Comment on Child of Fate

  1. Observer47 (Guest) on Chapter 2 Sat 14 Sep 2024 08:38PM UTC

    Who or what was Umberlee fighting with exactly. Also while Astarion promised not to kill Catelyn, he didn't promise about ruining her reptation and her relation with her family. He could probably trick her into confessing her attempts to kill Jon with her family listening, along with other witnesses.

    Comment Actions

    1. Beylerbey on Chapter 2 Sat 14 Sep 2024 11:05PM UTC

      You'll find out.
      And about Catelyn... When the fuck did she attempted to kill Jon?! I knew she begged for his death but not that!

      Comment Actions

      1. Observer47 (Guest) on Chapter 2 Tue 24 Sep 2024 02:39AM UTC

        Sorry, about that. I am not well adapt to the story or even what really goes on in the books, so I just assumed you had something like that since it is common with the Catelyn bashing tags. I do apologize for that.

        Comment Actions

    3. Ibjaxx on Chapter 2 Fri 14 Mar 2025 01:33PM UTC

      Her praying for his death is also show only. She never did it in the books and overall she wasn't even that horrible to Jon. She didn't verbally or physically abuse him. She was just distant and cold towards him.

      Most of the abuse she committed against Jon is from fanon, some example being, Catelyn being angry at Jon for being a better swordsman than Robb and thus Jon has to pretend he's a worse swordsman than Robb. Catelyn andthe Septa threatening Jon. Catelyn being physically abusive.

      Comment Actions

      1. Beylerbey on Chapter 2 Fri 14 Mar 2025 03:56PM UTC

        There's also that time she told him he should have fall instead of Bran, but I get your point. About the show part, I'm doing a mix between show and book, so if you see something wrong it's probably for that. I don't know if I said it before but there will be some changes in the fic both in asoiaf/got and bg3 wolrds

        Comment Actions