1 - 20 of 265 Works in Guilty Sam Winchester
Navigation
Listing Works
-
"I wanna be your dog" - Kinktober Day 10 (Punishment + Oral) by cosmic_caden
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
10 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
A typical day where Lucifer plays with Sammy in the cage. Afterall, pain and guilt are the two most delicious things for the devil.
Series
- Part 12 of Kinktober 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Dean has always wanted to control Sam. Finally, he gets to.
Series
- Part 1 of kinktober 2025
-
Tags
Summary
After Kevin's death, Dean Winchester drowns in guilt and self-loathing, isolating himself from Sam and Castiel in a desperate attempt to shield them from the "poison" he believes he’s become. Months pass with sporadic contact until a call comes from a South Carolina hospital: Dean has been found at the base of a waterfall, critically injured and barely alive.
As Sam and Castiel rush to his side, they grapple with the emotional wreckage left behind, Dean’s despair, Sam’s guilt, and the fragile hope of healing. With Dean’s life hanging in the balance, the brothers must confront the fractures in their bond and find a way back to each other. Can Dean find it in himself to fight for his recovery and trust Sam enough to help him, or will the silence and guilt between them prove insurmountable? -
Tags
Summary
Summary: the amulet is very powerful. It is faith. Not faith in God, but Sam's faith in Dean.
After Dean tosses it away, Sam starts losing his memories of Dean.
-
Tags
Summary
Dean is crying in front of Sam, and Sam tries to offer him comfort, but Dean refuses.
-
Tags
Summary
You see him everywhere you go.
Series
- Part 13 of he knows my habits, my aliases, everything
-
Tags
Summary
John yells at Dean, and Sam just can’t take it anymore.
(The story has a pretty long beginning, so the central scene of the fanfiction doesn’t show up right away… please be patient.)
-
Tags
Summary
Sam had a dream where he and Dean weren’t exactly… brotherly.
-
touch and touch and touch and touch me (i wanna feel guilty) by Anonymous
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
02 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
It's hard to jerk off. Especially when your right arm's in a sling, and especially when your left hand just... doesn't get the job done. But hey, that's what brothers are for, right?
-
Tags
Summary
Dean belongs to Sam. Protecting Sam, pleasuring Sam, pleasing Sam—it's what Dean was made for. So, when Dean loses Sam to Lucifer’s cage? He copes, because Sam told him how to cope. But when Sam returns from the cage? Dean's got no playbook for that.
-
Southern Comfort......with more comfort by AO3_thisismylife
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
27 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
Specter: ghost that possesses people and forces them to act on whatever betrayals they're feeling.
In 08×06, Dean is under the influence of that ghost, and his words hurt Sam more than he would have ever thought.
-
Tags
Summary
After Jessica’s funeral, Dean is eager to get on the road as soon as possible so he and Sam can search for their father. But what he really wants is to take Sam away from Palo Alto and all the bad memories. Sam says he needs to do something before they leave. Dean agrees, but something about the request doesn’t sound quite right. He decides to follow Sam and find out what his brother is up to.
-
Tags
Summary
Sam is unraveling under the weight of guilt he can’t escape. Dean returns to find more than just bruises—he finds silence, distance, and something breaking between them.
In a motel room thick with memory and grief, old wounds resurface. Some things are too painful to say. Others... maybe don’t need words at all. -
the pain makes you feel like you earned it (and i probably deserved it) by loveinourowngrave
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
24 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
“I’m sorry,” Sam says, limp on the bed, bracing himself.
Dean thrusts in like he’s saying: and I don’t forgive you.(Since coming back from hell—and since Sam let the devil out of his cage—Dean doesn’t fuck the same way.)
-
Tags
Summary
A hunt gone sideways leaves Sam and Gabriel shaken in ways neither of them expected. Back at the Bunker, the silence between them speaks louder than words—until one late night changes everything. Some truths are only revealed when there’s nowhere left to hide.
Whumptober 2024 Alternate Prompt 01: BODY SWAP
Series
- Part 32 of Whumptober2024
-
Tags
Summary
"Why? You gonna hate me any less? Am I gonna hate myself any less?"
"You'll never punish me as much as I'm punishing myself"Set after 5.04 The end.
.
.
.
“Sam”
His brother’s voice put his brain’s self-pity party on hiatus.
“Yeah?”
Dean looked at him with a little concern and another expression he couldn’t quite place. “You okay, man?”
Again, Sam almost laughed. “Yeah, I’m fine”He's not. He's really not.
-
Tags
Summary
A witch’s dying curse forces Sam and Dean to speak only the truth for 24 hours. What begins as harmless teasing spirals into an argument that unearths long-buried fears, guilt, and feelings neither of them dared to say aloud. In the end, the truth may hurt—but it also sets them free.
-
Tags
Summary
After returning from Purgatory, Dean is cold and distant with Sam. Until he finds his journal — and discovers the painful truth about the months of absence.
-
Tags
Summary
When thirteen-year-old Sammy takes a time journey, he is thrown into a future where the world is ending — and his big brother is colder, angrier, and more of a stranger than he’s ever known. Betrayed by the man little Sammy will become, Dean struggles to distinguish the boy in front of him from the brother who chose a demon over his own family. As the weight of the apocalypse bears down, Sam must face the guilt of the mistakes he will make in the future, and the sadness that his brother doesn’t believe in him anymore. Can they find their way back to each other before it’s too late?
-
Tags
Summary
When Dean tells him to walk away, he does it. There's nowhere to go this time. Sam should know better.