and crafty so of course he’ll help you decorate things for Halloween! His taste in decorations tends to be a bit more macabre, so your tastes get blended together and it ends up almost being too much by the time you’re both finished

- He adores how much you love Halloween though. That would mean your interests/tastes are more aligned than he thought! Like I said, he tends to be drawn to spookiness himself so if you love it it’ll make him feel weirdly more comfortable around you? And he’d love being able to have that time of year together where you can both be expressive and happy and it’s *on theme* so no one really questions it lol

Beetlejuice:

- Pretty unsurprised at your love of Halloween and spookiness, considering your taste in S/O (meaning he can be pretty spooky himself so obviously you’re into that sort of thing)

- He’ll get just as into the whole thing as you do, if not even more so. Loves helping you decorate for Halloween too, making up his own weird, somewhat gross things to put around the house in hopes you’ll get a kick out of it

- He really loves to see you happy and lit up about anything, so he’ll go all out himself to make sure Halloween is as memorable as he can. A complete sap, at least when it comes to you (not that he’d admit it. But you’d have to be super close with him and special to him to become his S/O so) so anything that makes you happy is actually really important to him

Candyman:

- Another one that is fascinated/intrigued by your love for Halloween. Interesting that time of year/a holiday would make you so excited and happy?? Not that he’s complaining, he adores seeing you all smiley and excitable

- You’re so strange and interesting to him. He can’t help but be endeared when he sees how decorated up your house is with Halloween decorations. If you admit you go around to different places in search for decorations and such he won’t be able to help but smile, finding it so sweet and kind of funny

- Willingly and happily takes part in whatever you’d like him to, half because he knows it would make you happy and half because he’s genuinely intrigued as to why you enjoy it all so much. Also fixates on you a lot on Halloween itself. Seeing you as happy as you are on Halloween will put him in a good mood, smiling throughout the day and quietly feeling really grateful for you for making him feel like that

Bo Sinclair:

- Not that into Halloween himself usually. Not that he doesn’t like it but he just doesn’t think about it or acknowledge it most times. He might even tease you a little for how much you like it at first

- However, he really likes seeing you happy, although it isn’t easy for him to show that sort of thing. So at the very least, he’ll lay off the teasing a little, and won’t complain as you slowly begin filling his house with Halloween decorations (which leads to you almost wanting to see just how much you can get away with before he says something)

- But he never will?? You can string orange lights all over Ambrose and line the streets with jack-o-lanterns and he’ll just be like 'you really like Halloween huh? 👀’ rather than teasing you because despite being a grouch he is a grouch with tact (lol to some extent) In other words, if he knows it’s important to you, he won’t make comments. Also, he kinda likes it. You make it feel homey and comfortable and he hasn’t even acknowledged Halloween in years so he won’t complain :’)

Vincent Sinclair:

- He loves to hear about any of your interests and about things you like, so if you talk about how much you love Halloween he’ll adore it. He never got really into it before (not for lack of interest though) so he’d be excited to see what sort of things you liked to do and how you celebrate

- Finds it cute that you go around in search for Halloween decorations and loves to see the things you find, smiling as he watches you enthusiastically talk about everything

- Will make you little spooky wax things throughout the month and completely melts if you get all excited about it. It only encourages him to make more and before you know it you have a whole collection of things he’s made like that

Lester Sinclair:

- So cute. Honestly he probably wouldn’t be that into Halloween (not that he wouldn’t like it/celebrate it, but it wouldn’t be a big deal for him) but your enthusiasm tends to rub off on him and he’ll find himself getting more into it than usual

- 100% helps you decorate everything up. He wouldn’t be able to stop smiling as he’d love that you were sharing that time together, especially since it’s so special to you (and he never really had Halloweens like that)

- Anything you want to do, he’s up for. Be it passing out candy, picking out costumes and dressing up together, going to haunted houses or watching scary movies, he’ll happily do it all. Genuinely thinks you’re the sweetest ever for being so excited and happy about it. Halloween is now his favorite time of the year too because of it!

Billy Lenz:

- Billy enjoys seeing all the Halloween festivities usually too to some extent, but seeing how much you like it will only encourage him

- Fascinated by how happy you seem because of it all, but he doesn’t question it. If you’re happy about it he’ll be happy about it too! Like some of the others, your enthusiasm will rub off on him. He’d nearly be just as enthusiastic as you, putting up every dusty old decoration he could find and happily waiting for you to notice he did a little decorating himself

- Loves activities like holiday baking, watching spooky movies while snuggled up together, things like that. And he’d absolutely dress up if you asked, has no reservations about it!

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- He’s pretty indifferent to the holiday. He does like the atmosphere of it (more or less) but he isn’t one to acknowledge it in any major way on his own

- He’s very intrigued by you, your behavior, and your interests, so your love of Halloween becomes his latest fascination. Admittedly finds it kind of endearing. He won’t partake in many of the various Halloweeny activities you have planned throughout the month, but he’ll enjoy watching you enjoy the month and holiday anyway (and if you really want him to participate, he won’t be totally opposed 👀)

- Celebrating with him is pretty simple. He’ll pass out candy with you on his porch, if you like. He’s more likely to express himself through gift-giving and such, however, so throughout the month he’ll spoil you by buying just about every spooky decoration he sees. Also, will find you completely adorable if you dress up, but of course that’s only expressed in a small approving smile

Otis Driftwood:

- Otis and his family tend to get pretty into Halloween too. Granted, it’s on a totally different level, but still 👀

- So he finds your love for Halloween to be endearing, in his own way. He won’t be too involved in the decorating or anything, but he likes to see what you come up with, and is surprisingly sweet about it if it’s just the two of you

- Kind of interested in the sorts of traditions you have and things you do. He’s weirdly touched that you want to include him (and maybe his family) in it as well, since it’s so special to you. He can’t help but be a bit more cheerful when you’re around, particularly when you’re as enthusiastic and happy as you are about it, just because how much you light things up. His family adores you too, since you get him to be in such a good mood

Charles Lee Ray:

- Well he definitely isn’t going to get as into it as you are, but he doesn’t mind at all. There are worse things in life to be enthusiastic about! If you’re happiest at the spookiest time of year then you’re probably well matched, after all

- Will he tease you for going to a bunch of different stores to buy Halloween decorations? Yes. Will he mind? Not really. In fact, if he sees anything spooky while he’s out, he’ll probably get it for you. But since he’s kind of mean, he’ll also try to scare you throughout the month, getting those random motion-activated jump-scare decorations, putting them around your house to scare you and laughing wickedly if he gets you (I’m /sorry/) (He’ll forget about them and will get startled himself too if it makes you feel better lol)

- Loves watching horror movies and eating Halloween treats together, believe it or not. He’s less into things like passing out candies and such but he’ll celebrate with you however you like anyway since you like it so much

Tiffany Valentine:

- She thinks you’re so cute and loves to see you all excited and worked up about it. She’ll start to love Halloween just as much, since you do

- Dresses up in spooky outfits throughout the month and melts if she gets a smile or reaction out of you. Her Halloween costume itself would be something elaborate and extra, hopefully matched to yours!

- Your house is completely plastered in Halloween by the time you’re both done, inside and out. Loves doing all the traditional Halloweeny things with you such as baking, carving pumpkins, etc. And not only will she help you hand out candy, she’ll probably insist you both go trick-or-treating a bit yourselves (Too old? Never!)

Josef (Creep):

- Josef likes Halloween too, though not as much as you do. However, as he picks up on your love for Halloween as the month goes on, he’ll sort of begin to adopt it as his own

- Very enthusiastic and extra about the whole thing. Will drive you all over the place to buy different decorations and such. Easily excitable and wants to start a bunch of traditions, such as decorating the house up, baking together, dressing up and carving pumpkins

- Admires everything about you a lot so your love for Halloween is just something new he finds lovable about you. When you’re all excited on Halloween itself, he’ll keep smiling to himself at how lit up and excited you are about it

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- It would take quite a while for Thomas to get past his nervousness about this sort of affection, particularly if he was without his mask

- Lots of trembling hands, blushing and nervous, shuddering breathing. Also through the mask kisses!

- He’d be both gentle and restrained, and very clumsy and awkward despite his attempts not to be. His hands would cup your face, lips both gentle and rough against your own. You have to take the lead a bit because he’d be so worried about doing something wrong

- Adores casual, quick kisses, like little pecks on the forehead/cheeks/through his mask. It’d make him feel so close with you and he’d smile each time

- Kisses your head a lot, though he’d be nervous to approach you each time, always giving himself away with his fumbling hands and intense looks. If you surprise him with a peck instead he’d melt :’)

Brahms:

- Of course you’d have many little masked pecks before your first actual kiss, after he’d gotten comfortable enough to remove his mask for you

- Honestly the hope of affection would be what drove him to remove it, though he’d be afraid you wouldn’t like him the same afterward. When you *did*, he could melt

- Far less confident without his mask than with. The feeling of your lips on his would cause his breath to hitch, shoulders stiffening as his hands lingered above your cheeks, uncertain about where he should even put them

- Very needy and passionate, will get as physically close to you as possible when he’s a little more comfortable, tangling his fingers around your face/into your hair

- Also loves casual little kisses, leaning into them a little and smiling to himself anytime you gave him affection like that

Michael:

- Everything takes a while with Michael, especially if it’s affection-related

- It isn’t that he doesn’t want your kisses it’s just that he isn’t used to affection and intimacy so :c

- There might be a mask kiss or two before he finally gets comfortable enough to remove it and actually kiss you, but I think once he decided he won’t be too hesitant (outwardly, anyway) about it

- Not the most romantic or practiced but he makes your heart flutter with the act itself, because you’d have to be very close with him for that to even happen

- Awkward, stiff, and rough, and lets you lead him along (at first anyway). Very obviously restrained, seeing the looks he’d give you without a mask hiding it would give him away

Jason:

- So reserved and shy at first. Will turn so red if you give him little mask kisses or anything like that, smiling to himself each time

- It would take a pretty long while for him to remove his mask and actually kiss you, as we all know he’s pretty restrained about that sort of thing. He’d really want to get comfortable with you first

- Once he does, however, he’d be so sweet and gentle. It doesn’t matter how many times you kiss him, he’d blush each time

- His kisses can feel restrained/controlled and to some extent they are, but it’s only because he’s purposefully gentle with you and is very unpracticed

- Gives you the sweetest looks anytime you kiss him, adores when you leave kisses across his face. Always kisses the top of your head when he hugs you

Bubba:

- Very hesitant at first, although he won’t have many reservations about forehead, cheek and top of the head kisses

- So happy and smiley if you do the same, he’d love sweet and casual intimacy like that

- His actual kisses would be much more passionate and romantic than you might expect. He’ll cup your face in his hands, kissing you with as much self-control and feigned skill as he can manage

- Though he’s unpracticed, he would want to be good at it and impress you, so follows your lead and pays attention to your cues

- Lots of blushing, tries to contain his emotions but his heart would race so bad anytime you kissed him or gave him any kind of affection that he’d have a difficult time not being obviously flustered

Chop Top:

- Chop Top adores being kissed and kissing you, at any time. Very shameless about it

- Has a habit of kissing your head randomly, and will grin relentlessly if you kiss him casually like that too

- His actual kisses are sloppy and unpracticed. Smiles a lot, makes you laugh, pulls away and gets distracted, continues as if he never stopped

- Can be surprisingly reserved about affection, however. Once he’s established you’re okay with it, he’ll be pretty shameless about random, casual kisses. However, when it comes to anything deeper than that, he’ll be a little nervous and as I said, unpracticed

- You’d have to guide him along more or less, or at least, encourage him to relax. He wouldn’t outwardly admit he was nervous, but there would be an airiness to his voice and a nervousness in his laugh that would give him away

- He’d peck your lips as he had a habit of doing one day when you’d pull him back, eyeing him cautiously before proceeding. When your lips met his once more, his breath would hitch. His lips would nearly twist into a smile, but his nerves would hinder him as your hands snaked around his waist, pulling him closer to you. Would melt, and be entirely at your mercy

Nubbins:

- Nubbins gives lots of little affectionate pecks if you allow it. On the forehead, cheek, nose, top of your head, really anywhere

- As far as actual kisses go, however, he’d be both unpracticed and eager. He’d attempt to match himself to you, but sometimes would get caught up in the moment and would still give sloppy, playful kisses

- Only because you make him a nervous, flustered wreck! Another one that would be pretty smitten by his S/O. He’d never quite get used to your kisses, his stomach twisting up and filling with butterflies each time you touched him or gave him any kind of affection

- Touchy any time you kiss him. Tangles his arms around you, plays with your hair, gets as close to you as he possibly can, etc.

- Can be strangely, sincerely sweet, despite being sometimes overly-eager and rough. Sometimes he’s intense and touchy, others he’s playful and pecks your face with little kisses, happy if he gets a smile or laugh out of you. Would feel kind of privileged to even be able to have that sort of affection with you?

Beetlejuice:

- Suggestive and playful, of course. A complete flirt and loves any kind of physical affection, kisses are no exception

- Can be rough, not typically the most romantic ever — it’s Beetlejuice, after all. He’s handsy, rough and shameless. Grins into your kisses and pulls you closer, things can get heated with him pretty quickly

- Despite it, he can also be pretty sweet, although he’d barely realize it himself. I’ve said it so many times now but Beetlejuice would be absolutely smitten for his S/O and despite the surface roughness, his affection would have a lot of tenderness and adoration too

- Any kind of casual affection and intimacy would just about make his heart explode, though he would try his best not to show it. Spicier kisses are no problem but knowing you want casual and sweet affection with him would make him all warm inside

- Does the same from time to time, will kiss your head/cheeks/hands even randomly and give you the most awkward, self-satisfied grin afterward

Candyman:

- Daniel is for sure one of the most romantic slashers so of course, as with anything with him, his kisses are heart-stopping

- Draws your chin up with his finger before kissing you, or gently rests his hands over your cheeks. His kisses are full of feeling, regardless of how drawn out or brief they may be

- Will physically melt into your kisses, however brief they are. Even if you so much as peck his cheek, he’ll unknowingly follow your lips as they part from him, if only to make it last a little longer

- Considering who he is and the natural effect he tends to have on people, any sort of affection from him will be somewhat overwhelming, even if he doesn’t intend it to be. He tends to be a bit hypnotic, so he can’t help it!

- Not that that’s a bad thing, really. He’ll leave your knees weak and head spinning with the most romantic, attentive kisses

Josef (Creep):

- Gives you the sweetest looks anytime you kiss him, smiling and gazing lovingly at you

- Very nervous and stiff though, will have a hard time relaxing with any affection at first. Not that he doesn’t want it! He’s just inexperienced and reluctant

- You have to initiate any kind of affection like that at first. He’s fine with hugging you and such but that’s about it. On the occasion or two he tries to kiss you first it’s super awkward and you barely know what he’s trying to do, so he leaves it to you going forward

- So sweet though! Casual kisses in passing will make him a smiling mess. Always leans into them, shoulders stiffening and cheeks rounding from smiling so wide. Takes ages to get comfortable doing the same, but he will kiss your head/cheeks a lot randomly when he does

- Regardless of how affectionate you both are with each other, he’d perpetually be flustered and enamored by you. Even after a hundred kisses, you’d make his heart race just as much as it did the first time you kissed him

Chapter Text

- Your first kiss with Josef could happen ages into your relationship, or almost at the beginning of it. It depends on how forward you are really because he certainly won’t kiss your first. He’ll hug you loads if you’re fine with it but that’s it

- At least, not without seriously hinting around at it first, and asking you (several times) if it’s okay. In which case, maybe he’ll initiate it first. *Maybe*

- Your first kiss with him would have to be in a completely intimate setting. When you’d been talking together for a while, he’d casually (and straight-forwardly) bring it up, or hint in a very unsubtle way

- Anything like this is a big deal for him, even just a short peck. So regardless of how much he talked about it or tried to prepare himself for your affection, he’d still get kind of overwhelmed

- Overthinks it *a lot*. His mind would be racing, even more overwhelmed at the thought of you actually wanting to be affectionate with him like that. Everything is so meaningful to him that it would be emotional for him, even if he tried to hide it

- Would nervously shut his eyes when you neared him, stiffening up at the feeling of your hands squishing his cheeks. His heart would pound as your lips finally met his, his breath hitching (and temporarily stopping tbh) until you pulled away. He’d be too nervous to react much, maybe besides hesitantly resting his hands on your arms

- He’d give you the sweetest look after, smiling with narrowed eyes as his cheeks quickly flushed pink

- Easily flustered, and wouldn’t expect anything more than just a brief kiss. That having been said, if it lasted longer/was deeper than expected, he would probably perish lol (not that he’s complaining…! But just don’t expect him to be functional for a minute!)

- Dramatic. After you’ve kissed, your relationship would be different/more serious to him. Makes a big ordeal out of it, almost unintentionally (because to him it is!)

- Still shy about affection and kisses going forward though. Still wouldn’t initiate them himself, besides maybe kissing your head when he hugs you, but that’s it. It wouldn’t be that he wouldn’t want to, only he still wouldn’t want to push it. He’d get a little addicted to your affection though, so he’d almost go out of his way to give you opportunities to give it (Perpetually flustered if you do. Like if you’re affectionate and kiss him a lot? Will melt)

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- Christmas with the Hewitts is unique, to say the least. They don’t normally make a fuss over it (although they don’t forgo the holiday entirely, they just don’t acknowledge it to any major extent) Thomas in particular hasn’t ever experienced much of a Christmas, so he’d happily decorate everything up with you, watching you enthusiastically deck the house out while smiling to himself

- That having been said, no, he probably doesn’t know what mistletoe means x-x So when you hang some up and ask, he’ll stare at you curiously as he waits for an explanation (also nervous af because should he know?? /embarrassed/)

- If you mention that people usually kiss beneath mistletoe, he’ll furrow his eyebrows, trying to suppress the inevitable blush that would follow. What are you suggesting, Y/N?? 👀

- Not at all opposed to the tradition, of course, though he wouldn’t instigate it himself. Forever flustered and amazed at the thought of you wanting to partake in traditions like that with him?? He’d happily kiss you anytime, however, as he’d adore your affection, although he’d be nervous you’d be caught by his family. It wouldn’t stop him from sometimes going out of his way to walk beneath the mistletoe, however, at least when you were close by too :^)

Brahms:

- Of course Brahms knows what mistletoe is. Would probably dig around in the attic for ages to find some crusty box of Christmas decorations in hopes to specifically set it out in your way, hoping you’d hang it up lol

- Will be lingering around as he helps you decorate. Even if you were his S/O, he would prefer to have an excuse to be affectionate with you, especially if he was the one initiating it. So when you finally hang it up, he’d be like 👉👈 as he watched you

- Honestly you probably wouldn’t get a chance to ask. He’d probably ask if *you* knew what it meant first, staring expectantly as you slowly worked out the sudden appearance of random mistletoe where there wasn’t any before

You: *begins to walk off, half teasingly and half because you’re done with his antics*

Brahms, in his shrill voice: …bUT Y/N…!!!

Michael:

- Just watches as you decorate for Christmas like hmm:)) Not that he has anything against Christmas or anything, but y'know, Halloween is sort of his brand. But you do you 👀 (Of course none of this is actually expressed, he’ll only watch you the whole time)

- Indifferent when you hang up mistletoe (not that he isn’t usually indifferent, but) Just tilts his head a little when you ask if he knew what it meant. He’d probably would, but he’d just be curious and amused at you asking

- It would really depend on the stage of your relationship. Things with him would never be totally average, but as time went by and you got more comfortable with him and understood him better, he woudn’t be very reserved about affection. So by all means, demonstrate!

- He won’t even mind if you take off his mask for things like that. It wouldn’t be a common occurrence or anything but yeah. He’d either just let you kiss his mask/his cheek, or he’d pull up his mask a little, resting his hand against your neck/cheek. Amused at your little fascinations and antics and tries to appease you out of curiosity, is all. He doesn’t have a soft spot for you or anything…!

Jason:

- When Jason notices you hanging Christmas decorations around his cabin, he wouldn’t be able to help feeling a little endeared. You’d make it so cozy and homey! Of course he’d help too

- But when you hang up mistletoe and ask if he knows what it means, he’d just stare, waiting for some sort of further explanation from you. Not because he doesn’t know what it is, but because why are you asking? 👀

- You offer to show him?? Instantly stiffens up and straightens himself out, heating up as he almost panics in anticipation. He isn’t at all *opposed* of course, but you’d make him so nervous, especially anytime you kissed /him/ and not just his mask

- His cabin is pretty small so there’d be a good chance of you bumping into each other beneath it many times a day. Eventually he just comes to happily expect your kisses, although he still wouldn’t get used to them. Lights up each time and will never forget to kiss you anytime you pass beneath it!

Bo:

- Huuu okay usually, if you asked Bo something like that he’ll just scoff and give you a hard look, because of course he know what mistletoe means?? (Which he’ll smugly confirm, non-verbally, of course)

- At least that’s how he’d want to react, but admittedly, it would have been a while since he had a real Christmas, especially one spent with someone who wanted to make it all special by doing things like hanging mistletoe. So he’d be in kind of a wistful mood before this moment between you, unable to react how he normally would (or at least would want to)

- Although, you’ll still get a scoff/glare. But it would come off as a little more grumpy than he intended, as sometimes you would just bewilder him and he wouldn’t know how to take it. It’s a small thing really, but to him it’s big. Sometimes when you did little things like that it would just sink in that he had you around at all and he’d be kind of sentimental in his own way

- He’d snap out of it when you just carried on decorating, looking a little disappointed at his seemingly sour reaction. His stomach would knot up in guilt, but at the same time, he wouldn’t be able to help but smirk at your disappointment. Later, he’d make up for it, being sure to bump into you beneath the mistletoe just to appease you:)

Vincent:

- Honestly not much of a reaction to you hanging up mistletoe, even if you ask if he knows what it means. Well, not that you can see, anyway — he’d flush up a little, no matter what stage of your relationship you’re in

- This only gets worse when you offer to demonstrate. Of course, there’s no need, he knows what mistletoe is but at the same time does he really wanna tell you that? 👀 (he is shy about things like this but at the same time he loves it, especially when you’re more comfortable together, so)

- You can’t help but smile because even something as simple as a kiss beneath the mistletoe is full of feeling coming from him. Like Bo, he’d really appreciate how he had someone to spend the holiday with at all, not to mention partake in traditions like that. He would have never expected something like that, so he’d appreciate it a lot

- Whether you kiss his mask briefly in passing or he pulls it up to allow you to kiss him properly, he’d melt into it each time. He wouldn’t always instigate it himself or expect it each time, although he might want to, but if you insist, he’d find you so sweet and definitely wouldn’t object

Lester:

- Lester wouldn’t be able to quit grinning to himself the whole time you’re decorating together. Definitely the type to make it a whole thing! As with the other Sinclair brothers, he wouldn’t really have ever had much of a Christmas, so he’d be more than willing to plaster his place with mistletoe, garland and lights if that’s what you wanted

- Already grinning to himself when he notices you hanging up mistletoe. Awkwardly shuffling around like…please, Y/N, scoot over so he can fit beneath it too!

- When you ask if he knows what it means (not that you’d have to, his body language would give him away) he’d deny that he did thinking he was being all coy, hoping you’d just show him instead

- However, you’d playfully shake your head and wave him off, denying him an explanation/demonstration and just continuing on with your decorating, leaving him staring pitifully (and a little dumbfounded) until you couldn’t resist

Chapter Text

- Bo, despite being a flirt, wouldn’t be *at all* easy to get close with. Out of the brothers, in my opinion, he is easily the most emotionally reserved. He’d have really hard time trusting people and feeling safe around them, barely able to see them as anything but a potential victim

- He’d say he had a certain type but honestly when it comes to making a connection with someone, it wouldn’t matter. In fact, it would probably be someone opposite to what he’d expect

- On that same note, attraction for him is a very person-to-person thing. He doesn’t really have a ‘type’ because a lot of times he surprises himself with who he ends up liking. More personality/demeanor based? Not to say he doesn’t get physically attracted to people like I said because he definitely does. It changes a lot and he’s flexible, idk, it doesn’t matter much in other words

- It would take him a while to catch feelings for someone but it would start simply, with him feeling comfortable enough to let someone hang around. He’d be genuinely confused and actually annoyed at his own feelings, which might manifest in him being moody with them, but in a different way than usual

- I also think he genuinely puts in an effort to be charming and polite with whoever comes into Ambrose, for obvious reasons. But, I think if he showed you his moodier side, it would kind of reveal that he was starting to open up around you and feel more comfortable

- (I don’t actually think Bo is that moody though, all the time anyway)

- All of the Sinclair brothers are, as with most of the slashers, starved for any kind of genuine affection, love, and kindness. For Bo, however, it’s a bit different. He would almost push those sorts of things away, not wanting to be vulnerable with someone easily. If you gave him those sorts of things unquestioningly, he’d almost be overwhelmed and not know how to react. He wouldn’t get moody (not always, anyway, he might at first) but he would get more reserved, having to process it. Honestly, kind of gets suspicious?

- When he finally opens up to you and lets you be affectionate with him, he’d actually break your heart a little with how unfamiliar he was with it and how much he didn’t know how to react. He would clam up at any verbal affection, sweet words, gestures, etc., even little touches, hugs, things like that would be a challenge at first. He is more comfortable with some than others (not opposed to any of it, just nervous) but still, stiffens up a little and goes quiet anytime you’re genuinely kind and affectionate with him. Normally he has a comment to make about everything, but he’ll easily go quiet or his speech will be less polished and more airy/clumsy. He’d be so grateful for you and after he’d gotten a little more used to how you treated him, he’d have no trouble expressing it, in his own way

- All of the Sinclair brothers would be fiercely protective and loyal toward their S/O. Bo would always be looking out for you in his own way (even if sometimes you don’t want to hear him, because he can definitely nag)

- Also the type to act as if you were the one that was massively head-over-heals for him (which, of course, you are) /but/ honestly he’s so much worse off than you. You could be out of his sight for five minutes and he’s wondering where you’re off to and if you’re alright. Thinking of you constantly and always feels better/more relaxed when you’re around

- Very passionate, pretty much constantly, even when he isn’t. He feels things intensely and although he wouldn’t always express it, you’d be able to tell, even with the way he looked at you or spoke with you

- Also, once he’s comfortable with you being soft/affectionate with him, he wouldn’t be at all opposed to you being as affectionate as you like. He would never outright ask for you to give him attention or anything but he *would* want it. Would melt at any random touches, support, anything like that

- Very reluctant to tell you about the sort of upbringing he had, and explain his scars to you. It would take ages for him to be comfortable enough, and even then, he might just let you figure it out on your own while sort of filling in the blanks for you. Talking about that would be one of the few scenarios in which he’d actually get emotional in front of you, exposing his more vulnerable side. Would really appreciate any reassurance and comfort you gave him, while desperately trying not to get overly emotional

- Would let you get away with anything. No matter how much he isn’t interested in something, he’ll always go along with whatever you like (albeit with the occasional gripe and moan) because he’s smitten really

- Can be kind of jealous/protective. He’d trust you, but he wouldn’t trust other people. So obvious about it too, would casually wrap his arm around you if someone else flirted with you or even looked at you the wrong way, giving them a death glare and then acting as if nothing happened later

- A clingy sleeper. He isn’t exactly the snuggliest slasher I write for, at least until he’s asleep. In which case, you’d be completely tangled up in his arms while he snores in your ear, whether you like it or not (trying to move away results in him pulling you closer and locking his arms around you lol)

- Dates with him are usually casual/uneventful, all things considered. But I think that would sort of bother him. He’d want to give you so much more than just lazy dates around Ambrose (Bo has many insecurities, IMO, and this is one of them)

- Needs more reassurance than he thinks, and puts in way more of an effort to please you and seek your approval than he’d realize. If you were supportive/reassuring, he’d melt, relaxing around you a little and only growing more attached to you for that reason

- Not the sort to give gifts very often or anything, but when he does, they’re either very random or very sweet and personal. Also absolutely see him as the type to bring you flowers and the like. Can be romantic in his own way and if he thinks it’ll get a positive reaction out of you, he’d do it (if you don’t like flowers, for example, he’d bring you the you-specific equivalent lol)

- Weirdly good at understanding you/reading you? He’d probably see through you a lot and would easily pick up on your moods, motivations, etc. even before you even know each other that well. Unless, of course, it involves him, in which case, he’s pretty oblivious and always believes the worst, despite being smug most of the time (he is /complicated/ lol)

- By that I mean, if you get quiet/moody around him, he’ll always assume it’s his fault. Really hard on himself :/ He can be a smug tease but admittedly he’s always wondering if he matches up/is good enough for you

- A relationship with him would definitely not be the easiest. He’d be moody, complex, both overly fast and slow-paced, sometimes argumentative and sensitive, but he’d be massively loyal and passionate. Absolutely the type to make your head spin and stomach knot up even by just thinking about him

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

- As I said in another post recently, the Hewitts aren’t really big on Christmas. They don’t *not* celebrate, they just don’t make it a big thing. No one (especially not Thomas – he’d be supportive of anything you liked) would have an issue with you wanting to go all out for it, however, as it would have been a while since they had any real Christmas spirit around. You’d probably put everyone in a cheery mood for once, although no one would outright admit it

- Thomas is especially unfamiliar with all the traditions and such you’d want to do. Throughout the season, he’d be so grateful that he had you in his life! You’d brighten things up so much and make his world so much bigger, even in just small ways like that

- Has no expectations whatsoever so when you give him something for Christmas, he’ll flush up, completely taken aback. Whatever it was, he’d love it so much, being sure to take good care of it and cherish it for ages! Especially loves something hand-made or personal like that, unable to stop thinking about how much thought you must’ve put into it

- Puts a lot of thought into whatever he’d give you too, so nervous when he actually gives it to you (avoids eye contact as his hands fidget nervously, occasionally glancing up to see if you like it, his ears burning the whole time) A blushing mess if you liked it, smiling in relief but tensing right back up if you thanked him with a hug

Brahms Heelshire:

- Honestly, I’m not really sure Brahms would share the sentiment. His parents probably had stuffy Christmases, usually just to keep up appearances, rather than out of any real liking for the holiday. They’d go through the motions almost every year, and each year, he found it more and more tiresome

- However, he might have a new found interest in the holiday if you actually liked it and made it spirited and fun. You’d go through all the same old traditions he already knew about, such as decorating a tree, and listening to Christmas music. But seeing you actually *enjoy* it would be different – especially if you actively included him and wanted him to be a part of it

- Actually super sweet when the holiday itself rolls around. He’d do his best to make you your favorite food, or make you something handmade (alternatively even plays something for you on the piano) very eager to do something thoughtful for you since you made the season special for him

- And if you surprised him with a gift he’d be so touched, no matter what it was. He’d quickly get out of the habit of stealing your things (lmao to some extent) when you became close, so anything you gave him would be very cherished and special to him. Will be mulling over it happily for a while

Michael Myers:

- Michael Myers is mostly just amused at you most of the time. Whether you’re decorating the house with too many lights, or dressed up in an ugly Christmas sweater, he’s just endeared in his own way

- Surprisingly not opposed to going along with certain things. He isn’t the most interactive or anything, but he’d be somewhat helpful and at least interested to see what sort of traditions you had/things you wanted to do together

- Helps you stir cookie dough as you bake, awkwardly stands on the opposite side of the tree as you wind lights around to help pass it back to you, etc. He’s doing his best okay :’)

- Genuinely surprised, for once, if you give him a gift at Christmas. While he’d be well aware of your love for the holiday, he wouldn’t really expect anything like that. He isn’t really the sentimental type, but whatever it was, he’d handle with much more gentleness than he normally would. Practical/small gifts would be better for him, and whatever it was, he’d either use or keep for ages. Really, really appreciates you for giving him the opportunity to experience things like that and see him as more than what everyone else does (wouldn’t even really know he wanted anyone to until you came along!)

Jason Voorhees:

- First of all imagine how cozy Christmas would be in his little cabin? Like yes it’s very small and shabby but like, clean it up a little and decorate it up and it would be so cute with a little homemade, naturey wreath on the front door and the tree visible from the window :’)

- Speaking of, if he knew you were really into Christmas, he’d either surprise you by finding a little tree out in the woods or would invite you to come along with him (especially if it was all snowy asldkfj) to help him find one

- Would love seeing you excited and enthusiastic about anything, Christmas decorating/the holidays in general are no exception. You’d make him feel all warm by doing things like that and wanting to celebrate with him, even making his little cabin all festive and pretty

- You can tell he’s blushing even with the mask when you give him his Christmas gift. He’d be so appreciative even without opening it, since you made it/got it for him at all. Cute and smiling, even if you couldn’t tell much

Bubba Sawyer:

- Bubba is always happy to humor you and whatever you’re interested in, so he’d go along with whatever you liked at the holiday season. Genuinely enjoys all the traditions, many of which he’d never have done before

- Cute and helpful! Happily helps decorate everything all prettily, crafting new decorations with things he finds outside. Also really cute and festive cookie baking/decorating time together :’)

- So happy when you give him a gift, he’d pull you into a hug to thank you even before he saw what it was. No matter what he’d love it, knowing how much thought you would put into it and since it’s from you at all!

- A genuinely sweet and thoughtful gift-giver, probably giving something hand-made and personalized. A blushing, shy mess when he gives it to you, unable to stop smiling if you like it

Chop Top Sawyer:

- Won’t really get too into it on his own but if you mention you’re into it, he’ll go along with it for your sake. If you want to decorate everything up from top to bottom, that’s fine by him! Will help you too

- …Although he’d end up being more of a distraction than actually helpful, and would somehow manage to end up decorating himself more than anything else lol. But he’d look cute :’)

- Late night drives to look at Christmas lights while you listen to old Christmas songs together! Of course his own favorite Christmas songs are super random and obscure but he’d be happy to listen to all the basic ones too if that’s what you liked

- Would love a music-related gift for Christmas, or something handmade/thoughtful to him (so probably something unique, colorful, etc.) No matter what though would get all excited and enthusiastic about it

Nubbins Sawyer:

- Cutie x-x would always be happy to go along with whatever you were into and what made you happy. So if that means drowning the old farm house in Christmas lights, so be it! (Not really because Drayton would complain but…at least you can inside lol)

- Idk, little activities like putting together gingerbread houses or stringing lights around the tree together :’)) Smiling the whole time, would love doing these kinds of things with you and getting a smile out of you

- Would spend ages coming up with the right gift for you, although of course, his options would be pretty limited. Chances are he’d make something unique and thoughtful to you from things he found

- And he’d be a smiling mess when you gave him something, no matter what it was. Anytime he sees it it would put him in a good mood (Would especially like something he can wear, like jewelry, or something handmade like a hat or something? Would have it on constantly. But he’d like anything really)

Beetlejuice:

- Will tease your enthusiasm about the holiday, while getting into it himself, especially seeing how much you enjoy it. Like yes, he’ll gripe about the same old Christmas songs playing over and over (and a million other things) but he’ll do so in an ugly Christmas sweater (shh 👀)

- When you ask if he wants to help you decorate, he’ll go along with it, but not helpful at all lol just distracts you with jokes, flirting, and typical antics. And will later go on about how nice it looks and what a good job you both did (even though it was just you)

- He’d love domestic, simple stuff like this admittedly. Decorating, celebrating, baking together (aka him just eating stuff while watching you bake I’m sorry asdfjkl) and just enjoying the holiday season?? The fact that you’d want that with him would make him smile endlessly

- Honestly he won’t not expect something for Christmas, especially knowing how much you’re into it, but when you actually give him something he isn’t as smug/unaffected as he’d like to be – especially if it’s something genuinely thoughtful. Typical Beetlejuice behavior from him but like…Soft and grateful version lol

Candyman (Daniel Robitaille):

- Honestly he’s just surprised at himself and at his situation when the holidays roll around and you’re bringing him into all your holiday-themed antics. Like…he’s a powerful, ghostly entity? And yet, here he is helping you place ornaments on the tree 👀

- Not that he’s complaining. He’s a romantic and very loving/adoring, so seeing you happy about anything at all will make him happy. If you’re all smiley and enthusiastic about the season, he’ll just smile at you contentedly, happy to have someone to let him experience that kind of thing

- Christmas with him would be more cozy/intimate. Loves how into it you get, and seeing how you decorate everything up. Lots of nights spent inside, looking out onto the snow and him going along with (distracting you from, though who’s complaining) whatever holiday activity you’re trying to get into

- A Christmas gift from him would be more of a grand, romantic gesture than something tangible. Alternatively, something artistic! A painting or sketch of you. Would love anything you gave him, especially if it was something really meaningful between you both or like several of the others, something you made by hand (or created somehow)

Pavi Largo:

- Pavi’s family probably has dysfunctional, mostly uneventful and insincere celebrations for the sake of keeping up appearances (if they celebrate at all). He isn’t against the holiday or anything, just doesn’t really see why you’d like it! (Simply coming from his experience, all he knows is chaotic holidays)

- That having been said, he’d mostly be curious as to see what you were so excited about, and wouldn’t be at all upset to have an excuse to forgo any family-related obligations. So :^)

- Honestly pretty easily convinced, just because he’d like seeing you all excited and festive. Completely unhelpful when it comes to decorations but generally cute and gets into it for your sake

- You wouldn’t think, all things considered, Pavi would be easily impressed with gifts or anything. That having been said, if it came from an S/O or someone he cared about, it’d be another story! Would be so over-exaggerated with his reaction, loving whatever you gave him. Of course he’d shower you with gifts throughout the whole holiday season (and in general tbh) as well!

Billy Lenz:

- Christmas with Billy can be kind of a stressful/chaotic time actually but if spent with someone who he cared for/cared for him, I think it might be a little better

- He wouldn’t easily show it, but as with many of the slashers, it would take him a while to get used to someone actually wanting him to be involved in things like this. Almost gets overwhelmed sometimes at it, just popping off to the attic for a while to process. He’d enjoy it but he’d also be a little mystified by you

- Likes being ‘helpful’ when you decorate (aka watching you decorate as he follows you around, and *maybe* helps you here and there) but would like activities better like just watching Christmas movies together or even baking/decorating cookies. Eats everything while you bake together though lol

- Genuinely won’t be expecting a Christmas gift! :^) (a lie) So when you give him one he’ll be like aww shucks, you shouldn’t have… >:)) (all while ripping into it to see what it is) But would genuinely love anything you gave him! You could give him a rock and he’d just stare at it in awe and love it since it came from you

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- Don’t even ask me why but I get basic vibes from Asa (which is weird, all things considered, because he’s anything but, but I think he’d want to appear that way to some extent at least) so I feel like he’d do all the basic Christmas stuff. He might not get into it much (or really any holiday) but y'know, it doesn’t hurt to keep up appearances!

- So if you’re into Christmas then even better! He won’t mind going all out and will willingly invite you to help him decorate up his generic little house :’) (Like Christmas tree by the main window, wreath on the door, all that!)

- Probably expects a gift honestly but pleased when you give him one, and will cherish it in his own way (Please get him something bug-related 🥺 A bug tree ornament! Or something! He’d love it so much)

- A pretty good gift giver in his own way. Although sometimes his gifts feel a little impersonal (or alternatively, too personal) he’s *expensive* and gets you something fancy

Otis Driftwood:

- You might not really expect Otis and his family to get into Christmas but they would, in their own ways (Maybe not Otis himself though, but his family might a bit)

- If you liked it he’d probably go along with whatever you wanted, to some extent (albeit begrudgingly) especially seeing your interactions with his family. Wouldn’t take part in it too much but he’d attempt to help here and there, and you wouldn’t be able to help smiling at the sight of his grumpy self decorating the Christmas tree with like, idk, doll heads or something

- Gift exchanges with him and his family are unique, to say the least. However, he really would appreciate whatever you gave him and his usual grumpiness would disappear at least for the time being (until his family teases him for being soft for you, in which case, grumpy again)

- Especially would like something handmade (be it art, music, baking, literally anything) He’d love knowing you took the time to create something with him in mind

Charles Lee Ray:

- Will barely acknowledge the holiday until you mention you like it. He wouldn’t complain (he would a little) about anything you wanted to do but he wouldn’t take part in it too much, or so he would say 👀

- No, I’m NAHT gonna help yOU DECORate the fuckin’ /TREE/ (helps you decorate the tree)

- Admittedly likes seeing you all happy and enthusiastic, and he isn’t really against some of the aspects of the holiday. Cookies, presents…Not to mention, it can be a pretty chaotic time of year, which is kind of his brand :^)

- Will love whatever you give him as a gift and since it’s your favorite time of year, he’ll attempt to be all nice and sweet about it (to the best of his ability, anyway…) Will give you something in return and it will either be: beyond random and impersonal, or surprisingly thoughtful (so proud of himself if it’s the latter lol)

Tiffany Valentine:

- She’d love this sort of thing! Domestic, simple things you could enjoy together. She wouldn’t usually go all out on her own, not because she didn’t want to, but because there would really be any reason/opportunity to. She’d love having someone to go all out with 🥺

- Chaotic Christmas decorating time! You both make a complete mess trying to decorate everything up (and probably bicker as you both get frustrated about halfway through) but in the end, your house is the prettiest around of course

- She adores doing all the basic traditions together. Be it wearing overly-festive, probably matching/coordinating outfits (plz, she’d melt at this) or baking together, she wouldn’t be able to quit smiling and exchanging happy looks with you

- So excited to see whatever you gave her for Christmas. She has high expectations, Y/N 👀 (Not really lol she’d actually be pleasantly surprised that you got her anything at all, smiling all bright as she excitedly opened it. Would love it no matter what it was! And of course, she’d spoil you with gifts throughout the whole season as well)

Josef (Creep):

- Not too big on Christmas usually himself, but he’s pretty willing to give new things a try. Mostly he just never really celebrated it much, there wasn’t opportunity really and he didn’t have anyone to get into it with

- Soon finds he loves it too though! Everything is such an emotional thing for him. Even something as simple as decorating a tree or going shopping for decorations will be a big thing, although he might not show it. He’s pretty mystified as to how he even got so far in a relationship with you to be doing such simple, domestic things together, but he definitely wouldn’t have any complaints

- Loves your enthusiasm for it, it would encourage him which would in turn make you even more excited. You’d hype each other up over the festivities and probably end up going all out lol

- Very touched at whatever you give him, he’s very sentimental in his own way and he’d love it. Would spend ages picking out or making the perfect gift for you too (it would probably be something either matching or something like, with both your initials carved into it or something like that)

Chapter Text

- First of all, as with any time spent with Tiffany and Charles, it would be a little chaotic. Charles would get impatient and bored being stuck inside all day, and he and Tiffany would bicker and argue a lot too

- That having been said! It would actually be kind of pleasant? (Or at least, as pleasant as time with these two can be…) Tiffany would see the opportunity as something fun and cozy, wanting to take advantage of the time to get into the holiday spirit

- Lots of fun times with Tiffany ensue – baking together and decorating and the like, while Christmas music or movies play in the background. Charles, meanwhile, would be getting kind of impatient with being stuck inside but eventually would join (if only to appease Tiffany, who would get irritated with him for not helping lol)

- On Christmas morning, Tiffany would probably wake you up early just so you can open her gifts for you. Will spoil you with lavish, sweet gifts, not really expecting anything in return (and completely lighting up if you gave her something) Charles would barely admit he’d gotten you anything at all, though his gifts would be surprisingly more thoughtful than you’d expect

- Snuggling up under blankets with you between the two of them while you watch Christmas movies (but probably the dark, scary ones, because I mean, it’s Charles and Tiffany) while eating the cookies you made with Tiffany

- These two would both love spending time with you like this in their own ways, Tiffany more obvious about it than Charles, but honestly he would too. Although he’d gripe about being stuck inside and being bored, he wouldn’t be in any hurry to rush out the door when all the snow had melted. Tiffany would be more than pleased to be stuck at home with you both, and wouldn’t be shy to say so. Quietly hoping the snow lasts longer just so you can be stuck with her a little longer!

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

- Rainy days out on the Hewitt farm are actually really pleasant. You and Thomas both don’t have much to do when it’s too rainy to go outside much, so instead, you’d sit out on the porch together and watch the clouds shift overhead and listen to the rain pattering against the roof

- He’s naturally very sweet and comforting anyway so whether or not he even realized it he would comfort you and cheer you up. Always going out of his way to make you more comfortable and make sure you’re taken care of, and is usually really loving/affectionate too (once he’s comfortable with you anyway)

- He’ll blush so bad if you admit you feel comfortable/safe with him, and enjoy spending time with him like that just watching the rain and such. The feeling is mutual of course :’)

Michael Myers:

- It isn’t often these sorts of days come around with Michael, but when they do, you’d both quietly appreciate them more than either of you would let on to each other

- Michael isn’t by any means the most tender or intentionally comforting slasher. But, I think if you were his S/O, his presence in general would be comforting! Knowing the notorious Michael Myers was content to spend a day in with you would be a lot coming from him

- You’d just sit together as the rain poured, all warm and cozy inside doing whatever you liked. If you admitted you needed a comforting day like that with him/told him you felt comfortable with him, he’d be a little surprised/confused, but relieved. He definitely isn’t used to being a comforting figure to people, but he’d be glad to be one for you!

Jason Voorhees:

- Jason would be more than happy to stay in with you whenever you liked, especially on rainy days. Honestly regardless of anything though, if you needed comforting, he’d drop everything and stay home with you. You’d be his first priority!

- Rainy or snowy days with him are always the coziest because you’re stuck inside, watching it from the window. He’d light a little fire to make sure you stayed warm and snuggle up with you

- A complete sweetheart if he cares for you, so he’d always be looking out for you in his own way. Would listen to anything you had to say if you wanted to talk or just sit quietly and wrap you up in his arms, resting his chin on your head and making sure you knew you were always safe with him

Bubba Sawyer:

- Like Jason, he’d drop everything if he knew you were in need of comfort. You’re definitely his top priority and no chores or bossing around from Drayton would convince him to think of anything but you!

- Will stay with you in bed all day if you like while you both listen to the rain, or go out and sit on the porch to watch it. Either way, Bubba would be stuck to you all day, checking in on you frequently and making sure you’re comfortable

- Loves rainy days a lot for that reason, since there’s a good excuse to just stay inside all day with you. They’d become your relaxing days where you both remain (mostly) undisturbed and cozy

Chop Top Sawyer:

- There are days when Chop Top would need comforting in his own way too, so he’d happily stay in and try to make you feel better if you asked since you do the same for him (he would anyway though). Really sweet toward you and concerned about your well-being, so he’d want to make you feel as happy, or at least as safe/content as you made him feel

- If he picked up on it on his own, he’d probably spend more time with you than normal in hopes to give you a chance to talk about it, or at least make sure you weren’t alone and he could distract you/make you smile

- Like Lester, might take you out for a drive in the rain if it wasn’t too heavy (or at least would want to sit in it while parked and watch the rain run down the windshield) would play songs he knew you liked and wrap his arm around you

Nubbins Sawyer:

- Rainy days with Nubbins aren’t much different than any other day with Nubbins really, he doesn’t let it slow him down much (absolutely the type to want to go out into the rain and actually feel it)

- Of course, if he notices that you want a cozy/more laid back day for once and need comfort, it’ll be a little different. He’ll try his best to cheer you up and comfort you however he can, not really thinking that just being with him in general would be enough to make you feel better

- Clumsy, reassuring ramblings and awkward arm pats until you just pull him closer to you and lean into him, effectively shutting him up whether or not you mean to. He would love just being able to be with you like that too, admittedly, not used to that sort of easy-going affection. You just sit there and snuggle up to him all day? He’ll melt, finding you so sweet

Bo Sinclair:

- Rainy days with Bo are always relaxed and lazy. He’ll just plant himself on the couch next to you, first pushing the curtains back so you can see the rain as you both spend the day resting together

- Will wrap his arm around you as you watch TV/movies or the rain together. Won’t say hardly a thing all day, and will almost definitely fall asleep/rest his head in your lap (he needs comfort too a lot of times, so days like this are comforting for both of you)

- Sometimes not really the most reassuring if you need comfort, just because he isn’t really used to that sort of thing. He’ll attempt to make you feel better in his own way, at least by letting you know he’s there for you, even if he can’t express it very well. Lots of little arm rubs, forehead kisses, etc. though and checking in on you without actually asking much (although he’d listen surprisingly well if you wanted to talk)

Vincent Sinclair:

- It would really depend on you. Rainy days with Vincent aren’t much different than normal, he’ll hang out beneath Ambrose working and such, barely noticing the change in weather

- Unless, of course, you like the rain, or seem like you’re in need of comforting (which he would be quite good at picking up on without having to be told) In which he would definitely put his work on hold to come spend time with you

- A naturally comforting/protective presence if you’re in a relationship or he cares for you, so he wouldn’t have to do much for you to feel safe and comfortable around him (that would also go both ways/apply to him around you as well). If you sit somewhere and enjoy the rain together, he’ll pull you over and wrap his arm around you and just keep you like that for as long as you like. Whether you wanted to talk or just sit quietly and enjoy it, he’d be fine either way

Lester Sinclair:

- If it isn’t raining hard, he’ll probably take you driving around slowly in the rain, windows down so you can smell it on the cool breeze. Weirdly serene with the sound of the rain on the concrete and on the roof of his truck

- Will probably park somewhere pretty in the woods so you can just sit for a while and take things in, hoping that it might be a nice change of scenery for you (and it definitely would be pretty, watching all the greenery of the forest sway in the rainy breeze, drops falling off of them and onto the windshield of the truck. The sounds too, like wind brushing through the branches and rain falling gently)

- Will melt if you slide over to him and sit next to him. Wraps his arm around you and gives you little squeezes here and there, doing his best to make you smile

Billy Lenz:

- If he knows you enjoy listening to the rain, he’ll probably invite you up to the attic so you can hear it a little better! (Please excuse the dust and leaky roof, Y/N :^))

- Will snuggle up with you on a pile of blankets by the attic window, watching raindrops fall down the glass as he holds you tight and mumbles on about random things, probably making you sleepy with how comfortable and warm it actually is

- He’s a bit more intuitive than he lets on as far as your moods go, so he’d drag you along to enjoy the rain whether or not you brought it up, simply because he’d think you look like you needed comforting. Whether or not you wanna talk about it is your business! He just wouldn’t want you to feel alone. (Also, if you didn’t want to go upstairs in the attic with him, he’d happily curl up with you in bed and probably doze off lol)

Chapter Text

- Beetlejuice would be the quickest to tease you about literally anything, loving to (lovingly) poke fun and jokingly annoy you about things. But if someone else teased you about anything or even laughed at what he teased you about he’d just glare and completely shift moods lol

- Loves doing domestic, simple things with you and likes a much sweeter/more laid back relationship than you’d expect. He wouldn’t admit it really but he’d always be in an especially good mood anytime you were just doing random, simple activities together

- Melts at even the simplest praises/compliments. Like, the embodiment of ‘aww shucks’ anytime you say anything nice to him at all. Goofy smile, incoherent mumbling, wiggling eyebrows, all that

- Genuinely sweet, encouraging and accepting, in his own way. Like, he can be a bit crass and rough around the edges with his words (if for no other reason to keep things on the humorous/light side for the most part and get you to crack a smile), but he’d be really good at picking up on things and knowing the right things to say and the right times to say them

- Very soft, but won’t admit it easily. Loves any kind of affection and both physically and emotionally clingy to some extent, liking to hold your hands or even play with them randomly and barely noticing he’s doing it, wrap his arm around you, etc. Is a physical touch/words of affirmation kind of guy (and quality time tbh)

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

- This isn’t unlikely with Thomas, as he tends to be more on the insecure side anyway. It takes a lot and a long time for him to really feel open and secure around you, and even then, he still has his moments. You being flirted with would definitely tear him up a little

- Regardless of how you reacted and if you didn’t flirt back/didn’t encourage them, he’d still feel kind of bad for a while. After all, why should you be with him and not someone else? All his insecurities would come slipping back despite himself. He wouldn’t expect that you’d leave him just like that, as he’d trust you more than that, but he might wonder if it would be better for you if you did

- Would need a lot of reassuring. Telling him how much you love him, and want to stay/be with him, things like that. That he has no reason to worry and no one is more appealing to you than him! He’d melt at your reassurances, eyes all intense as he listened and thought of how lucky he was to have you

Brahms Heelshire:

- Brahms is easily jealous anyway, so someone flirting with you around him/when he’s within hearing range is never a good idea. I mean, he wouldn’t do anything about it outright usually, but he’d be moody and irritable around you for a while because of it

- Honestly his biggest fear would be you leaving him anyway. He’d worry a lot and though he’d try to overcome that fear and trust you, he’d still have a lot of deep-rooted insecurities and fears of being abandoned. So when someone flirted with you and presented you with an alternative, all of that would present really badly

- If you reassured him that you weren’t going to leave him/that you actually wanted to be with him, he’d cheer up (despite feeling guilty about his moodiness) although it wouldn’t be totally better. It would take a long time for him to really get over that fear. But reassurances and sweet words would go a long way, as well as showing him that you enjoyed being with him and such

Michael Myers:

- Feelings of jealousy and insecurity in that context would be an unfamiliar thing to Michael. He’d watch as someone doted over you, tilting his head and wondering why he was feeling the way he was over something like that

- Gets more worried than he’d let on. It would take *a lot* for you to even be able to call yourself his S/O. He’d open up to you (in his own way) in ways he never thought he could. So when he saw/heard something like that, it would actually make him appreciate what he had a little more

- Wouldn’t directly bring it up or admit how he was feeling to you but you would be able to tell something was bugging him, despite his stoicism. When you eventually figured it out and reassured him, he’d for once be a little more emotive, wrapping his hand into yours or just lightly touching you in some kind of way, as if to let you know he appreciated you

Jason Voorhees:

- Jason isn’t at all easy to get angry about things, especially when it comes to you. But when he sees the *audacity* of someone to be flirting with you, he’ll be so upset. Insecurity would set in afterwards, when he had a moment to really think about it

- He would be insecure and hesitant anyway and this wouldn’t help matters. He’d love you so much and would often feel like you could do better. After seeing someone flirting with you, he’d kind of go inward as he pondered over his own feelings, leaving you worried about what was wrong

- When you figured it out and confronted him, he’d just stare expectantly, almost as if he expected you to hurt him more and admit you weren’t happy with him. But if you reassured him and spoiled him with sweet, kind and loving words instead, he’d completely melt, flushing up and kicking himself for thinking otherwise. Doesn’t feel so bad in the future if it happens again although he might still get kind of angry at whoever’s flirting with you lol

Bubba Sawyer:

- Bubba isn’t really the jealous type unless he was given reason to be. Definitely has his insecurities and he might get kind of upset to see someone flirting with you, but that’s where it would end, until Drayton started rambling on about things

- Drayton rambles often and usually it’s harmless and he doesn’t even mean anything by it, but he’d strike a cord with Bubba when he mentioned you’d probably run off after seeing someone flirt with you. Bubba would shake his head vehemently in disbelief, scrambling to find you and make sure of it himself

- A little more direct and just asks you about it, visibly upset and flustered at his brother’s words. He’s easy enough to reassure, and wouldn’t be able to stop smiling when you admitted you had no interest in anyone else and certainly didn’t plan on leaving. Nothing but hugs and clinginess from him for a while, though (and annoyance toward his oldest brother lol)

Beetlejuice:

- Has no trouble speaking out when he sees someone flirting with you. He’s very outspoken and crude at times and would probably kind of make a scene. But he’d only react that way because he’d already feel kind of inferior sometimes, and wouldn’t understand why you were with him (although it would take a lot for him to admit it)

- Would apologize for reacting badly later, feeling even worse after seeing you being upset with him as if he’d made things worse for himself. He’d really appreciate you more than he’d let on most of the time and the thought of you leaving him would make him a mess, which would show with how much more chaotic than usual he’d be

- Would finally admit why he reacted the way he did, almost making you more upset for him thinking you’d even be so easily swayed/doubting you. If you reassured him and admitted you really liked being with him and that he didn’t have anything to worry about, he’d lay off the teasing for once and would smile to himself as he listened

Bo Sinclair:

- Bo likes to pretend he’s very self-assured and confident but he’s far from it a lot of times. Normally if he saw someone flirting with you he’d just get annoyed though, making it obvious they should probably stop

- *But* sometimes he wouldn’t be able to help but think that maybe you’d start to prefer someone/somewhere else, especially if he was in an especially sour mood, or you had had any disagreements. He’d surprise you when he saw someone flirting with you by just letting out a sigh and wandering off, not at all his usual smug self

- The thought of you wanting to be somewhere else besides with him would make him a mess honestly, and he wouldn’t know what to do with it because he’d *want* to not care and seem unaffected. He wouldn’t be the most obviously receptive to reassurances at first, although he’d appreciate it more than he’d let on. If you pressed and wrapped him up in your arms and made sure he didn’t have any doubts, he’d definitely lose his composure, which he would hide by hiding his face into the crook of your neck and staying there a little longer than he usually would

Vincent Sinclair:

- Vincent would be really hesitant/self-conscious at first anyway, so seeing someone flirt with you wouldn’t help. Won’t react as dramatically as some though, as I think he’d be a little more trusting and confident of you, even if he wasn’t in himself

- Like, he *knows* you’re sincere, and wouldn’t just leave him. But that wouldn’t stop him from sometimes feeling like you would, or might be better off if you did

- A little reserved as he tried to just get over his feelings on his own, processing through them and trying to keep his own insecurities a secret from you. Of course, you’d inevitably catch on, as he would be far more distant than usual. A little nervous to even admit his own insecurities and feelings, but if you were understanding he’d melt, especially with any sweet words and reassurances

Lester Sinclair:

- He can be very insecure anyway so seeing someone flirt with you would get him down more than he’d let on, simply because it might remind him of what he feels he lacks if that makes sense. And if you weren’t really discouraging the person outright, he might take it the wrong way

- Rather than withdrawing or anything he’d actually get a little clingier than usual, in a noticeably different way. Just like, awkward and panicked about things, and kind of emotionally exhausting himself trying too hard, as if to over-compensate

- When you reassured him that he didn’t have to worry, he’d be the most likely to get a bit torn up (despite trying to hide it) half because he’d feel bad for assuming anything and half because he’d feel so grateful to have you

Luigi Largo:

- You might expect that he’d be furious if he saw someone flirting with you (and he kind of would be) but Luigi would always be on his best behavior around you. Mostly he’d just gawk in disbelief, trying to restrain his usual impulses lol

- Not one to suspect that you’d leave him without being given a reason. One of his family members would have to suggest something to him to plant that thought, which he’d brush off in annoyance at first, but would take to heart more than he originally thought

- Later comes to you in kind of a state, asking if you really like being with him and such. When you figured it out and reassured him, he’d ask you several times if you really meant it, smiling in relief if you reassured him with sweet words

Pavi Largo:

- Pavi is visibly hurt right away upon seeing you being flirted with. The audacity of some people!…Although he can’t blame them for trying. More interested in your reaction than whoever would flirt with you

- He has some deep insecurities though and gets shaken at the smallest things, especially early on in your relationship. He isn’t used to anything serious to begin with, so to him, he’d almost feel that it was a matter of time before you decided to go off with someone else

- You’d probably catch him witnessing the scene, and seeing his body language right away, would know exactly what was going through his mind. Politely declining the advances of whoever flirted, you’d turn and wrap your arm around him, smiling at him and quietly whispering reassurances that would make him smile in relief and contentment (and also a weird sense of pride seeing the facial expression of whoever you just blew off lol)

Billy Lenz:

- Billy would get jealous pretty easily but that combined with any kind of insecurity would cause Billy to be one of the most panicked on this list, especially in the early days of your relationship or the first time he saw someone else flirt with you

- It wouldn’t be hard to figure out what was wrong really (mostly because he’d just tell you outright if you didn’t guess it fast) But he’d be so moody and difficult at first, hardest to reassure right away because he wouldn’t even want to hear it

- However long term, he would be the easiest overall because if you admitted you were happy with him and reassured him, he wouldn’t think much of it if someone else flirted with you in the future. Almost has to laugh really because he’d get overly confident and has to commend their effort at least lol

Josef (Creep):

- Sooo grumpy if he catches someone flirting with you. Especially if you don’t outright say something to the person. Like really, Y/N?? (the real life version of this: -_-)

- Will just go sit somewhere in a dark room and think about how nothing lasts and you’re going to leave him. You’d catch on pretty quick as to what was wrong if he didn’t outright tell you, since he’s quite obvious. He is very lonely/can be insecure anyway, so this kind of stuff would always shake him up

- It somehow both takes a lot of reassuring and very little to cheer him up. Doesn’t believe you at first when you say you weren’t interested in the person who flirted with you, and that you weren’t going to leave him. But it wouldn’t take much else. You’d just pull him into a hug or play with his hair as you reassured him that you weren’t going to leave him and he’d be like. Awh. Well. Ok then. :^) (instant better mood lol)

Chapter Text

- Bo never really got into that sort of thing, or so he would have you believe. Anytime a holiday or festivity rolled around, he would roll his eyes at you for getting into if you did, although secretly he’d enjoy spending them with you like that

- And honestly even if you didn’t mention anything about it, I think he’d *want* to do things like that with you (like celebrate holidays and such) and just do basic, simple things like that together?…Again, not that he’d actually say so

- So he would kick himself for forgetting Valentine’s day, especially if you had mentioned wanting to celebrate, or made it obvious you’d done something for him for the holiday

- If he still had a day or two he’d quickly leave to get you *something* because he’d want to make it special, even if he said he didn’t care much for the holiday

- But if it was last minute, he’d probably do something more romantic, rather than getting you something (or at least, would behave a little softer than normal, mostly because he’d feel guilty)

- Something like a picnic, attempt at making you dinner, watching something of your choice together, something like that

- Will (lovingly) roll his eyes if you got him something like basic and soft, although he wouldn’t be able to stop smiling to himself. Like chocolates, flowers, whatever. Would treasure whatever it was so much though (for example if it was flowers, you’d see them neatly arranged in a vase later)

Chapter Text

Thomas:

- Thomas hasn’t ever really celebrated Valentine’s day with anyone before, but that wouldn’t stop him from loving the thought of it. He’d love the thought of having someone to spend it with, considering the theme of the holiday, and would get into it quite a lot for that reason

- Will light up if you give him any Valentine’s gifts. Doesn’t matter what it is, his ears would turn all red and you’d catch him smiling behind his mask

- Would put so much thought into something for you, making you something really specific to you/your interests, by hand. You’d both earn some eye-rolls from certain family members, but Luda Mae would find you both adorable

- *Slightly* more affectionate than usual, and would melt at the same. He is quite starved for anything soft, sweet, romantic, etc. so I can see him liking Valentine’s day (and anything of the sort) quite a bit

Michael:

- Once more, has never celebrated Valentine’s day before. Really isn’t that interested in it himself, but he’d always be a little curious about all the stuff you got into

- Little head tilt when you give him any Valentine’s gifts :’) of course he isn’t the most expressive but he’d always appreciate anything from you

- Mostly just shocked you’d want to spend a day like that with him at all, s/o or otherwise. He’s not the most Valentine-y man in the world so the fact that you’d look at him like that and would think to even include him, no matter what, would just surprise him? (Not in a bad way)

- Perpetually shocked at you and your relationship really. Doesn’t get how you managed to find (and stick with) each other and never will, but he’d be quietly grateful for it. Days like that would only intensify that feeling

Chapter Text

Bo Sinclair:

- Typically, kisses with Bo are either passionate and overwhelming or lazy and slow. They aren’t uncommon with him because I see him as being pretty physical

- He’ll pull you into his arms and hold your hips tightly, grinning if you get obviously flustered, enticing him to see how much of a reaction he can get out of you

- Alternatively, he’ll pull you into his lap and kiss you surprisingly gently. Perfectly contented to stay like that for quite a while, lazily pushing his hands through your hair and enjoying the gentleness of it

- He is less used to sweet kisses in passing, and intimacy for the sake of just being close with him. If you randomly kiss him and just go about your business or peck his nose/forehead/whatever he’ll always chuckle as if he’s annoyed, watching you walk off in bewilderment

- Once he’s more used to that sort of thing he’ll do the same, though not often. Forehead/top of the head kisses are his thing, though sometimes he’ll wrap his arm around you from behind and kiss your jaw/cheek

Vincent Sinclair:

- Vincent would be one of the masked slashers to take a little longer to get comfortable removing his mask. Despite the fact that he’d want your affection, he’d be a nervous mess about actually removing it in front of you for any reason

- He wouldn’t at all be opposed to any other sort of affection at first though, or even kisses over his mask, on top of his head, etc. But you’d definitely have to be patient with him

- When he does finally take his mask off, kisses with him are heart-stopping, even despite the fact that he isn’t the most experienced and is obviously a nervous wreck. However, he’d kiss you with so much love and feeling it wouldn’t matter

- Kisses with him can be lazy/slow like Bo, but in a different way? He’d wrap you up in his arms (fingers slightly concealed by his sweater 🥺), relaxing into your hands, resting gently on his face and making him feel warm and safe with you. He wouldn’t be in any rush for that to be over, in other words

- Not shy about initiating kisses with you once you’re in an established relationship/he’s confident and sure you want affection like that. Will appreciate sweet little kisses in passing and will do the same occasionally, but normally, even those turn into something else with him. He’s very romantic/full of feeling

Lester Sinclair:

- Touch starved as could be and literally always ready for your kisses. Will never turn you down and will often kiss you in passing himself, just planting big, playful smooches on top of your head, cheek, wherever he can

- Tons of playful pecks whenever he feels like getting a smile out of you. Especially if you’re in need of cheering up or you just decide to be affectionate with him randomly, he’ll just start smiling and won’t be able to resist

- Surprisingly restrained/shy about actually kissing you at first though. Not opposed or anything, just nervous. Turns a bright shade of red and heats up when you kiss him for the first time, melting into your touches and letting out a sharp breath

- But quickly finds himself very comfortable with it, if only because he loves your lips on his. Smiles into your kisses and pulls you close, wrapping his hands around your waist and/or playing with your hair, rubbing your cheek with his thumb, etc.

- All of the Sinclair brothers are lazy kissers more or less. Lester will just lazily grab your hand as you pass by and attempt to pull you over into his lap at random times, giving you a knowing smile. If you just keep going he’ll put in a little effort though 👀

Luigi Largo:

- I am 100% convinced Luigi would be totally different around someone he really cared for and respected (and would be very smitten for his s/o). That having been said, I think he’d be adore any kind of affection, kisses being no exception

- Very shameless and affectionate with you, to the point of everyone else having to question how he can be so gentle and sweet with you and so harsh with everyone else

- Would pull you over into his arms no matter where you were and press kisses to your forehead, cheek, etc. without even thinking about it

- Fluctuates between really gentle and over-enthusiastic and rough when he kisses you. Not one for short and sweet kisses himself, although he’d adore them from you, grinning and leaning into them each time

- Doesn’t matter how brief your kisses are, he’d always be amazed by you and would adore your affection

Pavi Largo:

- Clingy and touchy anytime he kisses you. Also not one for brief kisses, although he’d find them sweet. However, if you kiss him in passing, he’ll often just pull you back toward him for more

- At first, at least. I think as you got more comfortable with each other, he’d actually love random, sweet kisses. You’d make him feel really loved and warm, in a more tender way than he is used to

- Depending on his mood, he would be either a clingy, touchy kisser, barely letting you catch your breath and pulling you to the side anytime he got the chance

- OR very gentle and lazy, just pulling you into his lap, fingers feathering over your face as you spoiled him with affection

- He’s not inexperienced by any means, so he’d often easily leave you flustered and breathless. However, you’d soon realize you had the same effect on him, especially when you were softer and more loving with him

Billy Lenz:

- Sloppy, obviously, and unpracticed

- So nervous and breathy at first, but quickly gets overwhelmed and curious, squeezing your face into his hands and allows his feelings to overtake him

- Honestly even that would take him a while to get comfortable with though. Like yes, Billy talks big, but in practice?? It’s a different story. Nervous around people generally, especially around someone he has feelings for. It’s all new to him so he’s eager but reserved and very nervous

- Things can easily get passionate with Billy once you’re comfortable with each other, and since he isn’t the most experienced, you’ll have to guide him along otherwise he’ll just be chaotic lol

- If you give him random kisses throughout the day he’ll return them in his typical chaotic way, squishing your cheeks before giving you a sloppy smooch and grinning at your reaction

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- As with everything Asa related, it really depends on the context and which persona you’re picturing! But even if you only knew him as Asa, I think he’d have a hard time 100% hiding his true self

-…That having been said, it would show especially during intimate moments. He’s always somehow cold, even when he kisses you, but in such a strangely intense way? He treats you as a fascination (and with some amount of hesitancy, especially at first) easily making you get flustered and embarrassed with how attentive he is

- Will actually kiss you in passing sometimes, but it’s always brief and without much feeling. Actual kisses would be a different story, however. He’d be touchy and curious, kind of brief and strange? He’d pull away often, examining your reactions to him (but fully and happily going along with it if you’re more on the eager side lol)

- Sometimes he can be overly passionate as well, getting caught up in the moment and in his curiosities. Things can easily get heated and he’d be somewhat aggressive at times like that, pinning you against a wall or table and wrapping his hand around your neck/squeezing your hips hard beneath his fingers

- Somewhat amused if you kiss him randomly in passing or kiss him first at all really. He finds you sweet, in his own way, and allows it. Despite being pretty cold and such, he would get attached to you in his own way, so affection/intimacy is fine by him

Charles Lee Ray:

- Rough, fervent kisses as he pushes his fingers into your hair or around your waist, pulling you closer to him and grinning into you

- Either really lazy or really passionate. Usually both. Not the most affectionate or sweet ever but he wouldn’t be opposed to you kissing him in passing or being sweeter with him

- …Although he might not always be satisfied with brief, random kisses. Sometimes you get away with it but others he’d make you laugh by pulling you over grumpily and planting his lips on yours

- Would 100% have a habit of kissing you casually/innocently/in passing without even realizing it. Just passes by and plants a kiss on top of your head without even noticing. If you pointed it out he would just outright deny it lol

- Makes you roll your eyes with how unattached he seems and how he’d want to appear as not being clingy or affectionate while secretly always hoping for your affection. Not too proud to admit it if you hold out long enough 👀

Tiffany Valentine:

- Tiffany would adore your kisses, no matter how short or long they are. Quite affectionate herself and often kisses you quickly in passing, loving the sight of her lipstick on your face

- When she actually kisses you though, it’s so full of feeling that it can be almost overwhelming. She would be both gentle and rough, but would definitely take her time with you

- Whispered reverences and sweet words, fingernails on your neck all the while. Once she got you to herself, she wouldn’t often let you go easily

- Would really love if you kissed her first or really gave her any kind of affection without reservation. She’d never turn you down regardless of where you’re at or who’s around to see

- Completely smitten with you and would adore that you wanted to be affectionate with her like that

Dewey Riley:

- Very easily flustered. You could so much as innocently kiss his cheek and his ears would go all red and he wouldn’t stop smiling about it for ages

- Gentle, sweet kisses that would somehow both make your heart race but also make you feel warm and at ease at the same time

- Smiles into your kisses a lot, he wouldn’t be able to help it. Always really touchy but in a really hesitant way, like his hands would hover over you (especially at first when things are still awkward) and he wouldn’t know what to do with them

- Playful and talkative anytime he kisses you, often pulling away just to pay you compliments or make little comments to make you laugh

- Would be too shy to kiss you randomly at first, but if you kissed him in passing, he’d adore it. He’d go out of his way to give you opportunities to, lingering around randomly just because he’d adore your affection. Once he was more comfortable and confident, he’d do the same, although not without second guessing himself and hesitating enough to earn a smile out of you

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

- Soft <3 Superior bed-sharer. Nervous about sharing that kind of space with you at first, but soon grows to love it and ease up a little

- Warm and cozy, will wrap you up in his arms and love if you lean up against him all night. Enjoys having you close and feels all safe like that

- Sleeps pretty heavily/doesn’t move much himself but if you were a clingier sleeper, he’d melt. Like snuggling up to him and just burying yourself into his neck. 🥺 Also loves if you play with his hair before you doze off, he’d lean into your touches and completely relax at it

Brahms Heelshire:

- The clingiest. It’s a slippery slope with Brahms because if you let him cozy up to you once, he’ll want to do it every night lol

- Not one to just doze off, sharing your space like that! Even if you do, he’ll just stay up looking at you and admiring you because he thinks that’s romantic, even if you think it’s weird

- Arms and legs will be hooked around you, all night, every night. Loud breathing right in your ear and scruffy beard scraping against you anytime he snuggles up to you. I’m sorry :’)

(In all seriousness he’d be cozy, I promise)

Michael Myers:

- Sleeping next to him would be no different than sleeping next to a big pillow, besides the fact that he’d be a heavy breather while sleeping. Otherwise, he doesn’t budge the second he lies down

- Not opposed to you snuggling up to him, however. He’d be pretty warm and comfy, even letting you use his arm as a pillow if you liked

- He’d be kind of awkward at first honestly, but once you got used to him, he’d be a comforting presence in a strange way. And no matter how much of a chaotic sleeper you are, he doesn’t really care? You could steal the blankets and snore and kick him in your sleep and he’s pretty indifferent lol

Jason Voorhees:

- Does he even sleep??? Oh well. Even if he doesn’t, once you’re close enough he’d love being close with you like that so he’d love sharing a bed with you while you slept

- Soft for you really, and always amazed that you want to be all snuggled up with him in his little cabin, of all places. You’d make him feel safer and more at ease when you were all cozied up next to him like that

- Snuggly, but in a gentle, restrained way. Mostly, you’re the one snuggling up to him, although sometimes he’d wrap his arm around you and pull you in closer to him, resting his head above yours

Beetlejuice:

- Another one that I’m unsure if he sleeps, but honestly, I can just see that?? A very chaotic sleeper, like snoring and hogging the blankets and taking up most of the bed

- Can also be almost *too* clingy, when he’s in a mood. Which would result in you pretty much unable to move while he snores in your ear, his limbs trapping you in place

- But he’d also be really cozy and sweet sometimes, wrapping his arm around you and playing with your hair/rubbing your shoulder until you doze off

Graverobber:

- Snores, for sure

- Sleeps like a log and takes up a lot of space. He wouldn’t even budge once he dozed off either. It’d take him a while to fall asleep and he’d be more willing to chat, snuggle up with you, etc. when he was tired like that. Will lazily play with your hair or something for ages before finally falling asleep

- Might very well crush you a little bit in his sleep for that reason though like if he dozes off in a certain position he’d just trap you under his arm and you’d be like !!!! because good luck getting him to wake up once he’s out lol

Luigi Largo:

- Loves sharing a bed, and a surprisingly good bed-sharer. Won’t take up more than his share of space (although he would definitely steal the blankets from you)

- Always more willing to be sweet and laid back with you when you’re alone like that, especially when he’s tired. Loves being affectionate with you and you snuggling up to him

- Pretty basic idk?? Can be clingy at times though and loves when you wrap him in your arms and make him feel all safe and cozy

Pavi Largo:

- Probably has the most dramatic, lavish bed. Silk sheets of red and black or something like that. And probably wears a robe and a nightcap lmao

- Not used to sharing his space like that though, like regularly and innocently with someone. Not opposed! But it would take him a minute to get used to it is all

- Although he’d be especially clingy at first for that reason, only because he’d love having you close to him like that. But weirdly sweet about it? Just like gently wrapping an arm around you or kissing your head before you doze off. Doesn’t expect much from you, but if you cuddled up to him he’d melt

Charles Lee Ray:

- Completely depends on his mood. Sometimes he’s shamelessly selfish, sprawling himself out and hogging the blankets as much as he likes

- Others, he’ll just drape his arm over you and press kisses to the side of your face if you’re still awake, talking with you until you both doze off

- Not opposed to you snuggling up to him at night most of the time but he also wouldn’t be opposed to shimmying away from you or pushing your arm off of him if he was uncomfortable or hot lol

Tiffany Valentine:

- The second you’re in bed together, she’d cozy up next to you as close as she could get

- Depending on how tired she was, sometimes she’d stay up and play with your hair, pepper your face with sleepy kisses or just chat with you for a while. Other times she’d just doze off right away, resting her hand over your chest/stomach and keeping you close

- The type to wake up in the middle of the night and smile to herself at the sight of your sleeping face. You could be snoring with your mouth gaping open and she’d find you adorable, probably waking you up to her smiling at you

Josef (Creep):

- *Very* clingy. Even if you’ve shared the same bed for ages, it never wears off, either. One way or another, he’d want to be close to you. His arms would be locked around you, face buried in your neck, almost each time. But he’d love the reverse of that, too

- Also likes sleeping face to face, only because he would stare at you while you sleep sometimes lol

- Snores for sure, very loudly. The type of person to also tangle you up in his limbs in kind of uncomfortable way once he’s dozed off. (Or alternatively, literally not budge an inch, like it’s kind of alarming. If you get trapped under his arm or something you probably won’t be able to squirm out of it, either)

Dewey Riley:

- Cozy!…Or at least it can be. He’d want it to be. Goes out of his way to make sure you’re comfortable, like offering you whichever pillow is fluffier, whichever side of the bed you like, etc.

- And sometimes he’d be cozy and warm and nice! Just wraps his arm around you (and loves if you do the same or snuggle up to him) and sleeps pretty heavily

- But others he snores, hogs the blanket unknowingly, and/or traps you under his arm/leg. You wouldn’t really have the heart to complain though :’)

Chapter Text

Bubba Sawyer:

- Sweet and cozy! He’d be so happy you wanted to share a space like that together and would always be really considerate and respectful :’)

- Nervous as could be when you first start sharing your bed though, like just lies there stiffly and tries not to disturb you. But if you snuggled up to him or anything like that he’d melt, slowly relaxing over time until he’d always look forward to bedtime specifically just for cuddles 🥺

- A pretty heavy sleeper, but occasionally mumbles and groans in his sleep or snuggles up to you a little too tight. He’d also have a habit of playing with your hair or rubbing your shoulder with his thumb as he dozes off

Chop Top Sawyer:

- Probably really atmospheric and nice to share a room/bed with him?? He’d play music softly and have string lights and light candles or incense and all that before bed

- Can be a really chaotic sleeper, tossing and turning and mumbling in his sleep. But he’d adore having you by him like that and it would relax him a lot

- Definitely affectionate and cuddly when sleeping, but he’d especially adore if you wrapped your arms around him from behind or hooked an arm around him with your head rested on his shoulder

Nubbins Sawyer:

- Snuggly, to various extents. Some nights he just rests his head over your chest or arm or something, others he is pretty much inseparable from you, his face nuzzled in your neck and arms hooked around you

- Really would like sharing a bed with you ;-; would always look forward to that time because he’d love being physically affectionate with you and snuggling up. Also loves being able to talk with you for a while before you both go to sleep uninterrupted

- Wouldn’t move much once he actually dozed off, besides slowly drawing closer to you throughout the night. Also probably snores lol

Candyman (Daniel Robitaille):

- Once more, probably doesn’t sleep. But that wouldn’t stop him from happily sharing your bed anyway

- Really relaxing and cozy? He’d just wrap his arm around you and let you lean into him while he talked about random things as you dozed off, occasionally kissing the top of your head

- Loves the opportunity to freely admire you, not that he’d really need any excuse. Smiles at your sleeping face and makes sure you stay comfortable throughout the night

Bo Sinclair:

- I’m sorry, but all of the Sinclair brothers would be chaotic sleepers. Bo is obviously no exception

- Snores, tosses and turns, shoves you to the edge of the bed, steals your blankets, etc. One of these people that would randomly scratch his belly in his sleep too lol (does all this, but is a light sleeper. So if you do the same he just wakes up and gives you a grumpy look. Or alternatively finds you cute and smiles to himself until you wake up and notice, in which case, it never happened)

- It would take him a while to want to share his bed with you anyway (not because he wouldn’t want to, just nervous about closeness and such). So at first he’d have a hard time even falling asleep when you’re in his bed, but quickly gets used to it. Not the snuggliest (or so he says) but he likes having his arm around you while you sleep, or you to be snuggled up to him. Also likes when you play with his hair while he dozes off!

Vincent Sinclair:

- Also chaotic, but not as much so as Bo (Or at least, he would put in more of an effort not to be, only because sharing a bed with you would make him a nervous wreck anyway and he wouldn’t want to ruin it for you)

- Doesn’t fall asleep very easily, but loves if you stay up with him just to cuddle up to him or talk to him until he starts to finally doze off. He’d love falling asleep with his arms tangled around you or you sprawled over his arm with yours wrapped around his waist

- However once he fell asleep he’d be completely out, so if you *were* wrapped up in his arms, you wouldn’t be going anywhere for a while. Also grumbles, snores, and frequently nuzzles up to you without even realizing it

Lester Sinclair:

- Always cute and cozy at first. He’ll just snuggle up with you and make sure you’ve got plenty of blankets and wrap his arm around you and all that. You’d both doze off while talking about random things from throughout your days and it would be nice!

- Also *loves* if you’re big into snuggling up to him at night, like physically melts at it. Or play with his hair as he falls asleep or anything like that

- But once he fell asleep he’d be a little less pleasant lol :/ Will roll over and collectively remove all the blankets from you in one motion. He wouldn’t snore usually but he’d groan and mumble in his sleep

Billy Lenz:

- Before you decide to share a bed with him you’d probably just wake up to him staring at you from the foot of your bed like 👁👄👁

- Kind of nervous about getting close to anyone in any way, so sharing a space like that would be kind of intimidating to him at first (although obviously he’d want to, considering he’d be staring at you at the foot of your bed like that…)

- All stiff and awkward at first, but quickly warms up to the idea. Slowly becomes more and more affectionate with you, and would adore if you were all snuggly and cozy with him (like playing with his hair or wrapping your arm/leg around him or whatever) A pretty heavy, still sleeper especially as you’d put him at ease a lot, so once you’re both comfortable he wouldn’t budge

Asa Emory (The Collector):

- Honestly, probably not too big into sharing his bed with you most of the time. It would at least take him a while to get comfortable with the idea, but he wouldn’t be the worst person to share a bed with

- He’d be pretty basic? He’s not going to snuggle up to you (although he wouldn’t mind if you did to him, or used his arm as a pillow or something) but he’d be weirdly considerate like fluffing your pillows and all that

- His weirdest sleeping habit would be that he’d stare at you in your sleep *a lot*. When you first doze off he’d just be laying turned away from you and acting all normal, but the second you’re asleep he’s like right up in your face lol

Otis Driftwood:

- Bedtime with him usually means he’ll just stay up and talk with you for a while about random stuff, unless you’re both too tired. But almost every night you’d lie over his shoulder and just listen to him ramble on until one of you eventually dozed off

- Probably kicks the covers off in his sleep, so there’d be no shortage of blankets for you. Also probably kind of a light sleeper, and would mumble in his sleep a lot

- Otherwise pretty comfy though. Not very snuggly or anything although he would at least usually sleep with an arm around you or something like that

Chapter Text

Bo Sinclair:

- He has nightmares too from time to time (although he wouldn’t really talk about them/mention them much, at first anyway) so he would understand how upsetting they can be. He can be kind of a grump when he’s tired/has been sleeping, but he’d never complain or say anything if you’d had nightmares

- Wakes up the second you start to stir in your sleep or seem like you’re having a nightmare, and just gently shakes you to wake you up. His heart would always sink when he realized, especially if you cried in your sleep or anything like that

- Reassurances whispered in a gruff, tired voice as his arm slowly curled around you to pull you closer. He’d stay up and listen to you talk about it, or just keep you in his arms like that until you felt better. More concerned about it than he lets on though, although he wouldn’t pressure you to talk about it. But sometimes he’d be hesitant to fall asleep if you’d been having them frequently, wanting to be up to comfort you if you had one

Vincent Sinclair:

- He’d take a while to fall asleep at night so a lot of times, you’d doze off before him. That having been said he’d catch your nightmares before you woke up from them a lot of times, shaking your shoulder gently to wake you up before they got too bad

- Depending on your reaction, he’d usually just pull you into himself and wrap his arms around you in hopes to be a comforting presence. Rests his chin on your head and just strokes your back/rubs your shoulders until you calm down and are ready to fall back asleep

- He’d try to prevent them sometimes I think, by making you as comfortable and relaxed as possible, making your sleeping quarters really pleasant and just getting you in a nice state of mind before sleep?? He’s thoughtful and sweet and would want to be helpful. But if you still had them he’d just do his best to make you feel calm and safe and comfortable.

(Also: a heavy sleeper once he does fall asleep, but would really want you to wake him up if you had a nightmare! He probably wouldn’t notice or wake up but he’d insist that you get him up so he could comfort you through it, for sure)

Lester Sinclair:

- Lester is most likely to take your mind off of whatever your nightmare was about. His heart would ache every time he woke up to you crying or shaken up because of a nightmare, quickly asking you what was wrong and wrapping his arm around you in hopes to comfort you

- If you wanted to talk about whatever the nightmare was, he’d listen without question, letting you talk through it and such while having his arm wrapped around your shoulder, fingers playing with your hair/patting your head

- If you didn’t, he’d just get up and try to make you feel better, talking about random stuff or cracking ridiculous jokes to earn a smile from you. Would sacrifice hours of his own sleep time just to cheer you up, only dozing back off when he was sure you felt completely better (or otherwise, would just skip sleep altogether to take care of you if it was especially bad)

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

- Thomas would be a little reserved about this kind of casual affection at first. He wouldn’t deny you or anything but he’d just tense up each time, giving you a wide-eyed look anytime you went to play with his hair

- He’d love it though but I think for that reason he’d be more tense?? Unsure of what to do, how to react, all of that. At first he wouldn’t even want to get used to it because he’d be afraid he’d start to like it and relax into it and you’d eventually just stop or something

- But when you kept at it and still had a habit of playing with his hair he’d eventually let himself enjoy it. He’d adore any kind of affection from you but the casual, sweet little touches that signaled you just enjoyed touching him and being close with him for the sake of it would make his heart swell. Just watches you with eyes full of admiration all the while 🥺

Brahms Heelshire:

- Brahms would adore any kind of physical affection, as I’ve said before. Playing with his hair would be no exception. If you had a habit of playing with his hair he’d adore it since it meant you’d be affectionate with him often/for no reason and without him having to ask lol

- Would be content to lie in your lap for hours and just let you run your fingers through his hair. He’d lean into your every touch, eyelashes fluttering at the feeling of it. Very touch starved so every little thing would leave him flustered

- Would love lying facing you, his arm wrapped around your waist as you played with his hair. Would just nuzzle into your neck, remaining latched to you for as long as you’d let him

Michael Myers:

- The entire town of Haddonfield would all collectively drop their jaws upon seeing ‘the shape’ all docile and contented to let your fingers comb through his hair. But he would happily allow it, once you were both comfortable with each other, (not so) secretly enjoying the feeling of it

- Not as reserved about things like this as he might be about other things. He’d enjoy casual, easy affection from you that wouldn’t require much from him — only because he’d be tense about that kind of thing at first anyway. But you playing with his hair or anything like that would always put him at ease and he’d like it more than he’d show

- This would be one of the first ways he’d show his affection to you as well. He’d shock you one day by playing with your hair, only for a moment, with a surprising amount of gentleness and restraint

Bo Sinclair:

- Bo wouldn’t outright admit it (unless he was in a mood) but he’d *adore* when you played with his hair. The second your fingers push through his hair he would melt. Loves the casual affection and the feeling of it. If you watched him close he’d like actually physically relax and slump a little right away

- Especially when he’s dozing off or especially tired. Would close his eyes and lean into you, just enjoying the simpleness of it, the familiarity of having someone be close enough with him to do something like that

- Bo would actually calm down a lot when you played with his hair (or gave him any kind of affection really) so if he was upset or angry or just in a generally grumpy mood, you’d just knowingly start to run your fingers through his hair and push the messy strands from his forehead while nodding along sympathetically. He’d catch on, grinning begrudgingly at how easy it was for you to cheer him up

Vincent Sinclair:

- You’d quickly develop a habit of playing with his hair once you got comfortable around each other, just running your fingers through it absentmindedly. Who wouldn’t be kind of tempted to honestly??

- He wouldn’t mind it. A little tense at first, but when he got used to it it would be a comforting thing to him, just having you casually dote over him like that

- Thankful for his mask in moments like those. Your touches would always get him at least a little bit flustered, no matter how light and brief. He’d pretend to be all casual each time, continuing with his work as you played with his hair. But he’d still give himself away with his tense body language. (Once he was comfortable enough to be maskless around you this would be very cute. A blush would spread over his cheek, nervously eyeing you as his lips curled into a smile. Would adore you being so casual and affectionate with him like that)

Lester Sinclair:

- Would adore having his hair played with. You could even just scruff it around playfully and he’d have no complaints, only grinning and enjoying the casual affection

- Most of the time you running your fingers through his hair would end up in him falling asleep. So for that reason he’d love when you did so while you lie in bed together, dozing off to the feeling of you casually touching him like that

- Like Bo, would also love if you played with his hair when he was feeling upset or anything. It would always calm him down and cheer him up for you to look after him like that. He’d love it overall and if you left his hair kind of messy or anything he’d just leave it since it was your doing, would find it cute lol

Josef (Creep):

- He’d just close his eyes and relax his head into your touches, sometimes even nuzzling into you and wrapping his arms around you as you played with his hair

- Another touch starved slasher who would completely adore affection like this. Reserved about it at first but would quickly allow himself to relax and enjoy it, loving that you actually wanted to/had a habit of it

- Would never really get used to it though. He could be going on about something when you’d just brush his hair off his face and start playing with it and he’d just cut himself off, smiling and letting out a quiet, nervous breath at the sudden affection

Dewey Riley:

- I just *know* he’d melt at having someone play with his hair or run their fingers through it. Like to the point of losing his train of thought each time. If he was in the middle of saying something his words would just trail off and he’d just go blank

- Would find it endearing if you actually liked/had a habit of playing with his hair, and would happily let you anytime. Eventually he’d get so used to it himself he wouldn’t even seem to notice, apart from smiling a little at how sweet he found it

- Sometimes more emboldened to be physically affectionate himself when you played with his hair. He’d just pull you around to sit in his lap or closer next to him, giving him easier access to you. Would probably lose his nerve quickly though so you’d have to encourage him a little lol

Ash Williams:

- He’d act like he didn’t notice half the time when you started playing with his hair, but he’d adore it much more than he would want to let on

- He’d really like being doted over I think so he’d love any kind of affection like that and would get used to it quickly. So much so that if you didn’t do it for a while he’d just look at you with one cocked eyebrow anytime an opportunity arose for you to do so, like plz??

- Would love when you played with his hair while he lied next to you in bed, or when he rested his head in your lap. He’d just go on about things while you played with his hair, sometimes leaning back to get a better view of you, relaxing completely as your fingers brushed through his hair

Steven (Specs/Insidious):

- Gets kind of flustered if you play with his hair in front of others (although admittedly he’d be a little self-satisfied) but if you did it privately, he’d completely melt into it

- He’d try so hard to not let it effect him much and just carry on seeming like he wasn’t distracted anytime you played with his hair, and would probably fail

- Kind of like Dewey in that this would encourage him to be more affectionate as well in his own little ways like that. Wouldn’t play with your hair as much but just like random touches on your shoulders/arms, wrapping his arm around you, kissing your forehead for no reason, things like that

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

- Thomas would be very intuitive if you were upset, no matter how much you tried to conceal it. He’d see through it even if you tried to convince him you were okay, although he wouldn’t pressure you to open up to him, showing nothing but patience and understanding

- If he found you crying to yourself/breaking down in private, he would be torn between wanting to leave you alone and wait for you to open up to him, and comforting you. In the end he’d be too upset at the sight of you like that and would end up deciding to approach you instead, as I think he’d know the feeling, and wouldn’t want you to feel as alone as he often had before you came along

- Would just rest his hands on your cheeks and wipe at your tears or wrap you up in his arms until you calmed down. As I said, he’d be very patient and wouldn’t pressure you or anything, only wanting you to know he was there for you. He’d check in on you a lot going forward too, always looking out for you and being sure to comfort you however he could throughout the day, even if just in little ways

Brahms Heelshire:

- Brahms would probably be snooping around when he’d find you breaking down in private, and his heart would sink. You usually seemed happy and such, so his mind would scatter to all the worst possible assumptions (including that he’d done something wrong, shame and worry hitting him hard)

- Might have some of the same reservations Thomas would (not wanting to pressure you or anything) but not quite as hesitant. His own concern would get the better of him before he could even think, and he’d quickly approach you, nervously questioning you

- You getting emotional would make him emotional. He’d just wrap you up in his arms and hug you tight, reassuring you that you could always rely on him and talk to him. Would go out of his way to take care of you for a while after, in really endearing and thoughtful ways

Michael Myers:

- You would have a lot of alone time in a relationship with Michael, so it wouldn’t be much of a stretch to assume you were alone when you finally let yourself get emotional. You would probably also assume that Michael wouldn’t be interested in helping you through it (especially at first) but you would be wrong

- Michael would approach after being absent for a while, looming around when he heard you crying to yourself. Not much would get a reaction out of him the way that the sight of you like that would. His heart would sink, although he wouldn’t be the best at expressing that

- He’d probably startle you with his sudden appearance (to his dismay, he’d want to be more comforting than anything else) and would just sit with you and try to comfort you as best as he could. Would wrap his arm around you or pat your head stiffly. He’d be around more often after that, better paying attention to your moods and hoping to be there for you more

Beetlejuice:

- His usual playful, easy-going personality would sober up a lot seeing you upset alone like that. He’d just freeze, unsure what to do, or if you’d even want him around. But regardless he’d end up coming in to comfort you anyway because the sight of you upset like that would really get to him

- Nervously questions you about what’s wrong or if anything had happened. He’d kind of panic that he couldn’t do more for you (or hadn’t up to that point) and would just hold your hands and listen as you talked or just sat with you if you didn’t want to

- Later would put in a lot of effort to cheer you up if you wanted him to, but despite his own nature being more playful he would be really concerned about you and would encourage and comfort you anytime you weren’t feeling well

Bo Sinclair:

- I think he’d be more inclined to only really be emotional when he was alone most of the time as well. That having been said, he’d understand a little too well what you were feeling when he caught you breaking down by yourself

- And for that reason, he wouldn’t even have the thought to leave you alone. Like, it might cross his mind. Only because he isn’t always the best with feelings. But, he wouldn’t consider it really, because he would know what you were feeling, and he wouldn’t want you to feel like that alone

- He can be stiff with things like that, but he’d just nervously approach you, asking if he could do anything to help. He’d surprise you with how timid he was in that moment, but he’d be relieved to know that he could be comforting to you, even if it was just by being there for you

Vincent Sinclair:

- Would freeze at the sight/sound of you breaking down to yourself. He’d tense up a lot, worried about the many things that might have you like that. He’d be pretty intuitive to your moods so had he missed it, he’d feel horrible, as he’d always want to help you with things

- In the beginning he’d be afraid to approach you until later, but after you’d been together a while he’d hesitantly check on you, hands landing gently against your arms as he searched you with a cautious panic. Mostly really concerned you were hurt, or that something was seriously wrong

- He wouldn’t think to hold you or hug you himself at first but if you did so for comfort he would instantly wrap his arms around you and hold you like that for as long as you needed

Lester Sinclair:

- I think Lester would be pretty intuitive to your moods as well, although if he hadn’t noticed something was wrong or you weren’t doing well, he’d feel so guilty. Seeing you upset and knowing that you tried to keep up appearances around others would break his heart, especially if you tried to hide it from him too

- He would be really sweet about stuff like this and wouldn’t push it if you weren’t up to talking. He would just let you tell him when you were ready, but he’d definitely sit with you, hold you, wipe your tears, take care of you, whatever you needed

- All while trying to fend off his own emotions, as he would hardly be able to stand seeing you like that. He’d try to lighten your load and care for you however he could, hoping to be helpful and comforting to you however he could

Dewey Riley:

- His heart would drop at the sight of you like that. A million things would cross his mind that could be wrong. He wouldn’t even think before approaching you, wanting to help you in some way

- One of the most likely to get emotional at the sight of you emotional. Seeing you like that would pull at his heartstrings, and he’d get so nervous and scramble to comfort you and figure out what was wrong

- Always really sweet and thoughtful, clumsily spilling reassurances and comforting words in hopes he could make you feel better. He’d sit with you as long as you needed just to make sure you weren’t alone, trying not to get too upset on your behalf so he could be more reliable for you

Ash Williams:

- Mostly just confused and concerned. He’d feel guilty for not noticing something was wrong sooner, and would be a little hurt (but surprisingly understanding) that you didn’t come to him or tell him

- But would start overthinking things a little bit, thinking of all the times you seemed so put together and carefree. Would kind of over-analyze in the future, more cautious about your moods and observant of you

- Wouldn’t really expect an explanation or anything from you right away and, if you wanted him to, he’d just wrap his arms around you and rest his chin on your head, stroking your back and quietly reassuring you. But later he’d probably question you a little about what was wrong (not pushy though) and would just encourage you to rely on him more when you were up for it

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

- You would be sitting together outside somewhere on a pretty day when you would just casually take a ring from your pocket, proposing to him in a simple and sweet way. You would probably already know the answer, as Thomas’ feelings would be no secret, so you’d smile confidently as you watched him slowly realize what you were doing/asking

- His eyes would go so wide, ears flushing red when he saw the ring. You actually asking him to marry you would make his heart race so bad. He would have planned on it himself, but you beating him to it would be even better. He almost wouldn’t believe you, but before he could second guess it he’d make you smile with a fervent nod, smiling himself as relief spread over your face

- His hands would actually tremble as you slid the ring onto his finger, clasping them in yours as your smiling lips met his. His heart would swell with love and admiration for you, and he’d be thinking of the image of you proposing to him like that for ages

Brahms Heelshire:

- It would be difficult to keep anything a secret from Brahms, so you’d probably just have to spring it on him. Randomly asking him one day after thinking about it for a while, and watching in amusement as his eyes go all wide

- He’d wonder if you were serious or if you were just teasing him, probably just staring at you with wide eyes as he waited on you to give some indication

- When he realized you were serious, you’d instantly get wrapped up in the tightest bear hug, if only to hide his own flustered expression. He wouldn’t let you go for a while, accepting your proposal right away, his heart fluttering at the thought of you wanting to stay with him like that

Bubba Sawyer:

- Bubba would turn the brightest shade of pink when he realized what you were doing. You would hardly get your words out before he’d fervently nod, earning an emotional laugh from you at how sweet and eager he was

- His hands would tremble if you had a ring, or even if you didn’t, he’d just hold you with shaking hands and probably keep you in his arms for as long as you’d let him. You’d make his heart swell so much in that moment

- He wouldn’t have had any expectations from you (although he would definitely have thought of it himself, he would be unsure of himself) so he would almost be disbelieving of your offer. Easily one of the most emotional reactions and just can’t stop smiling and blushing

Chop Top Sawyer:

- Chop Top wouldn’t expect anything from you either. So when you asked him to marry you he wouldn’t even really know how to react. His words would get all clumsy and awkward and he’d just stare at you with raised eyebrows

- …Until a huge grin spread on his face when he realized you were serious. In which case he’d obviously accept, hardly able to stand how endearing he found you in that moment, looking all nervous and expectant

- If you proposed with something random and thoughtful, rather than a traditional engagement ring, he’d love it even more. Like a mood ring or something like that lmao. He’d probably turn it into a necklace or something though because otherwise he’d probably lose it :/

Nubbins Sawyer:

You: Will you marry me?

Nubbins: !!! Yeah :^)

You:

Nubbins: :)

(End of conversation)

(I’m kidding. But not really, that’s it in a nutshell. I do think he’d be a giddy, flustered mess though. Clingy as heck for the rest of the day, probably longer honestly)

Beetlejuice:

- The biggest grin when he realizes what you’re doing. He’d have jokingly proposed to you countless times in the past and while he’d *want* to actually marry you he wouldn’t really be sure about it, all things considered. Him being technically dead and all

- You would surprise him with it, in a casual way. First you’d just ask him to marry you. He’d just scoff, not really registering it as being a serious question until he examined your expression, his eyes narrowing as he tried to figure you out

- However when you showed him you’d even gotten a ring for the occasion, you’d have to laugh at how much his facial expression changed. Eyebrows raised and mouth just dropping open, looking back and forth between you and the ring before quickly agreeing, half-afraid you’d change your mind. Would drown you with kisses and affection afterward and wouldn’t stop calling you his future wife/husband/spouse

Bo Sinclair:

- When he realized what you were doing, he’d instantly stiffen up and try to keep his composure so as not to express how much you had just stirred him up. The thought of you putting yourself out there like that and asking him, wanting to be with him like that would just make his heart flutter and stomach knot up

- He’d try so hard not to let it show too much but would fail horribly. His eyebrows would raise and he’d nervously scoff, his smile slowly growing as you waited for him to answer

- Despite countless hesitations, the answer would be yes, of course. He’d ravish you with kisses and rough affection, overwhelmed with adoration at your bold proposal, genuinely contented and happy at the prospect of having someone like that

Vincent Sinclair:

- Examines you cautiously and hopefully when you propose to him. He’d hang onto your every word, no matter how clumsy and awkward. To him, they would be nothing short of perfect

- He would think of proposing to you several times, in his own way. But unless you gave him a lot of encouragement he would never actually do so, a part of him still worried you wouldn’t/shouldn’t stay with him in Ambrose

- So when you did the proposing his heart would melt. He could (and would) marry you on the spot if you asked. Would flush up so much as he pondered your words over, his heart wouldn’t stop racing and stomach wouldn’t stop fluttering at the thought of it for ages

Lester Sinclair:

- Wholeheartedly believe Lester would probably just cry if you proposed to him. Like, he would be a smiling mess, but that wouldn’t stop him from temporarily losing it

- He’d never have guessed he’d have that?? Especially having someone like you actually proposing to him first and wanting to be with him like that. His heart would just about burst. Would probably be all like are you sure?? You really want to?? And his smile would get wider each time you just nodded

- So affectionate afterward, and if you got him an engagement ring, he’d be extra careful about taking care of it. Would smile anytime he looked at it (which would be all the time really) and would ponder over you asking him all the time, beaming at the thought of it

Josef (Creep):

- One of the most likely to actually get teary eyed when you propose to him. He’d just go so quiet and would smile as he realized what you were doing, barely able to believe that he had someone like you, and had gotten to that point in a relationship with you

- He’d just nod, barely able to form words after you asked. You’d slip a ring on his finger with a smile on your face, and Josef would just about come undone at the sight of it

- You’d lift your hands to his cheeks and press a soft kiss to his lips, the tension and emotion obvious in his body language. He’d stiffly lift his hands to keep your hands on his face, trying to keep himself from getting too emotional as you smiled against his lips

Dewey Riley:

- Can you imagine his facial expression when you proposed?? Heavy-eyelids and raised brows, big goofy smile, nervous laughter asldfkj

- His heart would race so bad as you asked him. He would probably nervously have prepared to propose to you as well, but it would take him ages to muster up his courage. He wouldn’t have expected you to do so and would be pleasantly surprised, going so red around the ears and neck

- Would answer almost too quickly. If you got him an engagement ring he’d blush and smile so much as you slipped it on, and wouldn’t be able to stop staring at it and showing it off to others. So smitten with you in general but it would always show more when you surprised him like that

Steven/Specs (Insidious):

- You wouldn’t know someone would be capable of going quite so surprised and pink as Specs would when you proposed. You’d propose to him in the old fashioned way, with a ring and all. His ears would go so red and suddenly his glasses would fog up a whole bunch

- Would just clam up and go all quiet for a second, almost forgetting to reply, until you tilted your head toward him nervously. In which case he’d sputter a nervous ‘yes’, a sweet smile spreading over his face

- Instant hugs, would melt into you, his cheek pressing against yours as you squeezed him a little too hard. He would have no complaints though, his stomach all fluttery and mind spinning

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

• Thomas would never actually initiate something like that himself. You’d have to be listening to music yourself one day when he’d saunter in, giving you the idea right away
• You’d slide your hands over his shoulders after guiding his to your waist, instantly causing him to tense up and watch you intently
• You would guide him along, slowly causing him to relax as you smiled at him. He’d look at you so lovingly, his hands slowly trailing around and landing at your lower back, pulling you closer to him
• He’d love sharing things like that with you. Just little sweet, affectionate things that made him feel all the closer to you

Brahms Heelshire:

• Once you dance with him once, he’d want to dance with you all the time
• He’d play music all the time just to create the opportunity, pulling you gently toward him until your faces were inches apart and his arms were tangled around you
• Obviously, it’s just an excuse to be close to you. He wouldn’t care about dancing at all really, it would just be a chance to get you close to him
• Endless swaying to classical music, your hand wrapped in his as he slowly lowers his face next to yours, just to be closer to you

Bubba Sawyer:

• Bubba would love dancing with you so much. Anytime music plays and you’re both not busy, he’d pull you over into his arms, grinning if you just went along with it
• Can be goofy and light-hearted about it sometimes but also would love just being close with you and enjoying the casual intimacy of it. You having your arms around his neck as you swayed to the tune of a mutually loved song
• Always stares at you and admires you when you’re close like that. Just smiling and enjoying your company, counting himself lucky to have someone like you to do things like that with

Chop Top Sawyer:

• Dancing with Chop Top is normally chaotic, and frequent. When he realizes you enjoy it too (or at least, are willing to play along, if only for his sake) he’d constantly be trying to get you to dance with him
• Constantly playing music anyway so there’s no shortage of opportunities
• Usually he’d be playful about it, loving to joke around and play with you
• But when a slower song came on and you pulled him into you by his waist, he’d go silent, laughing nervously and happily wrapping his arms around your neck, laughing and blushing all the while

Nubbins Sawyer:

• Nubbins would always be happy to dance with you. And although music would be a good incentive to do so, he’d happily dance with you anytime, regardless of whether or not there’s any music
• Sloppy and clumsy, makes you laugh the whole time, which would only encourage him. He’d love knowing he could get smiles and laughs out of you
• Blushes so much if you pull him in close, making eye contact with him and swaying gently. Could easily stay like that for ages though
• The rest of the family looks at you two like you’re crazy because he’ll just drag you outside and dance with you to no music for no reason, and you’d just be laughing along with it the whole time

Bo Sinclair:

• Rolls his eyes at you when you first attempt to get him to dance with you. You’d have a lazy evening together when you’d put on some music and pull him over to you, earning a protesting grumble
• And yet, he wouldn’t resist at all. His hands would snake around your waist, pulling you as close to him as he could
• Depending on his mood, this would either just last a for a moment or two, until he got impatient and just crashed his lips against yours, pulling you further into him. Or, he’d actually enjoy it, savoring the moment and feeling himself get butterflies at the way you eyed him as you danced. Would lose his train of thought every time your hands moved or you looked at him too intently

Vincent Sinclair:

• He’d be listening to something pretty and classical in the basement when you’d sneak up on him, slowly pulling him into yourself to dance
• His whole body would go tense when your hands slid around him, his gaze burning into yours through his mask
• Everything is kind of intense with Vincent idk you’d probably go into all confident and playful and then a few seconds would pass and your face would already be hot lol
• Of course he’d happily go with it though. Everything would be gentle and restrained and you’d make his heart race, but somehow, you’d be the one that would end up all flustered

Lester Sinclair:

• Chuckles nervously when you pull him into you to dance, tangling your arms around him and grinning as an obvious blush spread across his cheeks
• He’d always be so amazed at you, even just over simple things like that. You’d make his heart race so bad, in the best way possible
• He would make you smile with how sweet he was about it. Awkward, sweet high school vibes honestly
• This kind of thing wouldn’t happen often with him but when it did it would be so special and sweet. He’d love sharing moments like that with you

Dewey Riley:

• He would love dancing with you honestly. Anything romantic or sweet he’d always be up for
• But that wouldn’t stop him from being so clumsy and awkward about it. Will he step on your toes? Probably. But you wouldn’t have the heart to complain really
• Nothing but smiles anytime you dance with him. He’d want to be as close with you as possible but he’d be so respectful and a little reserved about it so he’d never push his luck. Of course, if you pulled him closer, he would have no complaints at all (although his face would go super red suddenly)
• Doesn’t matter if you’re in a formal situation or if you’re just messing around alone at home, he’d always politely ask if you want to dance with him first, while smiling hopefully

Chapter Text

Bo:

• He wouldn’t really know what to make of your love poems/notes at first, and for that reason, probably wouldn’t respond even half the way you’d quietly wish he would
• Just acknowledges them appreciatively, you know?? If they’re poems he’d compliment your writing and would tease you for being so smitten with him, smugly smiling to himself that he inspired things like that
• The thought of you actually thinking to do something like that for him would really make him smile though. Knowing he was the inspiration behind your words and that you’d taken the time to do something like that because of him would make him grin to himself endlessly
• It would be the little things that would really do him in though. Like little notes and reminders you’d leave around, just warm and sweet things that let him know you were thinking of him and cared. He’d keep every single one and would look at them sometimes, smiling as he mulled your words over. Not that you’d ever know it

Vincent:

• Vincent is also a creative, so he would know the amount of time and thought that would go into things like this. And the thought of that would make his heart swell, because he’d love being the reason you did things like that
• Being on the receiving end of your letters and poems would make him redden each time. Would feel almost undeserving of your sweet words and the effort behind them
• You would be his inspiration as well, of course. Not so much with love letters or poems (although he would dabble, especially with love letters) but with art
• You’d catch him rereading your letters constantly, just smiling to himself with a loving look in his eye as he mulled your words over

Lester:

• Lester would *adore* things like this. You could so much as leave little notes just reminding him of little things and he’d adore it. Your every word would make him smile, and if you left little doodles or anything as well?? He’d melt
• If you actually took the time to write him whole love poems or letters, he’d be a flustered mess. Like, you really took the time to write something that beautiful for him?? He’d need a minute lol
• Would read them over and over and over, and would revisit them anytime he was missing you, or even just because. He’d be so grateful for you and would really take them to heart
• Most likely to write you love letters back. They would be clumsily written and really straight-forward but in such a sweet and endearingly sincere way, every word completely from the heart

Chapter Text

• Dewey would think himself the more protective one at first. Having gone through everything he has, he wouldn’t be able to help but worry after you and your well being, always sure to check in on you and such
• But when you started being the same toward him, maybe even more so, he’d be a little taken aback at how much you cared for him and worried after him. He’s used to being the one to be like that for others, so to know someone, especially you, was worrying after him would make him feel strangely warm
• But like. In such a way that he’d also worry more about you, especially if you had a tendency to put yourself in dangerous situations for his sake
• (scolds you for it) (but also can’t stay mad because he loves you so much for it)
• Little things like just sticking up for him in more casual settings would always earn an appreciative smile. He wouldn’t ever say much about it (besides maybe suggesting you didn’t have to do that for him) but he’d love that you cared about him the way that you did
• Wouldn’t appreciate you putting yourself in harm’s way, ever, though (Well, he would, but he’d worry about you so much) However the thought of you caring about him enough to take care of him like that wouldn’t go unappreciated. You’d always be so admirable in his eyes
• Doing little things like checking in with him to make sure he’s okay, insisting he be careful, making sure he’s okay and safe would make his heart flutter. He’d look at you with the sweetest expression, fully able to understand your feelings/concern as he’d feel the same toward you
• If you were on the chivalrous side and did things like walk him to his door and things like that he’d find himself enjoying it more than he would want to. He’d do those things for you too of course but knowing how much you cared for him would always earn blushes and smiles
• Overall your protectiveness would be really endearing to him and he’d love knowing that you cared for him that way, it would definitely go both ways

Chapter Text

Thomas Hewitt:

• Thomas would always be happy with anything that made you happy. And he’d find such a sweet and pleasant hobby so endearing
• He’d love watching you bake and helping if you’d allow him. Likes seeing you in your element all focused and such. He’d always admire how many things you could make and would always love sampling things you made
• If you made stuff just for him/with him in mind he would melt
• Huuu imagine him in an apron all focused and helping you in the kitchen :’)) his big burly hands being as gentle as they could manage as he tried to help you
• Or him getting flour or something on his face and you dusting it off and him going red at the ears, even at something as simple as that

Brahms Heelshire:

• Before you are his S/O (and before he even reveals himself to you) he’d adore when you baked because the smell would reach him wherever he was in the house. You’d make it feel so homey and comfortable
• Needless to say, you’d be left scratching your head as to where all your baked goods were disappearing to
• When you were actually together he would attempt to help you. And by help you, I mean trail around you in the kitchen and watch you work
• Attempts to reach for things before you’re finished with them which results in him getting his hands swatted away and him looking genuinely betrayed and heartbroken asldkfj

Michael Myers

• Michael is generally (seemingly) indifferent and uninterested and this would be no different. Just another thing you do that he kind of tilts his head to and then moves on from ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
• Except in reality he would be quite interested in you/your life, in his own way. And this would be one of your more endearing, interesting hobbies
• Which is a sentiment you’d only be able to pick up on after being around him a while. Actually hanging around and watching you bake would be a big thing for him in itself
• Not to mention, you’d begin to suspect him when things you’d baked began disappearing mysteriously 👀

Bo Sinclair:

• Complains about it some, like you’re baking again?? He’s going to be drowning in pies and cookies and everything else if you don’t stop… 👀 (this is more of a request than it is a complaint though, don’t be fooled)
• Coming inside to the smell of freshly baked goods would make him feel things he wouldn’t quite understand. It would feel way more homey all of the sudden and he wouldn’t know what to do with it?
• Pops in and out of the kitchen to try things as you go along. Swipes batter out of the bowl or eats raw cookie dough or anything like that. And if you swat his hand away it will only encourage him
• Lowkey wants you to invite him to help you. Would do so begrudgingly/hesitantly as if he didn’t love spending time with you like that

Vincent Sinclair:

• Anything you enjoyed doing, Vincent would be intrigued by. He would enjoy watching you bake and seeing the amount of thought and care went into it?? Like a quiet observer and learner
• Although he would want to help and if you invited him to he’d be very pleased/eager to help you and learn
• Half because genuine curiosity and half because he’d love spending time with you like that, especially doing something you liked that made him feel closer to you
• Would love sharing interests like that and would eventually open up to you and share his art with you more as well, quietly enjoying the sight of you all impressed as you watched him paint/sculpt/etc.

Lester Sinclair:

• He would think you were so wholesome and sweet for having a hobby like that. Would genuinely enjoy just watching you bake. Would watch you with a big smile, both finding you adorable but also happy to see you happy and enjoying yourself
• And of course would help you in a heartbeat, if you invited him to. Smiles the whole time and can’t help but stare at you while you work
• Actually seeks out recipes and cook books and things like that for you from time to time and would want to help you make new things
• And like Bo, coming home to the smell of something yummy baking would make his heart flutter. You’d make him feel so warm and cozy and at home??

Dewey Riley:

• Dewey would love helping you bake. Anytime he got the chance he’d happily assist you in the kitchen (while sampling things as you went along)
• Would quickly get spoiled on things you made lol
• He’d be so supportive, always encouraging you and complimenting you. Would genuinely think you were so talented for being able to make so many different things
• Baking dates with him for sure! He’d follow your every instruction with great care, secretly stealing glances at you while you worked
• Also: you can’t convince me Dewey wouldn’t be extra and festive about it. Will buy you matching aprons and oven mitts. Would come up with the idea to make seasonal appropriate things on his own. Your hobby would soon be adopted as his own :’)