1 - 20 of 314 Works in Neal Caffrey and Jason Todd are the Same Person
Navigation
Listing Works
-
A Series of Unfortunate Events (or, rather, a series of immense miscommunications leading to the rekindling of brotherly love and the ruining of various undercover identities) by Anonymous
Fandoms: White Collar (TV 2009), Batman - All Media Types
26 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
"Because Sonny Malone is dead. Robbie killed him, a decade ago."
"Neal Caffrey," said Robbie Malone. "It's good to finally meet you."
In which Sonny Malone is dead, and Neal Caffrey is not.
-
Too Cool (Dead) for School by JackofallTrades54
Fandoms: White Collar (TV 2009), Batman - All Media Types, Red Hood and the Outlaws (Comics)
22 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
“Hey Peter,” Jason greeted him with a picture-perfect smile.
Peter rolled his eyes and said, “Sorry to interrupt, but c’mon Professor Caffrey, let’s get going.” Jason startled slightly at the use of the honorific, but covered it with a scoff. Peter still narrowed his eye in a response.OR
Peter starts calling Jason (as Neal) "Professor Caffrey." Jason can't figure out why it slices a hole in his chest.
*****
BW365 Day 294 - Graduate
Series
- Part 1 of The Schoolhouse or the Playground
-
Answering the Call by Acxa_Kogane
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, White Collar, Red Hood and the Outlaws (Comics)
13 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
"Hello?"
"Hello, may I speak to Neal Caffrey."
"That's me."
"Mr. Caffrey, there have been reports of the Red Hood infiltrating the FBI. Your superior will escort you to the examination room. Thank you for your cooperation."
The line cut.
Peter stared at him.
Crap.
Series
- Part 1 of White Collar Curiosities
-
Things you should not do while undercover. by Acxa_Kogane
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, White Collar
07 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
It started out rather innocently. Just a few things that didn't quite match up with the story. Nothing too concerning.
Then they had an undercover mission and Neal knows a few things he is definitely not supposed to know. And as much as he'd like, Peter can't turn a blind eye to everything.
This is going to be a headache.
Series
- Part 2 of White Collar Curiosities
-
reprised role by impravidus for BabyGenius
Fandoms: White Collar (TV 2009), Chuck (TV), Batman - All Media Types
01 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
“So, what do you need Bryce Larkin back for?”
“We don’t,” Beckman says, sitting primly on the other side of the video call. “We need you to reprise another alias. The Red Hood.”
OR: Neal Caffrey is Bryce Larkin is Jason Todd
Series
- Part 126 of impravidus's folklore
- Part 43 of impravidus’s crossover fics
- Part 46 of White Collar/DC Fics
- Part 1 of AI-Less Whumptober 2025
-
Burning names, scrambling brains by GloamHyphen
Fandoms: White Collar (TV 2009), Batman - All Media Types
10 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
Jason has been relaxing in his role as Neal Caffrey.
So why is Tim here, and why does he have to burn the alias? -
Baby Talk by KezAHex
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, Supergirl (Comics), White Collar (TV 2009), Justice League - All Media Types
12 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
While undercover as Neal Caffrey Jason Todd has a normal-ish life, but then his speedster brother-in-law drops his de-aged Kryptonian girlfriend on him to 'babysit' because no one else on-planet speaks her language.
For Birdwatchers 365: #223 - Translate
-
Your Grandfather Is Dead (Time to Celebrate) by livingbetweenpages
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, White Collar (TV 2009)
02 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
Talia al Ghul drops by the FBI White Collar office with good news for Jason, aka Neal Caffrey.
“I recognize those,” Jones said, pointing his chin at Talia’s cloak. “You’re from the League of Assassins.”
“What?” Diana whipped her head around to gape at Jones. “No, she’s Neal’s mom!”
Jason hadn’t forgotten Diana spoke Arabic. But was it so much to ask that she miss that part?
A person can be two things.
-
Burning Red by caffeinatedbasil
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, White Collar (TV 2009)
30 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
Roy Harper is alive.
He’s there, just feet away, fast asleep on Jason's couch, with Lian curled up into his side. It's almost the same position as when she’d jumped into his arms at the ballet studio. She hasn’t let go of him since, even as they’d both eventually fallen asleep on the couch in June Ellington’s generously rented apartment.
Jason hasn’t let him out of his sight. He doesn't move until Roy cracks open his eyes. He blinks slowly, scanning the room, then looking down at his daughter’s still sleeping form nestled into his side. Finally, he smiles.
“Morning, Jaybird.”
Jason could cry.
or
Roy is back. Jason is still undercover, but he's not letting Roy out of his sight.
Peter Burke isn't too sure about Neal's new roommate.Series
- Part 2 of Triple Red
-
Who Cares About You? by ThaliaJackson
Fandoms: White Collar (TV 2009), Batman - All Media Types, DCU
24 Jun 2025
Tags
Summary
The White Collar team running into Arsenal in a warehouse leads to Jason desperately wanting his team to meet his boyfriend (if only to prove that he actually has other people in his life.)
aka, the two times Roy Harper shows his love to Jason Todd and the two times Peter finds out Neal actually has a life (and a daughter)
Written for Birdwatchers 365 Day Challenge, Day 174 — Care.
Day One: Identity Porn | Soulmate AU | Canon! Neal (for WCDC week 2025)
Series
- Part 4 of Jason in a Suit and the WC FBI office
-
Brother, Come Home by Teezey23
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, White Collar (TV 2009)
18 May 2025
Tags
Summary
Jason had stopped on his way to Titans Tower and turned around. He didn't go back to Gotham. He decided that it was safer for everyone if the Red Hood disappeared again, and Jason Todd never returned.
He invented a new identity, one with history.
Neal Caffrey.
It was the best cover. Neal was a nonviolent wordsmith, whereas Jason only spoke with violence. Neal never swore, Jason swore like a sailor. Neal hated guns while Jason knew every way to take someone down with a single shot. Neal was an artist, Jason hated art (of course, he did grow to appreciate it as he learned more about it).
Yes, Neal Caffrey was Jason Todd's opposite in every way.
Except one.Series
- Part 5 of WC/DC Brainworms
-
Tags
Summary
After meeting the Malones, Peter as "Paulie" gets to go on that zoo trip with Neal and Lil Matches and their mother. Because the littlest mobster wants to see wolf pups.
For Birdwatchers 365: #133- Wolf
Series
- Part 2 of M-O'B Life
-
Sleepy Zombie by Camelot1114
Fandoms: White Collar (TV 2009), Batman - All Media Types, DCU
14 May 2025
Tags
Summary
Jason!Neal has this condition of narcolepsy after being revived from the dead. Everything is going well until his meds didn't work so his medication for his narcolepsy is put on hold (since his dosage and components are different from the regular people with narcolepsy too) and has to suffer at least a week without his medication. Peter and the gang would see him sleeping in different parts of the office and at different times of the day.
-
Coming back from the dead is a family trait. by Whatever4242
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, White Collar (TV 2009)
07 May 2025
Tags
Summary
What happens when Jason Todd, undercover as Neal Caffrey, runs into a familiar face?
-
when we pretend that we're dead!!! by Discount_Emo
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, White Collar (TV 2009)
06 May 2025
Tags
Summary
“Who- Neal- What?” One of the people sitting across from them garbled out. His mouth was gaping wide, eyes darting between Jason, Steph, and Cass.
“These,” Jason grits out, “Are my sisters. Who shouldn’t be in New York.”
“Bitch, you can’t tell me what to do,” Steph instantly retorted through her laughter.
-
Written for BW365 day 126 : Confrontation
-
The Caffreys? Who the hell is Caffrey? (They're all Caffreys) by KaiValkrom8
Fandoms: White Collar (TV 2009), DCU, Batman: Under the Red Hood (2010)
04 May 2025
Tags
Summary
Alfred Pennyworth showed up at White collar. And he brought the colony with him.
In other words, Jason!Neal undercover and White collar struggle to fend off the bats and the Ratking.
First work, criticize if you want?
Also please tell me if you laughed at the tags, because then I will feel accomplished in life
-
two truths and many lies by ThaliaJackson
Fandoms: White Collar (TV 2009), DCU, Batman - All Media Types
24 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
The White Collar team settles in for team bonding night, complete with questions about Gotham and drinking games. Jason's doing his absolute best not to lie to the team; he just has to not give away that he's a vigilante. That shouldn't be a problem. Right?
Written for Birdwatcher's 365 day challenge, Day 114 — Share.
Series
- Part 3 of Jason in a Suit and the WC FBI office
-
You Can Outrun a Goat But You Can't Outrun Your Trauma by erikakathryn
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, White Collar (TV 2009)
04 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
Grunt-for-hire wants Neal Caffrey to get in the trunk of his nissan sedan.
Jason "the fuck you think I am" Todd has very different opinions on the matter.
—
BW 365 Day One Word Prompts Challenge - Day 93 - "Trunk"
Series
- Part 3 of Jason Todd v. Undercover (WC)
-
the art of hiding (from the arms that held you) by couldyoublameme
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, White Collar (TV 2009)
28 Mar 2025
Tags
Summary
“You’re alive,” is what Wayne settles on, voice oddly tense and clipped compared to the light tone of a minute ago.
Neal's face does something weird as he passes, filtering through emotions too fast for Peter to name before settling on something cold and harsh. Not Neal-like at all.
“Despite your best efforts,” Neal says, and Peter can hear the anger hidden beneath the words. “Yes.”
Series
- Part 3 of The art of finding home
-
It's certainly a possibility I died, why do you ask by ThaliaJackson
Fandoms: DCU, Batman - All Media Types, White Collar (TV 2009)
10 Mar 2025
Tags
Summary
Jason was glad he'd told the White Collar team he's from Gotham and shed the first layer of his lies, but his scars were never something he'd wanted them to see. Ever. Even with the light stabbing. At least Dick bothered to show up after the fact.
Written for Birdwatcher's 365 Word Challenge, Day 69 — Possibility
Series
- Part 2 of Jason in a Suit and the WC FBI office