Archive of Our Own ^beta

“You really used to do this?” Eve asked dubiously as she let Toni nudge her chin up, red lipstick held in her hand. “Why?”

“Because it looks pretty,” Toni said as she artfully mapped out the contours of Eve's mouth, emphasizing her pouty upper lip. It was a shame that Eve hated make-up of any kind because by god did she have amazing features. If Toni ever got to contour Eve's cheekbones, she was going to die a happy woman. “Rub your lips together like this?”

Toni demonstrated, and Eve followed her example a bit too enthusiastically, smearing the carefully drawn outlines of the lipstick. That was okay though. By the end of this it'd be smeared all over anyway.

“Looking good, Evie,” Bucky said where he was sitting on the bed, watching them get ready, and Toni smirked when she saw the slight flush high on Eve's cheeks.

“It feels kind of nice,” Eve admitted, and Toni grinned as she picked up her favorite shade of mauve and a small hand mirror to do her own lips.

“Right? And it looks great on you, sugarplum. You should wear red more often.”

Eve raised an eyebrow as she plucked at her bra strap. Toni followed the motion of the red lace with hungry eyes. “You took care of that already, I think.”

“And I'm glad for it, darling,” Toni purred as she snapped her mirror shut, crawling right into Eve's lap so they were pressed together, bare skin to bare skin. She'd chosen a blue set of lingerie for herself tonight that perfectly matched Eve's underwear, subverting expectations for no reason other than she could. She rolled her hips over Eve's bare thighs, humming in approval when she felt Eve's hands on her ass, steadying her. “You can grab harder, sweetie. I'm not gonna break.”

Eve grinned – the one where one corner of her lip raised in a way that was fifty percent cocky and one hundred percent a turn on – and leaned in to kiss Toni. Toni dodged her at the last second, tutting under her breath as she ran a hand through Eve's hair. “Let's keep the lipstick intact for now. Better results that way.”

She glanced over at where Bucky was sitting on the edge of the bed now, legs spread and a hand already on his cock as he watched them. Toni smirked, swinging her leg off Eve and instead crawling over to Bucky on all fours, looking him straight in the eye as she did.

“You look like a tiger,” Bucky said, half-amused, half-aroused, and Toni grinned when she heard Eve get up to join them, walking over and sinking down next to Toni on her knees.

“So we take turns?” Eve asked, and Toni batted Bucky's hand off his dick to replace it with her own, gripping him delicately around the base.

“I'd like that kiss now actually,” Toni said innocently, and Eve's eyes sparked as she moved closer, hand coming up to cup the back of Toni's head. Toni let Eve drag her forward, shifting down the crucial inch to get the head of Bucky's cock level with their mouths before they both leaned in, their lips meeting around the tip.

Bucky cursed wildly, and Toni absently noticed the way his hands dug into the mattress as she snaked her tongue around the girth of him to find Eve's, a thrill racing down her spine when Eve met her with an enthusiastic lick. It was less of a kiss and more of a filthy bit of frenching, but Toni loved it, especially once she pulled back and saw the streaks of lipstick that she'd left all over Bucky's cock.

“Fuck,” Bucky breathed, and Toni looked up at him from under her lashes as she let her mouth travel further down, smearing traces of purple all along his cock. “Jesus Christ, Toni.”

“This is the weirdest kind of painting I've ever done,” Eve said, and Toni laughed right against Bucky's dick, making his leg twitch.

“It's pretty. I told you.” She reached over to grab another lipstick, this time a deep blue, and put it on her lips. “Course usually the different colors would come from as many girls, but since my orgy days are behind me, we'll have to make do.”

“What a hardship,” Bucky said, his voice tight, and Toni took pity on him, taking him in her mouth and sliding down as far as she could. She closed her eyes when Bucky gripped her hair, a little too tight at first but quickly gentling his grip once he regained control. “Fucking hell. Little warning?”

Toni pulled off, eying the smears of blue she'd left behind with satisfaction. “What, can't handle head without a heads up?”

“You're not funny,” Bucky said warmly before he groaned as Eve moved in to replace Toni's mouth with her own. She'd put on the lilac lipstick by herself, Toni saw with a burst of affection, and Toni couldn't help but reach down to trace her stretched mouth with a finger, smiling when Eve looked up to meet her eyes.

“You're so pretty,” Toni mumbled, and Eve lowered her eyes as she got back to sucking Bucky's cock, but Toni caught the slight blush she was trying to hide. Fuck, she loved that woman so much it was ridiculous.

Not one to be outdone, Toni grabbed their last lipstick, the dark red one. As soon as she'd painted it on, she leaned down and fitted her mouth around the base of Bucky's dick, licking at the part that Eve's lips didn't reach. Bucky's thighs twitched, and on the next pass Toni followed Eve's lips up to the tip, digging her tongue into the slit as Eve went down the other side, pressing kisses along Bucky's shaft.

“God, do you have any idea how that looks? How am I supposed to last?” Bucky asked breathlessly, and Toni bit down on a smile as Eve's lips joined hers again, meeting around Bucky's cock head. They kissed leisurely, tongues sliding around the flesh and dipping in and out of each others' mouths until Bucky was squirming, his hips jerking in tiny, aborted thrusts against their lips. “Fuck, you're killing me here. Please.”

Toni gave Bucky one more lick before she pulled back, looking down at Bucky's cock. They'd really made a mess, streaks of color intertwining all along the shaft, forming a pattern that was almost artistic, like a modern painting. She only looked up when Eve pulled her forward by the shoulder and into a real kiss, deep and dirty from the get go. Toni's gut clenched at how swollen Eve's lips were, same as her own, and when Eve moved closer to fit a thigh in between Toni's, she whimpered, grinding her pussy into Eve's skin.

She could hear that Bucky had taken matters into his own hands, jerking himself off, and after all the work they'd put into this, that just wouldn't do. So Toni broke the kiss, panting as she tilted her head just enough to get her mouth back on Bucky's cock, sucking him down to the hilt. She jolted when she felt Eve's hand sliding down her thigh before she dipped two fingers between Toni's legs, dragging them over the wet patch on her panties. Toni keened, and Bucky cursed before the sound was cut off by what Toni quickly realized was Eve, kissing Bucky even as she kept playing with Toni's pussy and god, this had been the best idea ever.

“I can't,” Bucky gasped against Eve's lips, and Toni recognized it for the warning it was, sucking Bucky's cock so hard it hollowed her cheeks, tongue pressed right under the head. Bucky came with a muffled shout, one hand fisted in the sheets and the other grabbing Toni's head to keep her there as he pumped his come down her throat. Toni swallowed it all, unbearably turned on as Eve crooked her fingers to scratch her clit through the lace fabric, the sensation just on the right side of too much. She broke away from Bucky's cock as soon as he was done to grab Eve's hand, holding it still so she could grind against her fingers.

“I'll eat you out so fucking good after this,” she gasped, and Eve groaned, hooking an arm around Toni's waist to pull her closer, working her whole hand against her pussy now. The sight of the lipstick smeared all around Eve's mouth should've been ridiculous, but all it did was turn Toni on more, knowing what they'd done to make it that way.

“Room for one more?” Bucky asked as he slid behind Eve, wrapping an arm around her waist to get a hand on her pussy. Eve groaned, letting her head thunk back against Bucky's shoulder, and Toni seized the opportunity to kiss her neck, burying her nose in the smell of her. A hand in her hair made her move up so Bucky could drag her into a kiss over Eve's shoulder, right as Eve's hand picked up the pace, making Toni's legs twitch with a spike of lust.

She could already feel her orgasm building, and luckily Eve could read her like a book, keeping up the same motion and pressure until Toni was a gasping, writhing mess, grinding her pussy into Eve's hand until the tension snapped and pleasure washed over her, making her whole body sag as she groaned.

“Fuck, that's so good,” Toni moaned, and Eve whispered a breathy “Yeah”, pulling Toni into her arms and just holding on as she sat up on her knees to give Bucky better access, which he seemed to take shameless advantage of, judging by the noises Eve made. Toni would've loved to watch, but Eve's grip on her was tight, and Toni had no objections to being in Eve's arms, so she simply closed her eyes, running her hands up and down Eve's back until Eve tensed all over, shaking for a second before she let out a deep-chested groan that sent another pulse of pleasure right to Toni's pussy.

They all sat tangled together in the aftermath until Toni finally got her wits about her enough to say, “So. Rainbow parties, am I right?”

“Think you made your point, yeah,” Bucky said, voice still rough from his orgasm, and Toni chuckled, leaning up to press a kiss to his lips.

“Told you. I did this all the time in college. Good times.”

“We all need a shower after that,” Eve said, ever the pragmatist, and Toni grinned, kissing her too before she got up and held out her hands to both of her lovers.

“Good thing I've got the biggest one in the tower. Let's go.”