Comment on Hogwarts' Youngest Headmaster

  1. DJ_Mystic on Chapter 2 Wed 08 Sep 2021 08:38PM UTC

    False. It has been stated that first years aren't allowed to own a broom OR play Quidditch. Exceptions are made if said first year displays remarkable talent.

    Comment Actions

    1. RemusJLupin32 on Chapter 2 Sat 11 Sep 2021 08:26AM UTC

      Where did you get that info from cause HP6 contradicts what you state

      Comment Actions

      1. orphan_account on Chapter 2 Sat 11 Sep 2021 09:30AM UTC

        AO3 logo with text "orphan account"

        Which info are you referring to? And if I couldn't remember then I probably made it up idk

        Comment Actions

        1. RemusJLupin32 on Chapter 2 Sun 12 Sep 2021 12:11AM UTC

          The first years can't play Quidtch there were first years that turned up to Harry try outs in book 6 the rule bending was the broom not Harry being a 1st year

          Comment Actions

          1. orphan_account on Chapter 2 Sun 12 Sep 2021 07:42AM UTC

            AO3 logo with text "orphan account"

            Ah right, well if I'm honest with you I wrote this months ago and have mostly forgotten when I've written. However when I eventually read through this again, I'll have a look and probably correct it. Thanks for pointing it out :)

            Comment Actions

      3. DJ_Mystic on Chapter 2 Sun 17 Oct 2021 06:22AM UTC

        Ok, looking back, it was the PlayStation adaptation of the Philosopher's/Sorcerer's Stone where I heard that, so admittedly not the best source. It doesn't help that McGonagall's line from the first book "I shall speak to Professor Dumbledore and see if we can’t bend the first-year rule." could easily be taken that way.

        Comment Actions

        1. RemusJLupin32 on Chapter 2 Sun 17 Oct 2021 09:31PM UTC

          No problem I have both the US & UK vers of book 1 the funny part in the game is the chocolate frog cards by the dates Gillyweed's use was discovered before Gillyweed was even discovered but that was from the GameCube vers of Chamber of Secrets

          Comment Actions

          1. DJ_Mystic on Chapter 2 Sat 06 Nov 2021 09:40PM UTC

            Yeah, I saw a chocolate frog card in the Philosopher's Stone game that gave a witch's date of death as 1997, even though Philosopher's Stone takes place in 1991.

            Comment Actions

    3. RemusJLupin32 on Chapter 2 Sun 12 Sep 2021 01:00PM UTC

      Wrong there were 1st years at at Harry's tryouts in Harry Potter 6

      Comment Actions