Comment on A Mother

  1. Cherokeeaiman19 on Chapter 2 Thu 17 Apr 2025 01:42PM UTC

    I have a reason for the Sept that will be shown later on, also I was tired I was writing this at 4 am. not meant as a catelyn bashing that was my mistake so I fixed that, also this is a fic if you don't like it don't read it, it's only the second chapter she's going to jump to conclusions first. If you guys have any ideas on how you want it to go your welcome to comment about it or something you would like to happen im willing to hear it out.

    Last Edited Thu 17 Apr 2025 01:47PM UTC

    Comment Actions

    1. Joan_of_Arc on Chapter 2 Thu 17 Apr 2025 03:38PM UTC

      I'm sorry!! I read that segment again and the yelling is gone. Thanks.

      I guess I'm just tired of the old cliche "Catelyn didn't worship her husband's bastard so she's evil and stupid. South is bad, North is good. Blah", and so in order to make this point true authors invent bad things Catelyn never did (and never would do).... I did the same thing I criticized your Lyanna for: judged with my first impression and did not wait to see more. I'm really sorry! I apologise!!

      I guess I wished that, for once, we could have Lyanna appreciate the fact that her brother's wife carried the weight of her own doing and was actually quite decent to a child she had every reason to hate.

      So this is your first story? It's quite good! I'll be looking forward to your next chapter.
      And again, I apologise for my snap judgement.

      Thanks

      Comment Actions