Chapter Text
I never thought I'd start the new year with one girlfriend, let alone four- and days after Christmas, we invite family and some close friends to attend a small celebration at our shared house-
Before Anana, Manico, Dasuki, Monika's parents and others arrive, the five of us each set up a snack, beverage or activity to enjoy in the last couple of hours before midnight-
While Sayori sets up small cups of grapes for everyone to eat, I prepare the sparkling champagne to accompany it, enough for everyone but Sayori- (She's getting hot chocolate)
Yuri makes some sweet looking martini cocktails for us to enjoy in the meantime, as Natsuki made trays of cheese, crackers, carrots, strawberries, rolled ham slices with various dips, and even margarita cupcakes!
Monika provides confetti poppers, a new card game, and karaoke for anyone who gets drunk enough to do-
Most of the guests end up eating & drinking the snacks & martinis as the time gets closer, while Anana & Manico join us in Monika's 'Drink If' game- (All but Sayori)
I think I ended up drinking more than I expected- I also didn't expect Nat to drink for trying out a cigarette once, or that Monika tried being vegan, or that Yuri's shoplifted before (and that Manico used to strip for guys too)
Of course my perfect sister Anana barely had to sip her glass that much- either that, or she's somehow tolerant-
Barely an hour before midnight, Sayori starts off the karaoke- and I may have joined in- but only to make her not feel embarrassed- while Yuri & Nat sit out, Monika's willing to join us!
Right as we finish a nice pop rock song, the countdown begins: with our champagne & grapes in hand, in moment the time strikes twelve, we immediately gulp it down- (Sayori won)
While most of the guests confront each other in happiness or fire out the confetti poppers, before getting a bite of the margarita laced cupcakes, Monika turns to me, Sayori, Natsuki & Yuri,
"Let's share our New Year's Resolutions!"
Natsuki finishes drinking her glass, "Sure- you first!"
Monika smiles messily, "My New Year's resolution is to dedicate more time for those I love than purely doing business paperwork."
Nat shrugs, "Sounds good- mine is to be a little nicer & optimistic."
Yuri hums slightly, "Perhaps that will be difficult for you..."
Natsuki nudges Yuri's arm as we all sit on the couch, "What's yours then?"
"I want to be more open about the things I want to accomplish and not feel pressured to not be myself." Yuri sighs as I squeeze her hand in comfort-
"That's... I wish I thought of that." I murmur out loud before Natsuki turns to me, "What did you think about then?"
I look over to the side, "My resolution is to push myself to be the best partner and father I can be."
Natsuki rolls her eyes, "That should've always been true! Sayori, you got something better, right?"
Sayori reaches over and squeezes my hand, "I think that's great MC! Mine is for the five of us to have a pajama pillow fight tonight that ends with all of us getting silly~"
Natsuki shakes her head, "This isn't a birthday wish, it's a resolution! And it's not even night anymore- Monika can you explain it to her?"
While Monika tries to appease both Nat & Sayori, I turn over and notice Anana preparing to leave with Manico making me utter, "Hey Anana, want to share your New Year Resolution?"
Anana waves a hand, "Eh, mine's not special, I just want to get my doctorate early so I can deliver my nephew in five months- Manico has a more complex resolution-"
"Great!" I say standing up, "Why not let Manico go into detail about it while we have a little talk?"
Anana narrows her eyes as Manico sits down in my spot, "Sure- let's talk."
While most of our guests begin to depart, I lead Anana to a far-off corner from the living room before I whisper, "Can you keep a secret? I wasn't honest about my New Year's resolution."
Anana crosses her arms, "I do owe you, but what do you want kept secret?"
I sigh and lean back into a wall, "My real resolution is to be the best husband I can be to the four loves of my life."
Anana almost does a double take, "Husband-? Maine? Are you thinking about proposing? To all four of them?"
I bite my lip and nod, "I want to do it on Valentine's Day- but is it too soon? Do you think they'll all want to get married?"
Anana gains a flat expression before she grabs my shoulder, "MC, you managed to get four beautiful girls to not only date you, but each other! Not to mention you already got Sayori pregnant- their answer isn't the problem."
I blink, "Then what is?"
"Polygamy is illegal in Japerica Maine." Anana says with concern, "Being polyamorous is one thing, but a single guy marrying four women won't work!"
I frown, "Well, technically we'd be marrying each other?"
Anana shakes her head before she turns to leave, "Look, you can do whatever you want, but if you want legal advice ask Manico- he's considering part-time law employment."
I should probably heed her warning but- I still have a month in a half to figure out possible engagement plans-
Suddenly Sayori calls out, "MC! We're doing the Pj pillow fight now that everyone's gone! Lets's go!"
...
Once we get to the master bedroom, we slip into our 'pajamas' I don't really wear any anymore, but Sayori manages to fit some old pajama bottoms on me before I get a pillow to battle against Monika, Yuri & Natsuki-
Sayori's not participating for the obvious reason, but she did spell out a specific prize for whoever lasts the longest holding their pillow gets to choose how we end the night intimately-
I immediately charge at Monika since she's the more athletic, while Natsuki & Yuri battle it out, swiping purple against pink while my dark green mashed against lime- (Sayori just watches excitedly)
While Monika & I are locked in a standoff, Natsuki manages to knock Yuri's pillow off- I'm pretty surprised that Nat won- either that or Yuri doesn't mind not being on top-
This distracting thought allows Monika to swiftly swipe my pillow out of grasp, and it's not long before does the same to Natsuki, making the brown-haired woman hum triumphantly,
"Now, how should we begin~?"
I let out a muffled moan as Monika wraps her breasts around my erect penis as I lay back in bed, with Sayori straddling on my face, tightening her hips my head as she squeals,
"Maine~! Your wonderful tongue is tickling me~!"
Monika giggles as she pumps her mounds up and down my shaft, "I had a feeling you'd both love this position~ ooh, his tip's popping up~ any takers?"
Right as I delve my tongue deeper into Sayori's gushing walls, the pressure of Monika's soft bosom is matched by the succulent lips of Natsuki, burying her face between Mon's cleavage-
My hips thrust up into Nat's mouth as Monika's titjob speeds up, my hands squeezing and caressing Sayori backside & Natsuki's side as our movements get faster until-
The moment I feel Yuri's tongue slurp at my balls, I explode, shooting out a series of cumshots that fill Nat's mouth before she pulls back, allowing the rest of my seed to coat Monika's face and chest- (my loud grunt also causes Sayori to orgasm)
As Sayori slides off my face and I take a few deep breaths to recover, Yuri gets on her hands & knees, with Natsuki & Monika stripping her naked before they begin to suck on her milk potent breasts-
The moment Yuri gives me a stare of pure desire, I immediately shove my hardened shaft deep inside the purple-haired women from behind, making her gasp out before Monika shoves a few fingers into her mouth-
The sounds of Yuri sucking on Monika's digits while both Mon & Nat drink milk from her large bosom, invigorates me to pound her harder, grabbing hold of her waist to press her buttocks against my pelvis accordingly-
Sayori sleepily hugs me from behind as I continue to do Yuri in the doggystyle position, the excited giggling from Monika & Natsuki getting me to reach over to squeeze Yuri's mounds hard as I reach my limit-
Yuri lets out a muffled moan as she flushes her fluids to mix with my semen pouring into her womb, making her slump down before I pull out, still fully aroused-
After a quick cleanup blowjob from Monika & Natsuki, I spread Monika's legs and slide my length inside her walls, while Nat climbs on top of Monika before sitting on her face-
As I adjust to Monika's tighter walls, Sayori & Yuri slump down and rest their heads on Monika's semen stained chest, beginning to snooze as my thrusts get faster and faster-
What finally pushes me over the edge is when while my hands are buried into Monika's hips, Natsuki suddenly pulls me into a heated kiss, in which I lose myself and release my final loads-
Natsuki also climaxes on Monika's face before we both slump down and join in hugging our lover as we join Yuri & Sayori in a blissful sleep...
...
The rest of January is largely uneventful, with the weather remaining mostly cold even as less snow comes-
At least I did manage to finish my screenplay, and Monika's got four new Sugartea bakery locations finally open, and I along with the others get to visit them all across the city-
While Natsuki working on new food recipes, and Monika's figuring out more of the business as Sayori is preparing one of the extra bedrooms as a baby room- and I'm helping Yuri with new writing works-
Speaking of Yuri, while I'm still trying to figure out how exactly to propose to four girls when it's very illegal to do so, on one of the last days of January, after she's ridden me to completion, she murmurs,
"Maine..."
I hug Yuri back as she lays on top of me with the other three girls stained and slumping all around us,
"Yes, Yuri~?"
Yuri leans close with a tired blush, "I- I haven't told the others my birthday is coming up- and I didn't know the best way to hint at it-"
I wrap my arms around Yuri and pull her close,
"You want a nice surprise~ I'm sure we'll have something perfect for your special day..."
A few days later, Yuri awakens to the feeling of water water seeping down on her, making her gasp out as she finds herself in the master bathroom, with all four of us holding her up-
I lean close and plant a kiss on Yuri's lips from behind her, "Happy Birthday~"
While Natsuki & Sayori fondle Yuri's chest, Monika takes out a large bottle of purple lotion and giggles,
"Since you like Jasmine, I got shampoo & soap for body & hair~"
Once the four of us each get a handful of the wonderful scented liquid, I begin to rub Yuri's back & buttocks, while Monika does her hair, Natsuki her chest, and Sayori with her legs and what's between them-
With all this rubbing, it's not long before things get as heated as intended, starting with Monika pulling Yuri in a kiss as Natsuki dives between her breasts, while Sayori gets on her knees to eat out the lucky girl-
I'm content with giving Yuri a back massage until she rubs her backside against my pelvis, pressing my morning wood between her cheeks, even as she makes out with Monika, gets moterboated by Nat, and getting her slit licked by Sayori's tongue-
My grasp around, squeezing Natsuki's chest & my other hand's fingers slip into Monika's backside, with a few digits inserting into her entrance as well-
Yuri bucks back and forth as she locks lips with Monika and massages my cock between her buttcheeks even as she humps Sayori's face faster, before she pulls both Natsuki & Monika close as she-
Sayori hums in delight as Yuri squirts in her mouth, while I feel Monika leak onto my fingers as my own climaxes reaches, causing me to shoot out a few pearly loads onto Yuri's back & hair before it washes away in the water...
Once we clean ourselves, we begin to change, where Yuri notices us put on turtleneck sweaters as well, with Sayori giggling,
"Oh, it's also national sweater day! Do you mind?"
Yuri forms an amused smile, "Not at all- what plans do we have today?"
After an exquisite breakfast consisting of German styled pancakes, raspberry cinnamon rolls & cream tea, I drive us all in Yuri's car to a large bookstore, where we all purchase some new and old novels as an early birthday present-
A few hours later, we go to a steakhouse for lunch, where Anana & Manico join us in having ribeye, medium rare, shellfish, with salads & soups for sides, along with an assortment of beverages-
As Sayori practically finishes up the chocolate fudge cake for dessert all by herself, I turn to Yuri as she sips her chamomile wine,
"So- what should we do now?"
Yuri finishes her glass with a gulp, "You're asking me-?"
I gently squeeze Yuri's hand, "It's your day, and we'll down to do whatever you want."
Anana makes a cough sound, "Well, not all of us are down for anything- I know how intimate you guys get, and I'm not into girls or my brother!"
Before Manico can either agree or reveal a new side to himself, Yuri speaks up,
"I suppose I did make the resolution to be myself more... would you all like to take part in a murder mystery?"
Monika's eyes widen with delight, "Do tell..."
...
We return to the Polyhouse to play out this simple game: one of the seven of us is the 'murderer' whose goal is to 'kill' all but one other person to win- everyone else has to find the killer before it's too late- simple.
Natsuki raises her hand once Yuri's done explaining the rules, "If the killer is caught, we have to send them to the balcony- isn't this just like Among Us?"
Yuri blinks, "Is that similar game?"
Once Natsuki briefly go over about the video game, Sayori raises her hand, "Um, so how do we pick a killer? And how are they gonna be able to go after us if we're all sitting in the living room together?"
Yuri offers a playful smile, "When I asked to see each of you in private before we sat down, I may have told one of you to be the killer- or perhaps it could be me, but I shall not ruin the surprise-"
Suddenly the lights go out, and when they come back on a second later, Sayori's laying on the ground motionless!
"Sayori!" Natsuki & I gasp out loud- until Sayori opens one eye, "Don't mind me- I'm dead!"
Anana rolls her eyes, "So it begins- are we given any clues or hints to find this murderer?"
Monika leans down to inspect Sayori as she gets on her phone, lifeless, "It appears a small note was left behind- it says library or kitchen."
I shake my head grimly, "Who would target Sayori first?"
Natsuki sharply turns to Yuri, "It's you, isn't it? You said you know who the killer is- yourself!"
Yuri raises her hands in defense, before Anana steps up, "Let's get a move on before the lights go out again- Manico & I will inspect the kitchen- can one more join me, so the killer is stuck with two?"
Natsuki pushes Yuri towards them, "Take her! If one of you two die, then we'll know she's responsible!"
While Monika, Nat & I head upstairs, Sayori gets up and watches tv- once we enter the library, Monika spots a note on the ground, but before she can pick it up, the lights go out-
The lights go out for about five minutes, in which I hear Anana let out a loud scream before the lights turn back on- while Monika grabs the note, Natsuki & I rush downstairs-
On the kitchen floor, Anana lies motionless, clutching her stomach with Yuri & Manico over her-
While Monika leans down to inspect Anana, Natsuki turns to Yuri & Manico, "Ah-HA! I knew one of you was the killer!"
Manico shakes his head, "I swear it wasn't me- and how we know it was Yuri? In those five minutes, one of you could've gone down here to murder my girlfriend!"
Yuri turns to me, "You know it's not me- are you sure you didn't hear anyone go downstairs?"
Nat does a double take, "Are you trying to accuse me now?!"
I lower my head, "I didn't hear or see anything- if Monika or Nat is the killer, they must be pretty quiet and quick."
Monika gets up, "I didn't kill Anana- but whoever did used a knife."
I give Monika a concerned stare, "How do you know that?"
"Just look at how she's holding her stomach- a stab wound- Anana's trying to give us a hint, even when she's dead." Monika says proudly, "It's a good thing I had a minor degree in criminal justice- you can call me detective Monika!"
Natsuki points at Yuri & me, "Then you can call me Watson, because the killer's obviously one of the only two people who have their own custom knife!"
Manico points to the utensils on the counter, "Before the lights went out, Anana noticed a knife missing- it could be any of us."
"An even better reason for all of us to turn out our pockets, now!" Natsuki demands-
Nat really must wanna win- when we do take everything out of our pockets, the moment Natsuki sees red on my green blade, she gasps, "Its MC! He's the killer!"
"Natsuki, its red icing from the cake you baked for Yuri's birthday!" I retort back before Natsuki grabs my & Yuri's knives before placing them on the counter, "There! But- we're still missing a knife!"
Yuri frowns, "Whoever took the knife is hiding it somewhere, and likely only uses it when the lights go out."
Natsuki narrows her eyes, "You seem to know a lot Yuri- especially for the person who wanted us to play, and knows who the killer is, and refuses to tell us!"
"It's part of the game!" Yuri hisses back making Natsuki huff, "If you know so much, can we lock a suspect somewhere, so we keep looking for clues?"
"In fact, you can." Yuri says haughtily, "If majority agrees, a suspected person may be locked in the closet, until majority agree to free said person."
"Great!" Natsuki says, "Then I vote we lock Yuri in a closet until we get enough evidence to eject her into the balcony!"
While Manico & I share reluctant glances, Monika sighs, "I hate to admit it, but Natsuki's right- Yuri's my top suspect as well, so we should keep her locked tight while I continue my investigation."
Yuri grabs my hand, "It's not me! Please MC!"
But once Manico nods his head in agreement with Monika & Nat, I cup her chin, "Its ok- I know it's not you- I'll figure it out for us, I promise."
With Yuri locked in the pantry, the four of us sit around the counter as Anana gets up to join Sayori in the living room, before Monika takes out the note she found upstairs and reads out loud, "If you want to catch me, fix the right circuit board."
Manico sits up, "That must be how the killer is turning the lights off! All we need to do is fix it to force them to strike in broad daylight!"
"But our house has two circuit boards, one near the attic bathroom, the other near the workout room." I say with a frown, "If we all go together to fix one, the killer could strike again if we choose incorrectly."
Monika gets up, "Then we'll have to split up again."
Natsuki shakes her head, "Are you crazy? Then the killer will definitely attack- unless it is Yuri."
"Precisely!" Monika hums, "We'll expose the killer for sure, since they'll have to strike to keep the lights off- unless it is Yuri, then we'll all be fine."
Natsuki grabs onto my arm, "Then I'll go with MC to the basement circuit board- you go with the guy who definitely killed Anana if it's not Yuri, Monika."
Monika offers a sheepish smile, "You're so brave Natsuki- now, if one of us dies, remember to make noise, so we can gather since Yuri said the killer can only kill five minutes at a time- let's move!"
Natsuki & I make our way to the basement, where near the workout room, the circuit breaker is- and right as I open it to reveal its perfectly fine, the lights go out-
I hear Natsuki frantically try to turn the lights on from the circuit breaker to no avail- another five minutes of darkness occurs until Monika lets out a scream- then the lights go on-
Natsuki & I rush to the attic, where we find Manico standing over Monika on the ground, with him just fixing the circuit breaker-
"It's you!" Natsuki yells out at Manico, "You just killed Monika!"
"I didn't!" Manico gasps, "Don't you think its suspicious the killer takes five minutes to attack? It's because it's one of you two!"
Natsuki gives me a side-eye glance before she sighs looking down at Monika, "We should've been holding hands the whole time- I don't see any clues on her, besides the knife stab."
I glance between Manico & Natsuki, "Maybe we should check on Yuri- to see if she's still alive or somehow escaped."
Nat nods in agreement, "Yeah, so we can also lock Manico up too!"
The three of us return to the kitchen, where Yuri, still locked in the pantry asks, "What happened? The lights went out again- and I heard Monika-"
"Yeah she's dead too." Natsuki grumbles, "And since you're still here, it's probably Manico- can we lock him up too?"
"Only one person can be locked up at a time-" Yuri hums through the door, "And I'd be unwise for you two to be left together, so perhaps you can let me out-"
"Nice try!" Natsuki snorts, "Yuri might not be the killer, but she knows their identity, so she's an accomplice! We should just eject Manico now!"
I rub my neck, "I don't know- and we only have two minutes before the killer can strike again- maybe we should let Yuri out-"
"No!" Natsuki yelps, "She'll side with the killer, and its Manico! Vote him off with me!"
Manico backs away, "It's not me! How do we know it's not Natsuki? She's leading this witch hunt!"
They both turn to me- it's my choice...
"Its Manico!" I shout, "Lets eject him!"
We manage to shove him to the outside balcony (After giving him his coat & shoes) before I turn to Natsuki who looks triumphant, "So... can we ask Yuri if we won? I don't want to leave Manico in the cold, killer or not."
Natsuki shrugs, "Fine, but if she says the game's still on, lets eject her too!"
Walking back to the pantry door, Natsuki proudly announces to Yuri, "It's over we won! Right?"
Yuri begins to laugh, "Oh, poor Natsuki, its wasn't Manico... and it's not me either~"
Natsuki slowly turns around to face me as I take a knife out of my pocket and murmur, "You should've asked us to check our pockets again."
Once I show off my fake stab move to Natsuki, she collapses to the ground, and I open the pantry door, where Yuri straddles into my arms, "You did a wonderful job darling~ My handsome killer~"
Yuri & I engage in a heated kiss until Natsuki gets up, "Ok its over- you can stop!"
Monika & Anana enter the kitchen with the former chirping, "Just in time! I think dinner's ready!"
Anana gives me a semi-proud smirk, "I didn't think you'd get away with it- I'll go get Manico."
...
While we ate the delicious lasagna dinner, I explain how I managed to turn the lights off using a button in my shoe, thanks to Yuri- and how I sprint walked up and down to kill Anana & Monika-
After we wish Yuri happy birthday and enjoy a velvet cake with red icing, Anana & Manico leave before I turn to Yuri,
"So~ how do you want to do things tonight~?"
Yuri fidgets a little, "It's my call-? I suppose- first I want to share my... passion tea..."
I see a familiar glance in Yuri's eyes, making me pull a glass away from Sayori, "Don't drink it! It's not good for someone pregnant..."
Natsuki grabs Sayori's glass, "If you guys want to be wusses, then it's more for me!"
Once Monika & Nat drink enough of the 'special' tea, they move begin to fall back unconscious, and Yuri & I catch them, with Sayori staring curiously,
"Wow, that tea's pretty strong!"
Yuri bites her lip, "Let's go upstairs~"
I carry Monika while Yuri gets Natsuki, and when we reach the master bedroom, we begin to tie them to the bed, on either side before Sayori sits down on a chair and gasps,
"Oh! You're reenacting the night you & Yuri lost your virginity together!"
Yuri looks over to me with a crazed grin, "It's been nine months since, and it's still the best night of my life! I want to show that to Natsuki, willing or not!"
I give Yuri a concerned stare, "Uh, you did take your medication, right?"
Yuri reaches over and squeezes my groin, "I only took half of my pill! Ha! HA! Don't worry darling, I'll have you too- but first take Monika, while I have this fun sized snack~!"
As Yuri & I begin to undress the still sleeping Monika & Natsuki, Sayori sits back and takes her undergarments off, rubbing her clit as she coos,
"Keep going~ I'll hop in if I want to~!"
Once I unravel Monika's sweater & slide her sports bra up, I nuzzle my face into her warm bust, making her awaken and murmur sleepily,
"Mmm~ Maine~?"
Natsuki meanwhile, is less pleased about waking up tied to our bed with Yuri stripping her, making her struggle and scream,
"What the fuck-?! Yuri get off me! Did you drug me?!"
Yuri giggles and plants a kiss on Nat's lips before she shoves a purple dildo down her throat,
"Oh, don't you remember doing this to MC? And I'm sure you'll like what I got for you~"
While Yuri shows Natsuki her strap on vibrator, Monika blushes heavily as I strip her naked,
"What are you going to do to me~?"
I lean down and kiss Monika's entrance, making her squirm before I begin to eat her out messily, making my girlfriend squirm until she squirts her fluids into my face-
Once I pull my face free, I climb on top of Monika, and unzip my pants, sliding them and my sweater off, and rub my cock between her breasts a few times before I press my tip to her lips,
"Mine turn~"
Monika opens her mouth wide, "Ah~ mmph~!"
I grab hold of Monika's head and thrust down her thrust accordingly, sliding my entire length down her tight throat in a single gulp-
While I facefuck Monika in a messy fashion, I occasionally glance over at Yuri & Natsuki, with Yuri pushing the dildo deeper down Nat's throat while pushing her vibrator deep in her cunt-
I finally cum down Monika's throat once I grasp her soft hair as I bang her tight mouth hole with my balls bouncing on her chin- I grunt and submit to her tongue's spinning as my loads fire out-
Once Monika's gulps my cumshots down, I pop out of her maw, and she licks her lips as I slap my cock at her thighs to reharden, then I spread her legs and thrust in between-
"MAINE~!" Monika moans out as I push deep into her tight walls, with the sight of Nat & Yuri kissing and fingering each other right next to us making me thrust faster-
Monika's cries are muffled as Sayori sits on her face, and Sayori pulls me into a kiss, pushing me over the limit-
I pump Monika's walls full of my seed before I pull out- right as I do, Sayori gives my tip a few licks before she looks down at Monika's creampie leaking snatch,
"Mmm~ extra dessert~"
While Sayori humps Monika's face while eating her out to taste our combined fluids, I get up right as Natsuki faints as she orgasms right into Yuri's mouth once she pushes the dildo deeper into her ass-
Yuri opens her mouth to show Natsuki's fluids before I pull her into a sloppy kiss, and once she wraps her legs around my waist, I pull her up-
Our intimate parts quickly interlock as I begin to casually thrust into her walls as I hold her against me, our chests pressed together with our hands linking-
I hug Yuri close as I fuck her and murmur,
"You have no idea how glad I am you decided to kidnap me that night~"
Yuri mewls as I thrust deeper into her,
"I am grateful you wrote your fantasies out, otherwise I would never get to show my passion with my other lovers~"
Our lips smash again as we lose ourselves to our burning love & lust, our bodies pressing together so intimately until I finally erupt, satisfying her before we fall back down on the bed and slip unconscious...
...
Okay, so it's been a week since Yuri's birthday on the fourth, so I have three days until Valentine's Day- I have a full plan of what I'm going to actually do, but what if the girls ask me ahead of time what it is?
The next morning, I head out to go 'grocery' shopping, when I make a quick stop to a cafe, where Anana waits for me in a back corner table in the back before I arrive making her sigh, "Took long enough- what's wrong?"
I take a seat and stammer, "I have the dinner date planned out, at Romano Bertucci's- I'll propose to them right before dessert- I already made the reservations ahead of time, and the owner & manager are willing to look the other way about the polygamy thing."
Anana sips her latte, "Then why am I here?"
"I need a good excuse, so it isn't obvious that my proposal is the Valentine's gift!" I utter, "I have flowers & chocolates, but they know I'm hiding something!"
Anana eats her biscuit with gravy before she mutters, "Just do a spicy activity- or something fun like a rank list of your favorite things about your partner- I did one for Manico and he liked it."
I get up, "That's perfect! You're the best, Anana!"
Anana starts to say something, but I'm already out- as I drive back home, I consider the ranking idea- but I have to make one for each of them? Or maybe something even more special for us...
That night, when everyone's done with dinner, Sayori asks for a game to play before bed in which I rely, "I got one! Let's make a list of our favorite to least favorite lover!"
Monika's face immediately drops, "We don't have to do that exact list-"
Natsuki sits up, "No, I think we should do it- and see exactly how we feel about each other..."
Yuri & Sayori reluctantly agree, so we begin brainstorming- now that I'm actually doing this, maybe it's not such a good idea- but the others are already doing it- it's just harmless fun, right?
To start it off, Monika goes first saying, "MC, Sayori, Yuri then Natsuki."
Natsuki goes next, "Sayori, Monika, Yuri then MC- but I should've placed Yuri a little higher."
I'm not really surprised by my ranking on her list, but then Yuri stammers, "MC, Monika, Natsuki and Sayori."
Natsuki looks a little insulted despite her own ranking of Yuri being similar, leaving me to utter, "Yuri, Sayori, Monika then Natsuki."
While Yuri gains a nervous delighted expression, Nat looks aghast as Monika murmurs, "I didn't think you cared about Yuri that much... even more than your pregnant girlfriend?"
"I..." I find myself at a loss of words as Natsuki shakes her head, "I knew you loved them more than me! I guess I'm less attractive because I don't have big boobs, huh?"
Yuri lets out a tired sigh, "It's not that- MC's feelings more the rest of us are just slightly longer- it's only natural-"
"Natural?" Nat snorts, "I've been dating this idiot longer than Monika, and he still likes her more! You wanna know what's not normal? Dating more than one person at a time!"
Shit-
It's not long before Yuri, Monika & Natsuki each take a bedroom for themselves- leaving me in my rightful place on the couch- but not alone-
I lay up a little as Sayori joins me with some blankets and pillows before she cuddles me and murmurs, "I love you, Natsuki, Monika & Yuri equally- that's what I agreed once we all decided to date~"
Sayori rests her head on my chest before I caress her bloated chest and murmur, "Natsuki's right... I'm an idiot... but I'm going to fix this..."
With only one day until Valentine's Day, I need to do whatever it takes to get Monika & Natsuki to get along with the others- while Sayori goes off to talk to Yuri, I first confront Natsuki- with something rather embarrassing-
Natsuki leaves her room to find me waiting downstairs in an ice cream boy cosplay with strawberry ice cream with sprinkles in hand making her cross her hands, "You think the promise of sweets and sex can sway me?"
I offer Natsuki a genuine stare, "I'm the luckiest moron in the world, and the whole list idea might've been the dumbest thing I've ever come up with."
Nat raises an eyebrow, "And?"
"I'm a big pervert who can't stop thinking about your divine butt on my face." I murmur out loud, flushing heavily-
Natsuki leans close licks the ice cream cone, "Good boy~ we're going to the fun room, right fucking now~"
Once I find myself on the bed, Natsuki grants my wish, sitting on my face once she slides her shorts and panties off, allowing me to slurp her juicy cunt as she tries her best to give my dick a brainfreeze with the ice cream cone, before she fits the waffle cone on my cock, before she begins to take bites-
Eventually enough bites do the trick, and I shoot a few pearly loads down Natsuki's hungry mouth, with Nat gushes on me face nearly half a dozen times by then...
While Natsuki takes a nap, I get up and prepare to find Monika, only for her to emerge out of the workout room and stare down at me with a weak smile before she utters, "Lets have a little talk in the shower, shall we?"
Monika sighs as I give her a fully body massage in the master shower, washing her hair, front and backside before she hums, "You can hump my thighs- I'm not really that mad at you."
I slide my dick between her perfect thighs before I nibble on her ear, "But you are mad at me~ and you should be... I should've known better..."
Monika smiles as she leans back into me, "I love a man who admits when he's wrong- or however you choose to identify yourself."
I stop nuzzling Monika's neck, "What?"
Monika leans into my arms and squeezes my thighs, "Nothing dear~ I just can't wait to see what you have for us tomorrow~"
...
The day's finally here- the morning starts off rather lovingly- Natsuki rides my morning wood as she makes out with Monika- Yuri & Sayori proceed to share an open kiss with me at the same time, mewling out as I begin them in the process-
We enter a similar position in the shower, this time with Yuri sucking on my tip as I hump Nat's thighs- Monika & Sayori finger each other behind us, before we all finish off our early arousal-
After enjoying some breakfast muffins & cupcakes, we head out to a Valentine's Fair that's perfectly opened up with slightly warmer weather finally here, and the snow cleared out- the carnival games are fun, and the tunnel of love's just about fit us all!
We enjoy some lunch in the park in the form of a delightful picnic Nat & Sayori have prepared for all of us, and as we finish eating our pizza hot pockets & heart shaped enchiladas, I reveal the chocolate boxes with four sets of flowers, the colors green, purple, blue & pink-
Sayori hugs me from behind with both Yuri & Natsuki planting a kiss on my cheek while Monika hums amusingly, "This is delightful love- didn't you say you had something even more special for dinner?"
I offer her a sly smile, "I sure do, but we're going to have to go home to change first..."
After a nice stroll in the park, we get back home where I reveal the reservation to the Italian restaurant for tonight-
While I put on a nice black suit & pants with a pink undershirt and red tie, the other girls have even lovier outfits:
Yuri in a dark red dress, Sayori in a magenta & red loose top and skirt, Monika in a tight fitting red & black outfit while Natsuki has a perfect hot pink slip-on dress with a choker-
I drive us all to the restaurant, with four special little boxes in my pocket they haven't noticed yet- and right as we get into the nice center booth, I notice Anana & Manico watching from the sidelines- luckily none of the girl's noticed them yet-
For dinner we all agree to share a large spaghetti bowl, and get some red & white wine, while Sayori got sparkling apple juice-
Once the food arrives, we begin to dig in, with Yuri & I slurping down a noodle for a close kiss, only for Sayori to pop in between us, nibbling on some of it before we both plant a kiss on her cheeks- while Monika shares some meatball with Natsuki through a kiss-
While Natsuki then shares some meatball with Yuri, Sayori shares a breadstick with Monika, and I get in between to have a bite, making them plant kisses on my lips before they share one-
Some of the other couples are watching us, including Anana & Manico, but I don't care- especially since I'm about to do something even more open-
Right as Monika orders some cheesecake with strawberries for dessert, I get up before I kneel down before my four girlfriends, "Yuri, Sayori, Natsuki, Monika, you four have made my life a blessing the moment you entered it- I want us to be happy the way we've been together these past six months forever~ will you marry me?"
Yuri is stunned in place, Sayori giddily bounces in her seat, Natsuki looks like she's going to faint, and Monika merely smiles before they say simultaneously, "Yes!"
Some applause goes off from some of the guests, Manico, Anana and some servers- while a new couples either express disgust or jealousy- I honestly could've care less-
I hand my fiancées their rings before Natsuki hums, "This is- sweet and all, but are we only marrying you, or each other too?"
I shrug, "We can figure that out before we actually get married- lets enjoy some dessert first!"
As we begin to share a large slice of cheesecake, Monika hums as she spoon-feeds me, "Oh honey, this is just the appetizer for the special treat we have in store for you tonight~"
...
It turns out my four girlfriends decided to come up with a couple lists of their own for me to express, starting with which girl I liked more in each intimate position, first blowjob, then titjob, anal, then intercourse-
Of course, no one sucks my dick better than Sayori and she quickly unzips my pants and removes my belt as she pushes me back in bed before she dips her mouth hard, choking on my shaft audibly as the other girls watch-
"Ngh- Sayori!" I squeal out as she fits my entire length down her perfect throat, her lack of gag reflex making me grasp at the bedsheets with her cupping my balls fondly before she pushes deeper-
The other three gasp in delight as Sayori manages to fit my balls into her mouth as well, causing me to cum instantly, my pregnant fiancée gulping down my loads lovingly before she pops my member free and giggles, "Hmm~ so sweet and salty~"
Next Yuri slides the top of her dress off and wraps her breasts around my rehardening cock before she hums, "You're pulsating so much already, my love~ give in~"
I bite my lip and hump up into Yuri's mounds as she bounces her large bosom up and down, her tongue flickering at my tip with every thrust of my hips, her lustful gaze making me go faster-
Soon I grunt out and squeeze Yuri's buxom and yelp, "Y-yuri~!" Sending my loads splashing all over the top of her cleavage and face before she sucks on my tip with her chest still trapping my ejaculating dick-
I take a breather for a moment as Yuri pulls off, until Natsuki begins to stroke me phallus with her hands before she gives me a buttjob, getting me hard again as she spreads her cheeks and bites her lip-
Without hesitation, I slide my cock deep down into Natsuki's anus, making her bury her face into a pillow as I pound her wildly from behind, feeling her tightening hole clench only me closely, with her legs around my waist-
I plow Nat for a few good minutes before Natsuki squeaks out, "Hurry up and cum inside me~!"
I groan out and press Natsuki's buttocks against my pelvis, fitting my shaft entirely before I shoot out my loads and sigh, "Nat~"
I pull out and shoot out the rest of my cum ropes on Natsuki's rear before I'm left with Monika who climbs on top of me and quickly captures my lips in a deep kiss-
Our tongues curl together as she fits my length deep inside her tight and gushing snatch, our hands holding each other closely as I stare up into Monika's deep beautiful green eyes and lose myself to them-
Identity passes before we reach our simultaneous climax, and as Monika pulls off me to show our fluids pouring out of her, I lay back and sigh, "Monika~ I love you so much~ all of you~"
Monika hums, as she licks some cum off Yuri's cheek as they, along with Sayori & Natsuki go around me, "We know~ that's why we can't wait to share our favorite positions for you to be in, fiancé~"
I'm in for a long and very wonderful night...
——————————————————————