Chapter 1: Pure Chaos- hold up
Chapter Text
Truce
Two Timing: I almost killed someone once
I will Falter: White Lily, you what-?
Hiding: Woah… didn’t think you had it in you, guardian.
Two Timing: shut up.
Emo: …Me and Hollyberry left for two minutes to get Pitaya, what happened.
Dragon: Whoever keeps putting those stupid traps up-
Juice-aholic: no.
Dragon: but-
Juice-aholic: no.
Dragon: ..fine.
Several people have joined the server!
Burning: …ex-fucking-scuse me?
Daddy’s Girl: I told you it would work, BS :D!
Daddy’s boy: holy shit Candy, i was joking when i said hack the server
Anger issues: SO I DID THIS FOR NOTHING?
Oven Trauma: Nope!
I will Falter: …What the fuck?
Chapter 2: Oh my god, they’re orphans.
Summary:
Key:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch
Dark Cacao cookie - emo
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding
Burning Spice cookie - burning
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues
Custard Cookie III - orphan
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
Chapter Text
Orphan: I miss my dad…
Anger Issues: no- NO. Custard Cookie, stop reminding us of what we don't have anymore!
Oven Trauma: parents? What are those
Fluttershy: Gingerbrave… please.
I Will Falter: …as a fellow orphan…
Two Timing: Pure Vanilla, no.
I Will Falter: I want to adopt them. Can we?
Hiding: I already have two kids… know what, few more won’t hurt.
Daddy’s Girl: YAY I'M NOT THE YOUNGEST ANYMORE!
Daddy’s boy: no, you still are.
Daddy’s Girl: FUCK
Hiding: Candy Apple, language.
Daddy’s Girl: Sorry Shadow Milk Cookie :(
Juice-aholic: …Pure Vanilla, why.
I Will Falter: yes.
Emo: That's it, I'm going to visit my son.
Anger Issues: at least your family loves you and never hurt you in unexplainable ways!
Fluttershy: Wizard Cookie, do you need a hug?
Oven Trauma: and another therapy session.
Anger Issues: No, fuck you.
Juice-aholic: point taken, i'll get the adoption papers.
Notes:
Wizard Cookie holding Custard Cookie III
Meanwhile GingerBrave: SPARE CHANGEEE-
Strawberry cookie: about to snap
Chapter 3: Gay, Gay, Homosexual Gays
Summary:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch
Dark Cacao cookie - emo
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding
Burning Spice cookie - burning
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues
Custard Cookie III - orphan
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
Notes:
Just fucking realized I forgot to post chapter three so enjoy the double chapter-
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Daddy’s Girl: SMC. SMC. BLACK SAPPHITRE-
Daddy’s Boy: SHUT. THE FUCK . UP.
Hiding: What now-
I Will Falter: language.
Daddy’s Girl: BS HAS A-
Daddy’s Boy: I WILL STRANGLE YOU CANDY APPLE, SHUT.
Dragon: Who’s dying?
Juice-Aholic: no one, go back to sleep.
Dragon: :(
Sparkle: ✨I’M BACK✨
Sparkle: …I left for a week to speak with my kingdom once again, and this happens?
Burning: ha ha, stupid whore.
Sparkle: ha ha, no bitches.
Two Timing: Oh my gods, just fuck already.
The Actual Silent One: I agree.
Burning: Mystic Flour-?
Sparkle: WHITE LILY-
I Will Falter: Oh, they’re finally fucking? Good.
Sparkle: And back to no contact.
Emo: Dark Choco Cookie said that i need to talk to White Lily and… “Catch that ass”
Emo: What does this mean?
Anger Issues: ew. Custard Cookie, cover your eyes.
Two Timing: DARK CACAO THERE ARE CHILDREN HERE.
Emo: what? Did I say something wrong?
Daddy’s Boy: sigh… crisis averted in the end.
Notes:
*Sniffs* Hm... smells gay (Me who's a raging poly bisexual)
Chapter 4: Inches
Summary:
Key:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic/Dragon Fucker
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch/Whore
Dark Cacao cookie - emo
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding/Liar Liar
Burning Spice cookie - burning
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one/Flour
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues
Custard Cookie III - orphan
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
Notes:
If you know you know... Read the tags for the ships, people. I'm a multi shipper for a reason Also Name changes-
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Whore: 9 inches.
I Will Falter: …I’m concerned how you can still walk.
Dragon Fucker: Only 9? Try 12.
I Will Falter: …how are you alive.
Dragon Fucker: Talent.
Whore: Talent.
I Will Falter: Fuck you too. Also, 10 inches.
Whore: Did you measure-
I Will Falter: Down my throat.
Dragon Fucker: fair.
Sparkle: Are you fucking comparing your boyfriends dick sizes?
Emo: Excuse me-?
Flour: Knew it.
I Will Falter: FUCK-
Whore: ABANDON SHIP
Dragon Fucker: RUN.
Dragon: …What the fuck?
Liar Liar: Thats correct, what the fuck indeed.
Notes:
This was hell to make cause I made it in class and people were standing around me(they didn't see my screen).
Also I'll be making a poll on my Tumblr for if you guys want me to make a crk ship one shot? I'll be taking requested ships as well :)
Chapter 5: Chaos
Summary:
the trauma trio encounter something. Chaos insues.
Notes:
Key:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic/dragon fucker
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch/ Whore
Dark Cacao cookie - emo
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding/ Liar Liar
Burning Spice cookie - burning
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one/flour
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues/Sassy King
Custard Cookie III - orphan/ Orphan Issues
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Oven Trauma: WIZARD COOKIE
Sass king: I just said it wasn’t my fault, GINGERBRAVE
I Will Falter: Wait, whats happening?
Daddy’s Girl: Drama!
Daddy’s Boy: drama~
Liar Liar: I’m so proud of my kids.
I Will Falter: don’t encourage them. Also what happened?
Fluttershy: Well.. we had encountered a few cake hounds. Wizard said since they were puppies they were harmless and we could just pass by-
Orphan issues: BUTTT there were two BIG ones and we got like- chased two villages away!
Oven Trauma: Exactly! I mean like, why didn’t you tell me?!
Sassy King: Because I wanted us to fail.
Sassy King: OBVIOUSLY I DIDN’T KNOW
Dragon: ssssigh. Holly sssaid to come get you.
Dragon Fucker: why are you hissing now-
Dragon: Feelsssss right.
Googie: dhjbhjbashbahjsa
Dragon Fucker: SNAPDRAGON WATCH YOUR LANGUAGE
Googie: jddhjbjhabshbsx
Dragon: SnapDragon Cookie.
Googie: dhbsj
Dragon Fucker: apology accepted.
I Will Falter: Since when..?
Dragon Fucker: Don’t ask.
Liar Liar: BS, your grounded.
Daddy’s Boy: WHY?
Liar Liar: Cause you apparently snuck SilverBell in while me and Vanilly were.. Busy-
Whore: fucking.
I Will Falter: Shut up, go back to getting fucked.
Whore: GLADLY BITCH
Daddy’s Boy: One, ew. Two, that interaction scared me. Three.
Daddy’s Boy: CANDY APPLE
Daddy’s Girl: HEHEHEHE
Daddy’s Boy: WHEN I FIND YOU-
Liar Liar: No fighting.
I Will Falter: No, let them.
Liar Liar: …Is this my Vanilly or Truthless Recluse talking?
I Will Falter: both.
Sparkle: I can’t have a single day of peace here, huh?
Flour: With them…? No.
Burning: WHERE”S NUTMEG AND CAPSAICIN?
Flour: …YOU LOST YOUR CHILDREN-?
Sparkle: of for the love of….
Sassy King: womp womp.
Notes:
If anyone got the reference I'm gonna be so proud of my multi-fandom children. Also Truthless Recluse mentioned :)
Chapter 6: he did wHAT-
Summary:
based off a real life experience that happened yesterday during my singing rehearsal- it wasn't me who dislocated their knee, dw chat-
Notes:
Key:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic/dragon fucker
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch/ Whore
Dark Cacao cookie - emo
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding/ Liar Liar
Burning Spice cookie - burning
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one/flour
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues/Sassy King
Custard Cookie III - orphan/ Orphan Issues
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Daddy’s Girl: ohmugodohmygod
Daddy’s Boy: Im gonna throw up-
Fluttershy: G I N G E R
Oven trauma: I KNOW
Liar Liar: uh, heh… vanilly, my pookie-
I Will Falter: who‘s hurt.
Liar Liar: wellll-
Oven Trauma: Wizard Cookie dislocated his knee
I Will Falter: .
I Will Falter: …he fucking what-?
Sassy King: NUTMEG TIGER PUSHED ME DOWN THE FUCKING STAIRS
Burning: you found my baby?
Flour: …your worried about that?
Sparkle: really bitch?
Burning: fuck off, pretty bird
Sparkle: yes, i am pretty, im STUNNING thank you
Oven Trauma: … Wizard, why are you walking-
Sassy King: it popped back in place.
Flour: …
Liar Liar: oh dear-
Daddy’s Girl: uh… Black Sapphire passed out.
I Will Falter: im not drunk enough for this.
Dragon Fucker: if you steal my juice supply, im siccing Pitaya on you
I Will Falter: TRY ME BITCH
Flour: yeah no, im getting Cloud Haetae to guard my bagoda again
Emo: hell no, im not doing that shit again
Flour: no flour virus.
Emo: good.
Whore: Dark Cacao, you have five seconds
Emo: …coming-
Dragon Fucker: damn.
I Will Falter: i see why you had Elder Faerie wrapped around you finger
Whore: you wanna be next?
I Will Falter: id offer to you both, but not when your angry
Dragon: i left for a day, what the fuck jussst happened-
Flour: a lot.
Googie: fgdhsnfgydhsj
Dragon: FUCK YOU TOO LITTLE SHIT
Dragon Fucker: language, both of you
Daddy’s Boy: …why do i live. Just to suffer?
Sassy King: i feel you.
Notes:
a bit of a long chapter lmao- remember to check my Tumblr!
Chapter 7: Sex, sex and… more sex.
Summary:
Just warning y’all, lots of mentions of sex jokes and shit in this chapter. The rating is mature for a reason.
Notes:
Key:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic/dragon fucker
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch/ Whore
Dark Cacao cookie - emo
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding/ Liar Liar
Burning Spice cookie - burning
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one/flour
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues/Sassy King
Custard Cookie III - orphan/ Orphan Issues
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
I Will Falter: fuck.
Liar Liar: say less.
I Will Falter: no, not now, i just got my ass turned inside out-
Flour: didnt know Lily had a strap on.
I Will Falter: no-
Daddy’s Girl: dad please come pick me up im scared
Liar Liar: wheres the body
I Will Falter: im sorry?
Daddy’s Girl: no body… got rid of it
Liar Liar: thats my girl.
Daddy’s Girl: but im hearing two pairs of moans and its making me uncomfy
I Will Falter: IM SORRY??
Whore: its not us, Dark Cacao passed out
I Will Falter: i wonder why,
Whore: shut up before i fuck you again
I Will Falter: yes ma’am, message received.
Liar Liar: then who-
Liar Liar: …Wheres Burning Spice.
Daddy’s Girl: idk, hes been locked in his room :/
Flour: holy shit, i didn't think he’d actually do it
Liar Liar: WHATS THAT MEAN
Flour: i told him to fuck Golden Cheese or he’s the weakest beast.
Liar Liar: …why.
Flour: the hate flirting was getting annoying,
Daddy’s Girl: pretty sure the other pair is either Holly or Sapphire-
Liar Liar: …
Liar Liar: BLACK SAPPHIRE COOKIE I SWEAR TO THE WITCHES IF YOU SNUCK YOUR LITTLE FAERIE BOYFRIEND IN JUST TO FUCK HIM-
Daddy’s Boy: im not at home, dad.
Daddy’s Boy: and who said i was the one fucking him.
Whore: …Silverbell is a top-?
Daddy’s Boy: no, hes just angry- oh shi-
I Will Falter: …on second though, hurry up and come fuck me Shadow.
Liar Liar: fucking bet, Vanilly.
Flour: ugh… Candy Apple, you wanna hang out with Cloud Haetea?
Daddy’s Girl: yes please
. . .
Emo: Im awake, what did i miss-
Dragon Fucker: not much, just everyone being horny.
Emo: considering i just woke up to Lily trying to fuck me again-
Whore: shut up. Off.
Emo: yes ma’am-
Dragon: ha. Sssslut.
Dragon Fucker: dont make me get the strap on again.
Dragon: …understood.
Burning: did your dumbass challenge, Mystic Flour, that proves i'm not no pussy.
Flour: you do realize you just fucked your enemy, right?
Sparkle: its called hate sex for a reason, neither of us enjoyed it,
Flour: sure. Say it to my face. Not now, Cloud Haetae is on duty
Sassy King: i was gone.. For a week and i come back to THIS
Oven Trauma: can i go join my brother now
Sassy King: i will kill you myself, don't you dare.
Fluttershy: aw. Couple goals. Im ignoring everything else
Oven Trauma: were not dating-
Sassy King: WERE NOT DATING
Orphan issues: Ginger, look, Wizard Cookie in a bikini
Sassy King: wait wha- MOTHER F-
Fluttershy: oh.
Flour: I’m going to adopt you poor kids. Not those two, Shadow can have them.
Fluttershy: :)
Orphan issues: :D
Notes:
The end was just random my mind is everywhere and no where lmao
Chapter 8: Midnight Shenanigans
Summary:
Eternal Sugar Cookie joins!
Key:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic/dragon fucker
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch/ Whore
Dark Cacao cookie - emo
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding/ Liar Liar
Burning Spice cookie - burning/Hot Daddy
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one/flour
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues/Sassy King
Custard Cookie III - orphan/ Orphan Issues
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
Eternal Sugar: Succubus
Notes:
This was supposed to be a smc centric chapter to celebrate me getting him a few days ago but as you see, it spiraled out of control…
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Liar Liar: Vanilly…
I Will Falter: Yes, milky?
Liar Liar: You left… also Eternal Sugar is being an ANNOYING BITCH.
Dragon Fucker: thats my girlfriend, watch it.
Dragon: thatssss OUR pretty devil you piece of sssshit.
I Will Falter: Language.
Liar Liar: Fuck you- shit. Sorry Vanilly.
I Will Falter: I'm going to break up with you. That's a threat.
Liar Liar: ill bring you jellies and flowers every day.
I will Falter: Marry me.
Sassy King: Its 3am. Shut. the FUCK UP.
Daddy’s Boy: Please for the love of the witches.
Succubus: Hiiii
Liar Liar: …
I Will Falter: …
Dragon Fucker: :D
Dragon: :}
Daddy’s Girl: whos that-
Flour: oh hell no.
Hot Daddy: for the love of fucking-
Liar Liar: WHO LET YOU IN
Fluttershy: Go to sleep.
Sassy King: coming berry.
Succubus: hehe, pleasure to be here~
Hot Daddy: Fuck this shit im out.
Liar Liar: i’m going to fucking kill myself.
I Will Falter: This is Truthless Recluse. Do that ill choke you.
Liar Liar: understood.
Daddy’s Boy: I need new parents.
Sassy King: Don’t we all?
Notes:
I Stan my OT3s, I love PitayaBerry and EternalBerry equally, fight me.
Chapter 9: Children and ages
Summary:
Someone notices all the Beasts have children, ages are asked, and Pavlova joins the chat.
Also names got reset, I’ll fix them later.
Key:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic/dragon fucker
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch/ Whore
Dark Cacao cookie - emo/Simp
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding/ Liar Liar
Burning Spice cookie - burning/Hot Daddy
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one/flour
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues/Sassy King
Custard Cookie III - orphan/ Orphan Issues
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
Eternal Sugar: Succubus
Pavlova Cookie: Pavlova(for now)
Notes:
Eternal Sugar: Oh Pavlova..~ Come out and play~
Pavlova: *aggressively trembling*
Sugarfly: *just there to comfort him*
This totally happened before Pavlova was added, prove me wrong
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
I Will Falter: Ive notice something. All the beasts have children.
Liar Liar: Black Sapphire and Candy Apple are technically your children too.
I Will Falter: My point stands.
Dragon Fucker: i have a granddaughter too.
Oven Trauma: wait granddaughter? How old are you guys-
I Will Falter: wait… guess.
Orphan issues: uh.. 10,000?
Simp: wha-
Whore: Oh my-
Burning: . . .
I Will Falter: WHAT?
Orphan Issues: you said guess-
Succubus: darling, we're not that old.. Speaking of children.
Eternal Sugar has added Pavlova Cookie
Pavlova: Eternal Sugar..? What’s this-
Succubus: nothing of importance, my dear, i had felt it required to have you!~
Pavlova: Oh.. thank you?
Pure Vanilla has reset all names
Shadow Milk: Vanilly, what the f-
Pure Vanilla: its just for today.
HollyBerry: know what, that seems right.
Eternal Sugar: Aw, i was having fun with the names~
Wizard: I wasn’t.
Strawberry: Uhm.. Ginger.. Wizard… i need help-
GingerBrave: on the way!
Wizard: don’t even gotta ask, berry, im coming
Custard III: wait for me!
Black Sapphire: aw, cute. Its disgusting.
White Lily: ill gladly add SilverBell.
Black Sapphire: statement retracted, id like to keep the ability to walk.
Pavlova: …I feel frightened..
Candy Apple: You’ll get used to it.
Pavlova: heh…?
Notes:
Me who ended up taking about 5 separate naps in the same day, but wanting to get updates out:
Also check out my new fic, make sure to look at the request page and mention if you have anything you want me to write :)
Chapter 10: Unanswered questions
Summary:
Key:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic/dragon fucker
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch/ Whore/Lilies
Dark Cacao cookie - emo/Simp/dilf
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding/ Liar Liar
Burning Spice cookie - burning/Hot Daddy
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one/flour
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues/Sassy King
Custard Cookie III - orphan/ Orphan Issues
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
Eternal Sugar: Succubus
Pavlova Cookie: rip-off Cupid
SilverBell: SilverBalls
Dark Choco: father-stabber
Licorice Cookie: secretly gay
Notes:
Giving thanks to the comments who suggested the names! Love you guys~ ^^
Edit: ALMOST FORGOT- shoutouts too Imaghostdipshit and DarkChocoNeedsTherapy for name suggestions and ideas!
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Ripoff Cupid: Ah.. what’s a top..
I Will Falter: …
Liar Liar: …
Lilies: who.
GingerBrave added Dark Choco, SilverBell and Licorice Cookie
Daddy’s Boy: GOD FUCKING DAMNIT-
Daddy: Sapphire. You have three minutes
Daddy’s Boy: I know- I’m coming-
Succubus: oh?~
Daddy’s boy: not like that.
SilverBalls: it’s gonna be like that if you don’t- who changed my name?
Sass King: oops. Not sorry.
Dilf: …son.
Father-Stabbed: hello father- oh. I.. think you should change that.
Dilf: …what is a dilf
Secretly Gay: who added me-
Father Stabber: oh, hello darling.
Lilies: ..Dark Cacao, your sons gay!
Father Stabber: oh s-
Dilf: good for him, long as he’s happy.
Secretly gay: Aw.. your dad seems nice.
Oven Trauma: at least he has a dad.
Sass King: we are NOT going there again, Ginger.
ripoff Cupid: …no one answered my question.
Hot Daddy: well when-
Sparkle: no. Just no.
Liar Liar: yup. Just another day in hell.
Daddy’s Girl: papa, I don’t want to be here, Sappy is making noises again.
I Will Falter: STOP FUCKING AROUND YOUR SISTER, SAPPHIRE.
SilverBalls: oops- didn’t know anyone else was home.
Lilies: ah.. if only my ex was still here to control his surprisingly feral and horny kids.
I Will Falter: No.
Dilf: no.
Notes:
I lowkey ship Licorice Cookie and Dark Choco cookie, they just seem to blend well together… I love being a multishipper
Chapter 11: Dad jokes and insanity
Summary:
Dark Choco and Black Sapphire become dad joke survivors
Notes:
I feel silly even though I’ve been up until 4am for 3 day’s straight lmao
Key:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic/dragon fucker
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch/ Whore/Lilies
Dark Cacao cookie - emo/Simp/dilf
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding/ Liar Liar
Burning Spice cookie - burning/Hot Daddy
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one/flour
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues/Sassy King
Custard Cookie III - orphan/ Orphan Issues
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
Eternal Sugar: Succubus
Pavlova Cookie: rip-off Cupid
SilverBell: SilverBalls
Dark Choco: father-stabber
Licorice Cookie: secretly gay
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Father- Stabber: Oh dear god, no.
Lilies: hm? Is there an issue-
father-Stabber: I am in need of help
Dilf: hello in need of help, I’m dad.
Liar Liar: …oh fuck no.
Flour: oh dear god.
Succubus: we’ll this just got interesting~
Daddy’s Boy: wait, what’s happening here?
I Will Falter: heh.. it seems a bit muggy out today
Daddy’s Boy: …
Hot Daddy: damn, now I gotta add my kids
Flour: I will reduce you to flour.
Hot Daddy: …how is Silent Salt not scared shitless of you.
Flour: they are.
Father Stabber: I’m traumatized.
Daddy’s Boy: I feel you…
Sparkle: I am so happy I don’t have children.
Dragon Fucker: awe, now I miss my daughter AND my granddaughter!
Succubus: wha-
Dragon: YOU HAVE KIDSSSS?
Dragon Fucker: didn’t I mention this?
Dragon: NO?
Succubus: No..?
Sparkle: how are me and White Lily the only ancients without children…
Lilies: Well….
Sparkle: …you did not.
Lilies: I did.
Sparkle: Goddamnit Lily.
Lilies: SilverBell needed a parent after my ex died!
I Will Falter: Please stop calling Elder Faerie your ex.
SilverBalls: please.
Father Stabber: Has it stopped?
Daddy’s Boy: I believe so.
Daddy’s Girl: this is why I’m the favorite!
Daddy’s boy: well, seems I no longer have a sister.
Daddy’s Girl: wha- EEKEKEK-
Liar Liar: why are my kids screaming
I Will Falter: pretty sure BS is strangling Candy Apple again.
Flour: each day that passes here, I lose more and more of my sanity…
Dilf: you never had any sanity,
Flour: I wish I would’ve crumbled you the first time.
Sparkle: Every time I come into this server… I wish I just let this spice bastard kill me.
Hot Daddy: how do you think I feel around these lunatics?
RipOff Cupid: ah yes… LOVE!~
Sparkle: shut your bitchass up-
Hot Daddy: GET OUT-
Notes:
Can you tell I got lazy at the end?
Chapter 12: Bloody Mary
Summary:
It’s Friday the 13th… the kids summon a demon, the ancients are in panic and the beasts are just there.
Notes:
Key:
Pure Vanilla cookie - I will Falter
HollyBerry cookie - juice-aholic/dragon fucker
White Lily cookie - two timing bitch/ Whore/Lilies
Dark Cacao cookie - emo/Simp/dilf
Golden Cheese cookie - sparkle
Shadow Milk cookie - in hiding/ Liar Liar
Burning Spice cookie - burning/Hot Daddy
Mystic Flour cookie - the actual silent one/flour
Black Sapphire cookie - daddy’s boy
Candy Apple cookie - daddy’s girl
Gringerbrave - oven trauma
Strawberry cookie - fluttershy
Wizard cookie - anger issues/Sassy King
Custard Cookie III - orphan/ Orphan Issues/ mini vanilla
Pitaya Cookie - dragon
SnapDragon Cookie - googie
Eternal Sugar: Succubus
Pavlova Cookie: rip-off Cupid
SilverBell: SilverBalls
Dark Choco: father-stabber/back stabber
Licorice Cookie: secretly gay
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Daddy’s Boy: HELP
Daddy’s Girl: THIS WAS A TERRIBLE IDEA
Daddy’s Boy: IT WAS YOUR IDEA
Liar Liar: what the hell happened-
Back stabber: we may or may not have summoned a demon… aka Dark Enchantress Cookie-
Dilf: you what
I Will Falter: YOU WHAT-?
Mini Vanilla: we were trying to summon Bloody Mary!
Hot Daddy: nice.
I Will Falter: NO, NOT NICE.
Sassy King: oh sh- RUN FOR YOUR LIVES.
Daddy’s Girl: I don’t want to die beside Black Sapphire!
Daddy’s Boy: fuck you too.
Oven Trauma: I lied. I’m gay. I’m sorry-
Fluttershy: I love you guys
Mini Vanilla: WE LOVE YOU TOO
Cupid Rip-off: I should’ve stayed in the garden, I’m sorry SugarFly-
Back Stabber: guys. She’s gone.
SilverBalls: what do you mean gone-
Googie: Googie?
Dragon: MY CHILD
Succubus: Pavlova…
I Will Falter: this is why I don’t let you kids have sleepovers, I’m coming to get you.
Lilies: Yup, me too.
Dilf: we all are.
Sparkle: IS FETTUCCINE COOKIE WITH YOU ALL?
Mini Vanilla: uh.. yes
Sassy King: everyone is here, Cloud HaeTae, Nutmeg Tiger-
Hot Daddy: I’m sorry?
Flour: my child is what.
Liar Liar: yeah, we’re all coming to get our kids, no more sleepovers for you all.
Mini Vanilla: :(
Flutteryshy: 😞
Sassy King: know what, fair. Ginger, get off me.
Oven Trauma: sorry-
Back Stabber: pick me up please father.
Notes:
Can you tell I’m indulging all my stories today? Friday the 13th must be a lucky day!
Pages Navigation
H_U_H__W_H_A_T on Chapter 1 Sun 20 Apr 2025 11:39AM UTC
Comment Actions
ShadowVanillalover on Chapter 2 Tue 22 Apr 2025 12:32PM UTC
Last Edited Tue 22 Apr 2025 12:33PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 2 Tue 22 Apr 2025 01:21PM UTC
Comment Actions
ShadowVanillalover on Chapter 2 Tue 22 Apr 2025 01:42PM UTC
Comment Actions
SleepingAnonymous on Chapter 2 Tue 22 Apr 2025 12:34PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 2 Tue 22 Apr 2025 01:22PM UTC
Comment Actions
QueenOfSwords_2063 on Chapter 2 Tue 22 Apr 2025 02:14PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 2 Tue 22 Apr 2025 02:32PM UTC
Comment Actions
QueenOfSwords_2063 on Chapter 2 Wed 23 Apr 2025 09:20AM UTC
Comment Actions
Livelonglaughlong on Chapter 4 Wed 23 Apr 2025 02:34PM UTC
Comment Actions
Livelonglaughlong on Chapter 4 Wed 23 Apr 2025 04:36PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 4 Thu 24 Apr 2025 01:09AM UTC
Comment Actions
Livelonglaughlong on Chapter 4 Thu 24 Apr 2025 01:17AM UTC
Comment Actions
Noobyy on Chapter 4 Wed 23 Apr 2025 03:58PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 4 Thu 24 Apr 2025 01:09AM UTC
Comment Actions
Noobyy on Chapter 4 Thu 24 Apr 2025 02:10AM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 4 Thu 24 Apr 2025 06:03PM UTC
Comment Actions
Noobyy on Chapter 4 Thu 24 Apr 2025 06:19PM UTC
Comment Actions
ShadowVanillalover on Chapter 4 Wed 23 Apr 2025 05:26PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 4 Thu 24 Apr 2025 01:08AM UTC
Comment Actions
ShadowVanillalover on Chapter 4 Thu 24 Apr 2025 12:17PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 4 Thu 24 Apr 2025 06:04PM UTC
Comment Actions
ShadowVanillalover on Chapter 4 Thu 24 Apr 2025 06:30PM UTC
Comment Actions
InAComa on Chapter 4 Sat 24 May 2025 06:58PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 4 Fri 06 Jun 2025 06:53AM UTC
Comment Actions
passivepuppetboy on Chapter 4 Fri 30 May 2025 03:43AM UTC
Comment Actions
FanofViolet2000 on Chapter 4 Fri 06 Jun 2025 04:53AM UTC
Comment Actions
Cl@!re (Guest) on Chapter 4 Fri 06 Jun 2025 07:12PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 4 Sat 21 Jun 2025 11:39PM UTC
Comment Actions
M0on_Moth on Chapter 3 Wed 30 Apr 2025 09:35PM UTC
Comment Actions
DarkChocoNeedsTherapy on Chapter 3 Tue 27 May 2025 01:14AM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 3 Sat 21 Jun 2025 11:39PM UTC
Last Edited Sat 21 Jun 2025 11:40PM UTC
Comment Actions
ShadowVanillalover on Chapter 5 Fri 25 Apr 2025 03:22PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 5 Sat 26 Apr 2025 01:45AM UTC
Comment Actions
Noobyy on Chapter 5 Fri 25 Apr 2025 04:03PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 5 Sat 26 Apr 2025 01:44AM UTC
Comment Actions
Noobyy on Chapter 5 Sat 26 Apr 2025 04:22AM UTC
Comment Actions
JayNoWay21 on Chapter 5 Fri 25 Apr 2025 05:45PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 5 Sat 26 Apr 2025 01:44AM UTC
Last Edited Sat 26 Apr 2025 01:44AM UTC
Comment Actions
EstelleLuna on Chapter 5 Fri 25 Apr 2025 09:46PM UTC
Last Edited Fri 25 Apr 2025 09:47PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 5 Sat 26 Apr 2025 01:43AM UTC
Comment Actions
EstelleLuna on Chapter 5 Sat 26 Apr 2025 01:49AM UTC
Comment Actions
M0on_Moth on Chapter 5 Wed 30 Apr 2025 09:40PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 5 Thu 01 May 2025 12:47PM UTC
Comment Actions
ghost fan (Guest) on Chapter 5 Mon 12 May 2025 11:44PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 5 Wed 14 May 2025 01:56PM UTC
Comment Actions
Mimistle (Guest) on Chapter 5 Wed 18 Jun 2025 05:42PM UTC
Comment Actions
PrettyBlueJay on Chapter 5 Sat 21 Jun 2025 11:40PM UTC
Comment Actions
ShadowVanillalover on Chapter 6 Wed 30 Apr 2025 06:27PM UTC
Comment Actions
Pages Navigation