Actions

Work Header

Nikki and Kimi but it's Phoenix Wright.

Summary:

"Nikki’s heart thumped. Was it possible for your heart to beat so hard that it breaks your ribs? What did Kimi think of her? Did she just see her as an annoying rookie? But it didn’t feel threatening, Kimi’s eyes on her. More like, it made Nikki want to make a good impression. This was an important prosecutor, after all, so that’s natural! Was it weird to be looking directly into Kimi’s eyes like this? Well, Kimi was doing it too, so it can’t be that weird. Right?"

On her second ever case as a defense attorney, Nikki is given the unfortunate news that the prosecutor on her case has been changed. She'll now face the prestigious, undefeated prosecutor, Kimi.

Nikkimi is basically like if Edgeworth and Phoenix met, skipped the entire part where they were bitter rivals and understood the wisdom of simply falling in gay love with each other from the start, so I'm doing *exactly* that.

Notes:

Even though there's an LN character called Nina, Nikki's sister was always "Nina" in English for the longest time, and it just goes with Nikki the way that Yoyo goes with Nuannuan. I've reluctantly accepted every other character rename we've been given but that's my limit, Elex/Paper!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: Trial, Day 1, Part 1

Chapter Text

August 3, 9:47 AM

District Court

Defendant Lobby No. 3

 

“Hey, what kind of joke is this!” Bobo slapped the paper in her hands, shouting at the bailiff. “This is only Nikki’s second case!

“Ma-Ma’am, I assure you there’s no mistake!” The Bailiff said, attempting to be authoritative in the face of a defiant 5’2 girl in braided pigtails. “That is most certainly the correct information for the trial!”

“This is ridiculous!” Bobo said. “Aren’t there meant to be laws about this kind of thing?! How is Nikki supposed to prepare!”

“Bobo, calm down, please…” Nikki said “Whatever’s on there can’t possibly be that bad!”

Bobo spins around to face Nikki, stumbling a little bit and almost losing her balance. The “former spy” was Nikki’s first client, falsely accused of the murder of fellow spy Neva, but had none of the grace or sophistication that “spy” brought to mind. She was very invested in her spying expertise and knowledge, and brought it up at every opportunity, however. The orange overalls over her striped white turtleneck didn’t help. “Ohhhh, it’s bad, Nikki! It’s so bad we should sue! They can’t do this to us! They can’t do this to your client!”

Bobo hands the papers over to Nikki. Nikki looked the part of an experienced lawyer by LA standards, with her pink suit with a flared pleated box skirt, flat white shirt and pearl necklace with a little heart pendant. The strap on her stilettos had a heart shaped clip. But, this was only her second case. Bobo was the client in her first.

“You see?” Bobo says. “They took Payne off the case! The prosecutor for this case now is none other than Kimi Schiller!”

“...Kimi Schiller?” Nikki says. “Is that bad?”

“I’m afraid it most certainly is.” A man’s voice says. “At least, for yourself and your client.”

Bobo and Nikki turn to face him. Tall, with white hair slicked back in spiky tufts, a white gloved hand to his chest in a brown suit. “But for the people of Los Angeles and the side of justice, there can be no better news than for Prosecutor Schiller to lead the case. My name is Detective Joe Brownie. I haven’t had the opportunity to meet you during the investigation of this case, Miss Nikki. I apologize for the rudeness of only introducing myself now.” Joe gives a polite bow to the two of them.

“O-Oh, th-”

“What do you mean the side of justice? We’re the ones on the side of justice!” Bobo says.

“Bobo!”

Detective Brownie shakes his head. “The defendant in this case, Mr. Giroda, is most certainly guilty. Therefore, Prosecutor Schiller is the one on the side of justice. Rest assured that nobody in the legal profession will look poorly on you for abandoning this case with this knowledge, Miss Nikki.”

Nikki looked up at Detective Brownie with a gentle smile, and spoke in her usual soft, polite tone, clasping her hands behind her back. “...We believe in innocent until proven guilty, Detective. In fact, it’s the law. But I’ll demonstrate Mr. Giroda’s innocence in this trial.”

“...Some might find your persistence admirable, but only because you’re new to the profession.” Detective Brownie says. “I’m afraid that Mr. Giroda’s guilt has already been proven. The proof of this guilt is the fact that Prosecutor Schiller has taken the case. I would expect anyone who’s been through an American law school to recognize her name instantly.”

“Lady Kimi is the prodigy prosecutor who rules the courts!” Bobo says. “Even though she’s only young, the chief prosecutor lets her choose any case she wants because she’s never lost in court! Not even a demerit point! She’s undefeated!”

“And despite that privilege, Prosecutor Schiller has never taken a day off.” Detective Brownie says. “Although she has the ability to do so, and could choose a lighter caseload, and would even have our support, she refuses because she is committed to justice for the good people of Los Angeles. Therefore, because she cannot fail in court, the fact that she will prosecute Mr. Giroda proves that he is guilty. Before Prosecutor Schiller had chosen this case, I had thought there was a slim chance that he could be innocent as well, but she eliminated those doubts. I am sorry that you had to learn of it from me. A resignation will not bring shame to you or your firm. You can feel free to confirm this with your superiors at your firm.”

“...It’s my firm.” Nikki says. “My sister… won’t be able to practice law for a long time.”

Joe raises an eyebrow, seeming disturbed, and maybe even a hint of disappointment. “I was under the impression you were an associate at Mercury Law.”

“You think she actually took that creep up on his offer?!” Bobo says. “She knows better than that! She’s not selling her firm to anyone!”

“Indeed?” Joe says. “Then if you intend to fight, please ensure you do not disappoint Prosecutor Schiller. Her patience with defense attorneys does have limits, after all.”

With that, Joe bows, and leaves the two girls alone.

“The nerve of that Detective!” Bobo says. “I’d like to see that smugly stoic look on his face wiped off when the Judge confirms that Giroda didn’t kill Chigda once and for all!

Nikki doesn’t want to discuss the confrontation with Bobo just now. Although she put on a gently confident face in front of Joe, the conversation itself was frightening. Kimi has never lost a case. Kimi has chosen her case. And she can choose any case she wants. It was bad enough that Bobo was angry about the change on Nikki’s behalf.

She wasn’t really ever meant to be a lawyer… her sister needed her, and trained her to pass the bar exam by herself, before her sister had vanished searching for their lost father. Even her first case, defending Bobo, wasn’t just nerve-wracking but soul -wracking - one awkwardly delivered line, and an innocent woman could be put away for a murder she never committed while the man guilty of the crime would be able to laugh in her face and humiliate her forever. This was meant to be her sister’s company - that’s what everyone assumed when they saw the firm’s name. She also has to defend it and save it for her sister, so her sister even has anything to come back to.

Now, this perfect prosecutor, who’s never failed, is her opponent in just her second case…? What would Nina say? But in this system stacked in the favour of the prosecution, any pleading that this was unfair on Giroda would fall on deaf ears. 

Nikki has no business spending time being sad or upset. At least one of the things Nina would probably tell her right now, is “A lawyer is someone who smiles no matter how bad it gets.”

But then she’d also probably add “So that’s why I keep smiling whenever we go out and none of the rich managing partners try to make a move on me!”


 

Court was not yet in session. Giroda had taken the defendant’s stand, scrunching his hat as a nervous habit, looking around at the gallery, keeping his head low.

“Don’t worry, Giroda!” Bobo says. “You know, just a couple of weeks ago, I was in exactly the spot you’re in now! But the person who saved me was Nikki! She even managed to beat my old spymaster on the stand!”

“...I heard that they changed the prosecutor for my case.” Giroda says. “Is it bad?”

It’s easy enough to be kind to your client, to help them out, to console them, but they don’t just need a helping hand, they need a firm rock to have faith in. Nikki can be kind, but she needs to project confidence for Giroda to latch onto… even if she’s used to primarily following her sister around or letting other people mostly lead the way, since her case with Bobo, she’s learned she needs to be the one to lead the way.

“Don’t worry about that, Mr. Giroda.” Nikki says, gently raising a fist. “I believe that you’re innocent, and when the truth is on your side, you can’t fail in court. The truth is everything here.”

“Yeah! Even when it looks desperate, Nikki finds a way to turn it around!”

“Oh god…” That didn’t actually comfort Giroda. “...It’s gonna get desperate?”

Um… no she can’t say ‘Um’, Nina would tell her that. She can’t say ‘Um’, or ‘uh’. But the temptation to say ‘um’ was hard to bite back on, because everything she thought instead of ‘um’ became ‘um’ as well. Um.

“...Court can be unpredictable.” Nikki says gently, with a sympathetic look, folding her hands in front of her. Don’t say ‘I think’, because that sounds less confident. Just state a fact without any little speech ornaments that make you sound more modest or humble. That was what the judge kept telling her over and over in the case with Bobo, and the prosecution, and the witnesses, and Bobo. “But I promise we’ll help you weather the storm ahead. If it’s getting too intense, I can try to call for a recess, or… we can find other ways to help you.” 

The Judge shuffled into the room, and the people in the gallery began to sit down, but Prosecutor Schiller wasn’t here yet.

“We’d better go to the bench.” Nikki said to Bobo. Deliberately saying it before Bobo can suggest it - to make sure she looks like she has some leadership here.

Bobo nods. “Just sit tight! We might even get this sorted out in just one day!”

Bobo and Nikki head to the bench. Nikki shuffles some papers around, putting notes and evidence together in her physical folders. The gallery starts murmuring, and there’s footsteps and shuffling above as the last people begin to file in. 

Then the doors to the court fling wide open.

The whole room holds its breath, as if a spotlight shone at the entrance. 

Detective Brownie entered, bowing to the court. “The District Court would like me to announce the arrival of Prosecutor Lady Kimi Schiller.”

Like striding on a red carpet, the perfect prosecutor’s entrance was announced by the click of her stiletto heels. In a brisk pace, gaze focused on her bench, Kimi Schiller walked into court, with a proud, businesslike expression. Wrapped in a mermaid-skirt gown of glimmering white, a stylish and feminine white blazer, and a stark grey coat hanging off her shoulder, held in place by her hand. Platinum hair finer than silk, braided into a half updo by a black bow.

While the entire court held its breath at Schiller’s entrance, Nikki was transfixed. Her face… Nikki thought it was elegant, beautiful, maybe even adorable. She was probably shorter than Bobo without those heels, but just from her aura she felt 7 feet tall. But she also didn’t seem unapproachable. More like she was magnetic - she had the air of a leader. Someone who people would follow and listen to the command of, not just because she was in charge, but because they felt she had earned their loyalty, the kind of leader who always sees themselves as needing to prove their worth again and again-

Kimi Schiller took to her stand, with Detective Brownie behind her. No shuffling of the papers, probably because they were already perfect. Once settled in, with a perfect swish of her hair, Kimi flicked around to face the other side of the court, and set her eyes on Nikki.

Nikki’s heart thumped. Was it possible for your heart to beat so hard that it breaks your ribs? What did Kimi think of her? Did she just see her as an annoying rookie? But it didn’t feel threatening , Kimi’s eyes on her. More like, it made Nikki want to make a good impression. This was an important prosecutor, after all, so that’s natural! Was it weird to be looking directly into Kimi’s eyes like this? Well, Kimi was doing it too, so it can’t be that weird. Right?

There was a subtle shift in Kimi’s face, but not one Nikki could really define. The eyes creeping a little wider, her mouth parting just a touch, her posture straightening. What did that mean? They were still meeting eyes! Nikki felt like she was smiling. She was smiling? Wait. Is that good or bad? No it’s good because she wants to greet this important prosecutor in a way that makes a first impression, so a smile works! One of them should probably speak soon. That would be good. Generally to greet or introduce yourselves you have to speak eventually. Kimi was the more senior lawyer here so she’d go first, right? 

The gavel came down. 

Snap. Nikki blinked a few times, and looked down at Bobo, who was leaning in to Nikki with flattened eyebrows and her mouth in a confused curl, so exaggerated she looked like a chibi on a Moments sticker.

“Aaaaare you okay there, Nikki?” Bobo says.

“Court is now in session for the trial of Giroda Faeson.” The judge says. “Are the defense and prosecution ready?”

“The defense is ready, your honour!” Nikki says with a nod.

“The prosecution is ready, your honour.” Kimi says. Oh. She has a nice voice too! That’s probably helpful as a lawyer. That way people will want to hear your arguments, no matter how long they go for. Listening to Kimi talk will be nice.

“I must say, the defense looks quite cheerful today.” The Judge says with a skeptical look. “Even though your client has been accused of murder?”

Called out! Nikki nervously shuffles her paper together but smiles at the judge. Don’t say ‘I think…’. “...The facts will show that Mr. Giroda is completely innocent of all charges, your honour.”

“The facts will show no such thing.” Kimi’s voice cuts through the air. She talks simply, almost casually, but her voice is like a graceful steel blade. Kimi places her hands on her hips, letting her coat fall as she does - and in a practiced motion, Detective Brownie catches it before it can hit the floor, and folds it over his arm. Kimi stares down at Nikki, this time with a much sterner expression. “The prosecution will prove the guilt of Giroda Faeson in this trial. The facts will show that Giroda Faeson murdered Chigda, director of the Wishes 4 Kids foundation, because he learned about the truth - that Director Chigda was corrupt to the core.”

“M-Miss Schiller!” The Judge says, aghast. “Do you mean to say the victim in this case is some kind of villain?”

“That’s for history to decide, not the courts.” Kimi says. “Some people might find Mr. Giroda’s motive sympathetic, given his anxious and desperate state of mind. But Mr. Giroda learned that his employer was exploiting the donations and charity of others meant for sick children, and funneling them to his own extremist religious ends. The facts will show that in shock from this revelation, Mr. Giroda plotted to take the life of Director Chigda, in an act of premeditated murder. Detailed evidence will prove that Mr. Giroda made and wrote plans. They will show that the plans were definitely created by Mr. Giroda and nobody else. They will show that the plans show the same method of murder used in the crime. They will show that Mr. Giroda has no alibi for the murder. They will show that Director Chigda identified Mr. Giroda as his killer. In fact, I predict that in only three hours, you will be convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that Mr. Giroda is guilty, and the trial will be over.”

Oh no. She’s brilliant at this. She speaks so confidently, and with such authority - and everyone knows about her perfect record, so when she says ‘the facts will show’, everyone expects incontrovertible proof, because how and why could she lie or be mistaken about the evidence? She doesn’t even sound cruel saying it, but every word is like an incredible weight stitched into Nikki’s chest. In the defendant’s stand, Giroda looks like his neck is slumping with each sentence, looking crestfallen. Even Bobo feels herself sinking to the bench.

“...Well, that sounds quite decisive.” The Judge nods. “The trial itself feels superfluous now. The defense should note that as this is only their second case, nobody would judge them if they resigned now-”

 

Objection!

 

Kimi held her finger out, with an accusing glance up at the judge. The Judge reared back in shock, and seemingly, shame.

“M-My apologies, Prosecutor Schiller! I’m not certain what you’ve objected to, however, I’m sure th-”

“There is in fact someone who would judge the defense if she were to resign.” Kimi says. Then, she looks at Nikki. “That person is Prosecutor Kimi Schiller.”

Nikki raises a hand to her chest, her mouth dropping open slightly.

“Nikki.” Kimi says. “This is only your second case, is it not?”

“Y-Yes! That’s right!” Nikki says.

“Everyone else may be bluffed by your lack of experience, but I hope you aren’t one of them.” Kimi says. “I apologize for my presence being a surprise in this case. However, I’ve had the time to review your previous case. Nobody should be judging you by the fact that you’ve only had one case. They should be judging you by the quality of your cases. What you did in that case was beautiful yet flawed, like an uncut gem.” 

Kimi lowers her gaze, but keeps her eyes fixed on Nikki. “Despite that, I saw your raw talent shining through, and even more than that, I saw your commitment to being a zealous advocate for your client.” A flicker of flame in Kimi’s eyes. “I don’t look down on you as a clueless rookie. Anyone who does that is more clueless than they believe you are. I look at you and see a woman who can become my equal. You are more than worthy of being my opponent! Show that woman to me!”

Stunned, like blasted by a gale of wind, Nikki felt her fists curl on top of the bench and a smile grow on her face as she leaned in. Where Kimi’s face was fiery and determined, Nikki still felt her natural bounce and softness shine through even as she sounded more excited and ready. She raised a fist up. She tried to start speaking, but felt a little spring of nausea flutter in her throat, keeping her from easily saying… anything at all, for a moment. Don’t say ‘Um’. Say anything other than ‘Um’. Just start with a word, any word. “...You …seem like you care about the truth, Prosecutor, so…” Don’t say ‘Um!’ “...I want to show you the truth about Mr. Giroda’s innocence… so that even you can believe it!” Nikki gave Kimi a pure, uncompetitive smile.

“That’s exactly what it will take to win!” Kimi says. “I’m satisfied! Detective Brownie, take the stand. Let’s introduce the facts of this case!”


 

Joe takes the stand.

“Witness, state your name and occupation.”

“Joe Brownie. I’m a homicide detective with the LAPD.”

“Review the case for us, Detective Brownie.”

“Of course, my lady.” Joe gives a slight bow. 

 

~Witness Testimony~

 

“The victim in this case is Director Chigda, a member of the board of directors for the Wishes 4 Kids foundation. Chigda’s body was found in his penthouse apartment with multiple bullet wounds. He died of blood loss on the scene, at 1 AM on September 25th. Due to the presence of broken or disturbed furniture, we concluded there were signs of a struggle, but there are no signs of a break-in, so we’ve concluded the killer must have entered with a keycard.”

“Explain the keycard system of the building for us.” Kimi says.

“Certainly.” Joe says. “Wishing Woods is an exclusive, luxury residential tower. As part of its security features, all apartments use a keycard system for locks. One keycard exists for each resident, and a ‘guest’ keycard and a ‘staff’ keycard exist as well. But no other keycards exist - and because of a complex security system, it is impossible to create fraudulent ones, or open doors locked by them through other means, unless the door was to be destroyed completely. This means that for Chigda, who lived alone, there were three keycards for his apartment - his, the guest one, and the staff one.”

Kimi nods. “In my penthouse suite, I can request digital records of which cards are used and at what times. Wishing Woods is the same, is it not?”

“Indeed it is. That’s how we confirmed what happened. The guest card was used to enter Chigda’s apartment at 12:55 AM, five minutes before Chigda’s death. The staff card was never used for Chigda’s apartment, at any point. The only other card used that day was Chigda’ personal card.”

“We know that the killer did not break in, so they must have used a valid security card.” Kimi says. “With the staff card eliminated, the guest card - the one that wouldn’t be on Chigda’s person - is the only possible option. Therefore, whoever entered at 12:55 AM, using the guest card, must almost certainly be the killer.”

The Judge nods. “I see…! So whoever entered with the guest card must be the killer. Another flawless case from Prosecutor Schiller.”

“Wait a sec!” Bobo interjects. “If I worked for the building, I could use the Staff Card and just hack the records to say ‘tee-hee, no I didn’t’! How do we know nobody else entered?”

Kimi’s gaze cuts right through Bobo, who can’t help but shrink away. “If you’d like to suggest that the person who entered 5 minutes before Chigda’s death, using a card that wasn’t Chigda’s, was for some reason not the killer, you can save the entertainment for the true crime podcasts. I guarantee all evidence I present in court is completely free of tampering and has gone through my personal team of forensic experts. The reason it was impossible for the building staff to modify the records was because the system itself only has ‘read’ access - the only way to ‘write’ to it is by swiping the cards. But I had the system tested by the best pen-test hackers in the country, and not one of them were able to think of a way to add a card entry to the records that didn’t involve swiping a card. So if you’d like to propose there was a secret master hacker, better than all the others in the country, involved in the case, that would narrow down the suspect to maybe one of 80 people in the entire world, all of whom are under strict federal surveillance, and therefore, have airtight alibis.” Kimi pauses. “Does that settle that?”

“It does indeed!” The Judge says. “I would like to advise the defense to keep from bothering Prosecutor Schiller with pointless remarks.

Bobo withered under the combined glare of the prosecution, police, and the judge. Nikki placed a supportive hand on her shoulder, before turning back to Joe.

“Regardless, more evidence is still needed before I’m satisfied.” Kimi says. “Detective, continue.”

“Of course, Prosecutor Schiller.” Joe says with a slight bow. “We discovered the guest card at the residence of Giroda Faeson. When we tested it for fingerprints, his were the only set we could find. So we know for certain that the defendant possessed the card, and handled the card.”

“This also rules out the possibility that the defendant was unaware they possessed the card.” Kimi says.

“Indeed.” Joe says. “But that wasn’t all we found. We also discovered that the defendant had been doing his own independent investigation of Director Chigda. He’d documented, rigorously, his own evidence that Director Chigda was embezzling donations from the charity for his organization, New God Dominion Church.”

“NGDC was registered as a tax-exempt religious organization with Chigda as the sole owner and director.” Kimi says. “It’s a megachurch with ‘cultlike’ practices according to various NGOs and credible papers. Until his murder, Chigda’s role as director wasn’t known - it seems outside of Chigda’s inner circle, one of the only people who knew was in fact, the defendant.”

“Wait a sec!” Bobo yells in again. “How do we know that has anything to do with the case! Someone could’ve just killed him for no reason!”

Kimi shakes her head. “There’s no need to be silly. Detective Brownie, was anything missing from Chigda’s apartment?”

“...Yes. We found that his personal desk had several locked drawers. One of them was unlocked and left open, with the key still in the lock. Chigda’s belongings were organized quite meticulously, so the absence of anything that should’ve been there was immediately noticeable. In fact, each drawer had a slip of paper inside, taped to the back of it indicating what should be found inside. The drawer left open was supposed to contain an accounting ledger for church business, and several other ledgers - and these were missing. It appears Director Chigda kept records on his own embezzlement.”

“I… well…” Bobo says.

“And was anything else taken?” Kimi says.

“Not at all. There were no shortage of things a burglar might be interested in. In fact, even in that same drawer, there were several bound up wads of cash that were left untouched.”

“My theory.” Kimi says. “Was that the defendant was so disgusted with himself for his crime, that he couldn’t bring himself to take the cash. If this is true, I’d like to suggest a more lenient sentence. Or he believed he would be caught quickly, and so there wouldn’t be a point.”

“I see…” The judge nods. “Was Director Chigda’s ledger ever found?”

“Yes. But let’s return to that later. There’s another fact we need to attend to.” Kimi says. “The murder weapon. Detective Brownie?”

“An M1911 pistol - which for the benefit of those who don’t know about guns, is a very common and standard handgun you could find anywhere. In fact, it’s the kind used by the LAPD. The M1911 uses .45 caliber ACP ammunition - the exact type we extracted from the walls of Director Chigda’s apartment. Using tests of the ballistic markings, we were able to match the ammunition to a specific gun.”

“Good.” Kimi says. “Let’s tie everything together now. The police recovered the murder weapon. The police recovered the guest keycard. The police recovered the stolen ledger. The police also recovered plans for the murder of Director Chigda, that these events matched. And every single one of these things… was found in the home of the defendant.”

“Wait! Hang on! Objection!!” Bobo leans over the edge of the bench, waving her hands around. “That’s… you can’t do that!!”

The judge bangs his gavel. “The defense will-”

“I’ll handle it.” Kimi says.

“O-Of course, Prosecutor Schiller! My apologies for not knowing my place.”

Kimi narrows her eyes at Bobo. “Objections are for lawyers. Unless you are one, then let the defense herself raise an objection. Don’t blame me for raising facts about your client. If those facts point to your client’s guilt, then the fault lies in the facts, not the one who introduces them.”

“Wait! But what if the evidence was planted?!” Bobo says. “It has to be!”

“Your knowledge of the case is lacking.” Kimi says. “I’m happy to correct it. Joe?”

Joe bows. “...When we investigated the defendant’s home, we didn’t find these things immediately. They were all stored securely, in one location. …A safe.”

“This particular safe.” Kimi says. “Is fingerprint locked. Outside of destroying the safe or dismantling it, as we had to do, no other method exists to open it. And the only fingerprint that could open it… is the defendant’s.”

Silence in the court. Then, murmuring in the gallery.

The Judge bangs his gavel three times.

“Order!” The Judge pauses. “…I believe that we understand the facts of the case now. Thus, I am ready to render a verdict in this case. This court finds the de-”

 

Objection!

 

The objection comes from Kimi.

The Judge’s eyes widen. “P-Prosecutor Schiller! …But I don’t understand. Isn’t this an open and shut case?”

“The defense hasn’t had the opportunity to cross examine yet.” Kimi says. Kimi turns her gaze to Nikki. 

Oh, that’s Nikki’s heart going again. Thump, thump… but Kimi’s gaze is considerably nicer than the one she’s been using on Bobo, but also aggressively confused. 

“In fact, the defense - the actual defense - hasn’t spoken through the presentation at all. Not even to raise questions.”

Ah… that’s true. While Nikki has been watching and listening, feeling a sense of anxiety for Giroda, her confidence and determination haven’t really wavered. Even in a case like this, there are all kinds of places to start.

…And another part has just been in awe of Kimi, as a lawyer. If you look from the outside at the law as just an intellectual game, or performance, it was magical. She was clear, direct, she had perfect pieces of evidence, closed the holes, sounded authoritative, laid the foundation and built on it to a dramatic climax so perfect it gave Nikki a fright. And as she did it she spoke and moved gracefully, calmly, casually even - but powerfully. Underneath her beauty and calm was an invincible legal warrior. You even forgot that she was barely 5’1 without her heels as she spoke. It was just natural to look at this woman who was barely even Bobo’s height and look at her like a mountain.

Ah… the way she asked questions to Joe, so directly and confidently. That’s how a good prosecutor should be, isn’t it? Nikki thinks that when she becomes a better lawyer, maybe her attitude would be different. Her confidence is different to Kimi’s after all, but to be able to lay the facts so clearly, to lead the flow of logic so elegantly, and those beautiful eyes, how you could tell that underneath that princess of the court was a woman who could also be understanding and supportive, and hair so soft that Nikki-

Oh, right, court.

Oh, right, Giroda.

“...I had a feeling that as you explained everything about the situation, you’d eventually answer most of my questions.” Nikki says gently, but with confidence behind it. “So I didn’t feel the need to interrupt.”

“...I see.” Kimi says, nodding. Oh, Kimi is looking her over… is she appraising her? “You don’t seem fazed by any of the facts I presented.”

Nikki nods. “That’s because I know Mr. Giroda is innocent of all charges. There’s no need to worry about any of the facts you’ve presented.”

“Really? You think even with the knowledge of the safe that can only be opened by Giroda, that contained the guest keycard, the ledgers stolen from the apartment, the murder weapon, and the plans to murder Director Chigda, you’re still this confident in the defendant’s innocence?”

Nikki nods again. “Even knowing about the safe, I believe my client is still clearly innocent, and I will show that in this trial.”

“I don’t see how that’s possible.” Kimi says.

“Ah…” Oh god. There’s such an obvious logical point Nikki wants to bring up, but how to do it in a way that doesn’t insult Kimi? After all, Kimi certainly has thought of it too, so implying that she didn’t would be rude. No wait, it’s better to look like an impressive lawyer and bring up the points that matter. “It’s just… I was expecting you to go over the defendant’s alibi. Which you said he lacked.”

“Do you dispute that?” Kimi says. 

“The defendant was asleep during the time of the murder.” Nikki says. “And I have evidence to support that.”

“...I want to say ‘I don’t believe you’. However, I have more faith in you than that.” Nikki’s heart fluttered. Kimi has faith in her already? That’s nice!

“Nikki, stop smiling like that!” Bobo nudged her with her elbow.

“Huh? Oh, sorry… ahem!” Nikki turns back to Kimi. “Once the defendant’s iPhone and Apple Watch come back from repairs, I’ll be able to demonstrate that it recorded his sleep cycle during the time of the murder.”

Kimi’s eyes widen. Murmuring in the gallery.

“Forgive me, Miss Nikki.” Joe says. “But I’m afraid the objection that Bobo raised to the key records would be just as valid for sleep records on an Apple Watch. It could be hacked.”

“I’m sorry Detective, but I don’t believe that’s the case.” Nikki says. “The Watch doesn’t just record whether or not someone has pressed sleep or not, but it also records information about what phase of sleep someone is in by reading a constant heartrate. So, for information to be faked, someone would have to fake a realistic graph of sleep phases based on heart rate, and one that was consistent with all of the defendant’s past sleep logs. It’s a much bigger job than simply hacking somebody’s iCloud account!”

Joe’s eyes widen. “I… well…” He turns back to Kimi. “That’s…”

“Something that can be easily remedied.” Kimi says. “You’ve given the solution already, Nikki. Giroda’s iCloud account can be accessed on any device. His Apple Health information will be stored there. Why can’t we login there now and see the information that you say must exist?”

“I…” Nikki pauses. “...The defendant… has forgotten his password.”

“Then let’s reset his password.”

“...The password to his email is… stored on his phone.”

“...I see.” Kimi shoots a look at the defendant, who shrinks back further into the stand, trying to hide his face, then back to Nikki. “I can’t blame you for having a sloppy client, but you must understand this case could end before that information comes to us.”

Nikki takes a deep breath. This is hard to say, to someone like Kimi, but she needs to show Giroda that she really is an advocate for him. Gently, very gently, Nikki says: “...I understand you believe he’s guilty… but… please don’t speak about my client that way.”

The entire court is silent. Kimi is speechless, that someone would in any way, reprimand her. Joe looks partially aghast. The Judge’s shocked expression is so stock-standard it could be used as a sprite in a visual novel.

“Miss Nikki…” The Detective says. “It is not your place to-”

“That’s enough.” Kimi says to Joe. Then, she looks up at Nikki, looking… unsure. Not nervous, not intimidated, not lacking in confidence, not ashamed or anything like that, more… surprised.

Then, Kimi smiles. 

“Alright. I’ll agree to that. Unfortunately, your alibi won’t hold up without further evidence, and even then I’ll scrutinize it until it crumbles into ashes. However, with the little time you’ve had to prepare for the case, and your lack of experience, that was a very clever way to try to establish one, and I admire your commitment in how you stood up for your client.” Kimi says. She tilts her chin up, still smiling. “Now I want to see you do a cross-examination. Can you do that for me?”

“Of course!” Nikki smiles back. Maybe too cheerfully, maybe beaming just a little too much, but then again, Kimi looks really happy too, so it must be okay and appropriate in court!

“Nikki, stop blushing.” Bobo says under her breath.

Ah.

Chapter 2: Trial: Day 1, Part 2

Chapter Text

~Cross Examination~

Nikki thought Kimi was probably used to people calling her cold. Maybe they’d say she had a ‘cold gaze’, or a ‘cold attitude’, but Nikki didn’t think that was who she was at all. The way Kimi was looking at her seemed joyless, even arrogant, but… there was something in her face, in her movement, in the way her eyes focused on Nikki that felt more like a hopeful talent show judge, or maybe a coach. Kimi’s probably really nice when you get to know her!

That gaze was intense on her now, as Nikki turned to cross examining Joe Brownie. Joe, for his part, looked at Nikki in a way most people would probably mistake for polite and respectful, but Nikki couldn’t help feel masked some kind of contempt - in a way, he was the real arrogant one. This man really saw her as a rookie who should’ve given up from the start. He was annoyed this was still going.

“Detective, you said the murder weapon was an M1911 pistol, is that correct?” Nikki says.

“Of course.” Joe says with a slight bow. “There is no mistaking it, if you were planning on questioning it.”

“That wasn’t my intention. Actually, what I’d like to confirm is that you said the LAPD uses those handguns as well. Is that correct?”

“That is correct.”

“Should I infer from there that you use one as well?”

“Yes, I own several, in fact.” Joe glanced at Kimi, as if expecting her to raise an objection as to relevance. But Kimi simply stood with her hands on her hips, looking down at Joe with a less friendly gaze.

“Do you hold a license for your handgun?”

A very slight shift in Joe’s voice and brow were the only things that indicated he’d taken a little bit of offense. “Yes, of course, Miss Nikki. Even the men and women of the LAPD need a license for a handgun in the state of California, even though we’re required to carry them for our work.”

Nikki nods. “Does the defendant own such a license?”

Joe opened his mouth to respond, but then stopped. Then he glanced down.

“That’s a simple question.” Kimi says. “Surely the police investigated this.”

“My apologies Miss Nikki, but I’m afraid I don’t understand the relevance.”

“I can explain it for you.” Nikki says with a genuine smile. “Since we know for sure that weapon was used for the murder, then in order to commit the crime, Mr. Giroda had to come into possession of it. But if he didn’t have a gun license, he couldn’t actually purchase the weapon.”

 

“Objection!”

 

Kimi points at Nikki. “I’ve prosecuted dozens and dozens and dozens of cases where the culprit procured a firearm illegally. There’s nothing remarkable about it. The simplest way is to travel to a state with looser laws, purchase it there, and then travel back to California. Besides that, don’t forget that the defendant absolutely had possession of the firearm after the crime”

The Judge nods. “I agree. Just because he couldn’t purchase the firearm legally, it says nothing about whether or not he actually possessed it.”

“But every gun has a serial number!” Nikki says. “And through that serial number, you can trace it back to where it was purchased, distributed from, who purchased it, and even transfers across state lines!” The mention of state lines raises Kimi’s eyebrows. “Not only that, but if the serial number wasn’t filed away to begin with-”

“I’m afraid the serial number was in fact filed away.” Joe says. “Apologies for not mentioning this earlier in my testimony. I’ll ensure it’s added to my testimony right away.”

“Nikki, are you going somewhere with this?” Bobo whispers to Nikki.

“...I don’t know right now, but I can’t just leave flaws in the case unaddressed.” Nikki says. 

“Filing away the serial number of a handgun shows consciousness of guilt.” Kimi says. “We weren’t able to determine if they were filed before or after the crime, but before seems the most logical answer, which also speaks again to premeditation. However, that was an excellent line of questioning, especially for someone on only their second case.”

Joe raises his eyebrows and turns to Kimi.

“Is there a problem, Detective?”

“Of course not, my lady.” Joe says.

Nikki beams. Praise from Kimi! It only made her want to impress Kimi even more. It was almost distracting - almost, because Nikki wanted to be a good lawyer, and think about her client whose life was on the line above anything else, but the urge to impress Kimi only grew each time Nikki felt those stern, appraising eyes look her over. They were so pretty, too. Everything about Kimi was pretty.

“Keep going.” Kimi says. “I want to see what you do next.”

“Of course!” Nikki says. She looks back to Joe. “On the same line of thought… can we prove that the safe belonged to Giroda before the crime?”

“Is that reasonable?” Kimi says. “The safe was locked to his fingerprint. It had to have been locked after the contents were put in. The contents have his fingerprints. On top of that, he could have simply purchased it immediately after the crime, so when he came into possession of it wouldn’t prove anything.”

This safe is the biggest thing pointing to Giroda’s guilt. If Nikki can’t poke holes in it, then she can’t do anything to save Giroda. Even if the attack seems pointless, the most important thing to do is relentlessly wear down every detail about this safe until she can finally find a hole she can open with evidence.

Kimi’s logic is almost airtight. It’s exactly the kind of thing Nikki would expect from her. The safe had to be sealed by Giroda’s fingerprint - that can’t be questioned, because otherwise, how would his fingerprint unlock it? Wait a sec…

There’s an opening right there! A big one! But it must be something Kimi has a way to deal with. I mean… it’s Kimi! Nikki realized that a part of her buried deep down would be disappointed if Kimi’s case wasn’t so perfect that this seemingly obvious logical flaw couldn’t accommodate it. In fact, she almost felt excited to find out how Kimi would deal with it. Her arguments were so dazzling, but they also felt like guiding stars, arranged to point Nikki to being a lawyer with the skill of Kimi.

“...You said you were unable to open the safe except by dismantling it.” Nikki addresses Joe. “Is that correct?”

“It was Prosecutor Schiller who stated this… but yes, that’s correct.”

Nikki nods. “Then… how did you confirm that Giroda was the one who the fingerprint belonged to?”

“I…” Joe raises a finger, then closes his hand, looking down. Now he looks confused.

Gotcha! …Right? Well she may have Joe, but surely Kimi won’t be beaten by this. But if someone other than Giroda could open the safe, that opens the stage for him being framed deliberately.

Joe turns to Kimi.

“Don’t look at me.” Kimi says. “You should be able to answer this one yourself.”

“You’ve got him, Nikki!” Bobo says, pumping a fist.

“That’s… well… the safe was owned by the defendant, so it must have been his fingerprint that unlocked it.”

Nikki shakes her head. “I won’t let that kind of logic fly when my client’s life is on the line!” She says - and just like Kimi, she delivers a forceful point at Joe, who actually flinches back, perhaps by Pavlovian association, actually raising a hand to guard himself from it. 

Nikki looks past Joe, and sees Kimi, her eyes lighting up. Her chin tilts up with a smile - in fact she looks delighted . Hands on her hips, almost bouncing up a little. Nikki can’t help but beam and blush. 

Their eyes meet - oh, that’s intimidating. Kimi’s looking in her eyes, with a smile, a real smile. Nikki didn’t know that you could just look at someone smile at you and feel warm - like physically warm, like her body was really being comforted. But then there was an anxious side of it too - because did she mean it the way Nikki was feeling it? Because it felt intense, but was it as intense as Nikki was feeling it, or is Nikki just overexcited? Nikki couldn’t help but let her gaze lower just a little, but tried to keep her eyes on Kimi and remember that smile. It was relaxing and exciting at the same time. Could Kimi keep smiling at her like that forever? That would make her feel better.

“I… am afraid that… I do not know the method by which we determined that. Forgive me.”

Murmuring in the crowd. Nikki thought Bobo was saying something, but she couldn’t hear her. Joe lowered his gaze and looked away, a bead of sweat forming on his forehead.

The Judge’s gavel strikes three times. “Order! I must say, Detective, this is very concerning. If the prosecution is going to present evidence, they should at least verify it is valid evidence first.”

“My apologies, your honour, but this is not the fault of the prosecution.” He says, bowing slightly. “The blame lies with me alone. I did not adequately prepare to testify, and did not expect that question. However, Prosecutor Schiller will be more familiar with the forensic details of the case.”

“That’s correct.” Kimi says - still smiling. That felt wonderful. Kimi turned back to face Nikki with that same elegant flick, that made her hair fall so- “Nikki.” Oh, she’s talking! Nikki felt herself perk up, a little bounce in her stance. “That was excellent. I understand what you’re trying to do. You want to suggest that the evidence was somehow planted to frame Giroda, and it becomes much harder to do that if he really locked the door. But by questioning how we managed to figure it out, you’re pursuing an opening through a narrow but crucial hole, in a way many attorneys in this city would fail to do. In fact, I don’t think I can even describe everything about how good that was just now.”

“I…” Nikki felt dazed. “...Thank you, Prosecutor Schiller!”

“Nikki, are you okay?” Bobo says.

“However.” Kimi says. “That’s why I’m almost reluctant to close that hole. Detective, it’s disappointing and reflects poorly on you that you didn’t know the answer to this simple question.” Joe bows gently to Kimi with his eyes closed.

“H-How can you close the hole?!” Bobo says.

“By using my private forensic lab.” Kimi says. “In addition to using the services of the police, I also have my own forensic lab funded by my own wealth, employing some of the best forensic experts in the country and beyond, which the LAPD are certainly aware of. We’ve innovated many original forensic techniques, including ones that are strictly patented so they couldn’t possibly leak outside of our lab. One of them is ‘forensic fingerprints’.”

“Forensic… Fingerprints?” Bobo says, with her eyes widened and jaw dropped. “Hey, I never heard about anything like that as a spy!”

“If you’d paid attention to papers published in important forensic science journals, you would have.” Kimi says. “Not that it’s available to the public. By using specific, highly sensitive plastic materials, we can replicate the oils in a fingerprint to use on Touch ID or other fingerprint triggered devices. Naturally, the LAPD took the defendant’s fingerprints, and then we used them to test the dismantled safe. Even though the door would no longer open, we would be able to see if the lock released or not on the dismantled door.”

Kimi gives a pointed look to Nikki. “Before you suggest that a ‘true culprit’ could have used this technique to fake Giroda’s fingerprints on the safe, there’s only one factory in the world that produces the plastic material needed, and we have an exclusive contract with them. In other words, I can guarantee that only my private forensics lab can produce that material!”

Nikki genuinely resisted the urge to clap.

Joe bowed satisfied. The gallery murmured. Gavel strike.

“Order! …Well, it seems that Prosecutor Schiller has proven why her reputation is earned again. I apologize for the moment of doubt I felt.”

“What the hell is with this judge!” Bobo says under her breath.

“No apologies necessary.” Kimi says. “You only felt that way because of the work of an excellent defense attorney.”

Oh… there wasn’t a smile on Kimi’s face this time, but Nikki still felt borderline intoxicated. She couldn’t help but smile brightly at Kimi, but with a distinct blush. Kimi’s face was stern, but it felt approving. Nikki felt like she was floating.

“Nikki, what the hell has gotten into you?” Bobo says under her breath.

“H-Huh?” Like the breaking of a spell. Nikki looked back at an unimpressed Bobo. “O-Oh, sorry, um… I guess I… just admire the way Prosecutor Schiller practices the law. Even if she’s my opponent.”

“Are you sure?” Bobo says with a skeptical face. “Kinda looks like you’re admiring something else about her.”

“Bobo!” Nikki said. She felt her face crumple. Blush like a buzzing in her face. “She’s… just a very admirable person!” 

“Suuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuure.” Bobo says with that same flat, skeptical face. “She’s so admirable she wants to lock Giroda up for something he didn’t do!”

“Well… she’s a prosecutor! From her perspective, I’m trying to help Mr. Giroda avoid justice.” Nikki says softly. “So we can’t judge her for doing her job.”

“But do you have to be so happy about it?”

“Um… I just enjoy my job!” Nikki says. “Being a lawyer can be fun sometimes!”

“I believe we’ve gotten everything we can from your testimony, Detective.” Kimi says. “Unless the defense objects.”

Nikki can think of lots of other holes to poke… but they’re all going to come back to questions about what Giroda did or didn’t do, that are going to require answers from Giroda.

Putting Giroda against Kimi is intimidating… Kimi is relentless. Protecting Giroda from Kimi would be tough, because if she wanted to pick him apart she wouldn’t leave anything behind.  

“The defense has no objection.” Nikki says.

“Good.” Kimi says. “The prosecution’s next act is to bring the defendant, Mr. Giroda Faeson, to the stand.”

Oh no… now Nikki does look determined, and she gives that look straight at Kimi. But Kimi is still looking at, and pointing at the flinching, nervous Giroda. How could anyone look at that man and think he’d even hurt a fly? He looked so sweet and innocent, but in Kimi’s court, everyone saw him as a murderer. Even if Kimi didn’t say anything, just her attitude could direct everyone’s attention, change their perception. They’d believe it just because she seemed to. Nikki would be lying if she said she didn’t feel that pull too from Kimi… but while Nikki would like to gush about how amazing Kimi is, Nikki won’t let her own thoughts, her own perception, be overridden just by Kimi’s sheer charisma and authority. Does Kimi like that in a girl? Maybe she does! She seemed excited when Nikki was fighting back properly. So actually, not simply bending to meet Kimi’s approval probably just got her approval even more! That was exciting to think about. Nikki can’t lose!

Kimi looks back at Nikki. Nikki feels herself smile wider, although she doesn’t mean to. Kimi’s face stays stern, but Nikki has, in the short course of this trial, become an expert at studying what different little nuances in Kimi’s face and body language mean, so she’s pretty sure this is one of the good stern faces where Kimi looks tough but that’s because she always looks like that and not because she’s angry and upset. 


 

~Witness Testimony~

“State your name and occupation.” Kimi says.

“Um… my name’s Giroda. …I don’t really have an occupation anymore…” Giroda says, looking down.

“1 AM on September 25th, Director Chigda was murdered. The evidence clearly identifies you as the killer. The defense has begun laying the foundation for a way to claim that the evidence is misinterpreted or incomplete. However, all of it relies on speculation about your relationship with the evidence. I want you to go on record, on the stand, about your relationship to the evidence.” Kimi tilts her face up, and eyes down at Giroda. “Please keep in mind that you are under oath. I don’t permit lies in my courtroom.”

Giroda shrinks back. “...Yes Ma’am…” Boyish face, messy white hair, postboy cap, fur lined hoodie - nothing about him said ‘murderer’.

“In your house, we found a safe that could only be opened by your fingerprint, containing absolutely everything that would identify the killer as yourself, unmistakably.” Kimi says. “Including items inside it that have your fingerprints on them. Testify as to how you came into possession of the items, and the safe.”

“Okay…”

Giroda takes a deep breath, and begins his testimony.

“I never saw that safe before it showed up in my house! I don’t know anything about it!”

He stops, testimony apparently complete.

Court is silent.

“What the hell kind of testimony is that?!” Bobo says.

“Maybe it’ll be helpful to press him with more specific questions? Maybe there’s evidence that proves that the safe wasn’t found in his house.”

“But the safe was found in his house, according to the police… but maybe we can find evidence that he never purchased it.”

Kimi gives Giroda one of her bad stern looks, which looks nearly the same as her good one to Nikki, but Nikki could tell didn't have the same feeling of warmth and approval in it that Kimi gives her.

“...Is that all you have to say on the matter?”

“It’s not mine!” Giroda slams on the bench of the stand. “I swear it!”

“The safe opened only by your fingerprint. Containing objects that you have handled. With no other fingerprints on them. That safe isn’t yours.” Kimi says.

“You gotta believe me! I don’t know where it came from!” Giroda says.

“Y’know, I dunno how Kimi’s got all these people thinking Giroda can plan a sophisticated murder when he can’t even lie well.” Bobo says under her breath. “If I lied like this, I’d have been kicked out as a spy years ago!”

“He’s telling the truth, Bobo...” Nikki says. “...But he doesn’t know how to express himself well.”

“How are you gonna throw him a lifeline here?!” Bobo says.

“Alright.” Kimi says. “Nikki, it’s your turn.”

“Oh! Right!” There’s a sudden bounce in Nikki’s movement as she turns to Giroda, who’s taken off his postboy cap and started wringing it out of stress. Poor Giroda… Nikki might need to ask some tough questions, but she also needs to support her client too.

“The police found the safe in Mr. Giroda’s house, correct?” Nikki says.

“That’s right.” Kimi says. “There’s no mistaking that.”

“What room of his house?”

“Mr. Giroda’s house has a ‘study’ room, which had a desk and a few desk-shelves covered in stray papers. The room was at the back of the house. The door that lead into it was from the kitchen, and the only other way in was the window.” Kimi says.

“Mr. Giroda… do you remember the last time you were in the study room?” Nikki says.

“...No…”

“Seriously?!” Bobo says.

“Hey, I don’t need to use that room a lot!” Giroda says. “I don’t know, I don’t keep track of stuff like that!”

“...But, did you go into that room in the last few days? Can you say that at least?”

“...No, I don’t remember doing that.” Giroda says.

Alright. That’s a start. For Giroda to be innocent, the safe has to be at least partly, or entirely planted. But how could you plant his own fingerprint on it? For a fingerprint scanner to accept a fingerprint, it would have to accept an actual finger pressed on the scanner. So how do you fake this in the first place?

Wait a second.

There’s a much better question.

“Prosecutor Schiller.” Nikki says, trying to summon a bit of steadiness to her voice, addressing Kimi directly. Kimi’s eyes spark a little at the sound of her name, and look Nikki’s way - oh. Nikki can feel Kimi’s expectations for her. Kimi’s face is stern, as usual, but Nikki feels like Kimi is expecting something insightful, or clever, or an amazing move - and that she’ll be really disappointed if Nikki can’t live up to that expectation. Is this some kind of advanced legal technique? Does Kimi ensnare all of her opponents like this, with whatever she’s done to Nikki? That would be disappointing. It’d be nice if Kimi saved this for her. “...You mentioned… you were able to hire very sophisticated hackers for the test of Wishing Woods’s card system.”

“That’s right. I see where you’re going, good work.” Nikki celebrated that, but tried not to let it show too much on her face, in court. “Yes, they tested the safe too. And yes, they were unable to manually alter which types of fingerprints would open the lock. It was very sophisticated.”

“Thank you.” Now Nikki feels excited. Quickly, she turns back to Giroda. “Mr. Giroda… when you worked for the Wishes 4 Kids foundation… what was your salary?”

“I was making… like… 60,000 a year, before tax.” Giroda says.

Nikki nods. “You lived close to the office, didn’t you? But that’s an expensive part of the city.”

“Yeah… rent ate up most of my expenses.” Giroda says. “I had to cut back on everything else to be able to do this job, but I really thought I was working for an amazing charity so I thought it’d be worth it to help sick kids!”

“I don’t understand.” Kimi says, but to Nikki, not Giroda. “Where are you trying to go with this? The safe had to be opened by Giroda’s fingerprint. We confirmed the system is too sophisticated to be hacked.”

“That’s exactly my point!” Nikki can’t resist the urge to point at Kimi - and Kimi for just the briefest of seconds, flinches, her eyes shooting open, looking actually thrown off her game for once. “That safe is too sophisticated!”

Too sophisticated?” The Judge blinks in shock. “The defense will explain at once!”

“Of course, your honour.” Nikki beams at Kimi. “My client made a low wage, and most of his expenses had to go to his rent, otherwise he would’ve been evicted. On top of that, he’d be paying for groceries, utilities, health insurance, car insurance, gas, and maybe more! On that kind of income… there’s no way he could afford to purchase a safe like this!”

 

“Objection!”

 

Kimi fires back, her face is fiery but she’s smiling at Nikki. At the same time, she looks like, for the first time, she’s having even a single doubt or hearing something surprising. “The facts are the facts. Only Giroda’s fingerprint opens that safe. It must have been Giroda’s. He may have come into possession of it by purchasing it legally. He may have stolen it. Your logic makes sense, which means he must have stolen it.”

 

“Objection!”

 

Nikki fires back on instinct, riding Kimi’s fiery attitude like a slipstream, feeling some of the heat leak into her and set her determination blazing as she stares Kimi down too. “Is it so simple to steal such a sophisticated safe? Almost nobody has a personal safe in their house. To buy the right kind of safe, the one that’s so secure that the police have to dismantle it to access it, you have to spend time researching, and that can’t be easy. And almost nobody researches the right one to purchase the first time. How much harder must it be to find one to steal ? If the safe is important… how do you find the right kind of safe to steal?”

Kimi doesn’t have an immediate response. She just stares at Nikki - again - eyes wider, a hand actually lifting to guard her chest, but there’s a tone of awe underneath. Nikki’s heart beats faster. Right now, she’s forgetting to worry about if Kimi likes her or not - but in part, it’s because she doesn’t think she needs to.

“Woo-hoo!” Way to go Nikki!” Bobo cheers.

“If Giroda doesn’t have the cash, he can’t come into possession of the safe by purchasing it!” Nikki points. “And unless he’s a skilled and experienced thief… he can’t come into possession of it by stealing it! Not unless he’d know exactly where to find one!”

“That logic doesn’t follow!” Kimi fires back. Kimi’s laser focus feels like a sniper scope on Nikki’s chest. “It’s simple. If stolen, he could’ve simply stolen the first one he had access to. A crime of opportunity.”

“I’m sorry, but that doesn’t work either!” Nikki says. “Mr. Giroda would only have the opportunity to steal one from the Wishes 4 Kids foundation… but if that safe was clearly from those offices… you would’ve mentioned that by now!” That last one escapes Nikki’s mouth with almost a little bit of a yelp - it feels intimidating to say, for some reason.

As if catching Nikki’s bullet in the air, Kimi almost gives a twirl before she fires back again. “There are plenty of other places a safe can be stolen from, if you do some planning. You simply need to know a place, whether a home or business, has a safe. It doesn’t need to be the Wishes 4 Kids foundation.”

“Then if that’s the case… the police should’ve been able to match the safe with any reports of a stolen one!” Nikki says. “The gun may have had its serial number filed off… but what if the safe doesn’t? What if the safe still has a serial number? Would it be possible to track its purchase history? Would it be possible to tell if it’s stolen or not? I bet your forensic lab should be able to figure out if that safe is connected to any other reported crimes in the area easily!”

Attacking Kimi by using her own pride against her - Kimi looked like she was, even briefly, stuck speechless .

Nikki could only stare at Kimi, lost in the moment, breathing heavily. She was tense, waiting for Kimi to suddenly open a black hole over her and reveal that she had done exactly that, tracked it down to a specific Amazon purchase that Giroda had made, and make this entire thing a total waste of time. 

Kimi closes her eyes, her face tenses.

Then, she speaks. “Alright.” She sounds annoyed. “You’re right. I can do exactly that. Arguing over the exact nature of the safe when I can figure it out in 20 minutes is pointless.”

Nikki’s arm was still outstretched - like she hadn’t registered the fight was even slightly over.

“Your honour.” Kimi says, eyes closed, tapping her foot. “20 minute recess. That’s all we’ll need.”

“O-Of course, Prosecutor Schiller!” The Judge says. He brings his gavel down. “Court will now enter a 20-minute recess. That is all.” Gavel strike.

He got up to leave. The gallery began to get up to leave.

“Way to go Nikki!” Bobo’s cheering and tugging of Nikki’s arm almost brought her back to reality. Did Nikki just manage to push Kimi back? Oh. She seemed annoyed by that though. But it’s still okay right? Kimi probably likes girls who can fight back. “Nikki, over here! Hey, Earth to Nikki!”

“Huh? O-Oh, sorry Bobo!” Nikki says. “...Did… I really just win an argument with Prosecutor Schiller?”

“Yeah you did!” Bobo says. “We’re totally gonna show that stuck-up you-know-what and save Giroda!”

“Oh, Bobo, she’s not stuck up!” Nikki says, clasping her hands behind her. “I’m sure that she’s a wonderful person, but she’s just tough on the stand. That’s a good way for a lawyer to be!”

“...Nikki… you don’t have a crush on her, do you?”

“N-No!” Nikki says. “Um, I just really admire her as a lawyer, and I’m excited to learn from her, that’s all!” Oh, wait, she said Um. Kimi wouldn’t say Um. Nikki shouldn’t do that, she’s the kind of lawyer that Kimi can take seriously after all!

“Yeah, well-” Bobo froze mid sentence, like a cat spotting a cucumber, hearing the click of heels behind her.

“Nikki.” Kimi said. She brushed right past Bobo without so much of a word, looking Nikki straight in the eye. It was like a glow followed Kimi wherever she went, that just blotted everything else around her, but Kimi’s voice still registered some stress, annoyance, aggravation.

“O-Oh, Prosecutor Schiller!” Nikki says. Don’t say ‘Um!’ “...It’s a wonderful surprise to see you, here!” What do you mean!!! Of course you’ll see her here, it’s court, where she works, as the opposing counsel!!!! “...At the defense bench!”

Kimi just nods. “You deserve congratulations. I only get pushed back like that a few times a year.” Her eyes were closed, but she offered a hand out.

“Oh, thank you!” Nikki says, taking it. Oh, it’s so soft… Kimi doesn’t let go as early as Nikki thought she would, so Nikki keeps holding it for a bit longer too.

Kimi opens her eyes, and looks into Nikki’s. “Don’t take my attitude for being annoyed with you. I want to talk to you later and offer you all the praise I can’t at this moment when I have work to do. Meet me after court, and no matter what’s happened today, you and I should talk and learn about each other.”

Nikki’s head felt fuzzy. That same warmth from Kimi smiling at her had spread through her entire body, like it was pouring out of her heart. It probably wasn’t strictly professional to smile the way Nikki was smiling at her opposing counsel, or to feel so overjoyed that they wanted to get to know you, but Nikki just wanted to spend as much time with Kimi as possible. In fact.

“...” Don’t say ‘Um’. “...Prosecutor Schiller… would it be alright if… I used the recess to follow you and see how you work with your lab?”

In an instant, without taking a breath, Kimi rushes out “That’s an excellent idea why didn’t I think of that let’s go.” Very quickly. She didn’t even let go of Nikki’s hand, basically pulling her from the stand, rushing past any objection Nikki could offer, not that Nikki was about to. Nikki just beamed and almost skipped behind Kimi as they left the defense bench, while Bobo stared in disbelief.

“Nikki!” She says. “Wait! Hang on a sec!”

“Bobo, please take care of everything on our side!” Nikki says. She follows the stone-faced prosecutor out, happily letting Kimi pull her outside.

 

 

Chapter 3: Trial Day 1 - Recess

Chapter Text

Kimi pushed the double mahogany doors down, still holding Nikki with her other hand, stone-faced even while Nikki was beaming.

“This is the office I have at this courthouse.” Kimi says. Kimi’s office is spacious, tasteful, elegant - gleaming whites and polished hardwood, wall-scale windows and plush leather. Nikki tries to stand and admire it all, but Kimi doesn’t stop walking for a second, and pulls Nikki behind her - Nikki snaps back to following Kimi with a smile.

Kimi slots gracefully into her chair, finally letting go of Nikki’s hand (to her disappointment) and pulls herself in. “My lab manager, Hestia, will be able to take care of this.” Nikki stood behind Kimi’s chair with her hands clasped in front, but swaying just a little, resisting the urge to actually bounce. That’d be less professional.

With a few taps, Kimi opened her video call. The woman on the other end was blonde, in a lab coat and striped blue shirt and flat, serious face that was half bemused.

“Hestia.” Kimi says. “The safe in the Chigda case. You still have the physical pieces?”

“I do.” She says. “Who’s that?” Hestia’s eyes go to Nikki.

“O-Oh!” Nikki says. “My name’s Nikki. I’m the defense attorney for Mr. Giroda.”

Hestia looks back at Kimi skeptically. “You let the defense wring you into letting them monitor this?”

“The defense is here with my full permission.” Kimi says. 

“And why’s that?”

“You don’t need to question me on this.” Kimi says. Hestia looks skeptical, but doesn’t argue the point further. “We need to run a check on the serial number of Giroda’s safe. Let’s get as complete a readout as possible.”

“We already know the brand and general information.” Hestia says. “It could be hard to get the specifics beyond that.”

“You have 20 minutes.”

“Oh, 20 minutes? Why didn’t you say so?” Hestia says. “Talk to you soon.”

Hestia hangs up the call.

Kimi swivels the chair to Nikki. “As you can see, this won’t pose any difficulty to us at all. Thanks to my lab, we’ll have this resolved very quickly.”

 “Wow… your lab is so efficient!” Nikki says with a mildly surprised look. 

“Of course. Justice needs efficient answers. Every second wasted is a second the law goes without a resolution. As criminal lawyers, it’s our responsibility to ensure justice is swift and true.” 

Nikki listens and glows as Kimi talks about criminal law. She makes it sound so romantic and elegant and like it would be nice to go out to dinner with her and hold her hand again which actually must be professional and appropriate because Kimi did it so it’s okay. She feels almost dizzy in Kimi’s presence.

“Ah… I think so too.” Nikki says. 

“Good.” Kimi says. “You should find a seat.”

“Oh!” Nikki pauses, and looks around the office, trying to come up with a clever plan. “...Oh! Kimi, um… there’s only one seat in your office!” She says, looking at Kimi’s.

“No, I have three.”

“Ah, but… the other two are… on the other side of your desk, so-”

“Yes exactly you’re right we don’t have a choice there’s no way around it come on.” Kimi blurts out. “We’ll have to share a seat it’s simply how it is there’s no choice let’s not spend any time arguing about it we just have to accept these things.”

“Of course!” Nikki says.

Kimi hops up off her seat. Nikki sits down.

Then, Kimi hops onto Nikki’s lap.

Oh…

Nikki’s heart swam up and overflowed, feeling warmth through her entire body. This was so… comfortable. Kimi was so beautiful, but she sat on Nikki so elegantly… she could feel her weight against Nikki… feeling her rest into Nikki… her hair drape over… Nikki’s eyes half lidded and her head tilted a little, a serene, peaceful, warm smile on her face. She felt like Kimi was basically surrounded by love hearts and shoujo manga background bubbles. Kimi was pressing into Nikki's body, like a warm blanket, sitting into her lap, against her chest... she was actually touching Kimi, not just by the hand, but her body was pressed against hers.

Kimi looked back at Nikki - she seemed comfortable too, but she looked like she was suppressing a smile, or some other look - her face seemed a little red.

“Kimi…um…” Nikki tried to think of something else clever that would work as well as this did. “...Are your hands cold?” Nikki said softly.

“Yes actually they are.” Kimi said quickly, offering one up to Nikki.

Nikki gently takes it, grasping it softly. Kimi seems to smile a little more.

This is working…  Nikki hasn’t even noticed she hasn’t been calling her ‘Prosecutor Schiller’.

“While we’re waiting on Hestia’s results, allow me to ask some questions.” Kimi says.

“Sure!” Nikki says. “What would you like to ask me?”

“Many lawyers find it hard to balance work and their personal lives.” Kimi says. “Do you find it challenging to manage your time with work, and spending time with your boyfriend or girlfriend?”

“O-Oh! I-I’m… I’m single, Prosecutor Schiller!” Nikki says, blushing more deeply. “...Um… wh-what about you? Do you have a… boyfriend or girlfriend?”

“No.” Kimi says instantly. “Not that I would have a boyfriend.”

“Oh! I wouldn’t either!” Nikki says quickly. 

“Good we’re on the same page.” Kimi says. “However I’m not just interested in any kind of woman, only women who are truly special.”

“...I… also like special women!” Nikki offers. She’s already said ‘um’ too much here, she can’t say it again. “...We seem to have a lot in common!”

“Actually we’re very different, which is good.” Kimi says. “Although some people don’t recognize it, I have my own weaknesses, but those are areas that might be strengths for you.”

“...Oh!” Okay, what next? “...I was wondering… your hair looks so perfect, Prosecutor Schiller. What kind of products do you use?”

“Hm? I don’t use anything special compared to you. I assumed we were using the same brands.” Kimi says. “Your hair has a very soft appearance too. The scent is also very pleasant. I particularly like the way it comes down clean, tidy and straight, but has a subtle curl and bounce at the end that still looks natural and organized, but adds a hint of livelieness.”

Nikki blushes. “Ah... Thank you, Prosecutor Schiller! …Your hair is beautiful as well.”

“You think so?”

“Of course!” Nikki says. “It’s such a beautiful shade of silver… it almost looks like it glows when the light catches it.”

“I see.” Kimi says, attitude completely businesslike, with a small nod.

“...I have an idea!” Nikki says. “...If it’s alright with you, prosecutor, could I… feel your hair texture, to see if it feels like the product I use?”

“We could just compare the names of them.” Kimi says.

“...I forgot the names of-”

“Yes you’d better do that then go on no time to waste you should feel my hair texture to compare we’d better do that there’s no choice.” Kimi says, turning away from Nikki. Nikki perks up and smiles. She slowly reaches her hand out to Kimi’s hair. She feels a warm shiver as she makes touch with it. It’s so soft! Kimi’s body appears to tense for a second, and then relax. Really relax. She leans into Nikki more, Nikki still holding Kimi’s hand, and she starts running her other hand through Kimi’s hair.

“We’ll get a more complete comparison if I can do the same.” Kimi says. Nikki can’t see Kimi’s face just now… does it sound like she’s smiling? She sounds so comfortable…

“Oh! Of course!” Nikki offers a run of her hair, laying it gently over Kimi’s shoulder.

Kimi’s hand lays on top of it - as if just to keep it there. Nikki still gently runs her hand through Kimi’s.

“This is a good combination of colours.” Kimi says - flatly, but softly. “I think we coordinate well together.”

Nikki could see Kimi’s face a little better now - soft, eyes-half lidded. Only the subtlest hints of a smile, but she seemed so relaxed. Nikki was beaming, feeling the urge to cross her legs around Kimi’s, feeling Kimi’s hand in hers - but seeing Kimi’s face like that relaxed and soothed her too. She tilted her head, and let her eyes half-close, just admiring Kimi’s face… feeling Kimi against her was so wonderful. Every touch was like magic, but it was that sense of closeness, intimacy, that was soothing and lifting Nikki's heart. The weight of Kimi's body felt like it was lifting weight out of Nikki's.

“...Could we… compare makeup too?” Nikki says.

“Yes.” Kimi says instantly.

Nikki perks up again, and brings her hand away from Kimi’s hair, gently drifting to her face, a light touch of the fingers on Kimi’s cheek. A hint of a smile from Kimi. 

Kimi looks into Nikki’s eyes. She could probably feel Nikki’s heart pounding against her chest. Nikki’s smile became more gentle… something about the way Kimi was looking at her made her feel... pure.

When Kimi reached up to Nikki’s face and placed her hand against it, that’s when Nikki realized she was in love.

Maybe by Kimi’s smile, she felt the same way…?

“...Kimi…” Nikki says.

“Yes?”

Nikki pauses. “...Your-”

The spell was broken by the notification from Kimi’s computer. The real world trampled over their moment of intimacy. It felt like the real world hadn’t existed for a moment, that Nikki had forgotten about everything that wasn’t Kimi. Both of them stared at the video call request on Kimi’s computer, blaring out a banal default ringtone.

“That’s Hestia.” Kimi says, in her normal tone of voice. “You should stand behind my chair, for appearance’s sake.”

“Oh! Right!” Nikki says - with her normal polite and eager tone. She feels some disappointment that the moment has to end, but she’s happy to help Kimi with this anyway. Kimi slips off - and then Nikki really misses Kimi’s presence, and her closeness - but she slips off the chair too, standing behind it with her hands folded in front of her, while Kimi slips on and accepts Hestia’s call.

“There you are.” Hestia says. “Doesn’t usually take you that long to answer.”

“The defense and I were discussing something very important.” Kimi says.

Hestia looks at Nikki.

“Hello.” Nikki says.

“Okay. Here’s the details about the safe. I’m emailing over all the technical details and foundations of the evidence, but to summarize for you… Giroda definitely did not purchase this safe.”

Nikki resists the urge to pump a fist - even though for just a few minutes there, she’d forgotten about everything outside of Kimi, and almost feels like Hestia has been the one to remind her what the recess was for in the first place.

“That’s because the safe was purchased by Director Chigda.” Hestia says.

…Oh.

“It’s a bit sloppy on our part to have missed this honestly.” Hestia says. “But it makes sense if we look at Chigda’s apartment again. There was a clear, blank space on one of the shelves that fits exactly the measurements of this safe. I ran a few other tests, and to save you the trouble… there’s no doubt about it. This safe comes from Chigda’s apartment.”

“Then in other words, only someone who was physically in Chigda’s apartment could have obtained the safe.” Kimi says.

…Oh…

Wait… is Giroda’s hole only deeper now, by pursuing this? Now the safe is also evidence of having been in Chigda’s apartment!

But the panic quickly subsides. No, that was what Kimi already accused Giroda of. The evidence isn’t more solid than it was before. It was already a tall order to argue how all those individual components could’ve gotten into the safe from the crime scene. If they were carried there from the crime scene, it actually might make more sense for someone to have planted it who wasn’t the killer. For now, this doesn’t change anything.

“Alright. Noted. Anything else important?” Kimi says.

“No, nothing.” Hestia says.

“Good. Thank you for the prompt assessment. I’ll be-”

“If it was Chigda’s, how did Giroda prime the safe with his fingerprint!” Nikki blurts out.

Hestia and Kimi both stare at Nikki.

“You’re the defense.” Hestia says. “Save that for court.”

“...I’m sorry, but I can’t do that.” Nikki says. “If this became a crucial question, we’d likely end up needing to contact you again. Prosecutor Schiller says justice should be efficient, so let’s make it efficient!” Nikki says, her voice growing stronger - a sense of firmness. A smile slowly blooms on Kimi.

“Miss Hestia.” Nikki says. “You’re best equipped to answer this. In fact!” A sudden realization hits Nikki. “If the safe belonged to Chigda, then at the time that Mr. Giroda is accused of taking it, it must have been primed for his fingerprint!” Nikki points aggressively at the screen. Hestia actually flinches back. “So… how on Earth would he have been able to open it in the first place?”

“...I…” Hestia’s shock subsides. She grabs her chin, glancing down. “...I… wonder, now… the only explanation is that it was already unlocked when Giroda took it.”

“Does that allow Giroda to replace Chigda’s lock with his own?” Nikki says.

“Hey, excuse me.” Hestia turns her gaze on Kimi. “You look awfully happy about this.”

“I admire that this ‘rookie’ defense attorney is taking full advantage of everything she can.” Kimi says. “I also want answers.”

“Well…” Hestia pauses. “To prime this safe, you could get it at factory settings. The only way to factory reset it is with buttons inside the safe. At least that's one way.”

“Then no matter what!” Nikki says. “The safe must have been initially opened by Director Chigda… which means the lock on the safe isn’t proof of Mr. Giroda’s guilt!”

“Possession.” Kimi says. “Not just possession, but being able to unlock the safe. The proof is still as strong as ever.”

Nikki shakes her head. “Part of the strength of the safe as evidence is that it could only be opened by Mr. Giroda. But if Director Chigda was able to open it… what if others were able to open it as well? What if it was possible, all along, to add new fingerprints to the safe, to increase the number of people who could open it, not just replace them?”

“Are you saying my lab made an oversight when we investigated this safe?” Hestia says.

“I am.” Nikki nods. “If only Giroda can open the safe… then it’s difficult for him to not be involved in the crime. But if multiple people can open it… then it means there’s a mechanism for multiple fingerprints to exist on the safe at once. And if there is…” 

“And if there is what?” Kimi says. She’s completely back in work mode. The attitude she had resting on Nikki has vanished. “Let’s pretend it has five million fingerprints that can open it. One of those is still the fingerprint of the defendant. A fingerprint from the defendant on the safe is even better than his fingerprints on the objects inside of it - it has to be pressed on and recorded deliberately. Is that right, Hestia?”

“Something like that is right.” Hestia says. “You can’t actually record a fingerprint without pressing some extra buttons, that's for sure.”

“It requires deliberate interaction with the safe, no matter what.” Kimi says. “You’ve done well, but you’re no closer to proving anything.”

“But!” Nikki says. “Are the instructions for this safe available online, Miss Hestia?”

“No.” Hestia says.

“Then how would Mr. Giroda even know how to add his fingerprint?” Nikki says, with an excited smile. “It’s impossible for him to figure it out by accident! And if the instructions for this safe were in Director Chigda’s apartment… the police would’ve found it by now, and you would’ve determined the safe belonged to Chigda based on him owning instructions for it!”

“Nikki.” Kimi says. “That’s an effective question, but I don’t think you’ll like the answer it takes you down. That means that Giroda would’ve had to be taught how to use the safe. The most likely answer for who would’ve told him is Director Chigda. And prior to murdering him, Mr. Giroda had very, very few personal interactions with Director Chigda. It’s stunningly unlikely that any of them had to do with how to open a safe that belongs to him in his private apartment, and that safe will need to be open in order to record new fingerprints, otherwise the safe itself is pointless. Therefore, it would guarantee a personal interaction between Mr. Giroda and Director Chigda, in circumstances where Mr. Giroda must have had a way to compel him to open the safe. In other words… holding him at gunpoint.”

Nikki felt her breath snatched away.

No smile on her face, fists clutched to her chest.

Wait…

“...I don’t believe that.” Nikki says softly.

“I don’t see how you can avoid it. With someone else, I’d assume they were just avoiding the truth or lying. However, you won’t disappoint me. Why don’t you believe that?”

“...What if… there’s a third person who can unlock the safe, outside Director Chigda and Mr. Giroda?” Nikki says. “And what if this third person found a way to force Mr. Giroda’s fingerprint onto the safe…?” Nikki doesn’t sound sure of this as she says it, but the moment she says the theory, she realizes that’s exactly what must have happened. There’s no other explanation. “At least one more person can open that safe!”

“Is that so?” Kimi says. “Alright then. Do you have evidence of that?”

Nikki swallows.

“Show me evidence that anyone else can open the safe outside of Director Chigda and Mr. Giroda.”

Kimi’s gaze suddenly seemed so intimidating. They were having such a tender moment before, but she’s Prosecutor Schiller again, and Nikki feels the sniper sights turned on her. What pieces of evidence are there that could point to the safe having a third fingerprint? There weren’t even any pieces that pointed to a second , just a moment ago… so was there anything that could point to a third? What about from the new pieces of evidence? …No, nothing there either.

Or… is that the right way to think of it? Is there evidence that points to a third person at all? For Nikki to be correct, there must be a third person involved. That’s what saying “Giroda is innocent” has always amounted to, so she shouldn’t back down from this idea. But is there any evidence to support it, at all…? 

Circumstantially, Nikki could argue that the gun’s serial number being filed away, but the serial number still being present on the safe, implies a second person is involved who was either more thorough, or less thorough, than Giroda… but that still leaves Giroda on the hook for a part of the crime anyway. 

Or maybe…

“In your theory, the killer entered at 12:55 AM. Director Chigda died at 1 AM, of blood loss. Correct?”

“That’s right.”

“Then… he had to have been shot instantly, leaving him no time at all to open the safe!”

Hestia raised an eyebrow. Nikki saw a very subtle smile on Kimi’s face, but Kimi still looked serious. “Depending on the arteries being shot, you can die of blood loss in just three minutes. That’s enough time for someone to use a gun to order you to open and prime the safe. And it’s very easy to come up with a way that an intruder would notice a safe, quickly figure out it’s fingerprint locked, and then ask for help with it. There’s enough time to get that done.”

…Damn. Wait. “Miss Hestia!” Nikki said. “Is that consistent with where Director Chigda was shot?”

“Well… it’s borderline.” Hestia says. “Given where he was shot, he could’ve been laying there for 3 minutes or 20 minutes before he died. We’d try to estimate the truth from the conditions of the blood, but let’s simplify it and say the scene didn’t preserve those details so well. But basically - it is consistent.”

“Kimi.” Nikki says. “I-I mean, Prosecutor Schi-”

“Kimi will be fine.”

“Oh!” Nikki bounces her shoulders a little. “Okay! …Kimi… don’t you think your theory about how Mr. Giroda got Director Chigda to open the safe, and prime it so he could add his fingerprint, sounds implausible?”

“Of course I do.” Kimi says. “But you must have heard, ‘once you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth.’”

“I’m sorry, but I don’t believe we’ve eliminated the impossible yet!” Nikki says. “It’s still possible that there can be a third person!”

“Okay. Then that means Mr. Giroda has an accomplice.” Kimi says. “That matters. But the fact is, only one card was swiped to enter Director Chigda’s apartment, outside of his own. So any third person had to enter with the person who swiped that card, or enter as the killer was exiting the scene while the door was ajar. If it’s the former, they’re just an accomplice. If they’re the latter, then they’re likely a thief of some kind, and not the killer, because Director Chigda would be already dead, or dying. No matter what, a third person’s mere existence won’t save the defendant.”

“Sorry, Nikki.” Hestia says. “Your client is guilty. There’s no beating Kimi. I’m signing off, Prosecutor.”

Kimi nods to Hestia, who ends her video call.

“...We haven't eliminated everything yet. There’s still other possibilities.” Nikki says softly.

Kimi stands up. “And do they have evidence?” Kimi pauses, and places her hands on her hips, giving Nikki a heavy look, that seems to suck Nikki’s attention in.

“Nikki. Why do you believe Mr. Giroda is innocent?”

“...He’s my client, Kimi.”

“Why should that be enough? What about the truth?” Kimi says. “As lawyers, our first duty is to the truth and nothing more. It’s my job to act as a zealous advocate for the state, just as its your job to act as a zealous advocate for the defendant. The law needs both of us. Only by the clash of two opposing sides, arguing with everything they have, all the way to exhaustion… only that kind of conflict can crush all the illusions and leave the truth shining, exposed at the end. But this system only works as long as both of us understand that commitment to the truth, and never lie, and never mislead - even misleading ourselves.” Kimi pauses. “Aren’t you misleading yourself, when you say Mr. Giroda must be innocent because he’s your client?”

“I’m sorry Kimi, but I’m not misleading myself.” Nikki says, gently but firmly.

“Don’t you think the evidence is overwhelming? We haven’t even touched the plans in the safe.”

Nikki shakes her head. “Mr. Giroda is the most important piece of evidence I have. I understand you won’t be moved by it… and I understand the court won’t be moved by it. …I trust him because of the kind of person he is. His testimony must be the truth.”

“And I’m sorry, Nikki, but that’s a naive perspective for a lawyer to have.” Kimi says sternly. “The reason we have court is precisely because we can’t trust people to always tell the truth. The reason we have jobs is because people lie. Defendants. Witnesses. Plaintiffs. Other lawyers. There’s no shame at all in representing a guilty defendant, but there is shame in doing so knowingly, but pleading not guilty. I’m not saying that applies to you. But the trust you have in people can easily be broken, and other idealistic defense attorneys have learned that harsh lesson.”

Kimi pauses. “You’ve already done an excellent job. Even in defeat, your reputation will skyrocket. I admire everything you’ve done today. But I can’t understand why you genuinely believe Mr. Giroda’s innocent.”

“...I know some people can’t be trusted, Kimi.” Nikki says. “But when you look at him on the stand… don’t you think… don’t you think that he can be? I accepted his case… because I knew, I could feel how sad he was not that nobody believed him. How could he sincerely feel that if he was lying?”

“He’s not sincerely feeling that.” Kimi says. “Or he is, and he’s delusional. I do look at him and think ‘he’s lying’. I think that because the evidence tells me so. That’s how court works.”

“Mr. Giroda’s testimony is evidence. His sincerity and his feelings are evidence. They’re evidence of his memory, of his values, of his personality…” Nikki pauses. “...I’m sorry, Kimi. I don’t think you’ll understand me.”

Nikki looks at Kimi, almost looking… sympathetically, at her, almost seeming saddened. Kimi’s hard gaze has wobbled somewhat, her brow tilting out, a sense of… maybe even longing.

Kimi breaks the silence.

“I admire you.” She says quietly. “But in court, only one of us will win. Only one of our values will be validated. And I’ve won every time.”

“...But you’ve never faced me.” Nikki says, just as gently.

“Good.” Kimi says. “You’re not shaken at all. That’s your job, after all.”

Kimi walks right up to Nikki, gaze opening, lips parting as her hand lifts to Nikki’s face… just to touch it. Kimi’s face splits in awe and reverence. 

Nikki reaches for Kimi’s free hand. She takes it, tenderly. She lets her thumb brush over, back and forth… enjoying how soft Kimi’s hand is.

“...I think your makeup products are better.” Kimi eventually says. 

Neither of them say anything.

“I won’t be holding back.” Kimi says. “In fact, I’m going to bring out something decisive. I won’t apologize, because that’s my job.”

“I won’t apologize either.” Nikki says. “After all… we’re lawyers.”

“...You’re perfect.”

“I’m perfect?”

Kimi’s hand flinches like she brushed the edge of the stove. She quickly pulls out of Nikki’s grasp. “A-As a rival. In law. Yes.” Kimi says unconvincingly. High blush, covering herself up with a feigned cough. “Yes, of course. You’re exactly what I want in a defense attorney.”

“O-Oh!” Nikki says. Even amidst the disappointment of Kimi pulling back, she’s still smiling. “Well, I think it’s wonderful to have a prosecutor like you as an opponent, Prosecutor Schiller!”

“Even if it means your client will be found guilty?”

“...My client is innocent.” Nikki says. “Kimi… as long as you’re as committed to the truth as I am… I won’t need to worry about that at all.”

Kimi smiles… almost dreamily.

They both know the recess is about to end. It’s time to get back and resume the trial.

Chapter 4: Trial, Day 1 - Part 3

Chapter Text

At Kimi’s suggestion, Nikki and Kimi entered court at slightly different times. 

As Nikki wanders up to the defense’s bench, Bobo levels her with a flat stare. “Sooooooo.” She says mirthlessly. “How was your date with the prosecution ?”

“Bobo!” Nikki says, clasping her hands behind her back and blushing. “Th-That wasn’t a date! I learned important information about the case!”

“Oh, yeah? Like what? What Prosecutor Schiller’s lip gloss tastes like?”

“O-Of course not!” Nikki says, still blushing. She takes her place at the bench. She looks across. Kimi’s already there, seemingly filling Joe in on the new information. “It was about the safe!”

“Wait, really?” Bobo changes her tone completely. “Is it good news?”

“...Prosecutor Schiller’s lab determined it belonged to Director Chigda.”

Another cartoonish expression from Bobo. Her two quick blinks practically made a comedy squishing noise.

“...WHAT?!” Bobo says.

The Judge bangs his gavel.

“Court is now in session.” He says. “Prosecutor Schiller. During the recess, were you able to determine if the defense’s claims about the safe hold up?”

Kimi places her hands firmly on her hips, and looks up to the Judge. “Your honour.” Kimi says. “Allow me to fill the court in on what we learned.”

 


 

At the conclusion of the explanation, the judge nods. “I see… so the safe belonged to Director Chigda. That leaves us again with seemingly an open and shut case.”

“Your Honour!” Nikki bursts out. “The prosecution still doesn’t have an explanation for how the defendant would have been able to add his fingerprint to the safe! The prosecution also cannot prove that nobody else can open this safe!”

The Judge is about to speak. “I’ll handle this, Your Honour.” Kimi says.

“O-Oh! Certainly, Prosecutor Schiller. My apologies.”

Kimi stares back down at Nikki. It doesn’t feel the same as it did just moments before. Kimi has a pretty good grasp of Nikki now. In the short time this trial has lasted so far, Nikki feels like she’s gotten to know Prosecutor Schiller well too - rather than Kimi trying to feel out her potential, her strengths and weaknesses, Kimi is staring down an opponent she knows well. 

It’s almost like the training wheels are off. That same sense of encouragement isn’t there now - Kimi’s saber is pointed firmly at Nikki, challenging Nikki to cross swords with her properly. It’s as simple as staring back down at her, showing Kimi that Nikki won’t back down either, locking gazes like steel meeting steel.

In the courtroom, only one set of arguments and values can prevail. Arguments and values that haven’t been tested in a crucible could collapse at the slightest touch in the real world. They have to be tested for one to win - they have to fight. A real fight.

Kimi wants to see if Nikki’s are strong enough.

“The prosecution would like to call its first witness to the stand.” Kimi says.

“Wait, what?” Bobo says.

“Please come in, Mr. Avicinda Unseelie.”

The entire court turns in surprise as the doors open.

He’s the opposite of Giroda. Tall, sharp, confident. Athletic build, sparkly clean and well-styled. His spiky white hair sits in a flowing ponytail. With his low-buttoned white shirt and eyepatch, he looks like a cross between a fantasy C-drama hunk and a 17th century pirate.

Passing the defendant’s stand, Giroda cowers as Avicinda walks past, with eyes wide. Avicinda gives him a quick scowl in return, but doesn’t break his pace as he walks calmly to the witness stand.

With a look of burning cold iron, he’s almost like a menacing, masculine mirror image to Prosecutor Schiller. Whereas Kimi can seem steely and intense to some, this man’s confidence is distinctly physical - he walks like he doesn’t fear any kind of danger. It’s as if he thinks someone could drop a bomb on him and he’d walk away unharmed.

Avicinda places a hand on the stand.

“State your name and occupation.” Kimi says.

Avicinda briefly glances her way. “Avicinda Unseelie.” Avicinda says. There’s a faint, whispered gravel under his otherwise clear voice. “Former security consultant for the Wishes 4 Kids foundation, and to Director Chigda personally. Not anymore, obviously.” A slight, joyless smirk.

He may be intimidating, but Nikki feels like she can ride the wave of his presence. She looks briefly down to Bobo.

Bobo’s eyes are sparkling. Hands clasped together, dreamy and distant, almost on the border of drooling.

“Bobo!” Nikki whispers.

“H-Huh?” Bobo whips her head around and comes back to reality. “H-Hey, it’s not fair for her to bring in a guy like that! It’s a distraction to all the women in the courtroom!”

“Are you sure?” Avicinda says without looking away. Bobo jumps with her hands out.

Avicinda cranes his neck towards her with a smirk. “It seems like some of the women in this courtroom couldn’t care less.” He briefly meets Nikki’s eyes.

Something is off about this guy. Nikki feels like he’s trying to intimidate her, to lord his obvious strength and presence over her, but that triggers something that’s been buried - it only pushes Nikki’s heart up higher to meet him back. It doesn’t matter who he is - what matters is where they are. Some instinct to resist this intimidation, even resent it, triggers in Nikki. She can’t respond with anything like what Prosecutor Schiller would. She probably can’t hide the fact that she feels nervous about who this guy is, exactly - but she levels him down with a look of strength that’s all her own. There’s nothing he can do that can intimidate her here.

“I’ve never seen you before.” Avicinda says. No smirk. Just flat. “And I know just about all the big lawyers in this city. That either means you’re very new, or you’re not that successful.”

“I’m not that kind of lawyer.” Nikki says firmly. Breathing just a little bit harder. She can see Kimi behind Avicinda, bearing down on him with a fierce look of her own, but it’s clear she doesn’t intend to jump in and save Nikki.

“What kind are you?” Avicinda says.

“I’m a defense attorney.” Nikki says. “I fight for people in court.”

“I know what a defense attorney is.” Avicinda says. “You’re all either slime obsessed with getting obviously guilty people off for a huge payday, or you’re noble idealists who insist that the drug-addicted bank robber surely didn’t rob a bank this time.” He turns back with a sneer towards Giroda.

“My client has a flawless criminal record!” Nikki says, feeling a burning. “The evidence firmly establishes that… not only has Mr. Giroda never committed a crime-!”

“Not for much longer though.” Avicinda turns back to Nikki. “Soon he’ll be convicted as a murderer. That’s how justice works. Director Chigda was also a man without a criminal record, known to everyone as a brilliant humanitarian. But his reputation is ruined too now.”

“This country believes in innocent until proven guilty.” Nikki says firmly - there’s a wall she’s hitting. She feels angrier, but she doesn’t feel like she can embody it, so it starts to fizzle into simple tension. It’s not in her nature to lash out or seek conflict - but it is her job to solve it. That same gentleness keeps her from being able to meet a challenge like Avicinda’s the way Kimi might. She wants to try to get along with and be nice to everyone - lashing out feels almost… wrong. But she also can’t tolerate the way she’s being treated. “...Excuse me, Your honour?”

“What does the defense want?” The Judge says.

“The witness should be reminded not to interrupt counsel.”

The Judge nods. “Indeed. Witness, please remember you are in a court of law now.”

“Tch.” Avicinda says, looking away briefly. “Whatever you’d like.”

Bobo, back in a distant dreamy gaze, blinks twice and shakes her head to get rid of it, like a dog clearing off the water. “Waitasec!” Bobo says. “How can there be a witness to Director Chigda’s murder? That would mean you were at the scene of the crime!”

“Exactly why I objected to the label ‘witness’.” Avicinda says. “Your Honour, I’m familiar with what goes on in these courthouses. Two-bit attorneys will start accusing innocent witnesses of being the real killer out of desperation to get their clients off. I don’t intend to allow that kind of thing to happen to me.” He stares into the judge’s eyes. “You will allow me to take just a few minutes to defend myself.”

“Y-Yes, of course witness!” The Judge says, with a slight tremble in his voice.

Avicinda looks towards the defense’s table. Bobo clasps her hands together again.

“I did not ‘witness’ the crime.” Avicinda says. “I merely received Director Chigda’s dying message. In fact - every security alert that has to do with Director Chigda will ultimately come to me. Monitors in his apartment are set up to detect unusual spikes in loudness - so when a gun was fired in his apartment, I got the notification for that too. And so I reported the crime to the police. And I have an airtight alibi, too.”

“Oh yeah?” Bobo says. “What’s that?”

“I was asleep.” Avicinda says. “The police can all testify though, that I met them outside Wishing Woods, in my car, that I drove up to the building, and that CCTV footage shows was not there before.”

“It’s not enough to say you were asleep.” Nikki says. “You need evidence to make it an alibi.”

Avicinda holds up his wrist, and carefully rolls his sleeve down with a smirk. He taps his Apple Watch.

“I listened to what you said before, about why Giroda can’t be guilty.” Avicinda says. “The Apple Watch recorded his sleep cycle. Was that it? Amazing that he can afford one on that salary. Maybe he stole it too. All the same logic you used to protect Giroda assures that I was sleeping during the crime. I slept until 2:00 AM that night.”

“Wait a sec!” Bobo says. “The loudness alarm! Wouldn’t that have woken you up if you were doing your job properly? Like at least an hour before that!”

“The topic of a lawsuit I’m pursuing.” Avicinda says. “My home’s ISP promised me the 99% uptime I need to be able to do my job. Without internet availability, my devices can’t connect to the loudness alarm. I’ve already submitted the evidence to the prosecution, straight from the ISP, that my home was without internet that night until 2 AM. The moment the internet was connected, my alarms activated, and I woke up immediately.”

“That does sound like an airtight alibi.” The judge nods. 

“Giroda has the same alibi but they won’t let it count for him!” Bobo curls her fists on the table.

“Because unlike him, I can show you.” Avicinda says. He pulls out his phone, and taps on the Health app, scrolling and tapping through. Then, he dangles his phone up between this thumb and index finger.  “Right here. Sleep phase, all normal, all consistent with my own, right up until 2 AM. And my sleep records are more unique than most. Thanks to my Tinnitus, I can’t sleep easily, so I have to take special, extra-strength prescription medication that messes with my sleep phases. Still don’t fully understand it myself - but as you can see, these graphs from the past days…” Avicinda scrolls through. “Look nearly the same as the other, right up until 2 AM.”

The phone shows exactly what he says.

The Judge nods. “I see. Indeed, when you add the two together, that is a solid alibi.”

“We’re on the same page then.” Avicinda says. “The only men responsible for the death of Director Chigda are Giroda, and Chigda himself. He brought it on himself when he turned his back on the mission. While Giroda proved that weak men have an infinite appetite for abuse. There’s no whips or scorn they can’t bear right up until the moment they break, and they have to choose if they’re a man, or a coward.”

Nikki had never been more suspicious of someone’s alibi in her life.

And yet, it was flawless… wasn’t it? Consistent with his past sleeping patterns. It shows he slept through the murder. And if Nikki pokes a hole in that, she’s only sinking Giroda’s only possible lifeline of an alibi. On top of that, his car wasn’t at the murder scene - so how on Earth would he have gotten away and back? A second car? Kimi wouldn’t let that be overlooked.

But if she presses Avicinda’s story too hard, then she’ll risk everything collapsing - Avicinda and Kimi could have her completely cornered and restrict her from being able to question any of those details if she accuses too much.

“It’s important we clarify something.” Kimi says.

Avicinda turns to her.

“You were a member of the New God Dominion Church, the organization owned and run by Director Chigda, correct?”

“I was a layperson in the church, yes.” Avicinda says. “I knew the director through the church, not the charity.”

“Mr. Avicinda.” Nikki says. Avicinda cranes his neck towards Nikki, but with… a performative slowness to it. Nikki levels her brow and looks him down. “What did the New God Dominion Church actually believe in?”

“Ask an embarrassing question.” Avicinda says. “The core tenet, that I fell for… is the belief that the gospels have been misinterpreted. Jesus Christ was not merely the son of god, but a New God, who replaced the old one completely. And the logic of the church went, that eventually, another New God would come to pass on this world, the son of Jesus Christ.”\

“Was it a cult?” Kimi says simply.

Avicinda strokes his chin. “Not in my eyes.” He says. “It was just like going to church when I was younger. More energetic, perhaps. After I left PALADIN, I sought something deeper than the mercenary life. But Chigda saw my past experience, however, and offered me a job. Paranoia, really. He’d managed things well without me, and made very few enemies. If it wasn’t for the message he’d left me… I wouldn’t have even had a suspect.”

“That’s what we need testimony about.” Kimi says. “If you could?”

“I’ll settle this.” Avicinda says. “Prepare for a decisive blow.”

 

~Witness Testimony~

 

“My part is actually very simple.” Avicinda says. “This is my phone.”

Avicinda holds it up again. “Director Chigda and I shared messages on an encrypted app. It records the time the message is sent by his phone, not the time I receive it.”

He opens the app, and enters his passcode. “In order to open the app, you have to use Touch ID - Face ID and a phone passcode don’t work, so it’s impossible for a thief to use it.”

He dangles his phone up between the thumb and index finger again, holding it in the air. “Message sent at 12:58 AM, from Chigda.”

“This is without a doubt a message from Chigda, under Chigda’s contact information, and the text of the message is simply ‘Giroda’.”

Avicinda puts his phone away.

“This is decisive evidence.” Kimi says. “Not only do we now know that the safe absolutely came from Chigda’s office, we have the witness’s evidence showing that someone who could only have been Chigda identified Giroda as the killer. We have forensic evidence that places Giroda’s fingerprints on the material in the safe, and his fingerprint opens the safe too.”

“I agree.” Avicinda says. “The logic is very simple, but the prosecution makes it seem terrifying. It’s fascinating work.”

“There’s no miracle to it.” Kimi says. “The logic is only so strong because it’s true.”

“...Th… but wait!” Bobo raises her hand, waving it like trying to get a teacher’s attention. “The real killer could’ve just used Chigda’s phone to frame Giroda!”

“The real killer is the man at the defendant’s stand.” Avicinda says. “And he’ve had no reason to frame himself.”

“Nor is there evidence that anyone else so much as set foot in Chigda’s apartment. Remember. On that day, the guest card was the only other card used.”

“And I can confirm, personally.” Avicinda says. “That Director Chigda never let his personal card off his person. Nobody else could have used it to enter and pretend they were him.”

The Judge bangs the gavel.

“...It seems this trial is reaching a natural conclusion.” He says. “Nevertheless, the defense is entitled to cross-examine the witness.”

Nikki hasn’t said anything. 

All she’s doing is staring straight down at Avicinda, with a solid, calm, almost blank expression.

Avicinda stares back at her, and raises an eyebrow. 

“Nikki.” Kimi says.

But Nikki doesn’t take her eyes off Avicinda.

“I told you I wouldn’t hold back.” Kimi says. “That text is how we can be sure that he survived for at least 3 minutes after 12:55. I didn’t mention it to you before, because you’re entitled to being faced with my full strength in the courtroom. There are no more training wheels.”

“Right.” Nikki says softly, but she doesn’t so much as look at Kimi.

Avicinda meets her gaze.

“Something you want to say to me?” Avicinda says.

Yes. There are a million things Nikki wants to say. She can’t even get them all out at once. The trick of being a lawyer, in this kind of court, is to figure out a way to get them out in the right order, in a way that the prosecution and the Judge will allow, that won’t allow the witness to wriggle out and fight back by making it seem like a complete farce. That’s what Avicinda wants to do.

Nikki doesn’t know how the real killer got into the apartment when the guest keycard was only used once, and then found with Giroda, with his fingerprints on them. Nikki doesn’t know how the safe and its contents got into Giroda’s house. But the fingerprints are the key - it’s possible, even easy, to think of a million ways that someone could plant Giroda’s fingerprints on something, but they can get convoluted very quickly. If she was going to prove that something convoluted or strange happened, she’d need evidence for it, and she doesn’t have that evidence. There may be many ways to get those fingerprints on the evidence, and to get the evidence into his house… but no evidence of how it was done, or that it was done.

But she at least knows who the killer is.

And she’s meeting eyes with him right now.

Chapter 5: Trial, Day 1 - Part 4

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

~Cross Examination~

Okay. 

“Nikki?” Bobo says, feeling almost uneasy at the change in Nikki’s demeanour.

Avicinda stares her down back, with a smirk on his face.

Nikki is looking at him with her own brand of determination.

“If you’re taking the time to think of a bluff, you’d serve your honour better by surrendering right here.” Avicinda says.

Nikki closes her eyes, and stands up straight. “...I’m sorry for keeping you waiting.”

“Mm.” Avicinda says.

“Mr. Avicinda…” Nikki says. “There’s something that’s been bothering me about this case. And you’ll be the best person to answer it. You said that you have your own security devices set up in Director Chigda’s apartment, correct?”

“That’s right. It’s a very sophisticated suite of tools. No need to bore the court with the boring details if they don’t pertain to the case, however.” Avicinda says, with a distinctly arrogant tone, slowly craning his head back. “The prosecution is already completely aware of everything I’ve installed in Director Chigda’s apartment - and you’re already aware of everything with even a hint of relevance.”

“Exactly.” Nikki says.

Avicinda stops moving, his smirk turning serious.

Bobo looks up at Nikki. This isn’t a mode that she’s seen Nikki in before in the court - she’s confronting Avicinda’s attitude with her own confidence, and not only confirming she has something to fight with - but doing so casually, playing on what Avicinda had been saying. 

It felt like suddenly realizing a sword duel had been taking place around her without her knowledge - as if Avicinda had noticed the last slice of the blade he’d been carelessly parrying had shave an inch off his hair.

Nikki didn’t immediately follow that up.

Avicinda straightened his head again, staring her down. Waiting for Nikki to follow up.

But she didn’t.

Was… this pink lawyer… goading him into responding and asking? Did Nikki have a hidden reason for not saying anything? Could there be information she’d gain from Avicinda’s reaction?

There would be - because if there was something important that had been overlooked, and it was something Avicinda didn’t want people to notice, or had lied about, or whatever else - he’d have to decide what to say about it. And to decide exactly what to say, he’d need to decide exactly how much the defense already knows. And if she doesn’t reveal how much she already knows, then his options are more difficult. If he’s lying or misleading people, then doubling down on that could lead to being revealed. Or if there’s some trap he’d be walking into by being completely honest, then he can’t tell that either.

It’s not a particularly advanced tactic, but it’s more sophisticated and shrewd than even Bobo would expect from Nikki - in fact, Bobo couldn’t tell the purpose if it at all.

The Prosecutor didn’t voice anything either.

Avicinda met eyes with Nikki.

“‘Exactly’ what, then?” Avicinda says.

“You said it yourself. We’ve discussed every relevant security device you installed into the apartment.” Nikki says. 

So she is doing this on purpose. It’s exactly what it looks like.

“Is there a joke I’m missing?” Avicinda says. This will be his move. “You’re agreeing with me, and you’re saying it like you’ve caught me in some trap. Now isn’t that ridiculous?”

“Mr. Avicinda, could you tell the court how much experience you have in security?” Nikki says, in a polite and gentle voice.

Now that’s worthy of his attention. Is she walking him into a trap? This soft pink lawyer, nothing like the intimidating Prosecutor Schiller has a direction of questioning prepared. The Prosecution could do something to stop it… but she’s standing there with her hands on her hips, looking down at Nikki eagerly. It seems she has no intention of stopping whatever trick Nikki is pulling.

Avicinda looks back to Nikki, much more warily now. This wolf has dressed as the tiniest of sheep. No, that’s not it. He knew about her before walking into this courtroom - she was that sheep before. What’s changed her?

“Years.” Avicinda says.

“Is it fair to say you’re an expert on security?”

“Yes.” Avicinda says flatly. He turns to fully face Nikki, and give her his full attention, a hand resting at his hip, like on the hilt of a weapon. The actual swords they’re fighting with are already drawn, after all.

“Would you agree that the difference between a beginner in the security industry and an expert is extremely wide?”

“I would.” Avicinda says. The problem is - he knows he’s being walked into a trap. But his own pride won’t let him say no to these questions.

Wait, isn’t that even more sophisticated than he thought this girl was capable of? He stands much more on guard, tenser now. This is the kind of thing a much more experienced lawyer is capable of - to set forth a chain of questions that you can’t deny, but have a trap laid on the end. What kind of landmine is she trying to lead him onto?

“Do you take pride in being a security professional, and your expertise?”

“I do.” Avicinda says, narrowing his eyes, widening his stance.

Nikki responds by holding her hands by her side, unclasped, with a calm expression but standing tall and looking down at Avicinda. “What does that kind of pride mean to you?”

“Shouldn’t someone object to the relevance of this question?” Avicinda says. “This seems like a pointless tangent.”

“The prosecution has no objections.” Kimi says.

Tch.

“The witness will answer the question.” The Judge says.

Fine. “Obviously, it means that I do my job well. If you intend to mock me for the fact that someone I was employed to protect was murdered, it’s hard to believe that type of cruelty would suit a lawyer with the image you want to project… or maybe you’re that kind of lawyer after all.”

Nikki shakes her head. “...It would be naive to expect security to be flawless. I imagine in your pride as a security professional, and an expert, that you took every measure you could to ensure Director Chigda was protected, correct?”

“Of course it’s correct.”

“So then why… have we heard every relevant security device you installed in Director Chigda’s home?” Nikki says.

Avicinda tilts his head. “I don’t understand what you mean?”

“Why didn’t you install cameras?”

It was that after all.

Rather than raising a finger to strike the point like your average LA lawyer, she said it calmly, but Avicinda felt the sword bearing down on him, and raised his own to protect himself. “Is that all?” He says. “As a security professional, I understand that some things are worthwhile, and some things are pointless. Cameras are pointless.”

“What makes cameras pointless?” Nikki responds. She leans her hands on the bench and her voice starts to pick up.

“Isn’t it obvious?” Avicinda says. “Cameras need to have someone monitoring them to find threats. That requires paying someone. I had a security budget that I couldn’t go over, and it didn’t allow me to have someone surveilling the cameras, it’s that simple.”

“Please forgive me for explaining things you already know.” Nikki says politely. Even though there’s an extra hint of aggression in her voice, it remains soft and gentle all the same - she still seems composed. “But for the court’s benefit, allow me to reiterate that there’s an obvious security benefit to being able to have video footage of events in the apartment, since it could be used to identify thieves, record attempted break ins, identify security weakpoints, and more! I know you’re already aware of these benefits - but I don’t understand why you’ve ignored them!”

“I haven’t ignored anything!” Avicinda says. “You said it yourself - I’m the expert, and so I’m the one who knows things that beginners, or lay people, like yourself, can’t even imagine.”

“Then explain to the court!” Nikki says. “I’m sure you’ve been an expert witness in court before, haven’t you?”

Gnhgh…

Avicinda straightens up, and takes a deep breath. “Fine. The truth.” He says. “Director Chigda ordered me not to use any cameras. I’m ashamed to admit it, because the defense is right, it would’ve been helpful. It injures my pride as a professional, as she’s so helpfully established, to admit that there was something I didn’t do to protect my client. But it’s true. There was something I didn’t do, which was install cameras.”

He looks back at Nikki. “Does that satisfy you?” With a renewed smirk.

“Are you admitting that you were misleading the court just now, when you were claiming there’d be no obvious security benefits?”

That’s an obvious wound, but it’s worth taking one to avoid a much worse cut. “It seems I let my pride get the better of me. My apologies.”

Both combatants appeared to lower their swords for the moment.

“Nikki.” Kimi says.

That voice calling her name seems to break Nikki out of her focus. Still grasping at the bench, she looks up at Kimi.

“Is there a reason that the lack of cameras in Director Chigda’s home matters?”

Nikki nods. “Yes, of course. If there were cameras there, there’d be completely indisputable evidence.”

“We have completely indisputable evidence to begin with.” Kimi says. “Cameras would help, but the absence of them proves nothing.”

The judge nods. “I must agree with Prosecutor Schiller. This line of questioning appears irrelevant to the case.”

“Thank you.” Avicinda says. “Why don’t we all agree that the defense should stick to questions that have relevance to the case? Like the things I testified about, and nothing more.”

The judge nods. “Indeed. The defense will restrict her questions only to things that have relevance to the case… unless she has a reason that the questions are indeed relevant to the case, that is.”

Now Nikki was the one on the spot. Should she give her hand away now, when it was so flimsy she could be laughed out of court?

There wasn’t really a choice.

“There is a reason, your honour.” Nikki says. She turns to face Kimi. “Prosecutor Schiller. Was anyone else investigated by the police outside of Giroda?”

“No.” Kimi says. “The evidence was decisive, so the investigation ended.”

Kimi knew exactly what move Nikki was going to make. In a way, it was the only one she could. Her stare towards Nikki is intimidating, but not hostile. 

“Then that means the police did not investigate whether or not Mr. Avicinda could have committed the crime.”

Objection!

Avicinda raises his voice. “Predictable. The desperate Los Angeles defense attorney turns on an innocent witness without evidence, hoping to babble their way into getting them to accidentally slip up and poke a hole in their alibi so they can be convicted on some trumped up nonsense. I already said that won’t happen to me - Giroda can be proven, beyond a reasonable doubt guilty, and I am, beyond a reasonable doubt, innocent. It’s ridiculous to even broach the topic.”

The crowd murmurs.

Bobo blinks, finally processing what Nikki’s implying. “Wait… WHAAAAAAAAT?”

She swivels up to Nikki. “Nikki, wait, you’re not seriously suggesting-”

The judge bangs the gavel down, again, and again. “Order! Ordeeeer!” A pause. “Is the defense seriously proposing that the witness is the true killer of Director Chigda?”

“...Yes, your honour.” Nikki says. A definite answer. Giving a vague possibility would allow her to retreat if the tree bore no fruit without losing too much face in front of the judge - but the only lifeline is through Avicinda.

Nikki’s already certain that he’s the killer. She can’t prove it… yet. She just needs to be able to keep her cross examination going.

“I don’t see a reason to even entertain these questions then.” Avicinda says. “Judge, end this charade. Objection, relevance, or whatever it is you’re meant to say. Dismiss the entire thing.”

The judge nods. “That certainly can be done… once Prosecutor Schiller gives her approval of course.”

They both turn to her. Nikki looks down at her too, holding a fist to her heart, worry-meeting-determination, while Kimi only exudes metal and steel. Kimi said the training wheels were off. That she’d face Kimi at her full power. Kimi could easily end this line of questioning instantly, and crush any chance Nikki has of winning, especially now that she’s committed to such a seemingly outrageous statement.

And yet, it’s a statement that’s true. And Nikki’s sure of it, just as sure as she is that Giroda is innocent. It’s been written all over the way Avicinda carries himself, his attitude towards Giroda, towards Nikki, towards the court - how he did it remains to be exposed, but he definitely did it.

Kimi opens her eyes and looks up at the judge. “And why do you think I’ll give it?”

Avicinda is pushed back into a threatened scowl.

“M-My apologies Prosecutor Schiller! I merely believed that… the prosecution would-”

“There is certainly no evidence that Mr. Avicinda is the killer, and there is indisputable evidence that Mr. Giroda is.” Kimi says. “These facts, if true, will hold up to some extra scrutiny. There is nothing to lose by spending some of the courts time on this issue, and resolving it completely.”

Objection!

Avicinda raises his voice again, looking at Kimi, then addressing the entire court. “What, you believe ‘the innocent having nothing to fear’? Isn’t that naive? Evidence and testimony can be twisted, selectively interpreted. The innocent can be framed. Why shouldn’t I be concerned with that exactly? I have everything to lose and nothing to gain.” Avicinda says. “It’s an insult to my honour in the first place to even propose this idea. I don’t need to entertain it. And in fact, I don’t intend to.” Avicinda says. “I refuse to testify or submit to cross examination.”

He looks over at Nikki. He’s drawn his sword again, against hers, this time with a much more confident move, looking down at her as a lucky rookie. She’s shrewder than he thought before - so now he’ll go on the attack.

“Y-You can’t refuse to testify!” Bobo says, slamming the table. “The Court can compel you to testify!”

“Yes, they can.” Avicinda says. “And then I can refuse to testify. And then I’ll be arrested and fined, and sit in jail for a sentence of, oh, let’s say… 45 days? After all, I’m speaking quite contemptfully in court right now.” Avicinda says. “But 45 days is a lot shorter than life imprisonment for a crime I didn’t commit. It’s quite a simple trade!” He smirks down at Nikki. He imagines he has his sword at her neck. It’s a completely invincible move - they can punish him for not testifying, but he never has to speak.

The judge bangs his gavel. “I-Is the witness saying… they intend to deliberately be in contempt of court?”

“It seems I must act as a legal martyr.” Avicinda says. “It’s quite sad, but I’m sure that I’ll do well on the radio circuits afterwards for resisting this farcical cross-examination attempt. And the two-bit attorney and her firm’s reputation could take quite the hit over it too. And of course - Giroda will still go to prison, because he’s guilty. Justice will be served for everyone but me, but I am happy to fall on my sword to avoid the guillotine.”

There are no clocks in the courthouse - in fact, neither Nikki, Kimi, nor Avicinda are even wearing watches. Time feels almost subjective in moments like these.

He looks over at Nikki with another demonic smirk. Nikki feels that rising anger in her, that she felt before, when first confronting Avicinda, storing into her arms.

How dare this man? But what can she do? Not even Kimi can force him to testify - if he simply refuses, it’s over. And he’s simply refusing. So isn’t it over…?

What could possibly make him testify if he can’t be forced to do it?

Nikki scrambled through her mind, but this isn’t the kind of thing she’s used to confronting or thinking about. She likes practicing law because the law itself is meant to create some kind of fairness or equality between people - but a witness who’s in complete contempt of it is totally different to the things she’s good at as a lawyer. She can make arguments, or reason about things, but none of that helps here.

Or does it? What if she treated this like it was something that could help? Think about it like a lawyer. She wants to ensure Avicinda testifies - but he refuses to do so, and he can’t be made to.

Okay.

Is that a dead end? Think from the end then. What she wants is for Avicinda to testify. So why would he testify? The only reason he would would be if he wants to.

Can she get him to want to?

Wait… that’s it.

If he has more to lose from not testifying… all she has to do is to make not testifying a bigger risk to him than testifying!

Nikki does something she’s seen countless lawyers in LA do - but that she’s never done before.

Acting on the tension in her arms, she slams the table.

Even Kimi seems to jump a little in shock.

Avicinda stares her down, as if in a fighting stance.

“If you refuse to testify… you’ll also miss out on the chance to defend yourself.”

Avicinda doesn’t speak. He just smirks.

He’s already refusing to testify.

The judge bangs the gavel down. “D-Despite the witness’s stated intent… the court must remind the witness that if their testimony is compelled by the court, that they must provide it or face a severe penalty!”

Kimi raises her finger, like slowly unsheathing a graceful blade, then fires it at Nikki like a blast that rides past Avicinda. “The witness has nothing to defend themselves from.” She says.”There is no evidence that Mr. Avicinda has committed any crime.” Avicinda smirks.

Nikki parries, but it’s a bluff. She doesn’t know where she’s going yet. She simply left too much dead air without speaking - so she said the next right thing. It’s the only way to get him to testify after all. Now with Avicinda’s move and Kimi taking up her own sword, the pressure almost feels crushing. Nikki can only fight back desperately.

She can’t just say ‘I know there’s no evidence’. That’s terrible! Something else… something else! “Mr. Avicinda has already confessed to misleading the court!” Nikki says. “He confessed to misleading the court on why there were no cameras installed in Director Chigda’s home! We have no reason to assume the rest of his testimony is truthful!”

“Except it’s backed up by evidence!” Kimi gently raises a finger, as if catching a thrown knife in the air calmly, inches from her face. “There is evidence for Mr. Avicinda’s alibi, and not for Giroda’s. There is no evidence, however, that Mr. Avicinda committed a crime - in fact, the evidence says he never had the opportunity at all!”

The alibi! That’s where Nikki has to attack! She raises her own finger, not quite sure what she’s about to say - the alibi was that he was asleep. The Apple Health information proves it. The first temptation is to say ‘someone else wore the apple watch’ - that’s no good! She can’t argue that or she’ll scuttle Giroda!

Her face furrows. No, the information can’t be hacked on there either. There’s no doubt about it. That sleep information has to be accurate - but that means it’s impossible for Avicinda to have committed the crime! Unless a crime can be committed in your sleep - no, that’s ridiculous too! And if you believe that Avicinda was asleep, you have to believe he took that ultra strong sleeping medication, because that’s what the sleep phases on his Apple Health show! Not only that - Nikki could even see the timing on the phases on Apple Health, when he presented the phone! And it clearly showed the date of the crime, and that he was asleep up until 2 AM! There was no mistaking what she and everyone else saw!

…Is this a complete waste? Is there really iron clad evidence that he must be innocent?

That’s what Prosecutor Schiller was saying about Giroda too. That this was why Nikki’s way was wrong - was that true too? Was she that much of a naive rookie that she was going to believe…

The moment of doubt must have shown on her face, but Nikki puts it away quickly - flinging the finger forward with confidence now, and a look with just an inch more fierceness. “...I can prove that there’s a hole in Mr. Avicinda’s alibi!”

Kimi is shocked.

The judge is shocked.

Bobo is shocked.

The court starts murmuring.

“Ahahahahahaaaaa!”

Avicinda laughs.

“I can’t help myself!” He says. “This oughtta be a good one! Go ahead, Miss Defense Attorney!” He holds up his phone again, dangling it by the top left corner, between his thumb and index finger, tauntingly. Navigating to Apple Health. Showing that airtight sleep information. “It’s a fact - I really did sleep at these hours of the day!”

“He’s right!” Kimi charges her own blade at Nikki. “Nikki, I’m sorry - there’s no way you can defeat this evidence!”

Kimi stares down at Nikki. Nikki looks into Kimi’s eyes, like blades meeting in the air.

Kimi can’t ignore the determination in Nikki’s face. She has more faith in Nikki than to just say that it’s a dumb rookie move or a hopeless bluff. She wants to win her case, but more than that, she wants Nikki to prove her faith in her has been deserved. Can she say it would have been deserved if Nikki doesn’t turn up any evidence?

Nikki doesn’t want to disappoint Kimi - but right now, she fully understands, Kimi is her opponent. Kimi won’t show her mercy in the court - it’s not in Nikki’s nature to be fierce, and to fight without mercy. She still feels shaky, even now - but she’s come this far because she’s been trying to impress Kimi. But Kimi looking down at her with those eyes is intimidating, when all she wants is for Kimi to look at her with warmth, when she was so supportive earlier instead. It’s a wall she has to break through - she has to be able to beat Kimi.

Both of them are breathing heavily.

In the samurai movies, after the swords men meet, the camera lingers, until one of them starts spurting blood, and we learn who the victor is.

Is that why… Kimi can feel a strange certainty emanating off Nikki, like she’s made the true cut…?

Nikki slowly turns to Avicinda.

“Mr. Avicinda.” Nikki says. He could refuse to comply with nearly any question or measure right now. So the best one… is one like this. “...Sorry to ask… but what time is it?”

The court was completely silent.

Kimi looked at Nikki, almost baffled.

Avicinda looked confused.

A disbelieving smirk grew on his face, until it stopped completely cold.

“Di-... Didn’t I already tell you?” Avicinda says. “I refuse to testify! That means to any question, even one like that!”

What was with this sudden panic? Kimi hadn’t figured it out yet, and yet Avicinda clearly realized that the one who’d been cut was him.

“Is there a reason you can’t tell the court?” Nikki says, raising her voice. She points straight at Avicinda. “Your honour - I formally move that the court compel Mr. Avicinda to testify about what time it is!”

Crowd murmuring. Getting louder. Bobo, her eyes pure blank white circles, turns up at Nikki in shock. Kimi has slowly started lowering her finger, but is no less confused than everyone else, looking up at Joe with an actual expression of confusion.

“I-Is this really a testimony that must be compelled from a witness?” The Judge says.

“Of course it isn’t!” Avicinda says, sweeping his arm forward like flourishing a coat. “Surely nobody in this court can think this is serious? She wants me to testify about what time it is?” Avicinda picked up his phone - Nikki saw the home screen come up, and right at that moment she pointed -

“There’s no point to that!” She shouted at Avicinda. At first she panicked - she can’t stop him from hiding the evidence he’s about to hide - but just as she was about to panic more, she realized… that’s actually fine too.

“No point to what ?” Avicinda flared back, tapping more on his screen. “I’ll indulge your idiotic question! As you can see -” Avicinda locked the phone again, holding it up for Nikki and the court to see. “- It’s 11 AM! Satisfied?”

Bobo has already pulled out her phone to verify it. “Um… Nikki, wh-what’s the point of this? Are you going to explain?”

“The point is she’s babbling because she’s a moron !” Avicinda says. “I would like to be arrested and taken away in contempt of court now, I’ve had enough of this!”

Objection!

Kimi flung her finger at Avicinda. “The defense is not a moron, and statements like that are not acceptable in my courtroom!”

Avicinda couldn’t help but flinch at the admonition from Kimi. Nikki fired again.

“Mr. Avicinda, please show the court your sleep phase records again!”

“Nikki, we already saw those!” Bobo said.

But Avicinda registered the wound that Bobo - and perhaps even Kimi - hadn’t perceived yet. “I-I refuse to testify!”

“Your honour!” Kimi shouts. “The prosecution agrees that the witness should be formally compelled to testify!”

The judge bangs his gavel down. “Since the defense and prosecution are in agreement, the court has no objections. From this point forward, Mr. Avicinda, failure to testify will result in criminal penalties - and given the profile and magnitude of this case, as you’ve surmised, that will include incarceration. Think carefully how you proceed.”

Avicinda grips at his eyepatch, crushing the witness stand with his other hand. “Then arrest me! You don’t need any further information from me!”

“If you’re arrested…” Nikki starts. “...then you’ll need to surrender your phone to the court as well! And then if you do that-”

A flash of alertness crosses Avicinda’s face.

“- then you won’t have the opportunity to explain the evidence that I’ll show the court!”

Blood may as well have started spurting out of Avicinda’s chest while Nikki sheathed her blade.

By now, it was clear to the entire court, from Avicinda’s reaction, that he was indeed hiding something.

“Your honour.” Nikki says calmly. “I can prove that Mr. Avicinda should not have been overlooked as a potential suspect in this case. And I have evidence that backs it up - the evidence is Mr. Avicinda’s phone! …Therefore…” The force in Nikki’s voice was coming more easily to her now. “...I move that it be surrendered to the court to prevent any tampering!”

Avicinda must have been distracted - staring in disbelief at Nikki - because before he could react, the phone had already been taken from him by a bailiff. Someone with his experience and skills certainly wouldn’t be so easy to take a phone from if he was alert. 

“The phone has been accepted into evidence.” The Judge says.

“Bailiff.” Nikki says. “What time does the phone show at the top of the screen?”

“11:03 AM.” The bailiff says.

Nikki nods. “Bailiff… please open Apple Health.”

“...Done.” The bailiff said.

“Nikki, is this really oka-” Bobo was cut off by Avicinda’s own protest.

“The court may accept my phone into evidence, but the fact that my phone was previously locked should give me a basic right to privacy before the law snoops around in my private files.”

The judge nods. “Indeed… if it is discovered that there’s no evidence from this pursuit, I will have no choice but to penalize the defense. However, if the defense’s accusation is correct, and you have withheld or tampered with evidence…”

“Bailiff.” Nikki says. “Please open the sleep panel on Apple Health… and go to the date of the crime.”

“Done. …Wait a minute…”

Avicinda growled under his breath.

Joe’s eyes shot wider.

Kimi suddenly realized what was happening.

“That can’t be right… these times are completely different!” The bailiff says.

Bobo stammered. “Wh-what’s going…” 

“Bailiff!” Nikki says. “According to Apple Health… what time does it show that Mr. Avicinda was sleeping during the day of the murder?”

“...He was asleep during… the afternoon?!”

“O-Objection!” Joe Brownie ran up to the prosecution bench, beside Kimi, looking bewildered. “I-If I may! Mr. Avicinda clearly showed to the court-”

“Bailiff, please show exactly what you can see to the court as well.” Kimi interrupts.

The Judge nods. “Bailiff, if I may see the evidence?” The bailiff presents it. “M-My word… it does indeed say that! And yet we all saw a moment ago that it said a completely different time!”

“Whaaaaaaaaaat?!” Bobo threw her arms by her side, jaw gaping. Avicinda clutched his shoulder, like grasping at a bullet wound.

The whirlwind somehow felt invisible to Nikki. She was just in her element. Maybe in another moment she’d be able to register the anxiety, the pressure of getting here, or a catharsis that she’d been right after all, but all she can see now is just what she needs to do to get to the next step. “Whenever Mr. Avicinda presented his phone to the court…” Nikki says. “He would always hold it up by the top left corner, between his thumb and index finger, like he was dangling it.” Nikki says. “And by doing so… he was shielding one very important bit of evidence from the court…”

“The time!” Kimi blurts it out - looking, completely uncharacteristically, shocked.

“That’s right!” Nikki says. “That way, we wouldn’t be able to see the trick that he had pulled!”

Avicinda clutched his shoulder harder.

“There’s a trick?” Bobo says. “W-Wait… hang on…”

“The iPhone sets its time, automatically, to a timezone.” Nikki says. “But it doesn’t have to be your time zone. It’s possible to set one manually, and choose the timezone. And Apple Health will automatically update to reflect that time zone!”

Joe stumbled back, as if struck. “W-Wait a moment-”

“In other words…” Whenever Avicinda had taunted or mocked her, Nikki felt that pull towards anger, towards something more fiery than her normal nature would allow, and in this moment, it naturally springs forward as she points her accusation at Avicinda. “...Apple Health definitely shows when you were asleep! There’s no mistaking that it recorded your sleep times… but you changed the timezone to make it look like you had been asleep during the crime! Because you changed the timezone on your phone, it changed the times Apple Health would show when you were asleep, to reflect the change in timezone!”

“WHAT?!” Bobo shouts.

“I-I say!” The judge shouts.

Joe clutches the prosecutor’s bench for support.

“B-b-but why is it different now when it wasn’t before?”

“Because once Mr. Avicinda realized where I was going… he changed the timezone back on his phone!” Nikki says. “If he’d have simply tried to tell us the time on his phone, or shown us, we’d have seen it wasn’t set to LA time at all, but something completely different! Because he had to change the timezone in order to make it look like he slept through the killing!” 

Avicinda clutches his shoulder tighter, seething, glaring at Nikki, breathing ragged like a wounded animal. “When I said, ‘There’s no point to that’, he was using his phone - that was the moment he reset the timezone to LA! But that couldn’t erase the crime - now the Apple Health information looks different than what he showed the court! But if he hadn’t, we’d have seen the time on his phone was different, and still been able to figure out the timezone trick!”

The volume of the crowd was rising.

“Order!” The judge shouted.

It still rose.

“Order!” Slam. “Ordeeeeer!”

Nikki looked at Kimi.

Kimi… still stood with her hands on her hips, but no trace of that usual iron confidence. It was something else - she looked astonished, shocked… bewildered, even. This wasn’t even something Kimi thought could happen. Even for all the faith that Kimi had in Nikki, this outcome, this kind of major hole being missed by her, taking this kind of damage in court - is something that had never happened before. In that bewilderment, she almost looked lost - and as she started to process what was happening, she looked at Nikki with some kind of confused pride.

Nikki’s heart couldn’t beat much faster than it already was, but she could certainly blush. It’s not like anyone else would notice right now.

“...It appears the defense has proven something crucial.” The Judge says. “...Not only did Mr. Avicinda commit an offence by misleading the court with his testimony and the evidence of his phone… but he appears to have no concrete alibi for the murder of Director Chigda!”

Objection!

Avicinda clawed at the witness stand, like climbing out of the depths of hell.

He raised his head up to face the court, messy hair guarding his eyes.

“...Do you see… why I was worried now…?” He says.

The court is silent.

He stands up fully. “...I no longer refuse to testify.” He says. He pauses. “Evidently… the defense is committed to besmirching my reputation, and I underestimated her ability to twist the facts to do it. If I must testify to protect my reputation and honour… then I’m afraid I have no choice.”

“Wh- Yo-... Hey!” Bobo shouts. “We just proved that you faked the phone thing! You don’t have any reputation and honour left!”

“A mistake, is a lot different to murder, orange girl.” Avicinda snarls. “...I admit it. I didn’t notice that I hadn’t reset the timezone on my phone before using it as evidence. Once the defense noticed that fact, I noticed it too. In a panic, I changed the timezone back to LA, to avoid being smeared.” He pauses, and smirks. “After all. I already intend on being held in contempt of court. What’s one more charge?”

“B-b-but!” Bobo shouts. “You lied about when you were asleep! You used the phone as proof! That had to be deliberate!”

“Does it?” Avicinda says. “In my time as a mercenary, I faced many deadly combat scenarios. A side effect of post-traumatic stress disorder can be issues with memory, especially with regards to an especially stressful day. Sometimes the days can blur together. And as you can see - I have not been keeping a healthy sleep schedule, much to my own unawareness in some cases, and, that only makes my memory worse. The truth is, I used my phone to verify when I had been asleep that day once it became important to, and I hadn’t realized I hadn’t set my phone back from the timezone it was on before. The defense’s theory that I was deliberately hiding the time by dangling the phone is a mere coincidence.”

“However.” Nikki says, also beginning to calm down. “You no longer have an alibi for Director Chigda’s murder.”

Avicinda scratches his chin. “...Are you sure?” He says. “There is no evidence at all tying me to the murder, but all the evidence still points to the defendant. I admit that it’s clear I was not sleeping during that time. Lots of people weren’t - does that mean they also killed Director Chigda, and not the man whose fingerprints are all over the evidence, positively identified by Director Chigda?”

Nikki looks at Kimi.

She can’t tell what Kimi is thinking at all. She’s completely unreadable.

But Avicinda turns to face Nikki head-on.

“Congratulations on a good first round, rookie.” He says. “But landing a punch means nothing if you can’t go for the kill. Shall we resume?”

Nikki stares him back down.

She can't count him out of the fight. She also can't count Kimi out either. But right now, she's totally driven by the adrenaline, the pressure, the need to save Giroda and win this case. She has to cut down every last piece of evidence against Giroda, just like she cut Avicinda's alibi apart - but he's behind a many walled fortress, ruled by an undefeated general, and all she has is a sword.

"...The defense is ready."

Notes:

The Apple Health trick actually works. Seriously, if you record your sleep on Apple Health, try it. Even if you just have sleep mode set to start at different points of the day, it'll work.

Notes:

This idea has possessed my brain so hard that next chapter will probably feature a link to a custom Nikki Objection theme that I'm composing myself as we speak.