Comment on Of Kings and Bastards

  1. TheDarkRanger1160 on Chapter 1 Fri 24 Jun 2022 02:42PM UTC

    Who is Jon's biological father in this? I want the spoiler.

    Comment Actions

    1. Aegon_the_Dragon on Chapter 1 Fri 24 Jun 2022 03:51PM UTC

      No problem. :-) Rhaegar is Jon's biological father.

      Comment Actions

      1. Turtel98 on Chapter 1 Mon 27 Mar 2023 08:27AM UTC

        FUCK!!!!! This lost me, but I am willing to continue if you spoil me and said that Robert isn’t a womanizer who mistreat everyone please

        Comment Actions

        1. Aegon_the_Dragon on Chapter 1 Mon 27 Mar 2023 01:58PM UTC

          >FUCK!!!!! This lost me...
          Seriously? Was that really a surprise? Whose son was Jon supposed to be then?! :-D

          >...Robert isn't a womanizer who mistreats everyone please
          Well, he's definitely not a good husband. To write him entirely different than in the books, as devoted and faithful and a complete teetotaler, I would have found wrong. Then it would not have been Robert any more. If your question is whether he mistreats Lyanna (in the sense of beating her, for example), then no.

          Comment Actions

          1. Turtel98 on Chapter 1 Tue 28 Mar 2023 06:32AM UTC

            That’s the point, in the books Jon only canos father was Ned Stark, in the fanfics if you are going to change Ned for anyone else it also could be Robert’s son, as Robert is part targaryen by his grand mother’s side, he would name Jon after Jon Aryn and he wasn’t a bad lord/person but the war, lost of family and friends, the trone and people of the curt didn’t help him, Ned stark confirm that in the books as he doesn’t recognize his old friend anymore
            Put thank you for read my comment, maybe in the future I’ll give it a try

            Comment Actions

            1. Aegon_the_Dragon on Chapter 1 Tue 28 Mar 2023 05:55PM UTC

              Well, Ned was Jon's father figure in the books, but ( with a probability bordering on certainty) not his biological father. That was probably Rhaegar, just like in my story. So, at least biologically, "my Jon" is the same as "book Jon." However, if I had given him a different biological father, then he would indeed no longer be Jon, but just an OC character.
              But I guess that's a matter of interpretation as to when someone is still the same person, who - DNA aside - is someone's father, etc. :-)

              >Put thank you for read my comment, maybe in the future I’ll give it a try
              You're welcome. Give it a try if you feel like it. :-)

              Comment Actions