Comment on Lauren Faust, Queen of Equestria - The Return of the Queen

  1. CathU500 on Chapter 9 Tue 17 Jun 2025 11:51PM UTC

    Oh good God, counting all the Canon alicorns (5), Lauren, her husband, her daughter, the other main six, and shining armor possibly, that would be like 13 alicorns
    And that's not counting any possible extra children they have (probably at least one or two which would bump it up to 15), or twilight's student from the future episode that may eventually exist here (That could bump it up to 16)
    Or if cadence is shining armor have a second child, That could be the 17th alcorn, or who knows the baby could be born a Pegasus or unicorn.
    Or oh my God pinkie pie's son with cheese sandwich-
    Would he be an alicorn?! Or would he stay a earth pony like his father?
    If he's an Alicorn as well that would be 18, oh God it's getting so close to 20 alicorns- And again that's not counting possible extra unknown children

    (Not adding Sunny Star scout from Gen 5 though, since this world definitely would not take that route. Who knows the whole, maybe in the far far future with a world more like modern?
    Also DEFINITELY not adding the villain from that show at all, or the alicorn City thing that apparently exists in Gen 5)

    Omg, I just realized that if a Fluttershy becomes an alicorn that means discord won't have to outlive her! That would be wondrous

    I am thinking about so many alicorns right now
    This world went from one and could possibly go to 20 or more within a lifetime

    Because this is also not counting the other main six having any kids, pinkie pie having more kids, that could all possibly be alicorns

    Comment Actions

    1. TheItalianConstant on Chapter 9 Tue 24 Jun 2025 04:53PM UTC

      Yeah, Fluttershy being eternal like Discord and sharing a forever friendship with him would be wondrous.

      And let's say I DID take some inspiration from Gen 5, a few key elements (since I didn't like the premise)

      Comment Actions

      1. CathU500 on Chapter 9 Tue 24 Jun 2025 07:31PM UTC

        I am both intrigued and frightened by which possible elements you are taking from, but since you're saying you didn't like the premise that calms me slightly, since I am going to assume then that there will be no 'all the magic is lost' ruining twilight's happy ending-? Or if so at the very least all the pony races won't be divided again and the other creatures of Equestria won't be gone-
        I guess I'll have to wait and see though to be sure

        Comment Actions

        1. TheItalianConstant on Chapter 9 Tue 22 Jul 2025 03:03PM UTC

          Believe me, I am planning top take only a few token elements from Gen 5, and I plan to rework them to make them better than canon.

          Comment Actions

          1. CathU500 on Chapter 9 Tue 22 Jul 2025 11:15PM UTC

            More beautiful words have not been spoken
            This definitely makes me very happy
            And I hope it makes you happy too!

            Comment Actions

            1. TheItalianConstant on Chapter 9 Fri 05 Sep 2025 12:30PM UTC

              You already make me happier with your comments

              Comment Actions

              1. CathU500 on Chapter 9 Mon 08 Sep 2025 03:11AM UTC

                I'm glad!

                Comment Actions

                1. TheItalianConstant on Chapter 9 Sun 21 Sep 2025 03:05PM UTC

                  Thank you!

                  Comment Actions

                  1. CathU500 on Chapter 9 Sun 21 Sep 2025 04:15PM UTC

                    You're welcome 🤗

                    Comment Actions

                    1. TheItalianConstant on Chapter 9 Sun 21 Sep 2025 04:17PM UTC

                      Still thanks.

                      Comment Actions

                      1. CathU500 on Chapter 9 Mon 22 Sep 2025 01:45AM UTC

                        :)

                        Comment Actions

                        1. TheItalianConstant on Chapter 9 Tue 23 Sep 2025 09:58AM UTC

                          :)

                          Comment Actions