Actions

Work Header

Talk to me, Carter

Summary:

“Doctor Benton,” Carter whispers, terror rising. “You want me – you want me to perform a surgical procedure on myself? I can’t do that. That… that’s crazy.”

“Carter, you can and you will. I’m going to talk you through it. And then we’re going to get you out of there, and to the hospital, and then you’re going to be fine. But right now, we do not have a lot of time. So I need you to listen to me very carefully and do everything I say.”

Or: John Carter is trapped under a collapsed building and seriously injured. Peter Benton talks him through surgery... on himself.

Notes:

For context, this fic takes place shortly after 3x13. Dennis Gant is dead, and Carter has switched to Hicks's team.

Chapter 1: Below

Chapter Text

Carter wakes up coughing. It’s dark, and there’s something on his chest that hurts, and the air is thick with dust.

“Carter!? Answer me. Carter, can you hear me?” a voice is calling his name, muffled, sounding far away. It’s a familiar voice, but Carter’s head is spinning and he can’t quite make the connection.

Panic settling in, he coughs and coughs and coughs, choking on dust, vomiting to the side. When the coughing finally subsides, he lays there, wheezing. He’s still not getting enough air, he recognizes. There’s something heavy on his chest, weighing on his lungs, restricting their capacity.

Again: “Carter! Answer me, man!”

“Doc-Doctor Benton?” Carter chokes out, moving his head around in the darkness, looking for any indication of the surgical resident.

There’s no response, though, and it’s too dark to see anything. Gradually, Carter’s head begins to clear, begins to make sense of things.

He had been stuck doing a paramedic ride-along with Benton – the man whose service he had abandoned for Hicks’s just weeks previously. It had been awkward, Carter remembered – Carter chatting away with the EMT in the back of the ambulance while Benton sat in complete, stony silence.

There had been a gas leak explosion at a small apartment complex in South Shore. A lot of people hurt. A lot of people trapped inside. Carter had followed the voice of a screaming woman inside, traversing debris-riddled hallways with a flashlight and a medical bag in hand. And then… Carter remembers a terrible grating sound – like the whole building was groaning. He remembers the floor giving way beneath his feet, and then… nothing. Waking up here.

“Carter, you better answer this damn radio, man! Right now!”

Radio! Benton’s muffled voice was coming from the radio!

With a groan, Carter strains against whatever rubble has fallen on his chest, lifting his pelvis so that he can grab the radio that is – thankfully – still sitting in his back pocket.

Flicks the switch that sets the radio at continuous receiving.

“Doctor Benton?”

“Carter?? Jesus Christ!” comes Benton’s voice. Maybe John is concussed, but Benton sounds… scared?

“What happened?” Carter rasps, trying to move again, hissing as a stabbing pain fills his chest.

“The building collapsed. You were inside. Christ, man. We- I… everyone thought you were dead.”

“Doctor Benton, were you worried about me?” Carter says, delighted and amused in spite of everything.

Carter hears Benton start to say something but doesn’t get to hear what it is. Something catches in his throat and he erupts into another coughing attack. His chest is on fire, he cannot breathe he cannot breathe.

Distantly, he hears Benton shouting over the radio, but he can’t listen, can’t focus, oh my god he is going to die, he’s going to suffocate-

The edges of Carter’s vision go grey. The world disappears.

When he comes to, his lungs are slightly more clear, but his chest is heaving.

…are you with me? Carter, I swear to god if you’re aspirating down there and not doing anything about it, I will never let you see the inside of an OR ever again. Damnit, Carter-”

“I’m here, I’m here!” Carter gasps, still coughing a little, but keeping it under control.

For a few moments, there’s no response from Benton. Carter is a little pleased that his teacher – former teacher? – is so worried. When Benton’s voice finally comes back on over the radio, it is tight. Restrained. Controlled. Classic Peter Benton.

“Carter. We need you to focus on taking slow, shallow breaths. It will help minimize the dust inhalation. Now. I need you to concentrate. I need you to tell me where you’re hurt.”

“How do you know I’m hurt?” Carter wheezes.

Don’t be fucking smart with me, Carter. Give me the full rundown.”

“I, uh, I’m not sure,” Carter says hoarsely. “I think I hit my head, and… something… something’s on my chest. It’s hard to breathe. It’s dark. I can’t move.”

Silence on the other end. Then: “Okay. Carter, I need you to try moving the thing on your chest. I think it’s restricting your breathing. Then we can focus on everything else.”

Carter groans, knowing Benton is right. His chest fucking hurts.

“Okay,” Carter whispers. “Give me a couple minutes.”

I’ll give you one.”

John rolls his eyes. Begins to feel around the weight on his chest. It appears to be concrete, a support beam of some kind. Fantastic.

With a shuddering breath, John begins to push. It’s fucking heavy, but it’s not immovable. His arms shake, his chest is caving in on itself, he can’t breathe – but still he pushes, with everything he has. There is a little give at first, and then Carter feels something come loose, come unstuck. The corners of his vision are turning grey, but still he pushes, pushes – and then with a massive thunk, Carter is free. He lays there for a least a minute, trying unsuccessfully to catch his breath, to breathe through the pain.

“Talk to me, Carter.”

“I’m good, I, I got it,” John gasps. He doesn’t feel good, though. The support beam might be gone, but the feeling of a weight on his chest is still there. The pain is harsh, stabbing, radiating through his shoulder and back. It’s really hard to breathe. A diagnostic puzzle is piecing itself together in Carter’s mind, and it’s not a good one.

“Good, man. That’s good. The whole of the Chicago Fire Department is out here, they’re working on getting people out as we speak. Now give it to me- where else are you injured.”

Carter just wheezes. His chest feels like it’s being squeezed from the inside.

Answer me when I talk to you, Carter.”

Benton’s voice is sharp.

“M-my chest really hurts,” Carter gets out. He tries to keep is voice steady and clinical and unafraid – just like Doctor Benton. It’s the opposite of how he is feeling. “Hard to breathe. Doctor Benton, what’s my ETA on getting out of here?” He coughs, then coughs again. God, it hurt.

There is a beat of silence on the other line. Benton’s response is quiet, controlled.

What’s your diagnosis, Carter?”

John squeezes his eyes shut, trying not to give in to panic or despair. “Tension pneumo, I think. On the left side.”

There is an extended silence on the other side.

“Doctor Benton,” Carter wheezes. “Are you, are you still there.”

I’m not going anywhere, Carter.” Benton’s tone is flat and serious. “I was just talking to the fire chief. They don’t think they’ll be able to get you out for at least forty five minutes.”

John’s heart pounds. “That’s bad news,” he says as casually as he can. “I’ll probably be dead by then.”

Not if I can help it. Which is why you’re going to have to take care of this yourself.”

Carter emits a breathy laugh that turns into more coughing. “I’m trapped under a building, Doctor Benton. How exactly do you propose I take care of this?”

On the other line, Benton’s voice is grim. “You have your medical bag with you, right?”

Heart beating fast and utterly confused, Carter looks around. “I, uh, yeah. I had it with me. But it’s dark down here, I can’t see anything. Can’t see it.”

“Where’s your flashlight, Carter?”

“It’s uh, I don’t know.”

Find it.”

Carter begins to grope around, and miraculously, his hand immediately makes contact with the familiar grip of his flashlight.

“Got it.”

Good. Find that medical bag.”

Carter flicks the flashlight on. Looks around his surroundings for the first time. Obviously somewhere underground, Carter is surrounded by rubble, collapsed walls and concrete and pipes, insulation and cables and wiring. Nowhere does he see a way out. But – a few yards away, he spots the bright red medical bag he brought into the building.

“I see it.”

Can you reach it?”

“I-I think so.” Carter isn’t totally sure. Breathing is becoming harder, the pain getting worse.

Get it done. Quickly, Carter.”

“Doctor Benton, I… I don’t think there’s anything in my medical bag that can help me.”

Carter says it hesitantly, but clearly. As clearly as he can with an invisible elephant sitting on his chest. Tries not to reveal how scared he is. Trying not to think about the fact that his body will soon go into shock, that he will lose consciousness from a lack of oxygen. Who will retrieve his body? Will his parents come home for his funeral?

You’re not going to die, Carter,” Benton snaps, as if reading John’s mind. “Get that damn medical bag, now.

Slowly, Carter scoots towards where the bag had fallen. He is coughing again, but he keeps going. A pain in his leg registers – he’s probably injured there, too. That’s a problem for later. Reaching out, stretching, chest bursting, he grapples with the handle, pulling it closer to him.

“Got it,” he gasps.

Good. Open it up. I need you to grab the scissors, a scalpel, antiseptic. Then I need you to look around for something thin and hollow. A pipe, if you can find one.”

Carter obeys, digging through the bag. “Doctor Benton, I… I don’t know what you want me to do.”

We’ve got to relieve the pressure in your chest. You are going to perform an improvised chest tube,” Benton says calmly, as if it’s not the craziest fucking thing that’s ever been said out loud.

“On myself??” Carter asks, not sure if he’s hearing Benton correctly.

Unless you want to die,” Benton snaps.

Carter’s heart is pounding. He genuinely cannot believe what Benton is telling him to do. Benton would hardly allow Carter to insert chest tubes when they were in the trauma room!

“Doctor Benton,” Carter whispers, terror rising. “You want me – you want me to perform a surgical procedure on myself? I can’t do that. That… that’s crazy.”

Carter, you can and you will. I’m going to talk you through it. And then we’re going to get you out of there, and to the hospital, and then you’re going to be fine. But right now, we do not have a lot of time. So I need you to listen to me very carefully and do everything I say.” 

John shakes his head, heart beating fast, the panic threatening to consume him. “No,” he rasps. “This is crazy. I’m not – I’m not going to put in my own chest tube. There’s no way I can do that, Doctor Benton. I’ll bleed out, I’ll pass out. It’s just going to kill me faster.” Tears run down his cheeks. Carter prays that Benton cannot sense the tears, the vulnerability in his voice.

A pause on the other end. “Carter, you are going to do this. I am your resident, and I am not asking.”

“You’re not my resident,” Carter croaks despite himself. “Doctor Hicks is my resident.” Carter feels his breaths getting shallower, his limbs slightly heavier.

Another pause. Then Benton’s voice comes, sounding slightly strangled. “Look, Carter. If I could get Hicks here to walk you through this procedure, I would. But she’s not here. And I’m your best chance at getting through this. And I am not going to sit out here listening to you die, do you hear me?”

“Okay.” Carter whispers.

“Say it back to me.”

Carter coughs “You’re… you’re not going to let me die.”

“That’s right. Now look around. What can you use for the chest tube?”

Wiping away the tears from his grimy, dust-covered face, Carter looks around. “Broken pipes. I see broken pipes. I think… I think I fell near a utility room or something.”

Benton lets out a strangled laugh. “That’s great. Find the thinnest one you can. Quickly.”

Dragging his body over to a pile of rubble, Carter quickly finds an 8 inch shard of pipe, about 3 centimeters thick.

“Got one.” Carter describes it.

Alright, Carter. How are you feeling.”

“I- I’m alright. Getting pretty hard to breathe. though. I’m… I’m a little dizzy.”

“Okay. That’s to be expected. But we have work really fast now if this is going to work. Use the scissors to cut off your shirt. Tell me when you’re done.”

Carter obeys mindlessly. “Done.”

Good. Now. Pour antiseptic over the pipe, over the scalpel, over your side. I need you to get everything as clean as possible, alright?”

“Okay.” Carter does it, the smell of alcohol filling his dusty nostrils. He coughs once. And then again. And then he can’t stop.

“Damnit, Carter!” John hears distantly, but he can’t reply. Every cough is a knife to the chest. He’s being crushed by some invisible force. Tears stream down his face. His lungs feel like they’re barely taking in any air at all now. He’s light-headed, he can’t see straight. And Benton expects him to be able to perform surgery on himself?? He continues to cough, the coughs beginning to sound like sobs.

“I can’t do it, I can’t do it,” Carter gasps out. He hears cursing on the other end.

Yes you can.”

“No I can’t! I can’t!”

“You can, and you will!” Benton yells.

John doesn’t reply. The scalpel in his hand trembles uncontrollably.

On the other line, John hears Benton take a deep breath. And then another. “Look, Carter. What do you need me to say to get you to do this? That you’re the best medical student I’ve ever had? Because you are. That I messed up letting you switch to Hicks’s service? Because I did. Happy? And if anyone can do this, it’s you. So calm down, put your flashlight between your teeth, pick up that scalpel and make a four centimeter incision to your fifth intercostal space.”

Carter swallows. Head spinning. Heart glowing just a little bit from Benton’s praise, in spite of everything happening. “Okay.” He whispers.

He knows how this works. A four centimeter length incision between his fifth and sixth rib on his left side. Five centimeters deep, sawing through skin, fat, and muscle, right through the pleural space to get to the chest cavity. Conscious. No pain meds.

John takes the deepest breath that he can. Steadies his shaking hands. Positions the scalpel.

“Going in,” he mumbles. Presses down. And then he is screaming.

Chapter 2: Above

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Peter Benton is sitting at the back of an open ambulance, clutching his radio like someone is trying to take it from him. Like if he holds on to it tight enough, it can save the life of John Carter.

“Going in,” comes the muffled voice of the intern over the radio.

Peter inhales sharply.

And then there is a yell of pain. Benton shoots to his feet. The radio crackles with staticky sounds between Carter’s strangled gasps and tortured moans. Peter’s hands are shaking as he visualizes what is happening – his student cutting deeply into his own body, through skin and muscle with no pain relief, no medication, no anything. It seems like it goes on forever, the sounds of Carter panting and crying. An unwelcome tear slides down Benton’s face and he furiously wipes it away. 

“You got this, Carter. Keep going. Stay focused. Remember to breathe,” Peter coaches through the radio, aware that Carter probably isn’t listening, probably can’t hear him over the sounds of his own yells. “All the way through the parietal pleura, Carter. All the way through. You’ve got to cut through the membrane. Make sure you cut through the membrane. Listen for the pop, Carter! Listen for it!” Benton chants, shouting, pacing back and forth, ignoring the many firemen and search and rescue crew who are looking at him like he’s crazy.

And then it’s quiet on the other line. “Carter!” Benton shouts. “CARTER!”

Doctor Benton,” John’s voice crackles over the speaker, a faint whine.

“Stay with me, Carter,” Peter commands. “Keep your fingers inside the cut. Did you get all the way to the pleural space??”

I-I don’t feel so good,” comes Carter’s weak response.

Peter’s heart pounds. No. No no no no no.

“Do not pass out on me, Carter! Do not pass out! You stay awake! You stay awake!” he hears himself screaming.

An unintellible sound comes from his student. “…tired…”

“No, Carter, don’t you dare fall asleep, don’t you dare!” Peter yells. From a distance, he sees the fire chief approaching him. He waves him away.

“Carter! Carter!” Benton feels sick. He doesn’t know if the incision was successful. Carter could be bleeding out, bleeding out because of Peter, because Peter told him he couldn’t wait, made him cut inches into his body, and now he isn’t responding. He’s going to pass out and asphyxiate, and there’s nothing Peter can do. He killed Gant, and now he’s killed Carter. Couldn’t save them. Couldn’t save either of them. He’s a failure of a teacher, a danger to his students. Not Carter. Please, god, not Carter.

“Carter,” Benton whispers in the radio. “Please answer me, man. Please don’t fall asleep. You’re so close. So close.”

Peter thinks about the last time he and Carter spoke – really spoke. It was up on the roof of the hospital. Carter was telling him he was switching to Hick’s service. You know, a month ago you would’ve ripped my lungs out for going behind your back to another surgeon. Now you just stand there? Carter had said to him – bold, outspoken, confident. Peter had been too in his own head. Reeling from Gant’s death. Couldn’t bring himself to fight with Carter. Couldn’t find the words to say how he was feeling. Since when did I start caring about what you do, Carter was what he’d said instead. Now, his eyes smart with tears. The kid - this goofy, bleeding-heart kid was dying, and that was going to be the last real thing Benton had said to him. That he didn’t care.

What was the last thing he’d said to Gant? Peter wondered, not for the first time. And Peter couldn’t remember. He could never remember. It was certainly something horrible, though. Something callous and unfeeling. That was Peter’s expertise, after all. Callous and unfeeling.

You know, in that surgery today, everything I did, you taught me. Carter’s parting words ring in Peter’s ears. Peter chokes back a genuine sob. Stumbles back to the ambulance, collapsing against the side of it, sliding down, head in his hands. He’d been such a fool. Such a stupid, stubborn fool. And now – now it was going to be too late to fix things.

D-d-doctor Benton?”

Peter nearly drops the radio.

“Carter!” he cries out, jumping to his feet again, laughing almost hysterically. “Hey, man. Hey. Are you with me?”

There’s a long pause. Then: “‘m with you.”

“How’s your breathing.”

It-it’s p-pretty… bad, D’ct’r Benton…” Carter stutters.

Peter’s dread rises again like an ocean swell. They had so little time to finish this – so little time. “You’re doing so well, Carter. So well. I need you to tell me if you were able to cut through the parietal pleura. Did you hear a pop or a hiss when you were cutting?”

Yeah, yeah I got it. I’m pretty sure I got it.”

Peter’s heart pounds. He didn’t love “pretty sure”, but there wasn’t time to work with anything else.

“Okay, Carter. You’ve still got that pipe, right? This is going to be really, really hard. But you need to get that pipe through the incision, get it into your chest cavity and relieve the pressure.”

He hears a sound, like a sob, come from the other line. Peter’s grip on the radio tightens. “I’m sorry man. You’re so close. You can save your life if you do this.” Benton pauses. “Please do this, Carter,” he whispers into the radio. “Please.”

“O-okay,” comes Carter’s hoarse voice. Peter’s heart tightens.

“We’re going to do this quickly, okay? I’m going to walk you through how it’s done, and then you’re going to do it, nice and quick. And then it will be over, I promise. Then we’ll come and get you.”

Peter can’t even begin to think about the logistics of a rescue. He knows the fire department and search and rescue are working on it. With the injuries Carter had sustained, Peter honestly doesn’t know if he will make it to a hospital. But he knows that if the tension pneumo goes untreated, Carter will most certainly die.

“Okay, listen up Carter. You’re going to lie flat on your back. With one hand you’re going to hold the incision open with your fingers. In the other hand, you’re going to hold the pipe at a right angle and push it directly through the wound. Keep it straight as you guide it through the ribs. You’re going to push through the muscle, directly into the chest cavity. You know where your lungs are, Carter. Do not under any circumstance puncture your lung. You know how to do this. You’ve done it before in patients. I’ve watched you do it. When you get there, you’re going to hear a big gush of air. And you’re going to feel some of that pressure lift, okay?”

Okay.”

“It’s going to hurt, Carter. It’s going to hurt a lot, but if you do it quickly and precisely, you’ll start feeling a lot better, okay?”

No response from Carter this time.

Peter holds his breath, holds the radio. Nearly drops it as an agonized scream breaks through its wavelengths as Carter begins the procedure. It doesn’t go on as long as the last time, however. The screaming subsides, and Peter just hears panting and crying.

“Talk to me, Carter. Tell me what’s happening.” Peter orders.

Carter doesn’t reply, but Peter is soothed by the sounds he hears coming from Carter. Big, gasping breaths. They sound brutal, but… stronger than before, somehow.

Benton is suddenly startled by the form of the fire chief, right in front of him. “Hey doc, we think we figured out where your kid is. We’re going to go in to get him now. It’s going to take a while, though. At least half an hour, or we’ll risk bringing the whole building down.”

Relieved, Peter gives him a thumbs up. Turns back to the radio. “Hey Carter. Hey. Are you hearing me? Did you get it in?”

I got it,” Carter says, still wheezing a little. Peter hears John give a strangled, incredulous laugh. “That was… fucking… terrible.”

“That was fucking badass, Carter. They’re gonna write journal articles about you. An intern inserts his own chest tube.”

Carter laughs again, then moans. “Fucking hurts.”

Peter sighs. “I know, kid. I know. You did so good. I just talked to the fire chief, they’re coming to get you now. You just have to hold out for another half hour or so, okay. You can do that, right?”

I… I think so. ‘m pretty tired.” Carter mumbles. Benton’s heart clenches.

“You have to stay awake until we come and get you, alright? You have to stay awake. Now, what are you doing to control the bleeding?”

“…nothing.”

“Do something about it, Carter. Pull out the gauze from your medical bag, start applying pressure around the tube.”

‘s not a tube, it’s an old pipe.” Carter responds.

Peter rolls his eyes. Grins a little. “Yeah, yeah. Get it done.”

Done,” comes Carter’s response a few seconds later.

“Good boy,” Peter says. “I need you to work with me, now. I need you to tell me your heart rate. Count from your carotid. I’ll tell you when to stop counting.”

They sit in silence for sixty seconds, Benton hoping that Carter has the mental acuity to keep count of his own pulse.

“Stop.” Peter says. “What’ve you got.”

One t-t-twenty… five,” Carter mumbles.

Peter’s heart sinks. It’s too high.

“And how are you feeling, Carter?” Benton asks calmly, the opposite of how he feels.

N-not s-so good,” is Carter’s reply. “I’m p-p-pretty cold, and it h-hurts..

The kid is fading. He’s starting to go into shock. Peter can tell.

Benton paces frantically. Tries to think of something to say, something to keep him awake and talking. To keep him from succumbing to shock. He comes up with nothing. “I know it does, Carter. I know. I need you to keep talking. Tell me something. Tell me something about you that I don’t know.”

I’m so tired.” Carter’s voice comes out a sigh.

“No, Carter! No sleeping. Keep talking, Carter! We’re so close, they’re coming for you right now!

W-where ‘m I?”

Benton’s heart sinks. “Carter. You’re being rescued. You’re going to be okay, but you need to stay awake.” He practically begs into the radio.

D-doct’r Ben’n?”

“Yeah, kid, it’s me.” Peter whispers helplessly.

I-I’m scared.”

“I know you are. I know. You’re going to be okay, I promise. I promise, alright? Just please stay awake.”

Mmmm.”

“Carter? Hey, Carter?”

No response. Peter begs. He begs into that radio repeatedly, shouts and soothes and begs and begs and begs. But there is no response. He watches as search and rescues guys in heavy gear move in and out of the building. The seconds stretch on into minutes. Two minutes turn in five, five into fifteen. Complete silence over the radio. Peter pictures Carter down in the rubble, trapped and alone and scared. Unconscious. Bleeding sluggishly out of a brutal wound of his own design, a fucking pipe sticking out of his chest cavity. What other injuries had he sustained that they didn’t know about yet? Was he bleeding from his brain? How many broken bones?

“Hey doc, doc!” Peter is shaken from his spiral by the sound of the fire chief again. He looks up at the man wearily. “We got your guy, they’re bringing him out now.”

Benton stares at him. “Is… is he alive?”

The man nods at him. “Yeah, they’ve got a pulse. They say he’s not looking too hot, but he’s alive. Come on, come with me.”

Benton gets up, following the man mechanically to the entrance that the search and rescue team had been using. Distantly, from inside, he hears voices and scuffling getting louder and louder.

And then the team of search and rescue is stepping out of the building, into the night, a stretcher carried between them. Carter.

The kid is coated with dust and grime and blood. A scalp laceration, lacs on the arm and on his legs. His hands are covered in his own blood. A bruise is forming along his jaw. His face- his face is completely ashen, his dry and cracked and blue-tinged lips parted slightly to reveal a sliver of teeth. His breaths a shallow, stuttered wheezes. His pale skin is sweaty and feverish looking.

Peter jogs to move along with the stretcher, hops in the ambulance as the paramedics lift Carter’s boneless form onto a gurney. Moves aside as they start IV lines, strap on an oxygen mask. As the ambulance starts to move, Peter squeezes in next to them. Grabs Carter’s limp, sweaty hand.

He gets a good look at the chest tube for the first time. God, the chest tube. The pipe is a thing of nightmares. It’s dirty and rusty and jagged at the end. It’s the worst-case scenario of medical equipment. Peter wants to rip it out, get it out of him, get all the contaminants and infectious microbes out of Carter’s system. But he can’t. The pipe is keeping Carter alive, staving off the build-up of pressure around Carter’s heart and lungs.

As they speed through the night, back towards County General, Peter can’t help thinking that the very thing keeping Carter alive in the moment might be the thing that’s going to kill him down the line.

Notes:

Parts 3 and 4 should be up within the next few days :)

Chapter 3: Asleep

Notes:

Just a warning that this chapter contains some pretty graphic and frankly gross descriptions of medical procedures and body… stuff. You’ve been warned!

Also, shoutout to Mandy on Twitter. If you’re reading this, I see you and I love your content! Please post more bearded Carter edits set to Sabrina Carpenter songs xxx

Chapter Text

When they arrive at the ER, Peter feels in a daze. Like in a fever dream, he is pulled into the trauma room, then ushered to the side to watch as Greene and Weaver and Ross pour over Carter. They yell for IV lines, for antibiotics, for oxygen, for vitals, for narcotics. He feels eyes looking upon him in horror when the ER staff first get a good look at the makeshift chest tube.

“He… did this himself?” Mark asks with a mix of wonder and disgust, looking over at Benton, aghast.

Peter can only nod stiffly. We had to, he wants to say. He was going to die otherwise. He was going to suffocate without it. He wants to justify what has been done – what he made Carter do. But under the harsh fluorescent lights of the ER, Benton gets a good look at the surgical site for the first time, purple and gurgling and inflamed, and at the disgusting pipe sticking out of it like an impalement. And the words do not come. It’s horrific and unprecedented and dangerous. The doctors aren’t saying it, but Benton knows they’re thinking it, because he is thinking it to. This thing is probably going to kill him.

And so Peter just watches. Watches as they strip Carter down, attaching tubes and wires and monitors to his unconscious, shuddering body. As, in a flurry of activity, they remove the pipe from Carter’s chest cavity, dropping it into a surgical tray and shoving it to the side. Benton flinches at the wet, sloppy gush of air that leeches out of the hole in Carter’s side along with the pipe. Benton watches, as if outside his own body, as Weaver and Ross frantically work to clean the wound, debriding it, scraping out chunks of brutalized skin and muscle tissue. Carter’s skin, Benton thinks, looking at the accumulation of gory mess. Carter’s muscle tissue.

“I can’t believe he did this himself,” one of the nurses whispers emotionally.

There is a pounding in Peter’s ears. The monitors start beeping more frantically. Carter isn’t getting enough oxygen. The pounding gets louder. All my fault, all my fault, all my fault. The doctors prepare to insert a new chest tube. Clean and sterile. All my fault all my fault all my fault.

Peter stumbles backwards, out of the doors of the trauma room. Lurches down the hall in a daze, losing time completely until he comes to in the men’s room, staring at himself in the mirror. In an instant, he is overcome by nausea. He whirls around, vomiting into the sink.

Mark finds him in the lounge, minutes later, still wearing a blood-splattered gown.

“Peter,” Mark says, gently but urgently. “He’s awake. He’s asking for you. He’s pretty agitated.”

Benton looks up and roughly clambers to his feet. Stumbles down the hallway, following Mark back into the trauma room.

Carter’s been fitted with a gown now. Benton watches as he clumsily and weakly fights against the gentle hands of the nurses. Lydia stands at the end of the table, by Carter’s head, whispering in his ear, stroking his hair.

“We need to get him up for a chest x-ray and head CT,” Mark tells Peter quietly before moving aside.

The daze Peter had been in since arriving at the ER fades away as the room comes into sharp focus. Carter is awake. He is scared. He is asking for Peter.

Benton approaches the side of the table, grabbing a chair to sit right beside Carter. He waves Lydia away. He cups the side of Carter’s dust-covered face, gently turning it towards him. Through glassy, half lidded eyes, Carter’s gaze fixes on Peter’s. He tries to say something, but it is muffled by the oxygen mask.

“Shhh,” Peter says. “Don’t try to talk.”

Carter shakes his head.

Somewhere, he hears Weaver’s voice. “We can’t wait much longer, we’ve got to get him up to radiology.”

“Hey. Carter. You’re at County General. You need a chest x-ray and a head CT.” Peter’s heart breaks at the fear in Carter’s eyes. “We’re going to give you some versed to help you relax, okay? Just for a little while.”

Carter shakes his head again, scared and confused. A tear leaks out his eye, leaving a wet trail through the dust.

“You did good, Carter. You did so good.”

Lydia appears on the other side of the table, quietly pushing the drugs through Carter’s IV port.

Tears continue to run down Carter’s face as the versed takes effect. Carter’s eyes glaze over, his body stills, and eyelids flutter closed.

Peter gets to his feet. “Okay. Take him up.”

For the first few hours, everything was good. Carter was transferred to the ICU, where he slept under the influence of an elaborate cocktail of narcotics. Peter sat with him, taking a wet towel and wiping the grime from his face, his arms, his hands. Carefully debriding the small lacerations on his forehead, his scalp, his arms, his legs.

The head CT confirmed Carter’s concussion, but no bleeding in the brain. Small mercies, for someone who had had an apartment building collapse on top of them.

The chest x-ray confirmed the tension pneumothorax and several broken ribs. Carter’s left diaphragm was depressed, and the mediastinum shifted significantly to the right. With the new chest tube in place, however, Carter’s lung had re-expanded, and his oxygen levels were slowly normalizing.

But Peter watches with dread over the next twenty-four hours as Carter’s temperature increases higher and higher. It sets in quickly, and by hour thirty, Carter is completely delirious with fever.

The first seizure occurs shortly after Carter’s temperature reaches 103, about thirty-eight hours after first arriving at the hospital. Peter yells for help as Carter’s back arches off the bed, his muscles locked and his heart rate skyrocketing. He begins to thrash uncontrollably, the pulse ox monitor slipping off his finger, causing the monitors to blare their sirens as nurses rush in, trying to hold Carter down, cradling his head to keep it from bashing against the bed rail. Peter is shoved to the back of the room in the chaos. The nurses are able to administer diazepman and eventually, Carter stills. The seizure lasts for two and half minutes. Benton has to leave the room after that. He strides out of the hospital, refusing eye contact with anyone who tries to intercept him. Circles the block several times before dragging himself back to Carter’s ICU bed, a moth to the flame.

Shortly after that, the drainage from Carter’s chest tube turns cloudy, indicating infection in the pleural cavity. Labs come back showing an abnormally high white blood cell count. Carter develops an altered mental status that no one can break through, moaning and crying and thrashing around in pain and confusion whenever the versed begins to wear off.

Four days into his stay in the ICU, Carter’s fever reaches dangerous levels, with a temperature of 105.2 and a heart rate exceeding 136. Benton is paged to the ICU amid Carter’s second seizure, which lasts over five minutes. This time, Peter is the one to cradle Carter’s head while he shakes and convulses.

The fluids and the antibiotics the doctors are giving Carter seem to have no effect. That night, as Peter works on charts at the table next to Carter’s bed, Carter’s O2 levels begin to decline.

From there, Carter deteriorates quickly. The chills wracking his body subside as his fever reaches 105.5, his body going completely limp. He no longer wakes up in fits of delirium. His colorless, gaunt skin goes clammy and somehow even paler. Even with the oxygen mask, breath sounds grow weaker and weaker. When the pulse ox monitor falls to 86, the doctors announce that they have no choice but to intubate.

Benton watches with Mark in the corner as the ICU team places Carter under deep sedation, watches as a doctor methodically slides a laryngoscope down Carter’s throat, quickly followed by an ET tube.  A piece of tape is placed over the end of the tube, loosely securing it to the side of Carter’s face. Carter’s face is so sweaty that the edges of the tape immediately curl up. The vent is hooked up. The oxygen reading slowly creeps up to 90.

The doctors in the ICU treat Carter with an endless course of saline and fluids, of antibiotics and antihistamines. There is very little effect. A few hours later, Carter’s blood pressure bottoms out. In a quiet, solemn conversation with Benton, Greene, and Weaver, the ICU doctor confirms what they had all feared: the infection in Carter’s chest cavity had spread into his bloodstream. He was going into sepsis, and the prognosis was not good.

Peter leaves without a word. He walks out of the hospital, heart pounding and ears ringing. He mechanically gets into and starts his car. Numbly, he drives and drives and drives until he finds himself pulled over in a mostly empty grocery store parking lot. And there, for the first time since the incident, for the first time in years, really, Peter lets himself cry. Let’s himself cry for John Carter – his John Carter, his student, who was almost certainly going to die. His body shakes with sobs as he lets the events of the last few days wash over him.

The horrible sounds of the building collapsing. Choking on the dust filling the air. Looking around, trying to locate Carter. Not seeing him anywhere. The panic that had slowly consumed him as he screamed into the radio desperately. Imagined Carter’s crushed body underneath slabs of concrete – the image of it flashing through his mind in between memories of Dennis Gant’s pulverized face. The relief when Carter finally answered the radio. The horror when he spoke the words “tension pneumo”.

And now… an infection to the bloodstream. Sepsis.

Peter imagined the future. The next few days. Sitting at Carter’s bedside as his kidneys, liver, and heart began to fail. Fever cooking Carter’s brain, causing irreversible brain damage. Blood pressure falling. V-fib. Charge the paddles. Clear. Clear. Clear. Can’t get a rhythm. Time of death.

It’s midnight by the time Peter drags himself back to the hospital, dreading whatever fresh horrors await in the ICU.

Approaching the room, he finds the ICU doctor in deep conversation with Greene and Hicks. Their expressions are solemn. Peter approaches, a little hesitant, but Mark immediately makes room for him in the huddle.

“Peter. We were just discussing Doctor Carter’s options. We think that surgery is going to be the best chance we have to get the infection under control.” Hicks says.

“Surgery.” Peter repeats blankly.

“We did another chest x-ray,” Mark says quietly. “His chest cavity is filled with infected pus. Severe empyema. We’ve started a course of broad spectrum antibiotics, but it’s not going to be enough.”

“We want to do an open thoracotomy with a full washout,” Hicks says. “We need to remove the infected fluid and necrotic tissue by hand. It’s the best chance he has.” She finishes seriously.

The gears in Benton’s brain are turning. “Surgery,” he says again. “Okay. When do we scrub in.”

Hicks raises her eyebrows. “I will be scrubbing in, Peter. Mr. Carter is my resident, not yours. He is my responsibility.”

Peter stares at her. Mark coughs awkwardly. Not yours. His ears ring. He can hardly comprehend what Hicks is saying. Like hell Carter isn’t his resident. Like hell is he going through this surgery without Benton.

“You can’t be serious,” Benton says quietly. Dangerously.

“Peter,” Hicks sighs. “You’re too close to this. I can’t allow you to operate.”

Peter’s eyes narrow. “And you aren’t? You just said Carter is your resident and your responsibility. How is that not too close? This is ridiculous. You can’t keep me out of that OR.”

“…Peter…” Mark says gently, laying a hand on Benton’s shoulder.

No,” Peter snaps, shaking Mark off. “Carter is my student. He’s mine. You’re going to have to have security haul me out of the building if you want to cut without me. I swear to god, Angela, I will raise hell-”

“JESUS, Peter!” Hicks calls out, hands raised, expression severe. “Need I remind you that I am your superior and you have absolutely no authority to be making threats like this,” she pauses, eyes narrowed. “However. I understand that this is a very… upsetting situation. Therefore. I will allow you to scrub in. But you are only there to observe. You will not be cutting, you will not be laying a finger on Doctor Carter. If you even try to involve yourself in this surgery, I will have you out of that OR faster than you can blink.” Benton and Hicks stare each other down, Hicks’s eyes glinting dangerously and Peter’s chest heaving. Hicks doesn’t blink. “Do we have an understanding, Doctor Benton.”

Peter glares at her, but recognizes that she is not going to be swayed. “…fine.” He finally agrees, angrily.

“Good,” Hicks says, clapping her hands. “Meet me upstairs in ten minutes, we’re scrubbing in. Let’s see what we can do to save our Doctor Carter.”


Peter hovers behind Hicks as she makes the first incision.

Carter is positioned on his right side, exposing the infected left side of his chest. The vent covering half of his face whooshes rhythmically as the surgeons speak in quiet, serious voices.

Hicks slices long and deep along the mid-axillary line, cutting deep, all the way between the ribs.

“Rib spreader.” She commands, then methodically uses the retractor to widen the space between Carter’s fifth and sixth ribs.

As Hicks enters the pleural space, Peter nearly gags. A foul, rotten smell hits the air as viscous, yellow-green fluid spills out of the chest cavity, confirming the empyema. Benton’s heart pangs. It’s like a body horror movie, but… it’s Carter. Carter’s weak, sick body that is futilely wearing itself out, trying to fight a massive, gruesome infection. An infection that Peter was the architect of.

Peter swallows thickly, remembering the clatter of the broken pipe in the surgical tray when they took it out in the trauma room. Covered in dirt and rust and diseases that now course through Carter’s veins. It was Peter’s fault. He told Carter to pick up that pipe and shove it through his ribs and into his chest cavity. Oh god. Oh god.

“Suction.”

Angling the tip of the tube into the chest cavity, Hicks begins to suck copious amounts of yellowish pus out of Carter’s body. She is then handed forceps, which she uses to scoop out addition pus and fibrin. Peter is a surgeon, and he has seen some horrific things in his time, but this… this is the worst infection Benton has ever seen treated in an OR. He just can’t believe it’s Carter’s.

This goes on for nearly an hour, the evacuation of pus from Carter’ s chest cavity, filling up literal buckets of noxious fluid.

Finally, Hicks calls for irrigation. She begins to wash out the chest cavity with warm saline, again and again, until the clumps of pus disappear and the fluid runs clear. With a knife, Hicks scrapes out entire chunks of dead, necrotic tissue.

“Looks like we got everything,” Hicks declares, satisfied, after two hours in the OR. “The lung is expanding against the chest wall again.” A couple of nurses move around the table to collect the many, many containers of disgusting, infectious fluid removed from Carter’s body, taking it away to bio-waste disposal.

Peter lets out a shuttered breath.

“I’m going to put in another chest tube,” Hicks then says, turning to Benton. “I think it will be beneficial to Doctor Carter to have anterior and posterior evacuation of the chest cavity. This is one of the more serious cases of empyema I’ve encountered in my career.”

Peter just nods stiffly, his eyes fixed on Carter’s lax, ashen face.

When, at long last, Hicks finishes up, she asks him quietly, “Peter, would you like to close?”

He blinks at her. Clears his throat. “Yeah. Yeah, sure.” His voice cracks a little from… disuse. That is the only reason.

Hicks steps aside and Benton approaches Carter’s side, two large chest tubes emerging from the chest cavity. Peter takes a deep breath, grabbing the needles and thread from nurse. Tries to focus. Tries to forget that it is Carter under the knife. Carefully and methodically, Benton lets the world fall away as he begins to suture the boy back together, layer by layer, closing membranes, then muscle tissue, then skin.


After surgery, they keep Carter under heavy sedation, the ventilator still doing the work of Carter’s lungs. They continue to pump antibiotics through his system. His fever stays steady at 104.1 degrees. A day goes by. They monitor the chest tube outputs for blood and pus. Labs are ordered regularly, nurses coming in to take Carter’s blood every few hours, monitoring for blood cell counts, lactate, and cultures.

And miraculously, the sepsis does not worsen. His blood pressure remains low, however, and his O2 levels unstable. Comatose.

Peter sits unmoving, a constant presence at Carter’s bedside, wracked by guilt and regrets and what ifs.

Then, two days post-op, Peter watches in disbelief as Carter’s fever begins to decline. Slowly at first, dropping to 103.8, then 103.1. But by day three post-surgery, it falls to 102.1.

“This is a very good sign, Peter,” Kerry tells him one day, looking over Carter’s chart. “Look! His O2 levels are improving, His BPM is trending towards 90. This is…. This is great.”

Benton nods stiffly. Convinced for days that Carter was as good as dead, he was struggling to adjust to this new, unexpected reality. Couldn’t quite let himself believe it. He says as much to Weaver.

Her gaze softens. “He is alive because of you, Peter. He would have aspirated underneath that building if you hadn’t intervened. The only reason we are having a conversation about his recovery at all is because of you.”

Peter shrugs, kicking his feet absently. “He saved himself,” he mutters. “I could never have done what he did down there.”

Weaver laughs softly. “Don’t I know. I can’t imagine… I can’t imagine any doctor I know cutting into their own chest cavity and inserting an improvised chest tube. I’ll tell you Peter, I didn’t believe it when they first told me. But by god, when they brought him into the trauma room, there it was. Remarkable. An intern did that. It’s… astonishing. You did that, Peter. You taught him, and you walked him through it. You helped him save himself. I was the one who took that pipe out, and I saw the condition of the pneumothorax. I can tell you that he would have been dead for sure without it.”

Peter sighs. “Yeah. I suppose.”

He knows this true, to some extent. Without the chest tube, Carter one hundred percent would have died from the tension pneumothorax before search and rescue got to him. Without a doubt. Peter had done the math, run the scenario a hundred different ways in his head.

But the success of the procedure… it wasn’t because of Peter’s teaching skills or ingenuity or quick thinking or whatever Mark and Kerry and Doug had tried to tell him. It was dumb luck, and Peter had been reckless as hell. Reckless with Carter’s life. It was a fucking miracle Carter had managed to cut all the way through the pleural space. That he hadn’t passed out from the pain, bleeding out and asphyxiating. That he hadn’t jammed the pipe right into his lung, hadn’t died choking on his own blood.

And now… it looked like Carter might get better. That the sepsis hadn’t put him into to complete organ failure. That they could start weaning him off the vent, even. Reduce his sedation. The hope felt dangerous, like a trick.

And so, for the most part, Peter just said nothing. Couldn’t speak the hope out loud. He just sits by Carter’s bedside and waits.

Chapter 4: Awake

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

John Carter is floating on a raft somewhere off a beach in the eastern Caribbean. He dozes as the gentle waves rock him side to side, the tropical sun beating down on his face. Warm water lapping up his arms, his legs. He’s never been more relaxed, more at peace, in his entire life.

He knows that he has responsibilities at home – Gamma needs him to commit to a charity event in November, he’ll be starting his surgical sub-internship soon – but for now, John is content to laze away the day, nothing but pink sand and turquoise waters and drinks with tiny umbrellas.

He sighs contently, stretching just a little. His throat kind of hurts – he probably hasn’t drunk enough water the last few hours at sea. It doesn’t matter, he thinks. As far as he is concerned, he could stay here, bobbing on the water, forever.

Something squeezes John’s hand, which is confusing. He’s alone out here, the last time he checked. He decides to open his eyes, to take a look around, but god, his eyelids are heavy. That’s not quite right, either. John frowns. He wants to sit up, to figure out what’s going on, but there’s a pressure on his shoulders, something holding him down.

John is a little scared now. He can’t open his eyes, and everything is really dark. He can’t hear the waves anymore, and he’s kind of cold. The water in the Caribbean isn’t supposed to be cold this time of year. John whimpers, just a little bit. Something isn’t right. This isn’t right.

A gentle weight falls onto his forehead. Someone his stroking his hair away from his face. It feels nice, and John leans into the touch. He wants to ask who this person is, why are they here? But when John opens his mouth to speak, the words are garbled. They don’t come out right. Panic begins to set in, John feels his heart beating fast. He hears a car alarm in the distance. This confuses John even more. There aren’t supposed to be car alarms at the Club Med in St. Barts.

He wants to say this, to explain his confusion, but again, the words don’t come. His tongue feels heavy, his mouth is dry.

John doesn’t want to be here anymore. This is scary. He’s ready to go home. He wants to go home now.

The hand on his forehead is gently rubbing circles into his temple. It feels so nice. Maybe this person can help him. Is it his mom? His mom has never comforted him like this before, but it seems like something a parent would do.

Finally, John finds the words. “M-m-m-om?” he whispers. His voice doesn’t sound right. It sounds very, very far away, like at the far end of a tunnel. That’s pretty scary too. The hand on his head disappears. John doesn’t like that at all. He tries opening his eyes again, but it’s just so hard. His whole body feels very, very heavy. Maybe someone drugged him, he thinks. Maybe they stole his car, and then they drugged him, and that’s why so many car alarms are going off.

“Mom, w-why a-are there cars at… a-at Club Med?” John whimpers.

John feels someone take his hand. That’s also something his mom has never done. It’s all so confusing. John wishes someone would just tell him what was going on.

John tries to focus. He tries to listen for clues. It’s pretty hard to hear over the car alarms, which have only gotten louder. But then John thinks that he might hear voices. He squirms a little, trying to get closer, but that kind of hurts and his limbs are too heavy.

Suddenly, though, one voice breaks through. It’s right in his ear, sending shivers up his spine. “Hey. Carter. You’re okay. Open your eyes. You’re okay, just open your eyes.”

The voice is familiar, but John can’t quite place it. Something about it instinctively makes him relax, though. He trusts it when it says that John is okay. He wants to please the voice, too – to do what it says. But he’s been trying to open his eyes, and it’s just so hard. John feels himself getting upset. He feels a tear leak out through his eyelid.

Open up, Carter. I know you can hear me.”

John is really tired. He wants to go back to sleep. This is too hard. He hopes he wakes up in bed at the resort. He tries to drift away, into the unknown, when something snaps against his temple. “Owwwwcch,” John whines. Why would someone do that? He’s only trying to sleep!

No sleeping yet, Carter. I want to see your eyes. I want to talk to you. Then you can go back to sleep.” The voice says sharply. It sounds a little angry, and that stresses John out a little bit. He better open his eyes so that the voice doesn’t get any madder.

John focuses. He focuses like he did doing the jumping event at the regional invitational with Marigold back in ’84. With herculean effort, John wrenches his eyes open.

Oh god, everything was so bright. Everything was blurry. The car alarms were so loud. A brown blob swims through his vision. The hand is back on his forehead. It’s the brown blob’s hand, John puts together.

Does he know this brown blob? Something in the back of his mind is telling him he knows this brown blob.

John tries blinking a lot, trying to clear his vision. Slowly, the blurry edges around the blob sharpen. Recognition dawns on Carter.

“Huh,” he says, perplexed, his mouth feeling like it’s full of cotton. “Doctor Benton? What… what are you doing in St. Bart’s?”

Peter Benton looks at him like he’s stupid. “You’re in the hospital, Carter. You’re at County General.”

John frowns. “No. No, I’m in St. Barts.”

“No, you’re not, Carter. You were hurt. You’re in the ICU.”

“ICU?”

“Yeah, man.”

John sighs. That doesn’t seem right. He feels fine, mostly, although it’s really hard to move and he still kind of feels floaty, like he’s on a boat. It hurts to think about it too hard, though, and he doesn’t know why Doctor Benton would lie to him. His eyelids are still really heavy. He kind of wants to close them again, but Doctor Benton is looking at him reeeeeaally intently, and it makes Carter a little nervous.

“I’m tired. I want water.” John announces, to gage Doctor Benton’s reaction.

Doctor Benton sighs. “I know you are. I’ll get you some ice chips in a minute. I just want to do a quick neuro check. Can you tell me your full name?”

A neuro check! This is good news. John can ace this, make Benton happy.

“John Truman Carter the Third,” he says confidently.

John thinks he sees Benton smirk a little. “Are you laughing at me?”

Benton doesn’t respond. “Who is the president?”

“Bill Clinton,” John answers. “Am I on drugs?”

“Yeah, Carter. You’re on drugs. You need them for the pain. You were hurt pretty bad, but you’re going to be okay now.”

Hmm. That was certainly interesting information. It helps to know about the drugs, though. It explains why John is feeling kind of silly and woozy.

“What’s seven plus fourteen?”

“Uhh, twenty one.”

“Spell world for me.”

“W-O-R-L-D.”

To John’s shock, Benton gives him a wide smile. He is practically beaming. He tousles John’s hair. Is John having a stroke?

“No, Carter, you’re not having a stroke,” Benton says, rolling his eyes. Huh. Guess I said that out loud. “You just passed your neurological exam with flying colors. I told Hicks that that fever didn’t cook your brain. I knew it.”

John stares at him. “Huh?”

“Doesn’t matter, you’re not going to remember any of this later.”

That’s rude, John thinks.

Benton smiles, fooling around with something above John’s head. He tries to sit up, to see, but Benton’s hand shoots out out of nowhere, pressing John back down. “Don’t try to sit up yet, man,” Benton says, his voice suddenly sharp and serious. “You’ll hurt yourself if you do that.”

John frowns. He yawns. “Can I go to sleep now?”

“Yeah, Carter. Go back to sleep.”

John smiles vaguely, his eyes sliding closed. He’ll be okay – Benton is here.

He imagines himself floating on the warm Caribbean waters as he drifts off.


John Carter wakes up in a dark room. He’s in the hospital – he knows this because of the tell-tale sound of a heart monitor next to his bed. He feels like shit.

His body feels like it’s made out of lead, but every muscle in his body feels like its on fire, trying to break itself out of skin containment. God, his entire upper body felt like it had gone through a meat grinder. His chest, his lungs, his throat – they felt awful.

Carter frowns, blinking and trying to get a sense of his surroundings. Faintly, he wonders if he’d been intubated at some point. All his symptoms would suggest so. Jesus, Carter thinks.

“Hey Carter.”

Carter startles a little. He’d thought he was alone. There’s a dark shape in the corner of the room. Benton.

“Hey, Doctor Benton,” Carter says hoarsely, a little weary. A little scared. His voice cracks a little, and he winces.

“You thirsty?”

“Little bit.”

John watches as Benton stands up and walks closer. Outside of John’s line of sight, Benton rummages around. Reappears with a tray of ice chips.

“Just ice for now,” Benton says quietly. “Don’t try to sit up, ok?”

Carter nods. Benton holds out an ice chip in a pair of tongs. Blushing a little, John opens his mouth. The ice chip melts on his tongue, easing the dry scratchiness of John’s throat. Carter sighs in relief.

“Do you know where you are? Do you know why you’re here?” Benton asks.

“I’m… I’m at County, right?”

Benton nods.

Then Carter thinks. Trying to remember. Rank air. The taste of blood in his mouth. Dust on his tongue. The pain in his chest.

“Building collapse,” Carter says out loud, as it all comes back to him.

He scrunches his eyebrows together. “I’m… alive?”

Benton huffs. “Yeah, man. You made it.”

“Huh,” say John, thinking about it. He really thought he was going to die. He remembers thinking that, as he was losing consciousness and writhing around on the floor of that basement, a piece of pipe sticking out of his chest.

A piece of pipe sticking out of his chest.

Panicked, John clumsily pushes back the blanket that is covering his chest, frantically trying to get a look at his left side.

One, two chest tubes are sticking out of him.

“Oh, Jesus,” John says, for lack of better words. That would explain why his left side was killing him.

He looks up at Benton. His (former?) teacher looks really tired, John sees now.

“We’ll be able to take those out soon, we think,” Benton says. “Try not to move a lot, you don’t want to disturb them. They’re keeping infection out of your chest cavity.”

John is quiet for a minute, trying to process everything.

“I can’t believe I’m not dead,” he says honestly.

Benton… winces?

“It was really close, man. But we think you’re going to make a full recovery. I wouldn’t tell you that if I didn’t think it was true. Your neuro exam is good, all your reflexes are working. You’re still running a fever of 101, but it’s been gradually going down for a couple days now. Your labs are coming back clear. Your BP is great, all things considered. It’s…” Benton trails off. Carter watches his face carefully, the weariness of it. “I don’t believe in miracles, man. But this… this is pretty close.”

John swallows. The look on Benton’s face is one he does not recognize. There’s something far away about his eyes. Something old. John doesn’t know what to say. He wants to know what happened to him, how he was rescued. How he was saved. But something about the look on Benton’s face makes him afraid to ask.

“Everything hurts,” John says finally. Not to complain, really. Although his body is truly screaming at him. He just thinks Benton might want to know.

Peter looks down at him. Collapses into a chair next to John’s bed.

“Yeah, I know it does. I’m sorry. We needed to wake you up all of the way, to evaluate you for mental clarity. Had to majorly cut back on the morphine. You’ve been in and out for the last twelve hours or so, but you were too high to have a proper conversation with. You won’t remember any of that.”

John frowns a little. “I say anything interesting?” The edges of his lips quirk a little.

Benton rolls his eyes. “Something about cars and Club Med? It was mostly nonsense.”

“Hmm,” is all John can think of to say. He’s starting to wonder, now. To wonder why Benton is here. Why, it seems, he’s been here for a while now.

“We can up the morphine again,” Benton says. “It’ll make you fall asleep, though.”

“No,” Carter says, a little too quickly perhaps. Benton’s eyebrows twitch.

“I… I want to know what happened. After I passed out. Everything. How long it’s been.”

Benton closes his eyes. Lets out a long, tired breath. “You were unconscious when search and rescue got to you,” Benton begins. His voice is unemotional. Mechanical. “By the time we got you to the ER, your vitals were a mess. We were able to stabilize you, get you up to the ICU. You developed a really bad infection in your chest cavity. You had a fever of 106 at one point. Multiple seizures. The infection turned septic. We had to take you to the OR, open you up. Thoracic washout surgery. It worked. You got better. No long-term damage.” Benton pauses. “You’ve been here, in a coma, for the last week and a half.”

John swallows, trying to process. Sepsis. Thoracic surgery. Seizures. Coma.

“Jesus.” Is all he can think of to say.

“Yeah.” Benton says quietly.

Carter starts feeling confused again. “But I’m going to be okay?” he asks, brow furrowed.

“Yeah,” Benton repeats. “You’re going to be fine. Another week or two of recovery, but then you should be back to normal.”

“Huh.” All Carter can think of to say.

Benton looks at him. “What.”

“I just… I don’t understand, I guess.”

“What don’t you understand, Carter.”

“I just… If I’m going to be fine, like you say, I guess I don’t understand why you’re still here.”

Silence settles over the room. Carter avoids Benton’s eyes. But as the silence stretches on, he can’t help glancing over. Benton looks stricken.

“Do you… do you want me to leave?” Benton asks finally. His voice is strangled. This just confuses Carter even more.

“What? No. I mean, it’s fine. It’s good that you’re here. I’m glad you’re here. I just…” Carter trails off, thinking about the last couple of months. Dennis’s death. Benton’s withdrawal. His complete disinterest in Carter. The complete lack of reaction when Carter switched to Hicks’s team.  Since when did I start caring about what you do, Carter. The words that had been echoing around in John’s brain for weeks now. It just… none of it made sense to Carter. There had to be some reason why Benton was sitting here at his bedside. Something had to be medically wrong to warrant him doing that. “I just don’t understand why, you know,” he finishes, a little sheepish.

“You don’t understand why I’m here?”

“Yeah,” Carter mumbles, kneading at the blanket, staring directly to the left of Benton’s head.

Benton sighs. Buries his head in his hands. A minute goes by. Then two.

“Carter, Jesus. I’m here because I care about you. I thought you were going to die. That it was going to be my fault. That I’d essentially killed you. I’m here because I wanted to make sure that you were okay. That you didn’t wake up alone.”

“You what?” Carter says, astounded. Mind reeling. That can’t be right. Was Carter actively dying? Was Benton being nice to him because Carter was actively dying??

Benton glares at him through his fingers. “Big whoop, Carter. You know my secret. I care. I’ve cared this whole time.”

Carter blinks. “But… you said that you didn’t care what I did. You’ve been ignoring me for weeks. I thought… I thought you hated me.” He hates that his voice cracks. Hates how weak he feels, how infantile his words sound.

Benton groans. Sighs. Is quiet for a while. “Do you remember what I told you, before? When I was trying to talk you through the chest tube?”

Carter closes his eyes. Lets the horrific memory wash over him. The terror and the pain. And something warmer. Benton’s words.

What do you need me to say to get you to do this? That you’re the best medical student I’ve ever had? Because you are. That I messed up letting you switch to Hicks’s service? Because I did. Happy? And if anyone can do this, it’s you.

Something prickles behind John’s eyes.

“You weren’t… you weren’t just saying that? To get me to do the chest tube?” He hates how hopeful he sounds. How hopeful he feels.

“Of course I meant it,” Benton says quietly. “I meant every word. I never should have let you switch to Hicks’s team. I was… I was angry. Not at you. At myself. And I… I took it out on you. I let your education suffer. And when you told me you were switching teams… I genuinely thought that it was for the best. But I was wrong. I was wrong, Carter. You are the best student I’ve ever had. And I know… I know I don’t have a very good way of showing it. And don’t expect me to ever say it again. But it’s true. And then… then that building collapsed, and I thought you were dead. And then when I made you stick a fucking pipe into your chest cavity, and the infection nearly killed you. And that would have been my fault. And so I’m telling you this one time, okay? I’m here because I care. I’ve always fucking cared.”

John swallows, trying desperately not to cry. Trying not to show that Benton’s praise was all he had really cared about these last two years. That there was no one else in his life whose approval he cared about more. Everything was so overwhelming. It didn’t help that John’s heart monitor was audibly beeping faster.

He tries to take a deep, calming breath, but that just ends up hurting him more than it helps. He tries to grasp for words, something to say to Benton to express how he feels, but his brain is a muddled mess of drugs and hormones and exhaustion.

“Does that mean…” Carter says finally, his voice wobbly and hesitant. “Does that mean… I can come back to your service? If I want to?”

Benton’s head shoots up, his eyes widening ever so slightly. He stares at Carter, as if in disbelief, as if waiting for John to yell psych!

Carter doesn’t though, and for a moment the two of them just stare at each other. Finally, Benton laughs softly. “Yeah, man. Of course you can come back, if you want.”

“I want to,” Carter says quickly, then flushes a little bit. He wants to look at Benton properly, now. Not from this tilted perspective, flat on a bed. Without thinking, he tries to sit up.

Fireworks explode behind John’s eyes as pain erupts from his left side.

Fucking-shit-fuck-OW!” John cries out, moving his hands to grasp at his flaming side.

And suddenly Benton is there, right in his face, hands pulling John’s away.

“Stop that,” Peter says sharply. “Don’t touch, don’t move. Let me look.”

Peter pulls down John’s blanket to reveal the chest tubes once again. Gently, Peter prods along John’s ribs, then carefully presses around the thoracostomy sites. “I know, I know,” Peter says softly as John lets out a hiss of pain.

He pulls back, satisfied. “Looks like you didn’t shift the chest tubes in any significant way. That was dumb, Carter. I told you not to sit up.”

“I forgot.” John mutter grumpily. “Hurts.”

“I’ll push some more morphine. You need to rest. You’ve still got a fever.”

Carter is tempted to resist, but in that moment, he feels every throbbing pain in his body. The muscle cramping that is certainly a legacy of his seizures. The fever-induced headache. The aching in his lungs and in his throat. The burning and discomfort of two chest tubes sticking out of his side.

And so he sighs and nods.

Benton grabs a syringe from somewhere outside John’s field of vision. Carter watches as he depresses it into his IV port. He sighs as a rush of cool ice flows through his veins. The edges of the world soften.

“I might not be here the next time you wake up,” Benton warns, standing over John with his arms crossed.

Carter just nods.

“But, um. I’ll see you at work.”

Carter grins as he feels himself being pulled into sleep. “See you at work, boss.”

Notes:

Thanks for reading, I really put Carter through the horrors in this one haha. Most fun I ever had!